Salanoa and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

Salanoa and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (Migration) [2025] ARTA 1050 (2 July 2025)

Applicant/s:  Ken Faraimo Roy Jnr SALANOA

Respondent:  Minister for Immigration and Citizenship

Tribunal Number:                2025/3271

Tribunal:Senior Member N Manetta  

Place:Adelaide

Date:2 July 2025

Date of Written Reasons:    21 July 2025

Decision:The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and in substitution decides that the cancellation of the applicant’s visa be revoked.

Written reasons for this decision will be provided within a reasonable time hereof.

..........................[SGND].........................................

Senior Member N Manetta

Catchwords

MIGRATION – mandatory cancellation of a visa – section 501 of Migration Act – applicant a citizen of New Zealand – applicant does not pass character test – whether ‘another reason’ for cancellation decision to be revoked – applicant guilty of serious offence of drug trafficking – not a significant enterprise – committed family relationship – interests of partner – decision set aside and substituted

Legislation

Migration Act, 1958 (Cth)

Cases

Frugtniet v ASIC [2019] HCA 16; (2019) 266 CLR 250; (2019) 79 AAR 9

Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs v LJTZ [2021] FCA 92

Secondary Materials

Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs (Cth), Direction no. 110 — Visa refusal and cancellation under section 501 and revocation of a mandatory cancellation of a visa under section 501CA (7 June 2024)

Statement of Reasons

  1. These are my written reasons for the decision I made and published on 2 July 2025.

  2. This is an application by Mr Ken Faraimo Roy Jnr Salanoa seeking a review of the decision of the respondent’s delegate dated 7 April 2025.[1]  By this decision, the respondent’s delegate declined to cancel the revocation of Mr Salanoa’s visa.[2] The cancellation had taken place earlier, and mandatorily so, following Mr Salanoa’s conviction of two counts involving the supply of illicit drugs.  Mr Salanoa received two sentences for this offending, one of which was three years and two months and the other twelve months. Part of these sentences was required to be served on a full-time basis in jail. In this circumstance, the respondent was obliged to cancel Mr Salanoa’s visa under s 501(3A) of the Migration Act, 1958 (Cth) (‘the Act’).  I shall describe the offending in more detail in due course.

    [1] The delegate’s decision and reasons were before me at Hearing Book (‘HB’), 9ff. 

    [2] A Class TY Subclass 444 Special Category (Temporary) visa.

  3. Mr Salanoa made a timely application for an internal review. The internal-review delegate had two questions to consider under s 501CA(4)(b) of the Act.  The first was whether Mr Salanoa passed the so-called ‘character test’ as elaborated under s 501(6) and (7) of the Act.  Given the sentences to which I have already referred and the terms of s 501(6)(a) and 7(c), Mr Salanoa could not pass the test, and the delegate’s conclusion in this regard was clearly correct.  The second question, which arose if the answer to the first question was no, was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Salanoa and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (Migrat... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] ARTA 1050
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Salanoa and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship, the respondent, a citizen of New Zealand, challenged the mandatory cancellation of his visa under section 501 of the Migration Act. The primary dispute centered on whether the mandatory cancellation decision should be revoked due to certain mitigating circumstances. Mr. Salanoa had been convicted of serious drug trafficking offenses, which led to his visa being cancelled. However, he argued that other factors, including his personal circumstances and relationship with his partner, warranted reconsideration of the cancellation decision.

The legal issues before the court involved interpreting section 501 of the Migration Act and determining whether the mandatory cancellation of Mr. Salanoa's visa should be revoked. The court had to balance the seriousness of the criminal offenses against other considerations such as Mr. Salanoa's family situation, his reintegration into society, and the potential harm of deportation. The court also had to consider the primary consideration of community safety as outlined in the relevant Direction.

The court found that while Mr. Salanoa's criminal behavior was serious, there were significant mitigating factors to consider. He had engaged in criminal activity only after leaving his long-term relationship, which had since been restored. Additionally, Mr. Salanoa had a relatively good work history and a supportive family environment in Australia, including a partner who would benefit from his continued presence in the country. The court concluded that the balance of considerations favored revoking the cancellation of Mr. Salanoa's visa, recognizing the importance of maintaining family unity and the potential difficulties of relocation to New Zealand.

In light of these considerations, the court decided to set aside the decision to cancel Mr. Salanoa's visa and substitute a decision that the cancellation be revoked. The court emphasized the strong community safety considerations but weighed them against the personal and family circumstances of Mr. Salanoa. The final order was to revoke the mandatory cancellation of Mr. Salanoa's visa, allowing him to remain in Australia.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

I have decided to set aside the decision under review and to substitute a decision that the cancellation of Mr Salanoa’s visa be revoked. I set out below the background facts and then my reasons for this conclusion.BACKGROUND FACTS Mr Salanoa was born in September 1998. He is a citizen of New Zealand. He arrived in Australia with his family at the age of eight. He first lived in Brisbane and completed his primary and secondary schooling there. He met his future partner while at school, when he was just 16 years of age. She gave evidence on his behalf at the hearing. They moved to Darwin in due course to support her job opportunities. In his evidence to me, Mr Salanoa described his relationship with his partner as having had ‘lots of ups and downs’ but that overall it was a strong relationship. Despite an initial separation in 2023, the couple reconciled and they now have a child. The relationship has survived Mr Salanoa’s jailing. Mr Salanoa and his partner gave evidence that their relationship foundered in 2023 after he had an affair. He was required to leave her family home where they had been living as a couple. I accept his evidence that he was greatly upset and felt anxious after the separation. He had no fixed accommodation, and he said that he engaged in the offending behaviour ‘for survival’. I do not accept, however, that his changed circumstances left him so poor or threatened that he had no choice but to engage in the criminal offending of which he was convicted. I do accept that Mr Salanoa began to associate and live with an undesirable group of people after his separation, and that they introduced him to the possibility of making money from drugs; but I do not accept, as an objective fact, that Mr Salanoa was overborne to a degree where he had lost control over his life choices. I turn now to Mr Salanoa’s criminal offending. There are two convictions only in his criminal history, which was before me in evidence.[7] I also had the sentencing remarks before me,[8] and I accept and rely upon them. The first conviction involved the supply of a commercial quantity of MDMA, and the second involved the supply of less than a commercial quantity of cannabis. The offending occurred sometime between 12 and 27 July 2023. It was engaged in for the purposes of financial gain. On 26 July 2023 police executed a search warrant at the premises where Mr Salanoa was living at the time. The sentencing remarks record exactly what was located on Mr Salanoa’s person and in his bedroom.[9] [7] HB, 24-25.[8] HB, 26ff.[9] HB, 27-28. The sentencing remarks also record[10] that police seized in total police 126.46 g of MDMA and 220.84 g of cannabis. A commercial quantity of MDMA is prescribed to be 25 g, and so the amount seized was approximately five times this threshold amount. The quantity of cannabis seized was a little less than half the prescribed commercial quantity but more than the trafficable quantity of 50 grams. The sentencing remarks record that an analysis of Mr Salanoa’s mobile phone revealed messages that evidenced a supply of dangerous drugs.[11][10] HB, 28.[11] HB, 28

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

At the hearing before me, Ms Ranjith appeared for Mr Salanoa; Mr Plitsch, for the respondent. I am grateful to them both for their helpful submissions in what was undoubtedly a difficult case.STATEMENT OF CONCLUSION I have decided to set aside the decision under review and to substitute a decision that the cancellation of Mr Salanoa’s visa be revoked. I set out below the background facts and then my reasons for this conclusion.BACKGROUND FACTS Mr Salanoa was born in September 1998. He is a citizen of New Zealand. He arrived in Australia with his family at the age of eight. He first lived in Brisbane and completed his primary and secondary schooling there. He met his future partner while at school, when he was just 16 years of age. She gave evidence on his behalf at the hearing. They moved to Darwin in due course to support her job opportunities. In his evidence to me, Mr Salanoa described his relationship with his partner as having had ‘lots of ups and downs’ but that overall it was a strong relationship. Despite an initial separation in 2023, the couple reconciled and they now have a child. The relationship has survived Mr Salanoa’s jailing. Mr Salanoa and his partner gave evidence that their relationship foundered in 2023 after he had an affair. He was required to leave her family home where they had been living as a couple. I accept his evidence that he was greatly upset and felt anxious after the separation. He had no fixed accommodation, and he said that he engaged in the offending behaviour ‘for survival’. I do not accept, however, that his changed circumstances left him so poor or threatened that he had no choice but to engage in the criminal offending of which he was convicted. I do accept that Mr Salanoa began to associate and live with an undesirable group of people after his separation, and that they introduced him to the possibility of making money from drugs; but I do not accept, as an objective fact, that Mr Salanoa was overborne to a degree where he had lost control over his life choices. I turn now to Mr Salanoa’s criminal offending. There are two convictions only in his criminal history, which was before me in evidence.[7] I also had the sentencing remarks before me,[8] and I accept and rely upon them. The first conviction involved the supply of a commercial quantity of MDMA, and the second involved the supply of less than a commercial quantity of cannabis. The offending occurred sometime between 12 and 27 July 2023. It was engaged in for the purposes of financial gain. On 26 July 2023 police executed a search warrant at the premises where Mr Salanoa was living at the time. The sentencing remarks record exactly what was located on Mr Salanoa’s person and in his bedroom.[9] [7] HB, 24-25.[8] HB, 26ff.[9] HB, 27-28. The sentencing remarks also record[10] that police seized in total police 126.46 g of MDMA and 220.84 g of cannabis. A commercial quantity of MDMA is prescribed to be 25 g, and so the amount seized was approximately five times this threshold amount. The quantity of cannabis seized was a little less than half the prescribed commercial quantity but more than the trafficable quantity of 50 grams. The sentencing remarks record that an analysis of Mr Salanoa’s mobile phone revealed messages that evidenced a supply of dangerous drugs.[11][10] HB, 28.[11] HB, 28

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

So far as other considerations under section 9 are concerned, Mr Salanoa is a young adult and he would not face any particular difficulties relocating to New Zealand arising from a lack of familiarity with language or with its general customs. I proceed on the basis also that New Zealand has a broadly equivalent social welfare system. So, I do not believe there are any impediments of any substance for me to weigh in Mr Salanoa’s favour, although there will be the initial difficulties arising from relocation. Weighing the considerations I turn now to weigh the various considerations. This is not an easy task. I begin with the very strongly antisocial criminal behaviour in which Mr Salanoa engaged. This offending gives rise to very serious character concerns even though I am satisfied Mr Salanoa’s risk of reoffending is very low. Moreover, the consequences for the community of recidivism are severe, and a low risk is not ‘no risk’. As I have noted, the community-expectations consideration applies even where an applicant poses no risk to the community. There is no doubt in my mind that the Direction speaks very strongly against drug trafficking because of its potential for wide community harm. Strong efforts must be made to protect the community from illicit drugs, and the Direction is squarely based on a need to protect the community from harm. The safety of the community is the highest priority for the Australian Government[27], and it is ‘generally’ to be given more weight than other primary considerations.[28][27] Paragraph 5.2(2) of the Direction.[28] Paragraph 7(2) of the Direction. On the other hand, Mr Salanoa poses a very low risk of reoffending for the reasons that I have explained. He did not engage in his offending until he had left his long-term relationship (which is now repaired and reinstated). The Court found he had ‘a relatively good work history’.[29] There is a stronger financial background for the family as his partner has work from which she has taken leave but to which she has a right of return. Mr Salanoa now has a child to look after. He will be aware that any criminal offending punishable by imprisonment will lead to his having to serve the balance of the suspended part of the sentence. As the date of my decision on 2 July 2025, the balance of the sentence was two years and three months approximately. That is a lengthy time. I accept what the respondent put to me concerning the absence of monitoring and reporting obligations; but the existence of an as yet unserved sentence operates in my view as a most serious deterrent for Mr Salanoa, as does the future prospect of deportation if he reoffends. [29] HB, 29. I have also weighed very carefully the interests of Mr Salanoa’s partner, which are important and are a primary consideration. I believe that she would benefit substantially from his remaining in Australia. I believe she has better prospects in Australia than she would have in New Zealand. By ‘better prospects’, I mean the prospects of support for her are greater here than in New Zealand. She has a job here, and she has organised her life here. She is a young mother. Emigrating to New Zealand would be possible but not desirable for this young mother in the circumstances of her life. I accept her oral evidence that she would follow Mr Salanoa, and I find that this decision would be a reasonable one since she would be acting to preserve the family unit in the interests of her daughter. She would have Mr Salanoa’s support in New Zealand, of course, and a connection with her own father, who has relocated there; but having heard her evidence, I believe it would be emotionally hard for her to re-establish herself within a new community. I cannot assume that she would necessarily find work easily. Mr Salanoa’s prospects are reasonable here in Australia, and he has had work experience here, which augurs well, although those same skills are transferable to New Zealand, of course.