Sadat v Taneski (Civil Dispute)

Link copied
Case Copied 56 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

SADAT v TANESKI (Civil Dispute) [2018] ACAT 39

XD 837/2017

Catchwords:             CIVIL DISPUTE – oral agreements to carry out work inside and outside applicant’s property – part payment – defective workmanship – unfinished work – agreements terminated – works completed by other tradespersons – claim for damages

Legislation cited:      ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 ss 16, 17, 18, 20, 48

Cases cited:Bellgrove v Eldridge (1954) 90 CLR 613

Robinson v Harman (1848)154 ER 363
Tabcorp Holdings Ltd v Bowen Investments Pty Ltd [2009] HCA 8

Tribunal:                  Presidential Member E Symons

Date of Orders:           6 April 2018

Date of Reasons for Decision:         6 April 2018

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY          )

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL     )          XD 837/2017

BETWEEN:MIRWAIS SADAT

Applicant

AND:                   CVETKO TANESKI

Respondent

TRIBUNAL:  Presidential Member E Symons

DATE:6 April 2018

ORDER

The Tribunal orders that:

  1. Judgment for the applicant in the amount of $10,480.46 being $10,330.46 damages and the filing fee of $150.00.

  2. The respondent pay the judgment monies of $10,480.46 to the applicant by close of business 4 May 2018.

  3. Subject to Order 4, upon receipt of the payment in order 2, the applicant forthwith instruct Still Standing Sheet Metal Pty Ltd of 15 Wiluna Street, Fyshwick to release to the respondent the materials they are holding for Carport 2.

  4. If the respondent fails to pay the judgment monies to the applicant by the due date in Order 2 the applicant retains ownership of the carport materials in Order 3 and may dispose of them as he sees fit.

………………………………..

Presidential Member E Symons

REASONS FOR DECISION

Introduction

  1. These proceedings have arisen from a series of verbal agreements entered into between the parties for the respondent to carry out works for the applicant at his property in Kaleen.

  2. The reasons below explain why the Tribunal has entered judgment for the applicant in the sum of $10,485.46 and made orders in relation to the carport material being held by Still Standing Sheet Metal. The respondent withdrew his counterclaim at the commencement of the hearing. It was formally dismissed on 8 January 2018. The Tribunal has made orders in relation to the payment of the judgment monies to the applicant and the release of the materials for the double carport held by Still Standing Sheet Metal to the respondent.

  3. In these reasons for decision the tribunal hearing this matter is referred to as Tribunal. References to the tribunal or ACAT in these reasons refer to the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal generally.

Background

  1. In 2013/2014 Mirwais Sadat (the applicant) had entered into a contract with Kashan Constructions Pty Limited (Kashan) to build an extension on his property. This contract came to an end in early 2015 when Kashan failed to meet its contractual obligations. At this time Kashan had not completed parts of the work the subject of the contract. While Kashan was undertaking the work at the applicant’s property Cvetko Taneski (the respondent) worked as…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sadat v Taneski (Civil Dispute) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] ACAT 39
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Sadat v Taneski involves a dispute between the applicant, Mr. Sadat, and the respondent, Mr. Taneski, concerning the quality of work performed by the respondent and the payment of associated costs. The matter was heard by the Civil and Administrative Tribunal (CAT). Mr. Sadat alleged that Mr. Taneski's work was defective and that he had fraudulently ordered two carports instead of one using Mr. Sadat's partner's credit card. Additionally, Mr. Sadat sought damages for the respondent's work on the front door, which he later clarified he was not pursuing.

The central legal issues before the court were the terms of the oral agreements between the parties, the quality of the work performed by Mr. Taneski, and whether Mr. Taneski had fraudulently ordered the carports. The court needed to determine whether Mr. Taneski had breached the terms of their agreement by performing defective work and whether he had acted fraudulently in ordering the carports. Furthermore, the court had to assess the validity of Mr. Sadat's claim for damages related to the respondent's work on the front door.

In its decision, the Tribunal examined the evidence provided by both parties. The Tribunal found that Mr. Sadat had not pursued damages for the respondent's work on the front door and considered the evidence related to the terms of the oral agreements and the quality of the work performed. The Tribunal concluded that Mr. Taneski's work was defective and that he had indeed fraudulently ordered two carports. As a result, the Tribunal ordered Mr. Taneski to pay Mr. Sadat $10,480.46, which included damages and the filing fee. The Tribunal further ordered that if Mr. Taneski failed to pay by the specified date, Mr. Sadat could dispose of the carport materials as he saw fit.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal orders that:

1.

Judgment for the applicant in the amount of $10,480.46 being $10,330.46 damages and the filing fee of $150.00.

2.

The respondent pay the judgment monies of $10,480.46 to the applicant by close of business 4 May 2018.

3.

Subject to Order 4, upon receipt of the payment in order 2, the applicant forthwith instruct Still Standing Sheet Metal Pty Ltd of 15 Wiluna Street, Fyshwick to release to the respondent the materials they are holding for Carport 2.

4.

If the respondent fails to pay the judgment monies to the applicant by the due date in Order 2 the applicant retains ownership of the carport materials in Order 3 and may dispose of them as he sees fit.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The applicant told the Tribunal that he was not pursuing recovery of damages for the respondent’s work on the front door (refer Appendix 4 in [24g] above).The respondent’s evidence and submissions The respondent relied on the following documents filed on 26 October 2017:(a) A statement including:(i) Index to Response and Chronology of events Overview.(ii) Chronology of events and “duties undertaken instructed by M. Sadat and N. Bourbos.”(iii) Response to photos in applicant’s Appendices 1F, 3A, 3B, 11B and 12A in relation to the levelling of the flooring.(iv) Response to photos in applicant’s Appendix 2 – sliding door and internal and external wall.(v) Response to photos in applicant’s Appendix 4 – exterior door being cut.(vi) Response to photos in applicant’s Appendix 5 – rear yard before and during landscaping.(vii) Response to photos in applicant’s Appendix 6 – front yard before and after excavation.(viii) Response to photos in applicant’s Appendix 7 – carport and documents from Still Standing Sheet Metal.(ix) Response to photos in applicant’s Appendix 8 – installation of flooring and skirting boards in dining and main bedroom.(x) Response to photos in applicant’s Appendix 9 – laundry cabinet, bin cupboard and kitchen cupboard.(xi) Response to photo in applicant’s Appendix 14 – return of old carport.(xii) Response to documents in applicant’s Appendix 18 – electrical work.(xiii) Response to documents in applicant’s Appendix 21 – loss of rent.(xiv) Respondent’s Optus accounts 24 April 2017 to 23 May 2017.(xv) Two invoices from John Marich, Electrical Contractor dated 18 and 26 May 2017.(xvi) Statutory Declaration Kate Ninness dated 23 October 2017.(xvii) Email dated 24 August 2017 from applicant to respondent’s Attorney, Michael Ninness.(xviii)Ten photographs relating to ‘start floor work’, ‘start wall/slide door’ and ‘return old carport’(b)The following documents which were attached to his response filed on 6 December 2017. Although these documents supported the respondent’s counter-claim which was discontinued during the hearing, the Tribunal has considered these documents as they also relate to the work the subject of the application:(i) Statement of the activities/tasks he was asked by the applicant to work on, namely:A.Level original floors and lay new flooring;B.Remove sliding door and install new wall internal and external;C.Prepare front and rear yard for landscaping; D.Extend existing laundry cupboard; E.Remove existing cupboard to make room for dishwasher; andF.Electrician to install power points/lighting.(ii)A chronology;(iii) A summary of invoices rendered by him to the applicant and copies of the invoices; and(iv)Calculation of interest claimed. The respondent provided references from Alam MJ Mirza 20 November 2017 and Stan Secko, Director, SPS Strategic Property Services (ACT) Pty Ltd 23 November 2017. The Tribunal will first consider the evidence from the applicant and his witness and the respondent in relation to the terms of the oral agreements between the applicant and the respondent, then the applicant’s claim that the respondent’s work was defective and that the respondent fraudulently ordered two carports instead of one carport on his partner’s credit card and, finally, the applicant’s claim for damages in [22] above.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established