Sabin and Francis

Link copied
Case Copied 58 min read

FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SABIN & FRANCIS [2008] FMCAfam 1411
FAMILY LAW – Children aged 13 & 11 – best interests – weight to be given to views of children – whether children have been coached – family violence – presumption of equal shared parental responsibility – whether presumption rebutted – assessment of level of insight into responsibilities of being a parent.
Family Law Act 1975, ss.60CA, 60CC, 61DA, 65DAA

Relationship K (1994) FLC 92-461

Francis & Sabin [2008] FMCAfam 1410
Goode & Goode (2006) FLC 92-286
In the marriage of Patsalou (1994) 18 Fam LR 426
JG & BG 18 Fam LR 255
H v W (1995) FLC 92-598
R & R: Children’s Wishes (1999) 25 Fam LR 712

Applicant: MS SABIN
Respondent: MR FRANCIS
File Number: ADC 515 of 2008
Judgment of: Brown FM
Hearing dates: 9 & 10 December 2008
Date of Last Submission: 10 December 2008
Delivered at: Adelaide
Delivered on: 23 December 2008

REPRESENTATION

Counsel for the Applicant: In person
Counsel for the Respondent: In person
Counsel for the Independent Children’s Lawyer Mr Bowler
Solicitors for the Independent Children’s Lawyer Legal Services Commission

ORDERS

  1. That all existing orders be discharged.

  2. That the mother have sole parental responsibility for the children [D] born in 1995 and [K] born in 1997.

  3. That the children live with the mother.

  4. That the children spend time with the father as follows:-

    (a)during school terms on every third weekend from 10am on Saturday to 6pm on Sunday with such time to commence on the first weekend of each school term;

    (b)during the April, July and September/October school holidays from 5pm on the second Friday to 5pm on the following Tuesday;

    (c)during the Christmas school holidays from 5pm on the first Friday to 5pm on the following Tuesday and during the same period in each alternate weekend thereafter;

    (d)

    from 2pm on the 25th December 2008 to 6pm on the


    26th December 2008 and during the same period in each alternate year thereafter provided that the children shall live with the mother from 2pm on the 24th December 2008 to 2pm on the


    25th December 2008 and during the same period in each alternate year thereafter;

    (e)

    from 2pm on the 24th December 2009 to 2pm on the


    25th December 2009 and during the same period in each alternate year thereafter provided that the children shall live with the mother from 2pm on the 25th December 2009 to 2pm on the


    26th December 2009 and during the same period in each alternate year thereafter;

    (f)from 10am to 6pm on Father’s Day in each year provided that if Mother’s Day falls during a period when the children are spending time with the father then that time shall be suspended from 10am to 6pm on Mother’s Day;

    (g)from 10am to 6pm on Easter Sunday each year;

    (h)on the child [D]’s birthday from 10am to 6pm and on the child [K]’s birthday if a non-school…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sabin and Francis and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] FMCAfam 1411
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Sabin and Francis was a case in the Family Court of Australia, where the central dispute was the determination of parental responsibility and living arrangements for the children [D] and [K]. The case involved allegations of family violence and contentious parenting decisions between the parents, Ms. Sabin and Mr. Francis. The court was tasked with resolving these issues in a manner that best served the interests and welfare of the children.

The court had to decide several key legal issues, including the allocation of parental responsibility, the determination of living arrangements for the children, and the extent of the father's visitation rights. It was also necessary to consider the children's wishes, their maturity, and the history of family violence in making these determinations. The court had to balance the competing interests of both parents while ensuring the children's safety, emotional well-being, and stability.

In reaching its decision, the court considered the evidence and assessments provided by the Independent Children's Lawyer and other relevant parties. The court found that Ms. Sabin had been more involved in the children's education and welfare, and noted the volatile nature of the parents' relationship, including past incidents of family violence. The court concluded that sole parental responsibility should be awarded to Ms. Sabin, with the children living with her. The father was granted visitation rights, which were subject to the children's wishes, particularly [D], and certain conditions to ensure the children's safety. The court also ordered the use of a communication book and specified the terms of electronic communication between the parents.

The final orders of the court included awarding sole parental responsibility to Ms. Sabin, establishing specific visitation arrangements for Mr. Francis, and setting out conditions for contact and communication between the parents. These orders aimed to provide stability and protect the children's welfare while allowing for meaningful engagement with both parents.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

That all existing orders be discharged.

2.

That the mother have sole parental responsibility for the children [D] born in 1995 and [K] born in 1997.

3.

That the children live with the mother.

4.

That the children spend time with the father as follows:-

(a) during school terms on every third weekend from 10am on Saturday to 6pm on Sunday with such time to commence on the first weekend of each school term;

(b) during the April, July and September/October school holidays from 5pm on the second Friday to 5pm on the following Tuesday;

(c) during the Christmas school holidays from 5pm on the first Friday to 5pm on the following Tuesday and during the same period in each alternate weekend thereafter;

(d)

from 2pm on the 25th December 2008 to 6pm on the

26th December 2008 and during the same period in each alternate year thereafter provided that the children shall live with the mother from 2pm on the 24th December 2008 to 2pm on the

25th December 2008 and during the same period in each alternate year thereafter;

(e)

from 2pm on the 24th December 2009 to 2pm on the

25th December 2009 and during the same period in each alternate year thereafter provided that the children shall live with the mother from 2pm on the 25th December 2009 to 2pm on the

26th December 2009 and during the same period in each alternate year thereafter;

(f) from 10am to 6pm on Father’s Day in each year provided that if Mother’s Day falls during a period when the children are spending time with the father then that time shall be suspended from 10am to 6pm on Mother’s Day;

(g) from 10am to 6pm on Easter Sunday each year;

(h) on the child [D]’s birthday from 10am to 6pm and on the child [K]’s birthday if a non-school day from 10am to 6pm and if and if a school day from 4pm to 7pm;

(i) that all handovers occur at the Children’s Contact Service at [H] provided that if that service is not available then handovers occur with the mother delivering the children to the father’s home at the commencement of time spent and the father delivering the children to the mother’s home at the conclusion of the time spent.

5.

That the time the children spend with the father is accordance with these orders be subject at all times to the wishes of the child [D] and be subject to the wishes of the child [K] once that child attains the age of twelve (12) years.

6.

That the children have telephone communication with the father between 6.30pm and 7.30pm each Wednesday.

7.

That the parties utilise a communication book to exchange information relevant to the welfare of the children, with such book to be exchanged at contact handovers.

8.

That the parties keep each other advised of their current email address and they do email each other with respect to issues relating to the welfare of the children only.

9.

That the appointment of the Independent Children’s Lawyer be discharged.

10.

That all applications be removed from the Acting Pending List.

Background

Background to the litigation

I accept that Mr Francis is interested in the children’s education and wishes both children to do well at school. However, it seems to me that Ms Sabin has borne more of the responsibility of seeing to the children’s educational needs than Mr Francis has done. She has encouraged both the children to pursue various artistic endeavours. This is to her credit. g)The children’s maturity, sex, lifestyle and background [D] will be fourteen in January. She is a mature and intelligent child. She is of an age where it is appropriate that her views be consulted and her wishes respected. [K] is younger, being just over eleven years of age. She too, is a mature and intelligent child. I agree with Mr Vidot’s assessment that, fairly shortly, she too will be of an age where she is entitled to be in charge of her destiny, to some degree. h)Aboriginality This is not a consideration.j)Family violence k)Any family violence order Mr Francis vehemently refutes any suggestion that he is an inherently violent person. He disputes the mother’s allegation that he was violent towards her during the parties’ relationship. I do not propose to resolve this issue, in the context of the current proceedings, given the significant period which has elapsed since the parties finally separated. However, in my view, it is clearly the case that the parties’ relationship with one another was and is a volatile and unhappy one. There also remains the issue of family violence towards [D], arising out of the incident of November 2007. What [D] did was wrong and provocative, but in my assessment, Mr Francis exceeded the proper disciplinary response appropriate. I agree with Mr Vidot’s assessment that Mr Francis has sought to downplay the significance of this incident, which continues to reverberate for both [D] and [K]. The so-called “nudge to the bum” was behaviour which caused [D] to be apprehensive about her safety. In the context of this case, I think her reaction is objectively reasonable. l)Whether it would be preferable to make the order that would be the least likely to institution of further proceedings Finality is generally preferable in children’s cases. Litigation is expensive in both financial and emotional terms and does little to encourage an easy parenting relationship between the parties concerned. In addition, so far as children are concerned, it is usually desirable that arrangements for their care are stable and constant and not subject to the threat of further litigation. The parties’ relationship with one another is poor. In the past, Mr Francis has shown a propensity to bring proceedings against Ms Sabin and a reluctance to explore other potential therapeutic avenues to improve his relationship with the two children concerned. These are not hopeful indicators for the avoidance of future litigation between the parties. However, I am confident that, if I accede to Mr Francis’ proposals, inevitably there will be further proceedings between the parties. [D] and [K] are likely to be highly resistant to such an outcome and Mr Francis himself is likely to want to take proceedings to enforce what he perceives are his “rights”.