Names used in all child support published decisions are pseudonyms. Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been removed from this decision and replaced with generic information so as not to identify involved individuals as required by sections 16(2AB)–16(2AC) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988.
Catchwords
CHILD SUPPORT – review of care percentage determinations – actual care varied from arrangements as provided for in Court orders – whether payee was providing actual care – whether payer had obligation to pay child support – whether care is able to be provided when the payee is hospitalised – whether no parent was providing actual care for the child - conflicting evidence of extent of actual care – decision under review affirmed
Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634
Secondary Materials
Guides to Social Policy Law, Child Support Guide
REASONS FOR DECISION
Ms A E Burke AO Member
7 September 2021
The Applicant, RYKB, is seeking a second-tier review by the General Division of the AAT (AAT2) of a decision by the Social Security and Child Support Division of this Tribunal (AAT1 or First-Tier) on 29 October 2020. AAT1 affirmed the care determination made by the Child Support Registrar (the Registrar) that from 27 October 2019 there was no change in care and the Other Party (KZMS) continued to have 100% care of Child H. RYKB argued he did not have an obligation to pay child support as KZMS was not providing 100% care to their child.
The application was heard on 6 August 2021 by video-link. RYKB was represented by Counsel, Ms Alex Metherell; and KZMS was self-represented and appeared by telephone. Ms Katherine Whittemore, Solicitor at Sparke Helmore, appeared for the Respondent, the Registrar.
BACKGROUND
The Applicant, RYKB, and the Other Party, KZMS, are the separated parents of two children born in 2004 and 2006 respectively, who the Tribunal will refer to as Child V and Child H.
RYKB is no longer required to pay child support for Child V as she is no longer residing with KZMS. Child V is currently in receipt of Youth Allowance and living with her elder sister from KZMS’ first marriage.
On 27 December 2019, RYKB wrote to the Child Support Agency seeking an immediate review and reassessment of his obligations from 27 October 2019, as Child…
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read RYKB and Child Support Registrar (Child support second revie... and more:
This matter concerned a second review of a child support care percentage determination, brought by the applicant, RYKB, against the Child Support Registrar. The dispute centred on whether the payee, KZMS, had ceased to have actual care of the parties' child, H, from 27 October 2019, thereby impacting RYKB's child support obligations. RYKB contended that KZMS was incapable of providing care due to mental illness and that H was in the care of his maternal grandfather, WG, or that neither parent was providing actual care.
The court was required to determine whether there had been a change in the ongoing pattern of care for H from 27 October 2019, and consequently, whether RYKB had an obligation to pay child support. Specifically, the court had to consider whether KZMS was providing actual care for H, even during periods of hospitalisation, and whether the evidence supported RYKB's assertion that neither parent was providing care. The legal issue also involved assessing the weight to be given to conflicting evidence regarding H's residence and care arrangements.
The court applied sections 49 and 50 of the *Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989*, which require satisfaction that there has been a change to the ongoing pattern of care to alter recorded care percentages. The court considered evidence including school records, statements from WG, and the parties' own submissions. Despite RYKB's claims of KZMS's incapacity due to mental illness and hospitalisations, the court found that KZMS maintained responsibility for H's welfare and expenses, and that WG's involvement was that of a supportive grandfather rather than a primary carer. Crucially, school records indicated H resided with KZMS, and WG confirmed that while H and KZMS stayed with him sometimes, KZMS remained responsible for H's care and decision-making.
The Registrar's decision to refuse to reflect a change in H's care arrangements from 27 October 2019 was affirmed. Consequently, H's care was continued to be recorded as 100% with KZMS, and RYKB's objection was disallowed, meaning his child support assessment remained unchanged.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
The application was heard on 6 August 2021 by video-link. RYKB was represented by Counsel, Ms Alex Metherell; and KZMS was self-represented and appeared by telephone. Ms Katherine Whittemore, Solicitor at Sparke Helmore, appeared for the Respondent, the Registrar. BACKGROUND The Applicant, RYKB, and the Other Party, KZMS, are the separated parents of two children born in 2004 and 2006 respectively, who the Tribunal will refer to as Child V and Child H. RYKB is no longer required to pay child support for Child V as she is no longer residing with KZMS. Child V is currently in receipt of Youth Allowance and living with her elder sister from KZMS’ first marriage. On 27 December 2019, RYKB wrote to the Child Support Agency seeking an immediate review and reassessment of his obligations from 27 October 2019, as Child H was no longer in the care of KZMS but was living with his maternal grandfather (WG), so that neither parent had care of Child H. RYKB wrote:I have today (27 December 2019) received credible information from the payee's family that H is also no longer residing with the payee or in the care of the payee from the same date - 27 October 2019.The payee is living in a caravan park without the care or control of any of the children of the assessment - as evident in your letter related to V - and the information I have received today (27 December 2019). I do not know the physical address of the caravan park that the payee is residing in. You will no doubt have that information. H is now in the care of WG […] residing in [..,] NSW. I am unaware of the physical address; however, the payee does not live with WG nor does the payee have any care or control over H. The payee does not have care or control over H. I have been assessed to continue to pay child support to the payee for H. The payee does not have care or control over H. It is unjust, unfair and totally unlawful that I am required to pay money to the payee when the payee has no lawful entitlement to that child support obligation. On 23 March 2020, a Child Support case officer decided they were not satisfied on the evidence that there had been a change in care from the original decision. On 28 March and 8 April 2020 RYKB lodged objections to the decision with the Registrar. In a letter on 28 March 2020 RYKB wrote:This is long enough to make a very simple administrative decision that the payee does not have the care and control of H and that I should not be assessed to pay any child support obligation from 27 October 2019.As per my last correspondence: I am entitled to have the child support obligation and subsequent file finalised and closed against the payee. I do not have to pay the payee for something she is not entitled to receive. On 21 August 2020, the Registrar advised RYKB they had disallowed his objection:SUMMARY OF OBJECTION DECISIONThe outcome of this decision is that it has been disallowed.We have made the decision to refuse to reflect the care of H as being in neither parents care from 27 October 2019.The effect of the objection decision is: There is no change to the assessment as a result of this decision.DECISION UNDER REVIEWThe decision made on 23 March 2020 to refuse to reflect the care of H as being in neither parents care from 27 October 2019.RYKB has objected to this decision because KZMS does not have care and control of H.In considering this objection, a full merit review of the original decision has been conducted.This means that we have examined and evaluated all the relevant information in order to reach a conclusion based on the relevant facts of the case and how the law is applied to those facts.WE CONSIDERED THE FOLLOWING EVIDENCE IN THE DECISIONThe pre-existing level of care recorded for H was 100% to KZMS from 8 October 2016.On 2 January 2020, RYKB notified us in writing that H left KZMS`s care on 27 October 2019. RYKB advised H is residing with and in the care of WG who resides at … New South Wales. KZMS is living in a caravan park and does not reside with H and WG.Details of Objection DecisionOn 24 January 2020, KZMS advised she disagreed with the care reported by RYKB as H lives with her full-time. We requested KZMS provide evidence to support her claims.On 23 March 2020, we made the decision to refuse to amend the care of H from 27 October 2019.On 1 April 2020, we received RYKB's objection to this decision.On 20 August 2020, we contacted H`s School who confirmed their records show H resides with KZMS at the same address.On 20 August 2020, we contacted WG who advised H is not in his care. WG stated KZMS and H stay with him sometimes, but KZMS is responsible for feeding him and all the decision in relation to H`s care. WG advised on occasions, he may drop H off at the bus stop before school but KZMS is responsible for his care.REASONS FOR THE DECISIONIn order to make a decision to change the record of care for a child we must be satisfied that there has been a change to the ongoing pattern of care (section 49 and 50 of the Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989).When considering whether the increased care demonstrates a change in the pattern of care, the Registrar will consider the information presented or obtained to determine the care that is likely to be provided by the parents in the care period.In this case, pre-existing level of care recorded for H was 100% to KZMS from 8 October 2016.Care will generally be worked out based on the number of nights that the child is likely to be in the care of the person during the care period (CSA Act section 54A).A new percentage of care can be determined whenever the care of a child has changed.In this case, the email from A provided by RYKB does not stipulate H left KZMS `s care, it states that she had asked H if he wanted to live with her and H had declined.RYKB requested we contact the following people, as they would be able to confirm H`s care, M, N, WG and AC.The following unsuccessful attempts were made on the telephone numbers provided by RYKB for AC, N, WG and M, on 25 June 2020, 24 July 2020and 29 July 2020.On 20 August 2020, we unsuccessfully attempted to contact N and M.H`s school confirms their records show H resides with KZMS.We also contacted WG by telephone, and he confirmed H is not in his care but continues to be in the care KZMS.Based on the information available we cannot be satisfied a change to H`s level of care occurred.We have therefore made the decision to refuse to reflect that H is in neither parents care on 27 October 2019.H`s care will continue to be reflected as being in KZMS `s 100% care from 8 October 2016.The objection is disallowed.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
The Tribunal found that procedural fairness had not been denied to the Applicant as his Counsel was able to seek, by way of cross-examination, information from KZMS about her periods of hospitalisation, the medical reasons for her hospitalisation and her capacity to care for H while hospitalised.EVIDENCE On 29 November 2011, final property and parenting orders were put in place by the Federal Magistrates Court of Australia, ordering:The mother have sole parental responsibility for the children off the relationship V born 2004 and H born 2006 (“the children”). The children live with the mother. RYKB’s submissions to AAT1 hearing stated:The payee does not have care and control of the child of the assessment – H.…The CSA were notified on 2 January 2020 that the payee no longer had care and control of H. The Payee suffers from mental illness and is in capable of caring for the children of the assessment. This was proven in 2016 when the Payee failed to notify the CSA of her involuntary mental hospital admission for an extended period of time. It was in fact WG, the payees father, that arranged for the involuntary hospitalisation of the payee through his complaints to NSW Child Services because of the fact that the payee wasn’t caring for the children of the assessment, which included not sending the children to school and his complaints to the health department.At that time (July 2016), the payee provided false and misleading information to the CSA, along with her father WG indicating that she had the care and control of the children of the assessment. This was proven to be incorrect and the CSA ceased the ongoing child support obligations.The payee successfully reapplied for a child support assessment on 8 October 2016.The payee has been hospitalised frequently for long periods of time from that period due to her mental illness and has not been caring for the children of the assessment. The payee has neglected (or deliberately refused) to inform the CSA of these hospitalisations and has been receiving a child support obligation that she is not entitled to from that period.The CSA have failed to undertake any compliance measures to confirm the care and control of the children of the assessment over this period. Relying solely on the information from the payee, despite the payee having provided false and misleading information previously (PA1). The CSA ignored the fact that payee admitted to a 3 week hospitalisation in her statutory declaration dated 28 January 2020 and took no compliance verification process in relation to thisHad it not been for the fact that V made the decision to leave the payee and live with her adult sister and required a birth certificate, it would not have been known that the payee did not have care and control of the children. Meaning that the accepted assessment from 8 October 2016 would still be ongoing relating to both children.V left the residence because of the payee’s mental illness. The CSA have accepted that date being 27 October 2020. AC reached out to me to get assistance for Victoria as the payee was not providing any and had turned on both V and AC. WG had also turned on AC and V. Which was disappointing given the fact that it was WG that originally instigated the payee being involuntarily hospitalised for her mental illness. The CSA have relied on Statutory Declarations from the payee and a third party as proof that the payee has care and control of H. Those Statutory Declarations contain false information where the payee attests that V is holidaying with AC and that V resides with her and H from late October and early November. The third-party declaration attests the same information, suggesting that V was staying with AC for school holidays. This is factually incorrect where AC provides the evidence that H and V where visiting each weekend, but due to the payee’s mental illness this stopped. The CSA evidence is that V left on 27 October 2019. The CSA have failed to acknowledge this false information of which they, the CSA, have the records for. A simple check of the school holiday period Term 3 in Queensland indicates that that ended Monday 7 October 2019 contrary to the information provided in the statutory declarationsThe payee was residing in a caravan whilst H was under the care and control of WG. There has been no CSA verification of addresses undertaken to make the comparisons between WG’s and H’s known addresses. There is no confirmation of the payee’s addresses.AC had provided the evidence that H had decided to remain living with WG. The payee was re-hospitalised and not caring for the H.…2020: The payee has had unknown number of hospitalisations related to her mental illness, first triggered by WG in 2016 due to the payee’s failure to care for the children of the assessment. The payee failed to inform the CSA at that time and WG subsequently supported the payee in providing false and misleading information. The payee has failed to inform the CSA of the subsequent and ongoing hospitalisations since 2016, and neither the payee or WG have informed, confirmed or notified the CSA of the fact the payee was hospitalised again in 2020 and was only released on the conditional undertaking from WG that he care for the payee and the payee resides with him. Neither the payee nor WG have disclosed this information. The failure of the payee to provide forthright and truthful information is for the payee’s financial benefit in receiving a child support obligation that the payee is not entitled to received. The CSA has taken no compliance measures or initiatives to seek confirmation of all periods of hospitalisation of the payee and then verify who had care of H and where H was living during those periods. This is despite the CSA being aware of the payee’s mental illness, and even on the payee’s own admissions of hospitalisation in her statutory declaration.
Decision
Reasons for decision
On 21 August 2020, the Registrar advised RYKB they had disallowed his objection:SUMMARY OF OBJECTION DECISIONThe outcome of this decision is that it has been disallowed.We have made the decision to refuse to reflect the care of H as being in neither parents care from 27 October 2019.The effect of the objection decision is: There is no change to the assessment as a result of this decision.DECISION UNDER REVIEWThe decision made on 23 March 2020 to refuse to reflect the care of H as being in neither parents care from 27 October 2019.RYKB has objected to this decision because KZMS does not have care and control of H.In considering this objection, a full merit review of the original decision has been conducted.This means that we have examined and evaluated all the relevant information in order to reach a conclusion based on the relevant facts of the case and how the law is applied to those facts.WE CONSIDERED THE FOLLOWING EVIDENCE IN THE DECISIONThe pre-existing level of care recorded for H was 100% to KZMS from 8 October 2016.On 2 January 2020, RYKB notified us in writing that H left KZMS`s care on 27 October 2019. RYKB advised H is residing with and in the care of WG who resides at … New South Wales. KZMS is living in a caravan park and does not reside with H and WG.Details of Objection DecisionOn 24 January 2020, KZMS advised she disagreed with the care reported by RYKB as H lives with her full-time. We requested KZMS provide evidence to support her claims.On 23 March 2020, we made the decision to refuse to amend the care of H from 27 October 2019.On 1 April 2020, we received RYKB's objection to this decision.On 20 August 2020, we contacted H`s School who confirmed their records show H resides with KZMS at the same address.On 20 August 2020, we contacted WG who advised H is not in his care. WG stated KZMS and H stay with him sometimes, but KZMS is responsible for feeding him and all the decision in relation to H`s care. WG advised on occasions, he may drop H off at the bus stop before school but KZMS is responsible for his care.REASONS FOR THE DECISIONIn order to make a decision to change the record of care for a child we must be satisfied that there has been a change to the ongoing pattern of care (section 49 and 50 of the Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989).When considering whether the increased care demonstrates a change in the pattern of care, the Registrar will consider the information presented or obtained to determine the care that is likely to be provided by the parents in the care period.In this case, pre-existing level of care recorded for H was 100% to KZMS from 8 October 2016.Care will generally be worked out based on the number of nights that the child is likely to be in the care of the person during the care period (CSA Act section 54A).A new percentage of care can be determined whenever the care of a child has changed.In this case, the email from A provided by RYKB does not stipulate H left KZMS `s care, it states that she had asked H if he wanted to live with her and H had declined.RYKB requested we contact the following people, as they would be able to confirm H`s care, M, N, WG and AC.The following unsuccessful attempts were made on the telephone numbers provided by RYKB for AC, N, WG and M, on 25 June 2020, 24 July 2020and 29 July 2020.On 20 August 2020, we unsuccessfully attempted to contact N and M.H`s school confirms their records show H resides with KZMS.We also contacted WG by telephone, and he confirmed H is not in his care but continues to be in the care KZMS.Based on the information available we cannot be satisfied a change to H`s level of care occurred.We have therefore made the decision to refuse to reflect that H is in neither parents care on 27 October 2019.H`s care will continue to be reflected as being in KZMS `s 100% care from 8 October 2016.The objection is disallowed.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
KZMS contended that while she has been hospitalised, at all times during the period, she was nevertheless responsible for making arrangements for, and decisions about, H's welfare, as well as meeting all his expenses. She stated that WG had been providing for H as any normal grandfather would, by providing accommodation and support to a 14-year-old child whose sole carer was in hospital; but that was the extent of his responsibilities. KZMS stated that at all times she remains responsible for the actual care of H. CONSIDERATION There is no dispute that from 2011 until the present RYKB had 0% care of H. RYKB makes no claim to increase his percentage of care of H. RYKB is disputing whether he has any obligation to pay child support at all. He argues that he has no liability to pay child support for H as the various decision makers, including the Registrar and AAT1, have not appropriately considered the factual evidence which goes directly to the issue of whether the payee was incapable of caring for H; and therefore is ineligible to receive child support. RYKB relies upon a previous determination of the Registrar in 2016, where it was determined that his obligation to pay child support ceased because of the incapacity and inability of the payee to care for the children due to her mental illness. RYKB asserts this supports his current claim and argues that the payee’s mental illness is ongoing and remains relevant and critical to the decisions of this matter. The Tribunal is not in a position to make comment on the Registrar’s determination in 2016, nor on the recent determination in respect of Child V, however it was surprised the Registrar had not fulfil the principal object of the CSA Act to ensure that children receive a proper level of support from their parents. Without making comment on the previous decision as it is not before it, the Tribunal was perplexed that RYKB’s obligation to support his children could simply cease. As with all other child support matters, the Tribunal is required to determine the credibility of the witnesses with limited factual evidence to support the assertions made by the parties about the actual care of the child. The Tribunal would normally rely on the documentary evidence of the final parenting orders to assess the actual pattern of care for the children, as this is a legally- binding document that the parents accepted from the court, which neither party has sought to challenge. In this matter, the Family Court orders assist the Tribunal, as they clearly state KZMS has had 100% care of H since 2011. But the orders are not determinative, as this dispute goes to the actual care KZMS could provide whilst she was hospitalised. The Tribunal also recognises that the current orders do not reflect the actual care arrangements, as V is no longer in KZMS’ care. The Tribunal found both parents to be reliable witnesses at the hearing, with neither seeking to obfuscate. The Tribunal found RYKB did not seek to sugar-coat his firm belief that, as KZMS was incapable of providing care and control of H because of her mental illness, he should be assessed as having no child support obligation. RYKB was straightforward in his position that if he was not required to pay by law then why should he.