Ryan v A F Concrete Pumping Pty Limited (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Ryan v A F Concrete Pumping Pty Limited (No 2) [2013] NSWSC 219
Hearing dates:14 March 2013
Decision date: 14 March 2013
Before: Adamson J
Decision:

Reasons given for costs orders earlier made

Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE-costs-Calderbank offers-whether plaintiff may make offer directly to defendant through another party
PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE-costs-departing from general rule-conduct of parties-unreasonableness of conduct
Legislation Cited: - Civil Procedure Act 2005, s 98
Cases Cited: - Baillieu Knight Frank (NSW) Pty Ltd v Ted Manny Real Estate Pty Ltd (1992) 30 NSWLR 359
- Calderbank v Calderbank [1976] Fam 93
- Elite Protective Personnel Pty Limited & anor v Salmon [2007] NSWCA 322
- Messiter v Hutchison (1987) 10 NSWLR 525
-NMFM Property Pty Ltd v Citibank (No 11) [2001] FCA 480; 109 FCR 77
- Re Wilcox; Ex parte Venture Industries Pty Ltd (No 2) [1996] FCA 1942; 72 FCR 151
-Ryan v A F Concrete Pumping Pty Ltd [2012] NSWSC 723
- Jeffrey Ryan & another v A F Concrete Pumping Pty Ltd & another [2013] NSWSC 113
Category:Costs
Parties: Jeffrey Ryan (First Plaintiff)
Reliance Pools International Pty Ltd (Second Plaintiff)
A F Concrete Pumping Pty Ltd (First Defendant)
GIO Limited Ltd (Second Defendant)
Employers Mutual NSW Ltd (Cross-Defendant
Representation: Counsel:
RA Cavanagh SC and CJ Callaway (First and Second Plaintiff)
AB Parker and AR Davis (First Defendant)
N Polin (Second Defendant)
S Maybury (Cross-Defendant)
Solicitors:
Gillis Delaney (First and Second Plaintiff)
Walker Hedges & Co (First Defendant)
Gadens Lawyers (Second Defendant)
Edwards Michael Lawyers (Cross-Defendant
File Number(s):2010/408063

Judgment

  1. On 26 February 2012 I delivered judgment in this matter: Jeffrey Ryan & another v A F Concrete Pumping Pty Ltd & another [2013] NSWSC 113 (the principal judgment). I was asked to reserve the question of costs and hear further argument. I also asked the parties to prepare short minutes to reflect the reasons and to calculate the amount of the judgment. Accordingly I made orders on 14 March 2012 as follows:

Judgment for the first plaintiff in the sum of $2,438,405 with credit to be given for the $100,000 already paid.
Judgment in favour of the second plaintiff in the amount of $200,000.
  1. The parties made various applications for orders other than that costs on the ordinary basis ought follow the event.

  1. The plaintiffs applied for an order that the first defendant (A F Concrete) pay their costs on the ordinary basis until 26 November 2012 and on an indemnity basis thereafter. It also applied for a Bullock order that AF Concrete pay any costs the plaintiffs might be ordered to pay the second defendant (C & J), against whom they were unsuccessful.

  1. C & J applied for an order that A F Concrete pay its costs of the whole proceedings on an indemnity basis. In the alternative it sought an order that C& J pay its costs on the ordinary basis until 26…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ryan v A F Concrete Pumping Pty Limited (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NSWSC 219
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Ryan v A F Concrete Pumping Pty Limited (No 2) involved the plaintiff, Mr Ryan, and the defendant, A F Concrete Pumping Pty Limited, who were engaged in a legal dispute. The nature of the dispute was not explicitly stated in the text, but it involved claims for damages and costs. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The primary judgment was delivered on 26 February 2012, and the court reserved the question of costs for further argument.

The legal issues before the court were whether the plaintiffs could make an offer directly to the defendant through another party and if the defendant's refusal to accept the offer was unreasonable. The plaintiffs made a settlement offer through their solicitors to the defendant's solicitors, who then forwarded the offer to the defendant. The plaintiffs argued that the defendant's refusal to accept the offer was unreasonable, and as such, they should be awarded indemnity costs from the last date on which the offer was open. The defendant argued against this, claiming that the offer was unreasonable and that the plaintiffs had not substantially improved their position by litigating their claims.

The court held that the plaintiffs' offer was reasonable and that the defendant's refusal to accept the offer was unreasonable. As such, the court ordered that the defendant pay the plaintiffs' costs on an indemnity basis from the last date on which the offer was open. The court also ordered that the plaintiffs pay their own costs of the proceedings until that date on the ordinary basis. Additionally, the court ordered that the defendant pay the costs of the plaintiffs' unsuccessful claims against the cross-defendant.

In summary, the court found that the plaintiffs' offer was reasonable and that the defendant's refusal to accept the offer was unreasonable. As a result, the court ordered that the defendant pay the plaintiffs' costs on an indemnity basis from the last date on which the offer was open. The plaintiffs were also ordered to pay their own costs of the proceedings until that date on the ordinary basis. Finally, the court ordered that the defendant pay the costs of the plaintiffs' unsuccessful claims against the cross-defendant.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 26 February 2012 I delivered judgment in this matter: Jeffrey Ryan & another v A F Concrete Pumping Pty Ltd & another [2013] NSWSC 113 (the principal judgment). I was asked to reserve the question of costs and hear further argument. I also asked the parties to prepare short minutes to reflect the reasons and to calculate the amount of the judgment. Accordingly I made orders on 14 March 2012 as follows: The parties made various applications for orders other than that costs on the ordinary basis ought follow the event. The plaintiffs applied for an order that the first defendant (A F Concrete) pay their costs on the ordinary basis until 26 November 2012 and on an indemnity basis thereafter. It also applied for a Bullock order that AF Concrete pay any costs the plaintiffs might be ordered to pay the second defendant (C & J), against whom they were unsuccessful. C & J applied for an order that A F Concrete pay its costs of the whole proceedings on an indemnity basis. In the alternative it sought an order that C& J pay its costs on the ordinary basis until 26 November 2012 and then on an indemnity basis thereafter. The cross-defendant (EML) sought an order that A F Concrete pay its costs of its unsuccessful cross-claim against C & J. After considering the parties' written submissions and hearing oral argument, I made the following orders on 14 March 2013: My reasons for making those orders are as follows. By letter dated 25 October 2012 and marked "Without prejudice except as to costs" to the plaintiffs' solicitors, C & J's solicitors sought confirmation that the plaintiffs would settle their claims for $1,625,000 inclusive of costs, workers compensation payments and the interim payment and inquired as to the period of time during which the offer was open. By letter dated 29 October 2012 and marked "Without prejudice" from the plaintiffs' solicitors to C & J's solicitors, the plaintiffs offered to settle the proceedings on the basis of a payment of $1,625,000 inclusive of costs, workers compensation payments and the interim payment. This offer was expressed to remain open for 28 days. C & J's solicitors forwarded these two letters to A F Concrete's solicitors under cover of letter dated 2 November 2012 and offered to contribute 36% to a settlement on that basis. The offer was expressed to remain open until 26 November 2012 and reference to Calderbank v Calderbank [1976] Fam 93 and Messiter v Hutchison (1987) 10 NSWLR 525 was made. This offer was not accepted. It expired on 26 November 2012. The proceedings were not resolved. Mr Ryan (the plaintiff) obtained judgment in the amount of $2,438,405 plus costs. The second plaintiff, Reliance Pools International Pty Limited, obtained judgment in the sum of $200,000 plus costs. On any view the plaintiffs substantially bettered their position by litigating their claims. The plaintiffs submitted that A F Concrete's refusal of their offer was unreasonable and that the Court should order that A F Concrete pay their costs on an indemnity basis from the last date on which the offer was open.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.