RXRZ and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review)

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

RXRZ and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review) [2024] AATA 3542 (7 October 2024)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2023/7883

Re:RXRZ

APPLICANT

AndChild Support Registrar

RESPONDENT

AndXPKP

OTHER PARTY

DECISION

Tribunal:Member L M Gallagher

Date:7 October 2024

Place:Perth

The Reviewable Decision is set aside and substituted with a decision that:

(a)The care period commenced on 10 July 2022.

(b)The care period ended on 29 April 2023.

(c)During the care period, the Applicant had 79% care of the children and the Other Party had 21% care.

(d)The dates of effect of the new care percentage determination are:

(i)For the Applicant:

·     28 July 2022 for child L; and

·     14 August 2022 for child M.

(ii)For the Other Party:

·     9 July 2022 for child L and child M.

........................................................................

Member L M Gallagher

Names used in all published decisions are pseudonyms. Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been removed from this decision and replaced with generic information so as not to identify involved individuals as required by subsections 16(2AB)–16(2AC) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth).

CATCHWORDS

CHILD SUPPORT – percentage of care – whether there was a change in care – actual care – date of effect – evidence – decision under review set aside and substituted

LEGISLATION

Child Support (Assessment) Act (Cth) ss 5(a), 49, 49(1)(a)-(b), 50, 50(1)(a)-(b), 50(3), 51, 54A(1), 54A(3), 54F, 54F(1)(c), 54F(3)(a), 54F(3)(b)(i)-(ii), 54G, 54G(2)(b), 54H, 54H(1)(c), 54H(3)(b)(i)-(ii), 55C

Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth) ss 16(2AB)-16(2AC)

Family Assistance and Child Support Legislation Amendment (Protecting Children) Act 2018 (Cth)

CASES

Minister for Home Affairs v G and Another [2019] FCAFC 79

P v Child Support Registrar [2013] FCA 1312
P v Child Support Registrar [2014] FCAFC 98
Parent 1 and Child Support Registrar and Parent 2 [2013] AATA 562

Polec & Staker & Anor [2011] FMCAfam 959

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Department of Social Services,

Guides to Social Policy Law: Child Support Guide,


para 2.2.1

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member L M Gallagher

7 October 2024

THE APPLICATION

  1. The Applicant and the Other Party are the separated parents of two children, (child L and child M, together, the children).  

  2. The Applicant seeks review of a decision of the Social Services and Child Support Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT1) dated 28 July 2023, that the Applicant had 58% care of the children and the Other Party had 42% care, from 10 July 2022 (the Reviewable Decision).[1]  

    [1] R1, T2. As to date of effect, the AAT1 also found that pursuant to s 54F(3)(a) of the Child Support (Assessment) Act (Cth) (the Assessment Act), the existing care percentage determinations are revoked on the day before the change of care day (R1, T2, p 26).

    ISSUE

  3. The issue for determination by this Tribunal, being the General Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) is the Applicant’s and the Other Party’s respective percentages of care of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read RXRZ and Child Support Registrar (Child support second revie... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] AATA 3542
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a second review before the Tribunal regarding child support assessments. The applicant sought to challenge a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) concerning the percentage of care each party had for their children during a specific period. The dispute centred on whether there had been a change in the pattern of care and, if so, from what date that change took effect.

The Tribunal was required to determine the actual percentage of care provided by the applicant and the other party to the children during the period from 10 July 2022 to 29 April 2023. This involved assessing whether the existing care percentage determination should be revoked and replaced, and crucially, if a change in care had occurred, to identify the precise date from which that change was effective.

The Tribunal considered evidence from both parties regarding the fluctuating care arrangements. The applicant provided journal records and testimony suggesting a significant shift in care, with the other party's involvement progressively declining. The other party's evidence also indicated a gradual decrease in care, initially from full-time care to weekend care, and then further reduction as the children commenced employment and found the travel burdensome. The Tribunal noted that the concept of "care" extends beyond mere overnight stays and does not necessarily require a strict time-based calculation.

Ultimately, the Tribunal was satisfied that the pattern of care had changed during the period under review. It set aside the previous decision and substituted its own findings regarding the percentage of care provided by each party, thereby revoking the existing care percentage determination consistent with its findings.

Background

Background to the litigation

This case concerns a dispute over the percentage of care provided by each parent to their two children over a specified period, from 10 July 2022 to 29 April 2023. The Applicant claims to have had care of the children for 63 out of 283 nights, representing approximately 78.5% of the care, while the Other Party claims a significant reduction in her care due to changes in her daughter's work schedule. Initially, the children stayed with the Other Party from Thursday to Sunday each week, but this arrangement changed as the daughter started working on Friday nights, eventually leading to reduced overnight stays with the Other Party. The children eventually stopped visiting the Other Party entirely, citing the inconvenience of travel and limited time spent together.

The Applicant maintains that the care arrangements fluctuated significantly, with the Other Party's involvement diminishing over time. The Applicant provided a journal of care records to support his claims, which showed a progressive decline in the Other Party's care. The Other Party, however, argued that the children had been living with her full-time before the changes, and the reduction in their visits was due to her daughter's work commitments and the children's frustration with the travel distance. The Other Party testified that the children stopped visiting her entirely in April 2023, attributing this to their dissatisfaction with the arrangement.

This case involves a second review application by the Applicant against a decision made by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) regarding the percentage of care the Applicant and the Other Party had for their children. Initially, on 1 February 2023, a delegate of the Registrar disallowed the Other Party's objection, a decision which was promptly appealed by the Other Party to the AAT. The AAT conducted a first review of the objection decision and issued its Reviewable Decision on 28 July 2023. Unsatisfied with the AAT's determination, the Applicant applied to the Tribunal for a further review of this decision on 24 October 2023. While the application was initially deemed to be outside the prescribed time limit, the Applicant was subsequently granted an extension of time to apply for review on 10 November 2023. Notably, a subsequent care determination was made on 25 October 2023, which recorded that the Applicant provides 100% care for the children from 30 April 2023. This matter now comes before the Tribunal for a second review, with the central issue being the percentage of care each party provided to the children during the relevant care period, and whether there was a change in care, and if so, the date of effect of that change.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Tribunal is satisfied that all the relevant evidence was before the Tribunal and that the parties were provided an opportunity to address it, either orally or in writing.The Parties’ evidence and submissions The Applicant and the Other Party gave evidence and made submissions in support of their respective positions.[44][44] See R1 (various); R2, Attachment B; Transcript, pp 4 to 17.The Applicant The Applicant submitted that his records, including his journal records,[45] indicate that he had care of the children on 63 nights out of 283 nights, between 10 July 2022 and 29 April 2023, which he calculates at 78.5% care by himself and 21.5% care by the Other Party. The Applicant emphasised that this is vastly different to the conclusion reached by the AAT1.[46][45] R1, T1.[46] R2, Attachment B. At hearing the Applicant gave evidence that during the care period, the care arrangements changed and fluctuated, with the Other Party’s care of the children progressively declining during this time. The Applicant confirmed his evidence to the AAT1 that:[47][W]hile [child L] and [child M] did stay with [the Other Party] initially from Thursday to Sunday night every week, they soon stopped going on Thursday nights. [The Applicant] said then the girls stopped going on Friday nights, because [child L] got a job [The Applicant] added that he was uncertain of the exact dates, and would rely on the calendar of care he provided Child Support.[47] Transcript, p 8. The Applicant also gave evidence that child L commenced working on a Friday night on 29 September 2022.[48][48] Following the hearing, at the Tribunal’s request, the Applicant produced documentary evidence confirming child L’s employment commencement date was 29 September 2022. At hearing, the Applicant added:[49]So July school holidays – they probably spent a bit of time with [the Other Party]. And then perhaps again in the September holidays. But July holidays and then it didn’t take very long at all. It was only a few weeks after that where it started going down from four nights to three nights to two nights. It was only a few weeks. Only a matter of weeks.[49] Transcript, p 9.The Other Party When asked about the care arrangements for the children during the care period, the Other Party stated:[50]Well, (indistinct) there was nothing wrong with our relationship at that point. My daughters had been living with me full-time for the previous six months. Happy days. And what happened was my daughter received an apprenticeship that (indistinct) closer to her father. So both the girls, they both went together and started residing there. From then, I saw the girls every Thursday for quite a few months, from Thursday to Sunday. They were here every week. A couple of times we had an argument, they went home, like, on the Sunday or something, you know, early. But for the most part, for about two to three months, they were here from Monday – sorry – Thursday to Sunday. Because my daughter – Monday to Thursday and my other daughter was at school Monday to Thursday. Then what eventually happened was my daughter started working on the Friday. So instead of them coming on a Thursday, they started coming on the Friday night. So that went on for a little while. And then maybe a month or so, and then my daughter started to work late on a Friday. So then again it decreased. They started coming on a Saturday, from Saturday to Sunday. Yes. That’s the – that happened over a slow period of time. …… my daughter started work on a Friday, but I think that was around October. And then it went, like I said, from – yes. It just slowly decreased, until they were coming from Saturday to Sunday, and then they got upset because, you know, they were coming, driving here, and just basically – you know, they were getting up at 1 or 2 o’clock in the afternoon on a Saturday, as teenagers do, and they were coming up here and then sleeping, and then basically, you know, going home the next day, and they got frustrated with that and said that it was too far to come for just one night. And that’s when all of a sudden I just – I haven’t seen them since.[51] So – yes. [50] Transcript, p 11.[51] The Other Party said that it was only in April 2023 that the children stopped coming to stay with her (transcript, p 13).CONSIDERATION

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 1 February 2023, a delegate of the Registrar disallowed the Other Party’s objection (the objection decision).[23][23] R1, T38-T41. The Applicant and the Other Party were advised of the objection decision on the same date. On 22 February 2023, the Other Party applied to the AAT1 for a first review of the objection decision,[24] giving the reason:[25]I do not agree with the CS decision. I provided hard evidence that was not taken into consideration.[24] R1, T42. The application was made within time. [25] R1, T42. On 28 July 2023, the AAT1 made the Reviewable Decision.[26][26] R1, T2. See [2] above. On 24 October 2023, the Applicant applied to the Tribunal for review of the Reviewable Decision.[27] The Application was made outside the prescribed time limit, however on 10 November 2023, the Applicant was granted an extension of time to apply for review.[28][27] R1, T1.[28] R1, T49. On 25 October 2023, a subsequent care determination was made, which recorded that the Applicant provides 100% care for the children from 30 April 2023.[29][29] R2, Attachment A.LEGISLATIVE FRAMEWORK The relevant legislation is contained within the:(a)Assessment Act; the (b)Collection Act; and the(c)Family Assistance and Child Support Legislation Amendment (Protecting Children) Act 2018 (Cth) (the Amendment Act).[30][30] The Amendment Act came into effect on 23 May 2018. Relevantly, the Amendment Act amended some provisions of the Assessment Act. The relevant policy is contained in the Guides to Social Policy Law: Child Support Guide (the Guide). As established in Minister for Home Affairs v G and Another [2019] FCAFC 79 (G), the Tribunal is to apply Ministerial policy, unless there are cogent reasons not to do so.[31][31] G at [57]-[62]. The Assessment Act requires the Registrar to determine a person’s percentage of care where a person has had, or is likely to have:(a)no pattern of care for the child;[32] or(b)a pattern of care that corresponds with the actual care[33] of the child (ss 50(1)(a) and 50(3) of the Assessment Act),[34]during such period (the care period)[35] as the Registrar considers, having regard to all the circumstances.[32] Assessment Act, s 49(1)(a).[33] Section 54A(1) of the Assessment Act provides that the actual care of a child that a person has or is likely to have had may be worked out on the number of nights of care. The concept of ‘care,’ however, is broader than the provision of accommodation on any given night, and percentage of care does not necessarily need to be determined by reference to a time-based calculation (Polec & Staker & Anor [2011] FMCAfam 959 at [56]; P v Child Support Registrar [2013] FCA 1312 at [107]; and P v Child Support Registrar [2014] FCAFC 98 at [47]. See also Parent 1 and Child Support Registrar and Parent 2 [2013] AATA 562 at [33]. [34] Assessment Act, ss 49(1)(b), 50(1)(a)-(b). The Tribunal notes in this context that in the present matter, there is no dispute that the Applicant had a pattern of care during the care period.[35] A ‘care period’ does not have any fixed duration and is generally a 12-month period from the day on which the actual care of a child changed, however there are some circumstances in which a shorter or longer period may be more appropriate (the Guide at 2.2.1). In any event, the relevant care period is now in the past and as such the Tribunal is required to determine the actual care that occurred during the relevant period.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

When asked about the care arrangements for the children during the care period, the Other Party stated:[50]Well, (indistinct) there was nothing wrong with our relationship at that point. My daughters had been living with me full-time for the previous six months. Happy days. And what happened was my daughter received an apprenticeship that (indistinct) closer to her father. So both the girls, they both went together and started residing there. From then, I saw the girls every Thursday for quite a few months, from Thursday to Sunday. They were here every week. A couple of times we had an argument, they went home, like, on the Sunday or something, you know, early. But for the most part, for about two to three months, they were here from Monday – sorry – Thursday to Sunday. Because my daughter – Monday to Thursday and my other daughter was at school Monday to Thursday. Then what eventually happened was my daughter started working on the Friday. So instead of them coming on a Thursday, they started coming on the Friday night. So that went on for a little while. And then maybe a month or so, and then my daughter started to work late on a Friday. So then again it decreased. They started coming on a Saturday, from Saturday to Sunday. Yes. That’s the – that happened over a slow period of time. …… my daughter started work on a Friday, but I think that was around October. And then it went, like I said, from – yes. It just slowly decreased, until they were coming from Saturday to Sunday, and then they got upset because, you know, they were coming, driving here, and just basically – you know, they were getting up at 1 or 2 o’clock in the afternoon on a Saturday, as teenagers do, and they were coming up here and then sleeping, and then basically, you know, going home the next day, and they got frustrated with that and said that it was too far to come for just one night. And that’s when all of a sudden I just – I haven’t seen them since.[51] So – yes. [50] Transcript, p 11.[51] The Other Party said that it was only in April 2023 that the children stopped coming to stay with her (transcript, p 13).CONSIDERATION The Reviewable Decision concerns the care of the children in the period 10 July 2022 (the date of the change in care) to 29 April 2023 (the day prior to the day the Applicant was determined to have 100% care of the children)[52] (the care period). This is uncontroversial.[52] See subsequent care determination detailed at [21] above.Whether the existing care percentage determination should be revoked and replaced The task for the Tribunal is to determine what percentage of care the Applicant and the Other Party each had of the children during the care period, and if there was a change in care, from what date that change in care occurred. If the Tribunal:(a)is satisfied that the pattern of care was 58% to the Applicant and 42% to the Other Party, it should affirm the Reviewable Decision.(b)is not satisfied there was a change in care, it should set aside the Reviewable Decision and restore the existing care percentage determinations.[53](c)is satisfied that the pattern of care was some other percentage between the Applicant and the Other Party, then the Tribunal should revoke the existing care percentage determination consistent with those findings.Was there a change in care? If so, on what date did the change in care occur and what is the date of effect?[53] See [6] above.