RW & Me Smith Pty Ltd v Boral Resources (Vic.) Pty. Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

COURT OF APPEAL

S EAPCI 2022 0055
RW & ME SMITH PTY LTD (ACN 105 445 645) Applicant
v
BORAL RESOURCES (VIC) PTY LTD (ACN 004 620 731) Respondent

---

JUDGES: Sifris JA and J Forrest AJA
WHERE HELD: Melbourne
DATE OF HEARING: 28 September 2022 
DATE OF JUDGMENT: 4 October 2022
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: [2022] VSCA 216
JUDGMENT APPEALED FROM: [2022] VCC 729 (Judge A Ryan)

---

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Application for leave to appeal – Security for costs – Impecuniosity – Reasonable prospects of success of leave to appeal application – Whether order for security for costs of application for leave to appeal would stultify a reasonably arguable case – Discretionary factors – Application for security for costs dismissed – Mikkelsen v Li [2022] VSCA 126, discussed.

---

Counsel

Applicant: Mr L Magowan
Respondent: Mr O Fagir

Solicitors

Applicant: Aitken Partners
Respondent: Australian Business Lawyers & Advisors

SIFRIS JA
J FORREST AJA:

Introduction

  1. In August 2020, RW & ME Smith Pty Ltd (‘Smith P/L’) issued a County Court proceeding against Boral Resources (Vic) Pty Ltd (‘Boral’). The central allegation is that Boral, in July 2015, unlawfully terminated a cartage agreement (‘the Agreement’) between the two companies.

  2. After a five-day trial in May and June 2021, the County Court judge, on 30 May 2022, dismissed the claim and ordered Smith P/L to pay Boral’s costs.[1]

  3. Smith P/L has now sought leave to appeal. Boral in this application seeks that Smith P/L provide security for its costs in the sum of $40,000.

  4. Smith P/L is operated by Mr Robert William Smith (‘Mr Smith’). Mr Smith and his wife are the directors and shareholders of the company. Boral owns and operates a concrete plant (‘the plant’) at Swan Hill.

  5. The Agreement is dated 1 August 2014 and is described as a ‘Concrete Cartage Agreement’.

  6. By clause 22.2 of the Agreement, Boral was entitled to immediately terminate the Agreement in the event of ‘a material or wilful breach’ by Smith P/L of any of its terms. Boral contended that Mr Smith’s actions on 9 July 2015 (discussed in a moment) breached its safety policies and procedures. Boral was also entitled by clause 22.4 to terminate the Agreement without cause on three months’ notice to Smith P/L.

  7. Her Honour’s findings of fact at [15] can be summarised as follows: On 9 July 2015 at about 6.30 am, Mr Smith, at the request of a Mr Neil Congram (‘Mr Congram’), the acting site manager (and an employee of Boral), attended the plant to assist with the repairs of a drive chain on a ‘head drum’. Mr Smith, at Mr Congram’s request, ascended a ladder and identified that the chain was detached. Boral could not obtain the services of a contract mechanic, so Mr Smith, at Mr Congram’s request, carried out the repairs to the chain over a period of two hours.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read RW & Me Smith Pty Ltd v Boral Resources (Vic.) Pty. Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] VSCA 216
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of RW & Me Smith Pty Ltd v Boral Resources (Vic.) Pty. Ltd involved an application for leave to appeal from a lower court's decision, with an accompanying application for security for costs. The appellant, RW & Me Smith Pty Ltd, sought leave to appeal against the decision of the Supreme Court of Victoria, which had dismissed their claim. The respondent, Boral Resources (Vic.) Pty. Ltd, argued that the appellant should provide security for the costs of the appeal as a prerequisite to proceeding with the application for leave.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the appellant's impecuniosity and the arguable merits of their case justified the dismissal of the respondent's application for security for costs. The court needed to weigh the discretionary factors in deciding whether the order for security would stultify a reasonably arguable case. The appellant contended that the order would indeed stultify their case, while the respondent maintained that security should be required to protect their interests.

The court considered the principle in Mikkelsen v Li [2022] VSCA 126, which emphasised the importance of considering the merits of the appeal application in the context of granting security for costs. The court concluded that the appellant's impecuniosity and the arguable merits of the appeal application warranted dismissing the respondent's application for security for costs. The court found that ordering security for costs would likely stultify the appellant's reasonably arguable case, and thus dismissed the application.

As a result of the court's decision, the application for security for costs was dismissed, and the appellant was allowed to proceed with their application for leave to appeal without providing security for costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case concerns a dispute between RW & Me Smith Pty Ltd (the applicant) and Boral Resources (Vic.) Pty. Ltd (the respondent) regarding an application for leave to appeal. The applicant had previously been involved in litigation with the respondent and was seeking leave to appeal from a decision made by a lower court. As part of the application for leave to appeal, the respondent sought an order for the applicant to provide security for the costs of the appeal. The applicant contested the requirement for security for costs, arguing that it would stultify their reasonably arguable case and that they were impecunious, meaning they lacked the financial means to provide such security. The case hinged on whether the court should exercise its discretion to require security for costs and the factors to be considered in making that decision.

The matter came before the court as an application for leave to appeal from an earlier decision made by the Supreme Court of Victoria. The applicant had applied for leave to appeal, and the respondent opposed the application and sought security for the costs of the appeal. The court heard arguments from both parties regarding the requirement for security for costs and the applicant's impecuniosity. This was not the first time the court had to consider the issue of security for costs in the context of an application for leave to appeal, as the case Mikkelsen v Li [2022] VSCA 126 had also dealt with similar issues. The court had to determine whether to grant the application for leave to appeal and whether to require the applicant to provide security for the costs of the appeal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the court should exercise its discretion to require the applicant to provide security for the costs of the application for leave to appeal.
2. Whether the applicant's impecuniosity should be considered in the decision regarding security for costs.
3. Whether the order for security for costs would stultify a reasonably arguable case.
4. What discretionary factors should be considered in deciding whether to require security for costs in this case.

Held
1. The court decided that it would not exercise its discretion to require the applicant to provide security for the costs of the application for leave to appeal.
2. The applicant's impecuniosity was considered in the decision regarding security for costs.
3. The court concluded that an order for security for costs would not stultify a reasonably arguable case.
4. The discretionary factors considered in deciding whether to require security for costs in this case included the merits of the applicant's case, the public interest, and the need to avoid an oppressive or unfair outcome.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the matter of whether it should exercise its discretion to require the applicant to provide security for the costs of the application for leave to appeal. It noted that the decision was discretionary and should be exercised sparingly. The court considered the case of Mikkelsen v Li [2022] VSCA 126, which outlined the relevant principles and factors. The applicant's impecuniosity was considered as one of the factors but was not determinative. The court found that the applicant had a reasonably arguable case for leave to appeal, and an order for security for costs would not stultify this case. The court also took into account the public interest and the need to avoid an oppressive or unfair outcome. In light of these considerations, the court decided that it was not appropriate to require the applicant to provide security for the costs of the application for leave to appeal. The ratio decidendi of this case is that the court will consider a range of discretionary factors, including the merits of the applicant's case, the public interest, and the need to avoid an oppressive or unfair outcome, when deciding whether to require security for costs in an application for leave to appeal.