RW & G Johnston Pty Ltd v Workers Compensation Regulator

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION

CITATION:

RW & G Johnston Pty Ltd v Workers Compensation Regulator [2022] QIRC 078

PARTIES:

RW & G Johnston Pty Ltd
(Applicant)

v

Workers Compensation Regulator
(Respondent)

&

Peta Durston
(Interested Party)

CASE NO:

WC/2021/146

PROCEEDING:

Application in existing proceedings

DELIVERED ON:

7 March 2022
HEARING DATE: 

7 March 2022

MEMBER:

Industrial Commissioner Dwyer
HEARD AT:

Brisbane

ORDER:

1.   Application granted.

2.   Full orders as per last page of decision.

CATCHWORDS:

INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS – WORKERS COMPENSATION APPEAL – application in a proceeding – application by Appellant for order that the worker submit for medical examination – whether Commission should exercise its discretion to make an order - application granted

LEGISLATION:

Workers Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2016 (Qld) s 32, 556

CASES:

Grant v BHP Coal Proprietary Limited (No 2) (2015) 67 AILR 102

Gray v Hopcroft & Anor [2000] QCA 144

Yarrabee Coal Company Pty Ltd v Simon Blackwood (Workers’ Compensation Regulator) [2014] QIRC 028

APPEARANCES:

Mr G. Cross of Counsel instructed by Everingham Lawyers for the Applicant.

Mr M. Cutting of the Workers' Compensation Regulator, Respondent.

Mr K. Stegeman of GKS Law for Ms Peta Durston, interested party.

Reasons for Decision

Delivered ex tempore on 7 March 2022

Background

  1. On 15 February 2022, the Appellant in the substantive appeal (matter WC/2021/146) filed an application in proceedings ('the application') seeking inter alia, an order pursuant to section 556 of the Workers Compensation and Rehabilitation Act ('the Act') that:

    the worker submit to a personal examination by Dr Martin Nothling, psychiatrist, on the 14th of April 2022 at 9.30 am.[1]

    [1] Form 4 filed 15 February 2022.

  2. The application is accompanied by an affidavit sworn on 15 February 2022 by Mr Paul Everingham, solicitor for the Appellant. The affidavit of Mr Everingham contends that the medical condition of the claimant is a 'substantive issue' in the appeal. 

  3. In the affidavit, Mr Everingham notes that the only medical evidence that is on record has been supplied by the Respondent in the substantive appeal namely, the Workers Compensation Regulator ('the Regulator').  At the time of filing of the affidavit the only medical evidence available was from:

    ·Dr Lucy Ritchie, a general practitioner; and

    ·Mr Brendan Elliott, a psychologist.

  4. Mr Everingham in his affidavit contends that it is 'just and equitable' that the Applicant be allowed to procure a medical report of its own.

  5. Subsequent to the filing of the application and affidavit of Mr Everingham, the Regulator disclosed to the Applicant further medical evidence in the form of a medico-legal report from Dr Charana Perera, consultant psychiatrist. The report of Dr Perera is dated 24 February 2022 and appears to have been produced at the request of WorkCover Queensland, that is, it was not produced at the request of the Regulator or at the request of the injured worker in contemplation of the substantive appeal proceedings in this matter.

  6. It is not entirely clear, but it would seem from the multiple consultations referred to in Dr Perera's report…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read RW & G Johnston Pty Ltd v Workers Compensation Regulator and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] QIRC 78
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

RW & G Johnston Pty Ltd appealed against a decision of the Workers Compensation Regulator. The appeal was concerned with whether the injured worker should be required to submit to a medical examination. The Court was required to determine whether the Commission should exercise its discretion to make an order for a medical examination. Section 556(2) of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (Vic) provides a discretion for the Commission to make orders requiring a medical examination. This discretion can be exercised where the circumstances of section 556(1) are met. The discretion is one that ought to be exercised with care. The common law and statutory history of orders for medical examination provide that a person is not obliged to submit to a medical examination without their consent. However, legislation can require a person to submit to a medical examination without their consent if it is clear and unambiguous. The legislation granting the power to order a medical examination is clear and unambiguous. The injured worker consents to an examination, albeit there is a dispute as to the timing and the doctor. The Court found that the circumstances of section 556(1) were met, and the application was granted.

The Court found that the injured worker contends that she was subject to abusive and aggressive behaviour from her employer on 9 March 2021. The employer denies being abusive or aggressive and refers to the injured worker as 'no shrinking violet'. The basis of the appeal made by the Applicant in the substantive matter is wholly a factual challenge. It is broadly contended by the Applicant that the injured worker's assertion of verbal abuse is false. The Court found that the injured worker's diagnoses of major depressive disorder, acute stress reaction with panic attacks, and adjustment disorder with mixed anxiety and depressed mood meet the definition of 'personal injury' for the purposes of section 32(1) of the Act. The Court found that the circumstances of section 556(1) were met, and the application was granted.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Application granted.

2. Full orders as per last page of decision.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

At all times in this issue, the Regulator has taken a passive approach to the application.Consideration Section 556(2) of the Act relevantly provides:(1) This section applies if—(a) the condition of a claimant or worker who has, or is said to have, sustained an injury is relevant to the appeal; or(b) the cause, nature or extent of the injury or incapacity arising from the injury is relevant to the appeal.(2)The appeal body may, at any time before or after the start of the hearing, order the claimant or worker to submit to a personal examination by 1 or more specified registered persons. Section 556(2) of the Act contains a discretion for the Commission to make orders requiring a medical examination. The discretion can be exercised where the circumstances of section 556(1) are met. The discretion is one that ought to be exercised with care. Ordering a medical examination of an individual, especially against their will, is a significant step. In her decision of Grant v BHP Coal Proprietary Limited (No 2)[2] Collier J examined the common law and statutory history of orders for medical examination and concluded (at paragraph 127 of that decision) that:Examining these authorities, the following is clear: ·as a general proposition, a person is not obliged to submit to a medical examination without his or her consent. A forced examination of a person without the consent of the person is assault. ·Legislation can require a person to submit to a medical examination without his or her consent, however, such legislation must be clear and unambiguous.·…(Citations removed) [2] [2015] FCA 1374. There are two notable facts in the matter before me: firstly, the legislation granting the power to order a medical examination is clear and unambiguous and secondly, the injured worker consents to an examination, albeit there is a dispute as to the timing and the doctor. Notwithstanding the statutory power is clear and there is consent by the injured worker, it remains necessary for me to determine whether the circumstances of section 556(1) are met. Before turning to the provisions of section 556(1), it is necessary to consider the nature of the substantive dispute between the parties. In essence, the injured worker contends that she was subject to abusive and aggressive behaviour from her employer on 9 March 2021. It is a singular event that led to her injury and she has been diagnosed (variously) as suffering from:·major depressive disorder by Dr Perera;·acute stress reaction with panic attacks by Dr Ritchie; and·adjustment disorder with mixed anxiety and depressed mood by Dr Elliott. I note that each of these diagnoses meets the definition of 'personal injury' for the purposes of section 32(1) of the Act. The Applicant contests the acceptance of the injured worker's claim by WorkCover and subsequently by the Regulator. The basis of the appeal made by the Applicant in the substantive matter is wholly a factual challenge. That is to say, it is broadly contended by the Applicant that the injured worker's assertion of verbal abuse is false. It is further contended (by reference to the workers compensation claim) that the injured worker had been 'setting this up for weeks'. The employer broadly denies being abusive or aggressive and refers to the injured worker as 'no shrinking violet'. I note that these are factual arguments without any medical element.