Russo v Buck

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court: Civil)

RUSSO v BUCK & ANOR

[2007] SASC 423

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Justice Duggan, The Honourable Justice Bleby and The Honourable Justice Layton)

5 December 2007

GUARANTEE AND INDEMNITY - THE CONTRACT OF GUARANTEE - CONSTRUCTION AND EFFECT - EXTENT OF LIABILITY

Appeal against order by trial judge dismissing claim to set aside contract of loan and mortgage – whether trial judge erred in making particular findings of fact – whether contract, as performed, was illegal and whether illegality prevented respondents from recovering on the contract – discussion of principles relating to illegality of contract – where argument based on illegality not raised on the pleadings and not argued at trial – Held: no error by trial Judge in findings of fact – failure to raise illegality argument at trial precludes appellant from raising it on appeal – no relevant illegality demonstrated in any event – appeal dismissed.

PROCEDURE - COSTS - APPEALS AS TO COSTS

Appeal against order by trial Judge that appellant pay half of the respondents' costs of the action on an indemnity basis – mortgage agreement contained a clause requiring the appellant to indemnify the respondents in respect of any challenge to or resistance of the respondents’ rights under the mortgage – appellant successful in part at first instance – whether question of costs should have been delayed until determination of what, if anything, the appellant owed the respondents under the loan agreement or under the mortgage – discussion of principles relating to interference with a costs order – Held: no error, unreasonableness or injustice demonstrated – appeal as to costs dismissed.

Fair Trading Act 1987 (SA) s 56; Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006 (SA) r 264, referred to.
University of Woollongong v Metwally (No 2) (1985) 59 ALJR 481; Water Board v Moustakas (1988) 180 CLR 491; Holman v Johnson (1775) 1 Cowp 341; Waugh v Morris (1873) LR 8 QB 202; Southern Resources Ltd v Residues Treatment & Trading Co Ltd (1990) 56 SASR 455, applied.
Yango Pastoral Co Pty Ltd v First Chicago Australia Ltd (1978) 139 CLR 410, discussed.
Seal v Malaugh Holdings (No 2) Pty Ltd [2007] SASC 388; Suttor v Gondowda Pty Ltd (1950) 81 CLR 418; Coulton v Holcombe (1986) 162 CLR 1; O'Brien v Komesaroff (1982) 150 CLR 310; Wetherell v Jones (1832) 3 B & Ad 221; Ashmore Benson Pease & Co Ltd v AV Dawson Ltd [1973] 1 WLR 828; TP Rich Investments Pty Ltd v Calderon [1964] NSWR 709; St John Shipping Corporation v Joseph Rank Ltd [1957] 1 QB 267, considered.

RUSSO v BUCK & ANOR
[2007] SASC 423

Full Court:  Duggan, Bleby and Layton JJ

  1. DUGGAN J.         I agree that the appeal should be dismissed for the reasons prepared by Bleby J.

    BLEBY J.

    Background

  2. For the purposes of this appeal, the relevant facts are within a relatively narrow compass.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Russo v Buck and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] SASC 423
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Russo v Buck, the appellant, Mr Russo, appealed against the orders of the trial judge. The central issue was whether the trial judge erred in making specific findings of fact regarding the contract of loan and mortgage. Additionally, the court had to determine if the contract, as performed, was illegal, which would have precluded the respondents from recovering on the contract. The appeal also addressed the costs order, which required the appellant to pay half of the respondents' costs of the action on an indemnity basis.

The court considered the principles relating to the illegality of a contract and found that the argument based on illegality was not raised on the pleadings nor argued at the trial. The court held that there was no error by the trial judge in the findings of fact. The failure to raise the illegality argument at trial precluded the appellant from raising it on appeal. Furthermore, the court found no relevant illegality demonstrated in any event. Therefore, the appeal was dismissed.

The appeal against the costs order was also dismissed. The mortgage agreement contained a clause that required the appellant to indemnify the respondents in respect of any challenge to or resistance of the respondents’ rights under the mortgage. The court held that there was no error, unreasonableness, or injustice demonstrated in the costs order, and thus the appeal was dismissed.

The court's decision upheld the trial judge's findings and conclusions, affirming that the respondents were entitled to claim repayment of the first loan. The court also dismissed the claims made by Mr Russo against PFM and Ms Conn. The determination of the amount due and owing by Mr Russo to Mr and Mrs Buck was referred to a master.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr and Mrs Buck sought possession of the land following default by Mr Russo under the first and second loan agreements and the mortgage. Mr Russo then brought this action seeking declaratory and other relief in order to avoid delivery up of possession of the land to Mr and Mrs Buck, and seeking to have the first and second loan agreements and the mortgage set aside. In addition to the matters to which I have already referred, in seeking to avoid liability under the loan agreements for the first and second loans, Mr Russo relied on alleged misleading and deceptive conduct of the defendants within the meaning and for the purposes of s 56 of the Fair Trading Act 1987 (SA), misrepresentation by the defendants and unconscionable conduct. He also claimed damages against the defendants. All those claims were dismissed by the trial Judge and are not the subject of any appeal.The facts giving rise to the appeal As previously noted, the monies constituting the first loan were paid on Friday 16 March 2001. On that day cheques were either drawn by PFM on PFM’s trust account, or bank cheques were obtained by PFM and debited to that account. However, the cheque from Mr and Mrs Buck providing the funds to PFM for the purposes of the loan was not received and banked by PFM until Monday 19 March 2001, three days later. At trial, Mr Russo claimed that the advance could not have been made by Mr and Mrs Buck, as they had provided no funds to PFM on 16 March 2001, when the loan was actually made. An amendment to the plaintiff’s statement of claim giving effect to that contention was not made until well into the defendants’ case at the trial and was only made after tender of the relevant documents and after oral evidence of the defendants which established the timing of the relevant events. Mr Russo’s plea was that Mr and Mrs Buck had never paid the sum of $80,000 or any money to the plaintiff under the loan agreement, and that if the court found that the sum of $80,000 or any part thereof was paid to or at the direction of Mr Russo, it was money paid by clients of PFM other than Mr and Mrs Buck, and without the knowledge and consent of those clients. At the trial Ms Conn gave evidence that a Mr Michael Sultana was another investor client of PFM and that the funds used to effect the advance to Mr Russo under the loan agreement comprised, in part, PFM’s own funds, and, in part, funds held by PFM for Mr Sultana. Both Ms Conn and Mr Sultana gave evidence concerning an agreement between PFM and Mr Sultana whereby PFM was authorised by Mr Sultana to use monies held by PFM on his behalf provided that it did not affect Mr Sultana’s own investment activities. Ms Conn said that, although not obliged to do so, she would usually contact Mr Sultana prior to using his funds, but she did not recall specifically whether she spoke with Mr Sultana on this occasion and advised him that she was using funds held by PFM to settle the advance on the first loan. Mr Sultana said that Ms Conn would always contact him on behalf of PFM prior to using funds held on his behalf and that that was part of the arrangement. He could not recall whether Ms Conn specifically contacted him in relation to the use of funds for this transaction.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

DUGGAN J BLEBY J
Both witnesses were giving evidence at very short notice about a single transaction which had occurred more than five and a half years previously.The trial Judge’s relevant findings and conclusion The trial Judge accepted Ms Conn’s evidence and that of Mr Sultana, that Ms Conn had a standing arrangement with Mr Sultana under which she was permitted to use funds subject to his direction to cover another’s need for funds for a short period. However, no finding was made as to what Ms Conn actually did or intended to do in relation to Mr Sultana’s funds on the occasion in question. The Judge considered that the evidence was not clear enough to make a finding. In his view, that did not matter. The trial Judge concluded:The fact that for a period of several days the loan was funded from an unidentified source does not alter things. Once the Bucks’ funds became available, those funds became the source of the advance to Mr Russo. But in the interim period, as between Mr Russo and the Bucks, the Bucks are to be treated as the source of the funds advanced, even if the Bucks were liable to repay to someone else the initial advance of the moneys loaned and to pay interest on that amount for the first few days.…It may be that Ms Conn used the funds of another client without proper authority from that client. It may be that she has not accounted to another client for interest in respect of funds provided to Mr Russo for the first few days. Ms Conn’s evidence indicates that she dealt with client funds rather casually in some respects. But that does not alter the contractual position as between Mr Russo and the Bucks. In one way or another, acting on behalf of the Bucks, Ms Conn provided the funds to or at the direction of Mr Russo to enable the Bucks to meet their obligation to Mr Russo. The fact (if it is the case) that she acted in breach of trust, and used client funds without proper authority, does not mean that as between Mr Russo and the Bucks the funds are not to be treated as advanced by the Bucks. The claim that Mr and Mrs Buck never advanced the sum of $80,000 to Mr Russo was rejected. The Judge held that Mr and Mrs Buck were entitled to claim repayment of the first loan even if the monies advanced came from another source pending receipt by PFM of the funds from Mr and Mrs Buck several days after the advance was made. Mr Russo appeals against the relevant findings and conclusion of the trial Judge.The costs order The trial Judge dismissed Mr Russo’s claim that the contract of loan and mortgage be set aside. He dismissed the claims made by Mr Russo against PFM and Ms Conn. Because there was evidence that some payments had been made by Mr Buttigieg to Mr and Mrs Buck and because the second purported contract of loan had been set aside, the Judge ordered that the determination of the amount due and owing, if any, by Mr Russo to Mr and Mrs Buck pursuant to the first contract of loan, or otherwise due and payable and secured by the memorandum of mortgage, be referred to a master.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: DUGGAN J, BLEBY J

Full text does not contain this section.