Russo v Belcar Pty Ltd ACN 967 286 081

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court: Civil)

RUSSO v BELCAR PTY LTD ACN 967 286 081 & ANOR

[2011] SASCFC 151

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Justice Gray, The Honourable Justice Sulan and The Honourable Justice Peek)

16 December 2011

CONTRACTS - GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES

SALE OF GOODS - CONDITIONS AND WARRANTIES - IMPLIED CONDITIONS AND WARRANTIES - QUALITY OR FITNESS FOR PARTICULAR PURPOSE - MERCHANTABLE QUALITY

Appeal from civil claim following trial in District Court – plaintiff ordered a 360 Modena F1 Ferrari from defendant – a lengthy litany of complaints was made to the defendant as to the state of the vehicle – trial Judge dismissed claim against defendant on the facts.

Whether the vehicle was fit for its purpose – whether the vehicle was of merchantable quality – whether the plaintiff had an entitlement to rescind – whether purported rescission was legally effective.

Held:  Appeal dismissed.

Per Gray and Sulan JJ:  The plaintiff affirmed the contract of purchase – rescission not made within a reasonable time – circumstances demonstrate an acceptance of the vehicle – plaintiff never established any entitlement to rescind – any breach to be treated as a breach of warranty rather than a ground for rejecting the vehicle or treating the contract as repudiated.

Per Peek J: Plaintiff deemed to have accepted the car pursuant to s 35 of the Sale of Goods Act 1895 by reason of his continued possession and acquiescence in the performance of warranty work by defendant – plaintiff compelled to treat any breach of a condition on the part of the defendant as a breach of warranty – plaintiff did not unequivocally reject the vehicle – any purported rejection was too late.

No evidence to support any representation or misrepresentation preventing acceptance under s 35 – trial Judge correct in finding that the defendant was not estopped, that acceptance was not induced by misleading or deceptive conduct, that plaintiff not entitled to award of damages in consequence of reliance upon representations or misrepresentations as claimed.

Trial Judge correct in finding that taking the plaintiff’s complaints individually and cumulatively, it was still not established that the car was not of merchantable quality, nor fit for its purpose – trial Judge correctly concluded that it had not been established that the alleged problems existed at the time of delivery as distinct from developing later.

Sale of Goods Act 1895 s 11, s 13, s 14, s 34, s 35, s 36, s 41, s 52; Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth); Fair Trading Act 1987 (SA), referred to.
Annand & Thompson Pty Ltd v Trade Practices Commission (1979) 25 ALR 91; R v Ford Motor Co Ltd (1974) 1 WLR 1220; Graanhandel The Vink BV v European Grain & Shipping Ltd [1989] 2 Lloyd's Rep 531; Trevilyan v Donaldson & Anor (1997) 196 LSJS 26; Whitecap Leisure Ltd v John H Rundle Ltd (2008) EWCA Civ 429; Attorney-General of Botswana v Aussie Diamond Products Pty Ltd (No…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Russo v Belcar Pty Ltd ACN 967 286 081 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] SASCFC 151
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involved an appeal from a civil claim heard in the District Court. The plaintiff, Mr Russo, had ordered a new Ferrari 360 Modena F1 from the defendant, Belcar Pty Ltd. Following delivery, Mr Russo made numerous complaints regarding the condition of the vehicle. The trial judge had dismissed Mr Russo's claim against the defendant.

The legal issues before the appellate court included whether the vehicle was fit for its intended purpose, whether it was of merchantable quality, and whether Mr Russo had a legal entitlement to rescind the contract, and if so, whether his purported rescission was legally effective. A significant point of contention was whether the trial judge had erred in his assessment of the evidence, particularly in relation to circumstantial evidence and latent defects, and whether he had failed to consider the cumulative effect of various defects.

The appellate court, comprising Gray, Sulan, and Peek JJ, affirmed the trial judge's decision. The court reasoned that the trial judge had properly considered the evidence, both individually and cumulatively, and had correctly concluded that the plaintiff had not established that the alleged defects, such as engine problems, gear selection issues, or paint imperfections, existed at the time of delivery. The court found no substance in the appellant's arguments regarding implied conditions under the Sale of Goods Act, noting that the theory of a common cause for the defects had diminished after the trial judge's finding that the car was new and had not been misused. The court agreed with the trial judge's assessment that the plaintiff had not proven that the vehicle was not of merchantable quality or fit for purpose at the time of delivery.

The appeal was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The trial Judge rejected all the above claims. In my view, he was correct in so doing and the appeal should be dismissed. My reasons follow. Background matters of fact The following matters were agreed between the parties or were unchallenged findings by the Judge. On 28 October 1999 Russo ordered the car and on 31 May 2001 he was informed that it was to be manufactured in the month of September 2001. He provided his required specifications including the external and internal colours and certain accessories. The car was then built and test driven in Italy and shipped to Maranello Imports in Sydney. On arrival the odometer read 99km. On 20 November 2001, an initial pre-delivery inspection (including the body and paintwork under lighting) was carried out by Scuderia Veloce Motors on behalf of Maranello Imports. On 3 December 2001, Mr Lenn Kench (Kench), the National Service Manager of Maranello, inspected the car and signed a Ferrari body sheet which noted some minor body damage only.[1][1] Exhibit P1-42. The car was then transported from Sydney to Adelaide by TNT Automotive Logistics (TNT) and was initially taken to the TNT depot at Wingfield and then to the Prestige’s premises at Frewville. On 3 December 2001 an employee of Prestige signed a TNT consignment note which recorded minor body damage in a number of places.[2] Exhibit P1-41, a Ferrari body sheet, was completed by Mr Tony Cocca (Cocca), a mechanic employed by Prestige, who recorded “thin paint” at the top of the driver’s door, a “visible repair” above the left rear quarter panel and a “chip” on the right front.[3] (As will be shown to be relevant to “the blend line argument” considered below, no body damage or paint imperfection on the right rear quarter panel was recorded in relation to any of the above inspections).[2] Exhibit P1-39.[3] Exhibit P1-41. When the car arrived in Adelaide the battery was flat. On 3 December 2001 Prestige employees noted that the odometer reading was not correct; it had suddenly changed from about 100km (as referred to above) to 555,560km and “X” was shown on the visual display unit which indicated that it was inoperative. His Honour found that this was caused by the battery having gone flat, there being evidence that a “spiking” current which occurs when a vehicle is jump started can cause such a malfunction. On 6 December 2001, Cocca carried out a pre-delivery service at Prestige, briefly road tested the car and filled it with petrol. On 7 December 2001 Prestige gave Russo a tax invoice for $400,000 in addition to the previous $5,000 deposit. His Honour found that some time during December 2001 a replacement instrument panel was received from the Ferrari factory in Italy, that it incorrectly read 555km rather than about 100km as it should have and that it was installed between 19 and 20 December 2001.The contract documentation The agreed documents include a “Contract for the Sale of a New Vehicle” dated 22 December 2001[4] which was signed on behalf of the defendant but not by the plaintiff, although Russo’s name has been printed in the appropriate space. The parties agree that the settlement sum was paid on 24 December 2001.[4] Exhibit P1-50.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

As referred to above in the context of the new car dispute, his Honour specifically rejected the evidence of Russo and found that he did not raise the blend line complaint until July 2004. Again, his Honour found the matter of the blend line did not lead to a right to terminate for two reasons. First, it was not established by Russo that the blend line existed at the time of delivery. Second, once again Russo did not reject the car on the basis of that matter. His Honour further found that Prestige offered to repair the defect but Russo declined the offer. The appellant’s argument as to circumstantial evidence and latent defects In conjunction with the above complaints, the appellant developed an argument that his Honour had approached his task of assessing the relevant evidence incorrectly. Ground 4(e) of appeal is as follows:4 The trial judge erred and the trial of the action miscarried, in that he:e.erred in his approach to, and assessment of, circumstantial evidence, in concluding that:(i)there was “no evidence” [162], [174] that the Ferrari 360 was not of merchantable quality at the time it was delivered to the appellant;(ii)there was “no evidence” [164] that the Ferrari 360 was not fit for purpose at the time it was delivered to the appellant.The trial judge ought to have considered the cumulative effect of the proved defects (rather than each defect in isolation) and ought, accordingly, to have held, the Ferrari 360 to be not of merchantable quality, and unfitted for any of the identified purposes. The way in which the appellant developed this argument is adequately summarised in his outline of argument as follows:16.1The trial judge failed to consider the cumulative force of various defects with the Ferrari 360, some of which manifested over time, and how these to an extent corroborated each other. His Honour considered and disposed of each suggested defect in isolation from the others, and in so doing failed to consider the united force of all of the circumstances taken together.(Emphasis added) The appellant’s submission later continued thus:18.At the trial evidence was called about a catalogue of defects in the Ferrari 360. … In addressing the trial judge’s failure to consider the cumulative effect of the defects these submissions focus on the following defects:18.1 the engine defects;18.2 the gear box and clutch defects;18.3the blend line in the paintwork on the right hand quarter panel (and its link with the misalignment of the rear hatch).19.Although the nature of the vehicle must be assessed at the time of delivery, to meet that condition it must be such as to continue in a state of merchantable quality and being fit for its purposes for a reasonable period of time. This is because an inference about its state at the time of delivery may be drawn from its subsequent performance. The trial judge was asked to draw an inference about the merchantable quality and fitness for purpose of the Ferrari 360, based on evidence of defects, including defects which became apparent after delivery, and in circumstances where it was established by unchallenged evidence that there was no impact to the vehicle when it was in Russo’s custody, and no unreasonable use of it by him. It was the appellant’s case at trial that the Ferrari 360 revealed problems soon after delivery, in particular with the engine and the gearbox which respectively resulted in the engine being completely replaced in May 2002, and the clutch kit being replaced in March 2004.(Footnotes omitted, emphasis added)Conclusion as to the SGA s 14 implied conditions

Decision

Reasons for decision

The appellant’s submission later continued thus:18.At the trial evidence was called about a catalogue of defects in the Ferrari 360. … In addressing the trial judge’s failure to consider the cumulative effect of the defects these submissions focus on the following defects:18.1 the engine defects;18.2 the gear box and clutch defects;18.3the blend line in the paintwork on the right hand quarter panel (and its link with the misalignment of the rear hatch).19.Although the nature of the vehicle must be assessed at the time of delivery, to meet that condition it must be such as to continue in a state of merchantable quality and being fit for its purposes for a reasonable period of time. This is because an inference about its state at the time of delivery may be drawn from its subsequent performance. The trial judge was asked to draw an inference about the merchantable quality and fitness for purpose of the Ferrari 360, based on evidence of defects, including defects which became apparent after delivery, and in circumstances where it was established by unchallenged evidence that there was no impact to the vehicle when it was in Russo’s custody, and no unreasonable use of it by him. It was the appellant’s case at trial that the Ferrari 360 revealed problems soon after delivery, in particular with the engine and the gearbox which respectively resulted in the engine being completely replaced in May 2002, and the clutch kit being replaced in March 2004.(Footnotes omitted, emphasis added)Conclusion as to the SGA s 14 implied conditions I consider that there is no substance in these grounds or any of the arguments advanced by the appellant in relation to the SGA s 14 implied conditions. The theory of the various problems all having a common cause was originally part of the argument that the car was not “new”: it was postulated that some one had “used and abused” the car in ways that caused damage to the car, in some respects obvious (see the list of items alleged to display excessive wear dealt with seriatim above) and in other respects such as to cause latent damage which would only emerge in time, of which the engine and the rear selection problems were said to be the main exemplars. However, in the wake of his Honour’s finding that the car was new and that there was no such abuser, the theory of a common cause of various alleged defects commensurately dwindled. I have referred above to Russo’s various complaints in my consideration of the matters relied upon by him in support of his contention that the car was not new and of the trial Judge’s rejection of Russo’s case in that regard. His Honour also found that, taken individually and cumulatively, these complaints did not establish that the car was not of merchantable quality. On balance, I consider that the appellant has not succeeded in establishing that such finding constituted appellable error. In my view, his Honour did have proper regard to the various matters referred to by the appellant both individually and in a cumulative way but ultimately came to the correct conclusion that it had not been established by the appellant that such matters as the problem alleged to exist with the engine, the gear selection problem or the blend line defect in fact did exist at the time of delivery to Russo as distinct from developing later.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.