Russell v City of Melbourne

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

COURT OF APPEAL

S EAPCI 2022 0059
JOHN (JACK) RUSSELL Applicant
v
CITY OF MELBOURNE Respondent

---

JUDGES: KYROU, McLEISH and NIALL JJA
WHERE HELD: Melbourne
DATE OF HEARING: 6 March 2023 
DATE OF JUDGMENT: 1 May 2023
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: [2023] VSCA 97
JUDGMENT APPEALED FROM: [2022] VCC 476 (Judge Pillay)

---

PUBLIC LIABILITY – Judge relied on transcript of applicant’s evidence in dismissing claim – Whether transcript erroneous – Evidence was applicant tripped ‘upon’ unseen depression whereas transcript erroneously recorded applicant saying he tripped ‘in front of’ unseen depression – Reliance on erroneous transcript a material error.

PUBLIC LIABILITY – Judge said applicant never raised issue about the joining edge between asphalt and concrete pad – Applicant’s frequent reference to ‘the lip’ and ‘the trip zone’ accommodated allegation that join between pad and asphalt was uneven and he tripped on join – Judge did not make necessary findings of fact as to whether there was an uneven join and whether depth of lip exceeded intervention standard – Leave to appeal granted – Appeal allowed.

Road Management Act 2004, s 102.

---

Counsel

Applicant: Ms GA Costello KC and Dr A McBeth
Respondent: Mr MJ Latham

Solicitors

Applicant: Not applicable (Victorian Bar Pro Bono Scheme)
Respondent: Hunt & Hunt

KYROU JA
MCLEISH JA
NIALL JA:

  1. On 26 September 2017, the applicant was injured when he fell on the footpath on Lonsdale Street in the Melbourne Central Business District. Following the fall, he commenced a proceeding for damages in the Supreme Court alleging that the fall had been caused by negligence or breach of statutory duty on the part of the City of Melbourne (‘the respondent’). The proceeding was remitted to the County Court.

  2. Following a trial, at which the applicant represented himself, a judge of the County Court dismissed the proceeding. Briefly put, the applicant claimed that the footpath at the point he fell was defective, the defect had caused him to fall and the failure to rectify the footpath constituted a breach of common law or statutory duty. The judge concluded that the applicant had failed to prove the cause of the fall and therefore could not make out either cause of action.

  3. As will appear, the judge relied on the transcript of the applicant’s evidence which was, in an important respect, inaccurate. The transcript misstated the applicant’s evidence about where on the footpath he had fallen. The error is such that the verdict cannot stand. Because the judge decided the case on the basis of causation, he did not make findings about the state of the footpath and whether it was defective in the way alleged or the state of the respondent’s knowledge about the matter. This latter question was relevant to a pleaded defence under s 102 of the Road Management Act2004 (‘RMA’). Further, the judge did not make any findings about the extent of the injury nor decide what damages, if any, ought to be awarded in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Russell v City of Melbourne and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] VSCA 97
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Russell v City of Melbourne, the Court of Appeal reviewed a decision made by a lower court in a public liability dispute. The applicant, Russell, alleged that he suffered injuries when he tripped over an uneven join between asphalt and a concrete pad on a footpath in Melbourne. The City of Melbourne denied liability, and the lower court dismissed Russell's claim. Russell appealed this decision to the Court of Appeal.

The central legal issues in this case revolved around two main points. Firstly, whether the judge's reliance on an erroneous transcript of Russell's evidence constituted a material error, as the transcript inaccurately recorded the location of the unseen depression that caused Russell to trip. Secondly, whether the judge adequately considered and made necessary findings of fact regarding the uneven join between the asphalt and concrete pad, and whether the depth of any lip exceeded the intervention standard.

In delivering the judgment of the Court of Appeal, the Court found that the reliance on the erroneous transcript was indeed a material error, as it misrepresented the evidence provided by Russell. Furthermore, the Court held that the judge had not made the necessary findings of fact regarding the uneven join between the asphalt and concrete pad, and the depth of any lip. Consequently, the Court granted leave to appeal and allowed the appeal, finding that the lower court's decision was flawed.

As a result of the Court of Appeal's decision, the lower court's dismissal of Russell's claim was set aside. The case was remitted back to the lower court for further consideration in light of the Court of Appeal's findings. The lower court was directed to make the necessary findings of fact regarding the uneven join between the asphalt and concrete pad, and the depth of any lip, in accordance with the Road Management Act 2004, section 102.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established