Ruru Mahara (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

Ruru Mahara (Migration) [2019] AATA 4768 (28 October 2019)

DECISION RECORD

DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division

APPLICANT:  Ms Mere Ruru Mahara

CASE NUMBER:  1911703

HOME AFFAIRS REFERENCE(S):           BCC2019/278665

MEMBER:K. Chapman

DATE:28 October 2019

PLACE OF DECISION:  Brisbane

DECISION:The Tribunal affirms the decision to cancel the applicant’s Subclass 444 (Special Category) visa.

Statement made on 28 October 2019 at 10:05am

CATCHWORDS
MIGRATION – cancellation – Special Category (Temporary) (Class TY) visa – Subclass 444 (Special Category) – ground for cancellation – risk to safety of Australian community or individual – extensive history of proven criminal offending – Serious Assault of a Police Officer – pending criminal charges – consideration of discretion – best interests of minor sister and niece – strong family and social ties in Australia – preservation of family unit – emotional and financial hardship – gravity of offending – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION
Migration Act 1958 (Cth), s 116

CASES
Botha v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] FCA 362
Gong v MIBP [2016] FCCA 561
Tien v MIMA (1998) 89 FCR 80

STATEMENT OF DECISION AND REASONS

APPLICATION FOR REVIEW

  1. This is an application for review of a decision dated 30 April 2019 made by a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs to cancel the applicant’s Subclass 444 (Special Category) visa under s.116 of the Migration Act 1958 (‘the Act’).

  2. The delegate cancelled the visa under s.116(1)(e)(i) on the basis that the applicant has a history of criminal offending and pending criminal charges, and therefore her presence in Australia ‘is or may be, or would or might be, a risk to the health, safety or good order of the Australian community or a segment of the Australian community.’ The issue in the present case is whether that ground for cancellation is made out, and if so, whether the visa should be cancelled.

  3. On 10 May 2019, the applicant applied for review of the delegate’s decision to cancel her Subclass 444 visa. She was held on remand at the Brisbane Women’s Correctional Centre at the time her application for review was made. The applicant is presently held on remand at the Southern Queensland Correctional Centre. Between May and June 2019, the applicant submitted various documents to the Tribunal. These included documents in connection with an application for reduction of the review application fee, such as financial records and a letter from Centrelink. The Tribunal Registry granted the fee reduction to the applicant.

  4. Additionally, the applicant submitted to the Tribunal various third party statements in support of her character. These included statements from Ms R (her mother), Ms T (her sister), Mr M, Ms D, Ms N, Ms B and Ms S. The Tribunal has duly considered all of the documentary evidence submitted by the applicant.

  5. On 26 June 2019, the Tribunal issued a Summons to the Commissioner of the Queensland Police Service seeking documents relating to the applicant’s criminal history. The response to Summons included material pertaining to both proven and pending…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ruru Mahara (Migration) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 4768
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal affirmed the delegate's decision to cancel Ms Ruru Mahara's Subclass 444 (Special Category) visa. Ms Mahara, a New Zealand national who had resided in Australia since childhood, had her visa cancelled due to concerns about her risk to the safety of the Australian community. At the time of the cancellation, she was on remand facing multiple criminal charges, and she possessed an extensive history of proven criminal offending between 2015 and 2018, including serious assault of a police officer.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether the ground for cancellation under s 116(1)(e) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) was made out, specifically whether Ms Mahara's presence in Australia posed a risk to the health, safety, or good order of the Australian community. If this ground was established, the Tribunal then had to consider whether to exercise its discretion to cancel the visa, weighing all relevant circumstances.

The Tribunal reasoned that Ms Mahara's extensive criminal history, particularly the convictions for serious assault of a police officer and common assault against a police officer, demonstrated a significant disregard for authority and indicated a risk to the safety of the Australian community. While acknowledging factors weighing against cancellation, such as Ms Mahara's long residence in Australia, her family ties including a minor sister and niece, and the potential emotional and financial hardship to her family, the Tribunal found these were outweighed by the gravity of her offending. The Tribunal was not satisfied that Ms Mahara was no longer a risk, noting her history of offending when exposed to temptations like illicit drug use and her demeanour during the review hearing, which suggested a lack of genuine remorse or acceptance of responsibility. Consequently, the Tribunal concluded that Ms Mahara presented a real risk of reoffending and posed a threat to the safety of the Australian community.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the following reasons, the Tribunal has concluded that the decision to cancel the applicant’s visa should be affirmed.BACKGROUND Ms Ruru Mahara, the applicant, is a 23 year old national of New Zealand. Her most recent Subclass 444 visa, issued on 19 September 2008, was cancelled by the delegate on 30 April 2019. At that time she was held on remand at the Brisbane Women’s Correctional Centre with several criminal charges pending. The applicant first arrived in Australia on 14 February 2003 at the age of 6 years. She came to Australia with her mother and two older sisters after the passing of her father. The applicant has made three short return visits to New Zealand since her first arrival in Australia. The applicant has no partner and no children. The applicant was found guilty of multiple criminal matters between the years of 2015 and 2018 for offences including serious assault of a Police Officer, common assault, stealing, breach of bail, failure to appear in accordance with undertaking, possessing dangerous drugs and breach of Probation Order. The applicant is currently held on remand for several offences yet to be determined by the Court. Information obtained from the Queensland Police Service confirms the applicant has the following proven criminal history:-23/11/2015 – Stealing (on 21/11/15). No conviction recorded, fined $300;-23/11/2015 – Commit Public Nuisance (on 21/11/15). No conviction recorded, fined $300;-10/03/16 – Breach of Bail Condition (between 07/02/16 and 10/03/16). No conviction recorded, 80 hours of Community Service;-10/03/16 – Possess Utensils or Pipes etc. for Use (on 23/02/16). No conviction recorded, 80 hours of Community Service;-14/04/16 - Breach of Bail Condition (on 04/04/16). No conviction recorded, fined $400;-14/04/16 – Contravene Direction or Requirement (on 30/03/16). No conviction recorded, fined $400;-16/04/16 – Stealing (on 08/02/16). No conviction recorded, Probation 15 months;-16/04/16 – Stealing (on 08/02/16). No conviction recorded, Probation 15 months;-16/04/16 – Failure to appear in accordance with undertaking (on 27/10/15). No conviction recorded, Probation 15 months;-16/04/16 – Failure to appear in accordance with undertaking (on 06/04/16). No conviction recorded, Probation 15 months;-16/04/16 – Failure to appear in accordance with undertaking (on 23/02/16). No conviction recorded, Probation 15 months;-16/04/16 – Unauthorised dealing with shop goods (on 27/10/15). No conviction recorded, fined $450;-18/04/16 - Failure to appear in accordance with undertaking (on 12/04/16). Conviction recorded, imprisonment for 1 month (suspended for 9 months);-24/06/16 - Failure to appear in accordance with undertaking (on 07/06/16). Conviction recorded, imprisonment for 1 month (cumulative, suspended sentence fully invoked regarding Breach of Order imposed on 18/04/2016); -20/07/16 – Possessing dangerous drugs (on 10/11/15). No conviction recorded, Probation 18 months;-20/07/16 – Possess Utensils or Pipes etc. for Use (on 10/11/2015). No conviction recorded, Probation 18 months;-20/07/16 – Serious Assault of Police Officer (on 10/11/15). No conviction recorded, Probation 18 months;-20/07/16 - Breach of Bail Condition (on 11/11/15). No conviction recorded, Probation 18 months;-20/07/16 - Breach of Bail Condition (on 20/11/15). No conviction recorded, Probation 18 months;-20/07/16 – Commit Public Nuisance (on 20/11/15). No conviction recorded, Probation 18 months;-20/07/16 – Being Intoxicated in a Public Place (on 20/11/15). No conviction recorded, released absolutely;-21/12/16 – Breach of Community Service Order (on 10/03/16) (regarding Breach of Bail Condition, Possess Utensils or Pipes etc. for Use, Possess Tainted Property). Order revoked, resentenced for original offences, conviction recorded, fined $300;-18/05/17 – Contravene Direction or Requirement (on 02/11/16). Conviction recorded, fined $200; -18/05/17 – Common Assault (on 15/11/16). Conviction recorded, Community Service 80 hours;-18/05/17 – Unauthorised Dealing with Shop Goods (on 25/01/16). No conviction recorded, not further punished;-29/05/17 - Unauthorised Dealing with Shop Goods (on 12/04/17). No conviction recorded, Recognisance $500 with Good Behaviour Period of 6 months;-29/05/17 - Unauthorised Dealing with Shop Goods (on 12/04/17). No conviction recorded, Recognisance $500 with Good Behaviour Period of 6 months;-29/05/17 - Unauthorised Dealing with Shop Goods (on 12/04/17). No conviction recorded, Recognisance $500 with Good Behaviour Period of 6 months;-29/05/17 - Unauthorised Dealing with Shop Goods (on 12/04/17). No conviction recorded, Recognisance $500 with Good Behaviour Period of 6 months;-29/05/17 - Unauthorised Dealing with Shop Goods (on 12/04/17). No conviction recorded, Recognisance $500 with Good Behaviour Period of 6 months; and -13/02/18 – Breach of Probation Order imposed on 16/04/16 (regarding Stealing x 2, Breach of Bail Condition, Failure to appear in accordance with undertaking x 3); Breach of Probation Order imposed on 20/07/16 (regarding Possessing Dangerous Drugs, Possess Utensils or Pipes etc. for Use, Serious Assault of Police Officer, Breach of Bail Condition x 2, Commit Public Nuisance); Breach of Community Service Order imposed on 18/05/17 (regarding Common Assault). For Breach of Orders conviction recorded, fined $200. Orders revoked for Original Sentences – Serious Assault of Police Officer conviction recorded imprisonment 2 months (suspended for 12 months) concurrent, Stealing x 2 and Common Assault convictions recorded imprisonment 1 month (suspended for 9 months) concurrent, Failure to appear in accordance with undertaking x 3 convictions recorded imprisonment 2 weeks (suspended for 6 months) cumulative, Breach of Bail Conditions x 3 and Possessing Dangerous Drugs and Possess Utensils of Pipes etc. for Use and Commit Public Nuisance convictions recorded imprisonment 2 weeks (suspended for 6 months) concurrent.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

It is important to note that the applicant has advised the Tribunal that she will plead not guilty to all of the pending criminal matters and that they will not be next heard by the Court until around February 2020. CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE Under s.116 of the Act, the Minister may cancel a visa if satisfied that certain grounds specified in that provision are made out. Relevantly to this case, these include the ground set out in s.116(1)(e) of the Act. If satisfied that the ground for cancellation is made out, the decision maker must proceed to consider whether the visa should be cancelled, having regard to all the relevant circumstances, which may include matters of government policy.Does the ground for cancellation exist? A visa may be cancelled under s.116(1)(e) if the Minister is satisfied that the presence of the visa holder in Australia is or may be, or would or might be, a risk to: the health, safety or good order of the Australian community or a segment of the Australian community; or the health or safety of an individual or individuals. There does not have to be any direct, solid or certain foundation before the power can arise. It can arise on the possibility that some event occurred in the past: Gong v MIBP [2016] FCCA 561, at [41]. The expression ‘good order of the Australian community’ is not defined in the Act. Although considering an earlier version of s.116(1)(e), the reasoning in Tien v MIMA (1998) 89 FCR 80 is still relevant. The Court held (at 94) that the term must be construed in the context in which it appears, that is juxtaposed to the words ‘the health, safety’ of the Australian community. That is, it contains a public order element and concerns activities which have an impact on public activities or which manifest themselves in a public way. It requires that there be an element of risk that the person’s presence in Australia might be disruptive to the proper administration or observance of the law or might create difficulties or public disruption in relation to the values, balance and equilibrium of Australian society.Evidence at the review hearing The applicant’s oral evidence, which was provided by video link from the Southern Queensland Correctional Centre, may be summarised as follows. She confirmed that her letter (in the form of a submission) sent to the Tribunal prior to the review hearing contained true and correct information. The Tribunal informed the applicant of her right to exercise the privilege against self-incrimination in respect of any pending criminal matters. The applicant advised that she understood this right. She informed the Tribunal that she had several pending criminal matters and she did not wish to make further comment about them. The Tribunal raised with the applicant that her pending criminal matters might tend to suggest that her presence in Australia ‘is or may be, or would or might be, a risk to the health, safety or good order of the Australian community or a segment of the Australian community’. She was invited to comment and replied, ‘I don’t know what to say.’ The Tribunal raised with the applicant that these pending criminal matters might tend to weigh in favour of cancelling her visa. She was invited to comment and replied, ‘I don’t know what to say.’

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal has also carefully considered all relevant circumstances pertaining to the applicant’s case and does not consider there is any other circumstance weighing either in favour of, or against, cancellation of her visa. CONCLUSION The Tribunal must balance the factors both against, and in favour of, the cancellation of the applicant’s visa. The Tribunal has carefully reflected upon the aforementioned factors and it has considered the applicant’s claims individually and cumulatively. Multiple factors have been found by the Tribunal to weigh against the cancellation of this visa, as outlined above. The hardship faced by the applicant and her family members if the visa is cancelled, including their rights to remain as a family unit, weighs significantly against such cancellation. Similarly, ‘the best interests of the child’, which is a primary consideration, weighs significantly against cancelling the visa on account of the applicant’s minor sibling, niece and nephews. However, the following combination of factors presents considerable concern for the Tribunal and weighs strongly in favour of cancelling the applicant’s Subclass 444 visa. The applicant’s proven criminal conduct, which includes convictions for Serious Assault of a Police Officer and Common Assault (in relation to a Police Officer) for which she was sentenced to suspended periods of imprisonment, are matters of some gravity in the view of the Tribunal. Her proven criminal conduct displays a blatant disregard for authority in this country. Whilst the Tribunal has paid due regard to all relevant matters including her lengthy residence in Australia, expression of remorse, the limited sentences imposed by the Court in relation to her proven criminal conduct, her evidence that she is no longer using illicit drugs (including the completion of drug, alcohol and employment courses), the third party evidence suggesting she is of good character, the assistance available to her from the neighbourhood centre and job agency outlined by Ms R, and the option for her to live at her mother’s residence upon release from custody, it is not satisfied that the applicant is no longer a risk to the Australian community as a result. Rather, the Tribunal is satisfied the applicant presents a real risk of reoffending and she might be a threat to the safety of the Australian community if she remains in this country. That is because the applicant has a lengthy history of criminal conduct when in situations of exposure to the temptations of illicit drug use, even when family support has been available to her, and she has not demonstrated a reasonable amount of time where she has been living as an adult in the community without offending. Further, the applicant’s demeanour during the review hearing pointed to her not taking responsibility for her actions and offering somewhat hollow expressions of remorse in the view of the Tribunal. Accordingly, the Tribunal is not satisfied upon the evidence before it that the applicant will desist from her former lifestyle upon release from custody.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On balance, following careful consideration, the Tribunal is satisfied that the weight of evidence suggests the ground for visa cancellation exists. In particular, it is of much concern to the Tribunal that the applicant has been convicted of two matters involving assault in relation to serving members of the Queensland Police Service. Accordingly, the Tribunal finds that the applicant’s presence in Australia might be a risk to the safety of the Australian community. The Tribunal is therefore satisfied that the ground for cancellation in s.116(1)(e)(i) exists. As that ground does not require mandatory cancellation under s.116(3), the Tribunal must proceed to consider whether the power to cancel the visa should be exercised. Consideration of discretion There are no matters specified in the Act or Regulations that are required to be considered in relation to the exercise of the discretion to cancel the visa. However, in considering whether to exercise its discretion to cancel the applicant’s visa, the Tribunal has had regard to the relevant circumstances including, but not limited to, matters identified in the Department’s Procedures Advice Manual PAM3 ‘General visa cancellation powers’. The Tribunal has also very carefully considered the attribution of weight to the evidence before it in assessing whether the applicant’s visa should be cancelled. In doing so, the Tribunal is mindful of the observations of Collier J in Botha v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] FCA 362 at [39]: There is ample authority at high level in this country that it is for a decision-maker to attribute such weight to relevant information as it sees fit: see for example Kirby J in Minister for Immigration & Ethnic Affairs v Wu Shan Liang (1996) 185 CLR 259 at [24]; Gummow and Hayne JJ in Abebe v Commonwealth (1999) 197 CLR 510 at [197]; the plurality in Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZJSS (2010) 243 CLR 164 at [33]. The applicant’s background has been detailed above. She has resided in Australia since 2003 from the age of 6 years, arriving with her mother and siblings. The applicant has her mother (Ms R), one adult sister (Ms T), one minor sister (Miss K), one niece (Miss O) and two nephews (Ms T’s children) resident in Australia. Other family members associated with the aforementioned individuals also reside in this country, as do friends of the applicant. The Tribunal accepts the oral and documentary evidence that some emotional and financial hardship will be faced by these family members, and the applicant, should the visa be cancelled (noting in particular the hope of the family that the applicant will work once released from custody and assist with the care of Miss K and Miss O in Ms R’s residence). The Tribunal also accepts that there will be upset and emotional hardship to the friends of the applicant, and those family members associated with the immediate family members of the applicant, if her visa is cancelled. The Tribunal affords some weight to the respective evidence concerning these matters and finds that the aforementioned family and friendship considerations weigh against cancellation of the visa. For completeness, the Tribunal notes that no professional medical or psychological evidence was before it to suggest that either the applicant, or any other person, will suffer psychological hardship if the visa is cancelled.