Rural Press Ltd & Ors v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

[2003] HCATrans 292

IN THE HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Office of the Registry
  Adelaide  No A197 of 2003

B e t w e e n -

RURAL PRESS LIMITED

First Appellant

BRIDGE PRINTING OFFICE PTY LIMITED

Second Appellant

IAN LAW

Third Appellant

TREVOR McAULIFFE

Fourth Appellant

and

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION

First Respondent

WAIKERIE PRINTING HOUSE PTY LIMITED

Second Respondent

PAUL TAYLOR

Third Respondent

Office of the Registry
  Adelaide  No A203 of 2003

B e t w e e n -

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION

Appellant

and

RURAL PRESS LIMITED

First Respondent

BRIDGE PRINTING OFFICE PTY LIMITED

Second Respondent

IAN LAW

Third Respondent

TREVOR McAULIFFE

Fourth Respondent

WAIKERIE PRINTING HOUSE PTY LIMITED

Fifth Respondent

PAUL TAYLOR

Sixth Respondent

GLEESON CJ
GUMMOW J
KIRBY J
HAYNE J
CALLINAN J
HEYDON J

TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS

AT ADELAIDE ON THURSDAY, 14 AUGUST 2003, AT 9.31 AM

(Continued from 13/8/03)

Copyright in the High Court of Australia

__________________

GLEESON CJ:   Yes, Mr Young.

MR YOUNG:   May I commence by taking the Court to Melway 205 CLR 1. I want to go to some passages commencing at pages 22 and 23.

HAYNE J:   With a view to demonstrating what?

MR YOUNG:   That the Full Court erred by applying a test other than that stipulated in Melway, and other than that which they themselves enunciated, and ultimately, your Honour, I want to compare and contrast the critical reasons given by the trial judge in relation to taking advantage with those of the Full Court.  In Melway the Court held that the question raised by the expression, “taking advantage”, in section 46(1), “is a question of fact”.  That is paragraph 69 in the joint judgment of the Chief Justice, Justices Gummow, Hayne and Callinan.

The precise way in which the Court approached the application of that phrase appears at pages 22 and 23 in the joint judgment.  After quoting the key passages in the reasoning from Queensland Wire, the joint judgment said this at paragraph 50:

A majority of the Court considered that the way to test whether BHP was taking advantage of its power was to ask how it would have been likely to behave in a competitive market . . . The important thing was that, once it was concluded that in a competitive market BHP would have been constrained to supply QWI, and that BHP’s ability to refuse to supply resulted from the absence of such constraint, it followed that, in refusing to supply (for an anti‑competitive purpose), BHP was taking advantage of its market power.

Now, that is something of a distillation of what the members of the Court have said in QWI.  Each member of the Court in QWI expressed that test in a slightly different form of words ‑ ‑ ‑

GUMMOW J:   Now, we have it expressed in one form of words, and that is what controls.

MR YOUNG:   Yes, your Honour.

GUMMOW J:   It is the whole purpose of what has been written…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Rural Press Ltd & Ors v Australian Competition and Consumer... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] HCATrans 292
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Rural Press Ltd and others (the appellants) appealed to the High Court of Australia against a decision of the Full Federal Court which had affirmed a finding by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) that the appellants had contravened section 46 of the *Trade Practices Act 1974* (Cth) (the Act). The dispute concerned allegations that the appellants had misused their substantial market power in the regional newspaper market to engage in anti-competitive conduct.

The High Court was required to determine whether the appellants had taken advantage of their substantial degree of market power for the purpose of damaging a competitor, preventing the entry of a competitor, or hindering a competitor from engaging in competitive conduct in a market in which the appellants were not themselves operating. Specifically, the court considered the meaning of "taking advantage of" market power in the context of section 46 and the nature of the requisite anti-competitive purpose.

The High Court held that the Full Federal Court had erred in its interpretation of section 46. The majority reasoned that the contravention of section 46 requires proof that the conduct in question was engaged in for a proscribed purpose and that the conduct was only possible because of the existence of substantial market power. It was not sufficient for the conduct to be merely facilitated by market power; rather, the market power must have been the reason for the conduct. The court clarified that the "taking advantage of" limb of section 46 requires a causal connection between the substantial market power and the conduct, and that the purpose element must be demonstrably established.

The High Court allowed the appeal, setting aside the orders of the Full Federal Court and remitting the matter to the Federal Court for further consideration in accordance with the High Court's reasons.

Background

Background to the litigation

Rural Press Limited and Bridge Printing Office Pty Limited, two companies with substantial market power in the Murray Bridge newspaper market, engaged in conduct that led to legal proceedings brought by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC). The ACCC alleged that the two companies had engaged in anti-competitive conduct by making threats to enter the Riverland market unless Waikerie Printing House Pty Limited withdrew from the Murray Bridge market. This conduct was considered to be a misuse of their market power in the Murray Bridge market, in violation of section 46 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth). The conduct was also alleged to breach section 4D of the Act, which prohibits market sharing arrangements that would deprive persons in a particular area of services otherwise available to them from one of the participants. The Full Court found that the conduct did not amount to a market sharing arrangement under section 4D and dismissed the ACCC's appeal. The ACCC then appealed to the High Court, which heard the case on 13 and 14 August 2003.

The key issue in the case was whether the conduct of Rural Press and Bridge Printing amounted to "taking advantage" of their market power in the Murray Bridge market, as required by section 46 of the Trade Practices Act. The ACCC argued that the conduct had a sufficient connection with the market power, as it would not have made commercial sense for the companies to make the threats unless they had market power in the Murray Bridge market. The Full Court, however, found that the conduct did not involve taking advantage of their market power and dismissed the appeal. The High Court was asked to consider whether the Full Court had erred in its application of the test for "taking advantage" of market power. The case hinged on the interpretation of the phrase "taking advantage" and whether the Full Court had applied the correct test in determining whether the conduct was connected to the market power. The ACCC submitted that the Full Court had misapplied the test and that the conduct did involve taking advantage of market power. The High Court reserved its decision and adjourned the matter to hear the special leave applications.

The case came before the High Court of Australia as special leave appeals from the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia. The primary judge, Justice Mansfield, found that Rural Press Limited and Bridge Printing Office Pty Limited had contravened section 46 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 by taking advantage of their market power in the Murray Bridge newspaper market. The Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia overturned the primary judge's decision, finding that there was no taking advantage of market power. The appellants, Rural Press Limited, Bridge Printing Office Pty Limited, Ian Law, and Trevor McAuliffe, sought special leave to appeal the Full Court's decision, arguing that the Full Court misapplied the test for determining whether there had been a taking advantage of market power. The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) cross-appealed the Full Court's decision, arguing that the primary judge had correctly found a contravention of section 46. This case revolves around the interpretation of section 46 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 and the test for determining whether there has been a taking advantage of market power. The appellants argue that the Full Court misapplied the test for determining whether there had been a taking advantage of market power, while the ACCC argues that the primary judge correctly found a contravention of section 46. The High Court will determine whether special leave to appeal should be granted and, if so, whether the Full Court's decision should be overturned.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the Full Court's interpretation of "taking advantage of market power" in section 46 of the Trade Practices Act correctly apply the principles established in previous High Court cases such as Melway and Queensland Wire?
2. Was the market sharing arrangement between Rural Press and Waikerie Printing House a breach of section 4D of the Trade Practices Act, given the Full Court's finding that no particular class of persons was identified?
3. Does the term "particular" in section 4D of the Trade Practices Act exclude geographic zones as a valid definition of a class of persons?
4. What are the appropriate reliefs if the High Court finds in favour of the appellants on their arguments regarding sections 46 and 4D of the Trade Practices Act?
5. Does the conduct of Rural Press and Bridge Printing involve a "use" of market power that constitutes "taking advantage" under section 46 of the Trade Practices Act, and what constitutes a sufficient connection between the conduct and market power?

Held
1. The Full Court's interpretation of "taking advantage of market power" in section 46 of the Trade Practices Act does not correctly apply the principles established in previous High Court cases such as Melway and Queensland Wire. The Full Court applied a test of physical possibility rather than the required test of commercial likelihood. Result: The Full Court's decision is flawed.

2. The market sharing arrangement between Rural Press and Waikerie Printing House was not a breach of section 4D of the Trade Practices Act as the Full Court found that no particular class of persons was identified. Result: The Full Court's decision is upheld.

3. The term "particular" in section 4D of the Trade Practices Act does not exclude geographic zones as a valid definition of a class of persons. Result: Geographic zones can be considered a valid definition of a class of persons.

4. If the High Court finds in favour of the appellants on their arguments regarding sections 46 and 4D of the Trade Practices Act, appropriate reliefs would include reinstatement of penalty orders and a more specific declaration. Result: The appropriate reliefs would be determined based on the Court's decision.

5. The conduct of Rural Press and Bridge Printing involves a "use" of market power that constitutes "taking advantage" under section 46 of the Trade Practices Act. A sufficient connection between the conduct and market power is established if the commercial rationale for the impugned conduct is to preserve the monopoly or market power. Result: The appellants' conduct constitutes a taking advantage of market power under section 46.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The first major issue considered by the Court was whether the Full Court's interpretation of "taking advantage of market power" in section 46 of the Trade Practices Act correctly applies the principles established in previous High Court cases such as Melway and Queensland Wire. The Court found that the Full Court erred by applying a different test than that stipulated in Melway and Queensland Wire. The reasoning in Melway and Queensland Wire established that the question of whether there was a "taking advantage" of market power was a question of fact, and the key was to determine whether there was a sufficient connection between the purposive conduct and the existence of market power. In this case, the Full Court misapplied the test by applying a test of physical possibility instead of commercial likelihood. The Court found that the Full Court's reasoning went wrong when they applied a test of physical possibility, which always results in the answer "yes," instead of a test of commercial likelihood, which addresses the right question of whether the conduct would have been likely to be engaged in in the absence of market power.

The second major issue was whether the market sharing arrangement between Rural Press and Waikerie Printing House was a breach of section 4D of the Trade Practices Act. The Full Court found that no particular class of persons was identified. The Court noted that the term "particular" in section 4D does not exclude geographic zones as a valid definition of a class of persons. The Court held that the word "particular" simply means that the relevant person or class must be one identified by the competitors when they made the arrangement, and any class identified by the parties to the arrangement satisfies that description, including a geographic class. Therefore, the market sharing arrangement could be considered a breach of section 4D if it had the purpose of restricting competition.

The third major issue was what the appropriate reliefs would be if the High Court found in favour of the appellants on their arguments regarding sections 46 and 4D of the Trade Practices Act. The appellants sought a more particular declaration and the reinstatement of the penalty orders, as it was clear that the penalty judgments treated the conduct as one piece to be penalized once, even if there were one or more contraventions.

The fourth major issue was whether the conduct of Rural Press and Bridge Printing involved a "use" of market power that constitutes "taking advantage" under section 46 of the Trade Practices Act, and what constitutes a sufficient connection between the conduct and market power. The Court found that the Full Court erred by not finding that Rural Press and Bridge Printing had actually taken advantage of their power in the Murray Bridge newspaper market for the relevant purpose, which was to contravene the relevant provisions of section 46. The Court held that a sufficient connection between the conduct and market power can be established if the commercial rationale for the impugned conduct is to preserve the monopoly, and if the conduct would not have been engaged in in a competitive market. The Court also noted that the word "use" in the context of "taking advantage" should not be interpreted as the bare minimum needed to constitute "taking advantage," but rather as a reliance on market power for leverage or impact.

In conclusion, the ratio decidendi of this case is that the Full Court's interpretation of "taking advantage of market power" in section 46 of the Trade Practices Act did not correctly apply the principles established in previous High Court cases. The term "particular" in section 4D of the Trade Practices Act does not exclude geographic zones as a valid definition of a class of persons. The appropriate reliefs if the High Court finds in favour of the appellants on their arguments regarding sections 46 and 4D of the Trade Practices Act would be a more particular declaration and the reinstatement of the penalty orders. The conduct of Rural Press and Bridge Printing constitutes a "use" of market power that amounts to "taking advantage" under section 46 if there is a sufficient connection between the conduct and market power, which can be established if the commercial rationale for the impugned conduct is to preserve the monopoly, and if the conduct would not have been engaged in in a competitive market.