RRML and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship)

Link copied
Case Copied 56 min read

RRML and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship) [2020] AATA 1654 (4 June 2020)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2018/6876, 2018/6877

Re:RRML and XJFZ

APPLICANTS

AndMinister for Home Affairs

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President Boyle

Date:4 June 2020

Place:Perth

The decisions under review are affirmed.

...............................[SGD]......................................

Deputy President Boyle

CATCHWORDS

CITIZENSHIP – citizenship by conferral – Citizenship Policy – status of policy – persons aged under 18 years of age – significant hardship or disadvantage – best interest of the child – access to education – ties to Australia – discretion to approve or refuse to approve citizenship application – COVID-19 – resident return visa - reviewable decision affirmed

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) – s 19D(2), 37

Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth) – ss 20, 21, 21(2), 21(3), 21(4), 21(5), 22, 22A, 22B, 23, 24, 24(2), 26(1)(a), Division 2 of Pt 2

CASES

CQJV and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] AATA 653
Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No. 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634
Galesloot and Minister for Home Affairs [2018] AATA 4450
G v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 1229
Grass v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] FCAFC 44; 231 FCR 128
GZQZ and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] AATA 1052
Han and Minister for Home Affairs [2019] AATA 3325
Hneidi v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2010] FCAFC 20
Minister for Home Affairs v G [2019] FCAFC 79
Perez v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs [2002] FCA 450; 119 FCR 454
Roach v Electoral Commissioner [2007] HCA 43; 233 CLR 162

Wijewardhanage and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] AATA 746

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Citizenship Policy, Department of Immigration and Border Protection, 1 June 2016 – pages 1, 33, 75-76, 224

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President Boyle

4 June 2020

THE APPLICATIONS

  1. The Applicants, who are sisters, made applications for the review of decisions of delegates of the Respondent made under s 24(2) of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Act) refusing to approve the Applicants’ respective applications for Australian citizenship by conferral
    (the Decisions).

  2. The Decisions were made on 30 October 2018 and 31 October 2018 and contain substantially the same reasons, despite being made by different delegates. Because of the similarity in the Decisions and the alignment of issues in each application, on
    15 January 2019 the Tribunal ordered that the two applications be joined and programmed together. The applications were heard together.

    BACKGROUND

  3. XJFZ was born in the United Kingdom (UK) in June 2003 and is currently 16 years old.


    She is a citizen of the UK. She began living in the United Arab Emirates (UAE) with her mother in November 2004 when she was approximately 17 months old. XJFZ has not resided in the UK since then (Applicants’ Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions).[1]

    [1] (ASFIC) para. 6.0

  4. RRML was born in June 2006 and is currently 13…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read RRML and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] AATA 1654
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerned two sisters, XJFZ and RRML, who sought review of decisions by delegates of the Minister for Home Affairs refusing to approve their applications for Australian citizenship by conferral. The applications were joined and heard together by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT). The applicants were born in the UK and Sierra Leone respectively, and had resided in the UAE for most of their lives, having arrived in Australia on skilled-independent visas in 2012. Their mother, a veterinary surgeon, had intended to relocate to Australia permanently in 2017 after resolving legal proceedings in the UAE, and the applicants had briefly attended school in Australia in 2017.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the Minister's decision to refuse to approve the applicants' citizenship applications, exercising the discretion under s 24(2) of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007, was the correct or preferable decision. This involved considering the relevant Citizenship Policy, which generally required applicants to demonstrate significant hardship or disadvantage if citizenship were not granted, and assessing the applicants' claims of significant disadvantage, including a lack of freedom to travel, deprivation of quality education, disconnection from Australia, and the non-realisation of their intention to reside in Australia. The impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on their ability to travel and renew visas was also a factor raised by the applicants.

The Tribunal reasoned that while it was guided by the Citizenship Policy, the policy itself was not determinative and the ultimate decision rested on an overall assessment of the individual circumstances. The Tribunal found that the applicants had not demonstrated significant hardship or disadvantage as contemplated by the Policy. Specifically, it was held that refusing citizenship did not significantly impede their ability to travel internationally, as they held UK passports. The Tribunal also found no evidence that their current education in the UAE was deficient, nor that denial of citizenship would deprive them of quality education in Australia, especially as permanent residents have the same legal rights to education. Furthermore, the Tribunal concluded that the applicants had minimal ties to Australia, and their intention to reside there was speculative and primarily driven by their mother's circumstances, thus not warranting significant weight in the exercise of discretion.

The Tribunal affirmed the decisions of the delegates of the Minister for Home Affairs. The applications for Australian citizenship by conferral were refused.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Decisions were made on 30 October 2018 and 31 October 2018 and contain substantially the same reasons, despite being made by different delegates. Because of the similarity in the Decisions and the alignment of issues in each application, on 15 January 2019 the Tribunal ordered that the two applications be joined and programmed together. The applications were heard together.BACKGROUND XJFZ was born in the United Kingdom (UK) in June 2003 and is currently 16 years old. She is a citizen of the UK. She began living in the United Arab Emirates (UAE) with her mother in November 2004 when she was approximately 17 months old. XJFZ has not resided in the UK since then (Applicants’ Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions).[1] [1] (ASFIC) para. 6.0 RRML was born in June 2006 and is currently 13 years old. She is a citizen of Sierra Leone. She also became a citizen of the UK in August 2007. RRML lives with her mother and stepfather in the UAE and has never resided in the UK. In 2008 the Applicants’ mother, a UK qualified veterinary surgeon, purchased a veterinary clinic in Dubai. In 2009 and 2010 the Applicants’ mother completed courses in Australia to qualify to practice as a veterinarian in Australia. She says that that it was her intention to move to Australia in 2012 and to run her Dubai veterinary practice from Australia.[2] [2] ASFIC para. 9. In 2010 the Applicants’ mother married [redacted]. In August 2011 the Applicants’ mother gave birth to a son in Attadale Western Australia. That child is an Australian citizen by birth. The Applicants’ mother says that in September 2011 her two partners in the Dubai veterinary clinic tried to defraud her which started a long-running legal process in the UAE. These legal proceedings, according to the Applicants’ mother, required her presence in the UAE which disrupted her plans to move the family, including the Applicants, to Perth. Those legal proceedings were not resolved until mid-2017. In 2011 the Applicants’ mother’s brother and his family moved to Perth. In 2012 her parents retired and purchased a home in Perth. In September 2011 the Applicants were granted Skilled-Independent (Class VE) (subclass 175) visas and first arrived on those visas with their mother in February 2012. In 2012 the Applicants’ mother established a veterinary hospital in Dubai, according to the Applicants’ mother, to support herself and her family while the legal proceedings in UAE were resolved. In mid-2017, following completion of the legal proceedings in the UAE, the Applicants’ mother came to Australia with the Applicants with the intention of residing in Australia on a permanent basis. It was the Applicants’ mother’s intention that the veterinary hospital in Dubai would be run by the hospital’s head veterinarian when the Applicants’ mother was absent. The head veterinarian resigned in June 2017. In July 2017 XJFZ enrolled in year 9 at [redacted] High School and RRML enrolled in year 6 at [redacted] Primary School.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In a statement dated 21 April 2020, the Applicants’ mother advised that:(a)She and the Applicants continue to reside in the UAE;(b)The UAE has advised non-citizens to return to their home countries until the COVID-19 situation is over. There are, however, no flights to Perth;(c)She is concerned that the COVID-19 pandemic disruption will cause further delays in processing their Australian permanent visa renewals;(d)Given that their ability to renew permanent visas is dependent on them spending time in Australia, she is concerned that travel restrictions could affect their ability to renew the Applicants’ permanent visas;(e)She has spent $600,000 on purchasing a property in Australia and is planning on spending a similar amount to build a new house on the property;(f)COVID-19 is causing uncertainty on the length of school closures (presumably in Australia) and course availability;(g)They had planned to be in Australia from 21 March 2020 to 11 April 2020 but because of travel restrictions they had not been able to come.(h)The uncertainty about the Applicants’ citizenship and delay and restrictions caused by COVID-19 have ‘further disadvantaged’ the Applicants and her ability to ‘make clear plans for their future’THE HEARING AND EVIDENCE The Applications were heard by Member C Edwardes and Member D Fitzgerald on 2 May 2019. The Applicant was represented by Ms A Graziotti of Estrin Saul Lawyers and the Respondent was represented by Ms A Ladhams of Australian Government Solicitor. The Applicant’s mother and XJFZ gave evidence at the hearing. After the hearing Member Edwardes ceased being a member of the Tribunal. By direction made on 10 July 2019 pursuant to s 19D(2) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (AAT Act), the direction by which the proceedings were constituted to Members Edwardes and Fitzgerald was revoked and a direction was made that the proceedings be constituted to Member Fitzgerald alone. On 5 March 2020 Member Fitzgerald stopped being a member of the Tribunal and by direction made on 18 March 2020 pursuant to s 19D(2) of the AAT Act, the direction of 10 July 2019 constituting the proceedings to Member Fitzgerald was revoked and a direction made that the proceedings be constituted to Senior Member Dr M Evans-Bonner. By direction made on 31 March 2020 pursuant to s 19D(2) of the AAT Act, the direction of 18 March 2020 that the proceedings be constituted to Senior Member Dr M Evans-Bonner was revoked and a direction was made that the proceedings be constituted to Deputy President Boyle. On 31 March 2020, with the agreement of the parties, the following directions were made:(i)The applications are to be determined on the basis of the transcript of the hearing on 2 May 2019 and the papers;(ii)On or before 10 April 2020 the Applicants were to file and serve any submissions in relation to the impact of COVID-19 pandemic; and(iii)On or before 23 April 2020 the Respondent were to file and serve any submissions in reply.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Applicants, who are sisters, made applications for the review of decisions of delegates of the Respondent made under s 24(2) of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Act) refusing to approve the Applicants’ respective applications for Australian citizenship by conferral (the Decisions). The Decisions were made on 30 October 2018 and 31 October 2018 and contain substantially the same reasons, despite being made by different delegates. Because of the similarity in the Decisions and the alignment of issues in each application, on 15 January 2019 the Tribunal ordered that the two applications be joined and programmed together. The applications were heard together.BACKGROUND XJFZ was born in the United Kingdom (UK) in June 2003 and is currently 16 years old. She is a citizen of the UK. She began living in the United Arab Emirates (UAE) with her mother in November 2004 when she was approximately 17 months old. XJFZ has not resided in the UK since then (Applicants’ Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions).[1] [1] (ASFIC) para. 6.0 RRML was born in June 2006 and is currently 13 years old. She is a citizen of Sierra Leone. She also became a citizen of the UK in August 2007. RRML lives with her mother and stepfather in the UAE and has never resided in the UK. In 2008 the Applicants’ mother, a UK qualified veterinary surgeon, purchased a veterinary clinic in Dubai. In 2009 and 2010 the Applicants’ mother completed courses in Australia to qualify to practice as a veterinarian in Australia. She says that that it was her intention to move to Australia in 2012 and to run her Dubai veterinary practice from Australia.[2] [2] ASFIC para. 9. In 2010 the Applicants’ mother married [redacted]. In August 2011 the Applicants’ mother gave birth to a son in Attadale Western Australia. That child is an Australian citizen by birth. The Applicants’ mother says that in September 2011 her two partners in the Dubai veterinary clinic tried to defraud her which started a long-running legal process in the UAE. These legal proceedings, according to the Applicants’ mother, required her presence in the UAE which disrupted her plans to move the family, including the Applicants, to Perth. Those legal proceedings were not resolved until mid-2017. In 2011 the Applicants’ mother’s brother and his family moved to Perth. In 2012 her parents retired and purchased a home in Perth. In September 2011 the Applicants were granted Skilled-Independent (Class VE) (subclass 175) visas and first arrived on those visas with their mother in February 2012. In 2012 the Applicants’ mother established a veterinary hospital in Dubai, according to the Applicants’ mother, to support herself and her family while the legal proceedings in UAE were resolved. In mid-2017, following completion of the legal proceedings in the UAE, the Applicants’ mother came to Australia with the Applicants with the intention of residing in Australia on a permanent basis. It was the Applicants’ mother’s intention that the veterinary hospital in Dubai would be run by the hospital’s head veterinarian when the Applicants’ mother was absent. The head veterinarian resigned in June 2017.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Applicants’ reply also reiterated the arguments around the unpredictability of the RRV process and the impact that that had, and would continue to have, on the Applicants’ travel and the parents’ travel and the affect that that has or would have on the Applicants’ education. It also responded to the Respondent’s submissions on the lack of ties to Australia and asserted that the Applicants’ most significant ties at this stage of their lives are family members and that two of their siblings are Australian citizens as well as the majority of their extended family.CONSIDERATION The Respondent concedes that the Applicants meet the criteria in s 21(5) of the Act and both parties identify the issue for determination as being whether the correct or preferable decision is to refuse to approve the Applicants’ becoming Australian citizens relying on the discretion in s 24(2) of the Act. The Full Court decision in MHA v G has put beyond doubt the validity of the Policy. The Tribunal understands that, while it is to be guided by the Policy in the exercise of a discretion (MHA v G at [65]; see [47] above), the Policy is not determinative, it is merely one factor that is to be taken into account. As Mortimer J put it in G v MIBP:171.Justice or injustice is not found within a policy: it is found by looking at the overall circumstances of an individual’s case, with the principal focus being on the purpose and context of the statutory power, not the executive policy framed to guide it.…266.A Tribunal must give active intellectual consideration to what is the correct or preferable decision on the basis of all the material before it, in all of the circumstances before it. One of those circumstances is the existence, and content, of an executive policy. The Applicants concede that the relevant Policy provision applying to them is that set out in the third bullet point on page 76 of 237, namely that an application for citizenship “would usually not be approved… unless… they would otherwise suffer significant hardship or disadvantage” (see [43] above). The Applicants also concede that their circumstances may not constitute significant hardship, however, they contend that there is no doubt that a refusal of their applications would cause them to experience significant disadvantage or detriment (see [102] above). They identify the significant disadvantage or detriment as being:a.a lack of freedom to travel and re-enter Australia given unpredictable processing times for RRVs;b.deprivation of access to and continuity of quality education;c.disconnection from the country they consider “home” (given their lack of ties to the UK and UAE); andd.non-realisation of their intention to reside in Australia. The disadvantage or detriment is significant, the Applicants say, because it relates to their education. The Tribunal does not accept that argument. Dealing with each of the above identified claimed detriments:(a)A lack of freedom to travelThe Tribunal accepts the Respondent’s argument that while the Applicants may consider that they could travel more conveniently as Australian citizens, refusing to grant them citizenship does not significantly impede their ability to travel to and from Australia. Generally, the ability of a citizen of any country to travel into and out of their country is going to be greater than that of a non-citizen. That is not a basis for, or even a relevant consideration in, granting citizenship. It is simply a function of international borders. Insofar as the Applicants seek to argue that their international travel is somehow restricted or curtailed, as the Respondent points out, they are both citizens of the UK and hold UK passports. Their ability to travel internationally, other than into Australia, would be no greater than it is now as UK citizens if they were to be granted Australian citizenship.The Tribunal accepts that the process of having to apply for RRVs is undoubtedly inconvenient, however, it is not a problem that cannot be addressed in the ways identified by the Respondent (see [85] above). The Tribunal also accepts that the whole process of renewal of visas, including RRVs, may be more difficult now because of COVID-19 as described in the Applicants’ mother’s statement dated 21 April 2020. That, however, and the uncertainty around the Applicants’ schooling in Australia caused by COVID-19, are not matters that give rise to significant disadvantage as those terms are defined in the Policy (see [44] above) (b)Deprivation of access to and continuity of quality educationThe Applicants are both enrolled, and have been for at least three years, in schools in the UAE. There is no evidence before the Tribunal that the education that the Applicants are receiving in the current schools is deficient or somehow of a lesser standard than would be available in Australia or in the UK. There is no basis upon which the Tribunal could draw the conclusion, which seems to be implicit in the Applicants’ argument, that the education available in the UAE is not a “quality education”.The Applicants’ submissions focus on the impact that the need for RRVs and the claimed uncertainties surrounding the process of renewing RRVs has on the Applicants’ education. It is the Applicants’ parents’ desire to educate the Applicants in Australia while the Applicants’ parents both continue to live in the UAE. The difficulties identified by the Applicants’ mother and stepfather primarily relate to the difficulties in the Applicants and their parents travelling between the UAE and Australia. Apart from saying that the Applicants have no ties to the UK, and in the younger Applicant’s case, has never lived in the UK, no explanation is provided as to why the Applicants could not be educated in the UK. They and their parents are citizens of the UK and hold UK passports so, presumably, none of the issues arising from the need to obtain visas would be apply if the Applicants were educated in the UK. As the Respondent also points out, the Applicants as permanent residents, have the same legal rights to education in Australia as a citizen does. The claimed difficulties described by the Applicants in coming in and out of Australia are not “depriving” them of a quality education nor even depriving them of an education in Australia. There is simply no basis for the Tribunal to conclude that denial of citizenship will result in a “[d]eprivation of access to and continuity of quality education”(c)Disconnection from the country they consider “home” (given their lack of ties to the UK and UAE)The Applicants’ connection to Australia is not significant. The Respondent’s summary of the Applicants’ ties to Australia in his closing submissions is, in the Tribunal’s view, a fair statement:24. The applicants have spent minimal time in Australia. Their longest stay in Australia has been a period of less than 2 months from 11 July 2017 to 6 September 2017. Aside from this, the applicants’ time in Australia has generally been limited to a few weeks each year. Although they have extended family and some friends in Australia, they have had limited involvement in the Australian community aside from the school and community activities they engaged in during the part-term in which they attended school in Australia in 2017.The Applicants’ time spent in Australia more recently has similarly been minimal (see [98] above). While COVID-19 and the associated travel restrictions may explain the fact that the Applicants have not been to Australia since January this year, the fact remains that the time that they have spent in Australia has been minimal and, in the Tribunal’s view, insufficient for any significant ties to have developed.(d)Non-realisation of their intention to reside in Australia.The Respondent responds to this ground as follows:31. …The applicants’ future intention to reside in Australia does not at this stage warrant the exercise of the discretion in s 24(1) in their favour in circumstances where to date, their time in Australia has been so limited. Intentions are not always realised, as can be seen from the evidence given by the applicants’ mother that she intended to move to Australia in 2012 and to reside here permanently when she came in 2017: Exhibit A3 at [8] and [10]. If the applicants are able to realise their current intention to move to and reside in Australia, they will be able to apply again for citizenship in the future. Further, it is unclear whether applicant RRML has any intentions as to her future residence separate to those of her parents.The Tribunal agrees with the Respondent’s submission. A mere desire, which appears to be more a desire on the part of the Applicants’ mother rather than the Applicants themselves, is a consideration to be taken into account, however, is not a consideration in the present circumstances that should be given any significant weight. The Applicants’ relocation to Australia is presently still a matter of speculation and appears to be dependent on a range of factors and circumstances, primarily their mother’s financial affairs in the UAE. The best interest of the child