Royal Victorian Aero Club v Commonwealth

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read
92 CLR 236

ROYAL VICTORIAN AERO CLUB

THE COMMONWEALTH Contract-Training of Air Force personnel by flying club in club's planes-Recom-

pensing of club for damage arising from " wilful misconduct" of such personnel -Failure to recall instruction while acting in breach thereof. MELBOURNE,

Under an agreement for the training of Air Force personnel by the plaintiff club, it was provided that where damage arose from the wilful misconduct' BRISBANE,

of such personnel the Commonwealth would recompense the club for damage etc. to its property.

An aeroplane owned by the club crashed while piloted by an Air Force trainee who was practising the technique required to make a forced landing. The trainee, who had carried out the practice several times and was well versed in judging a height of 200 feet, had been instructed that on fields of his own selection he was not to come below that height. On the occasion in question, which was on a field of his own selection, the trainee was not absolu- tely certain when he was about 200 feet from the ground, whether he would have made the field had he to come down or whether he was landing dead into the wind ". He accordingly came down "slightly' further to check. At about 50 to 70 feet he noticed two wires running across the boundary fence and attempted to regain height. The engine spluttered, however, in consequence of which the plane touched the wires and crashed. The trainee was aware that he was flying below 200 feet, but he did not think of the instruction to the contrary until after the crash.

Held, that, in the circumstances, the trainee was not guilty of wilful Lewis v. Great Western Railway Co. (1877) 3 Q.B.D. 195, at pp. 206, 210- 211; Graham v. Belfast &Northern Counties Railway Co. (1901) 2 I.R. 13, at p. 19; Fordes v. Great Western Railway Co. (1905) 2 K.B. 532 Transport Commission v. Neale Edwards Pty. Ltd. (1954) 92 C.L.R. 214, at p. 230, applied.

92 CLR 237

Royal Victorian Aero Club, a company incorporated in Victoria commenced an action on 17th June 1953 in the High Court of Australia against the Commonwealth of Australia. The plaintiff claimed under an agreement between it and the defendant dated 22nd February 1951 in respect of damage it had suffered by reason of an aircraft crash on 21st December 1951.

The action was heard before Webb J. from whose judgment the facts sufficiently appear.

A. H. Mann, for the plaintiff. M. v. McInerney, for the defendant.

Cur. adv. vult. The following written judgment was delivered :-

WEBB J. In this action the plaintiff club claims £1,067 16s. Od. from the defendant Commonwealth for the destruction of the club's aircraft in a crash during a solo flight by an Air Force trainee and for other damage to property caused by the crash. This sum is made up as follows :-

Value of the aircraft Cost of salving Amount claimed by State Electricity

Commission for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Royal Victorian Aero Club v Commonwealth and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1954] HCA 59
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Royal Victorian Aero Club (the plaintiff) commenced an action in the High Court of Australia against the Commonwealth of Australia (the defendant) seeking recompense for damage to its aircraft and other property. The claim arose under an agreement for the training of Royal Australian Air Force personnel by the club, which stipulated that the Commonwealth would compensate the club for damage caused by the "wilful misconduct" of such personnel. The Commonwealth denied liability and counter-claimed for costs it had incurred in repairing damaged high-tension wires.

The central legal issue before the court was whether an Air Force trainee, Graeme Lowe, was guilty of "wilful misconduct" when he flew an aircraft below the instructed altitude of 200 feet during a forced landing practice, resulting in a crash. The agreement defined "wilful misconduct" in the context of the parties' obligations and liabilities, and the court was required to determine if Lowe's actions met this definition, thereby triggering the Commonwealth's obligation to recompense the club.

Webb J. held that the trainee was not guilty of wilful misconduct. Applying established principles from cases concerning "wilful misconduct" in contracts, particularly railway consignment notes, the court reasoned that the term requires more than mere negligence or an error in judgment. It necessitates knowledge that the act or omission is wrong and an intentional disregard for that wrong. While the trainee was aware he was flying below 200 feet and that this was contrary to instructions, he did not recall the specific instruction at the time of the manoeuvre. His concentration was solely on the complex landing procedure, and he did not appreciate that his actions were wrong or that they were creating an actual danger. Therefore, his conduct, though a breach of instruction, did not amount to wilful misconduct.

Consequently, the court entered judgment for the defendant Commonwealth on the plaintiff's claim and for the Commonwealth on its counterclaim for £47 16s. Od. The plaintiff was ordered to pay the defendant's costs of the action.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.