JURISDICTION : DISTRICT COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
IN CHAMBERS
LOCATION: PERTH
CITATION: ROYAL -v- ALCOA OF AUSTRALIA LIMITED [2004] WADC 31
CORAM: MULLER DCJ
HEARD: 23 FEBRUARY 2004
DELIVERED : 5 MARCH 2004
FILE NO/S: CIV 2514 of 2002
BETWEEN: DARREN ROYAL
Plaintiff
AND
ALCOA OF AUSTRALIA LIMITED (ACN 004 879 298)
Defendant
Catchwords:
Application for leave to amend defence - Section 175(1) Workers' Compensation and Rehabilitation Act - Whether proposed defence consistent with provisions of the Act
Legislation:
Workers' Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 1981
Result:
Appeal dismissed
Representation:
Counsel:
Plaintiff: Mr B L Nugawela
Defendant: Mr J P Allan
Solicitors:
Plaintiff: Friedman Lurie Singh
Defendant: Clayton Utz
Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):
Hooker Corporation Ltd v Commonwealth (1986) 65 ACTR 32
The State of Queensland & Anor v JL Holdings Pty Ltd (1997) 189 CLR 146
Tony Sadler Pty Ltd v McLeod Nominees Pty Ltd (1994) 13 WAR 323
Case(s) also cited:
Nil
MULLER DCJ: This is an appeal against a decision by the Registrar giving the respondent/defendant leave to amend its defence. The decision by the Registrar is challenged on two grounds: first, it is submitted that the Registrar was wrong in law in allowing the defendant to plead a defence under s 175 of the Workers' Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 1981; second, it is said that there was undue delay by the defendant in applying for leave to amend its defence and that no adequate explanation for such delay has been given.
The defendant operated an alumina refinery in Kwinana. On 1 September 2000 it entered into a contract with G & F Beltline Services to provide conveyor belt splicing, repair and inspection services and pulley lagging services at the refinery in Kwinana. The appellant/plaintiff was employed by G & F Beltline. On 19 June 2001 it is alleged that the defendant was informed by G & F Beltline that belt repair work was required on the B4 North East conveyor at the refinery. This was one of two conveyors on site. A maintenance work order was issued by the defendant for work on this conveyor and the plaintiff was assigned the task in hand. The defendant alleges that contrary to the maintenance work order the plaintiff began work on the other conveyor described as the B4 North West conveyor. It was while he was working on this conveyor that the accident happened and he was injured. The plaintiff claims that his injuries were caused by the negligence of the defendant. In its defence filed on 11 October 2002 the defendant denied it had been negligent. The pleadings were closed and a pre‑trial conference was scheduled for 1 July 2003. On 19 June 2003, approximately one week before the pre‑trial conference, the solicitors acting for the defendant wrote to the plaintiff's solicitors enclosing a minute of a proposed amended defence and requested their consent to the amendments. The plaintiff refused his consent.
In the light of this refusal an application was made by the defendant…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Royal v Alcoa of Australia Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2004] WADC 31
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue was whether the proposed amendment disclosed a valid defence. The court considered whether the amendment, which suggested the applicant was working on a conveyor belt outside the scope of the maintenance work order, was consistent with Section 175(1) of the Act. The applicant argued that the amendment was inconsistent with the Act, while the respondent maintained that the work fell within the scope of the contract between the respondent and G & F Beltline. The court had to determine whether the proposed amendment could be reconciled with the Act and if it was arguable.
The court held that the proposed amendment was not inconsistent with the Act and that the interpretation of Section 175(1) by the applicant was too narrow. The court found that the contract between the respondent and G & F Beltline related to both conveyors at the refinery and that the applicant was on site to work on a conveyor as contemplated by the contract. The court believed that it was arguable that the applicant was injured while executing work contemplated by that contract, even if the work fell outside the scope of the maintenance work order. The court also found that the amendment would not unduly prejudice the applicant and that the applicant would have adequate time and opportunity to address the issue.
The court granted leave to amend the defence and allowed the respondent to litigate the issue. The court noted that any monetary prejudice suffered by the applicant as a consequence of the late amendment could be addressed by an appropriate award of costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The first question I have to decide is whether the proposed amendment discloses a valid defence because a party cannot be given leave to make a defective amendment. Hooker Corporation Ltd v Commonwealth (1986) 65 ACTR 32 at 38. If, as the defendant has admitted in par 3(d) of its proposed amended defence, the plaintiff was working on the B4 North West conveyor contrary to the maintenance work order issued by the defendant which specifically related to the B4 North East conveyor the question does arise whether s 175(1) of the Workers' Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 1981 has any application. Counsel for the plaintiff has submitted that the allegations in par 3(d) and 7A(iii) of the defendant's proposed amended defence are inconsistent with a defence under s 175(1) of the Act. I believed there might have been merit in that submission and at the conclusion of the appeal I invited counsel for the plaintiff to consider an amendment to either one or both these provisions. The defendant has now filed a further minute of proposed amended defence in which par 3(d) remains unaltered but par 7A(iii) has been amended by the deletion of the reference to the B4 North East conveyor. As I understand the position the defendant still maintains that the plaintiff was undertaking work contrary to the maintenance work order but that the work he did on B4 North West conveyor, though not specifically authorised by the maintenance work order, still fell within the scope of the contract between the defendant and G & F Beltline. The proposed amendment has been criticised by counsel for the plaintiff who contends that the proposed pleading is still deficient because there is no express assertion that the plaintiff was involved in the execution of work that was the subject of the contract between the defendant and G & F Beltline when he was injured. I am unable to reconcile the conflict between the parties. In his statement of claim the plaintiff alleges that he went to the defendant's refinery to repair conveyor belt B4 North East but was asked by the defendant's employees to work on conveyor belt B4 North West. The defendant by implication denies having made that request. This is a dispute which can only be resolved by evidence. Whatever the situation might have been I do not believe the defendant's proposed pleadings are inconsistent with s 175(1) of the Act. In my view the interpretation placed on this provision by counsel for the plaintiff is simply too narrow. The contract between the defendant and G & F Beltline related to a number of different sites and clearly covered the repair and inspection of all conveyor belts on those sites. Paragraph 2 of the agreement between the defendant and G & F Beltline specifies that the defendant could modify the contractual duties of G & F Beltline by a direction in writing. The question whether the maintenance work order constituted such a modification as to take the work the plaintiff was doing outside the scope of the contract between the defendant and G & F Beltline is a matter of evidence. As I see it the position is clear enough. The contract between the defendant and G & F Beltline related to both conveyors at the refinery. The plaintiff was on the site to work on a conveyor as contemplated by the contract. That was clearly the intention of both the plaintiff and the defendant. Giving s 175 a broader interpretation than that suggested by counsel for the plaintiff I believe it is strongly arguable that the plaintiff was injured while executing work contemplated by that contract even if the work fell outside the scope of the maintenance work order. I find that the pleading sought to be introduced by the defendant's proposed amendment is certainly an arguable proposition and, in my view, the defendant should not be shut out from litigating an issue which is fairly arguable. The State of Queensland & Anor v JL Holdings Pty Ltd(supra). I do not believe the amendment will unduly prejudice the plaintiff. While the defendant has sought to introduce the amendment at a late stage in the proceedings the plaintiff will still have adequate time and opportunity to address the issue and any monetary prejudice he suffers as a consequence of the late amendment can be addressed by an appropriate award of costs.