[2002] TASSC 52
CITATION: Royal & Sun Alliance Assurance Aust Ltd v Falzon [2002] TASSC 52
PARTIES: ROYAL & SUN ALLIANCE ASSURANCE
AUSTRALIA LTD (ACN 008 3413 545)
v
FALZON, Frank John
TITLE OF COURT: SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA
JURISDICTION: APPELLATE
FILE NO/S: 304/2001
DELIVERED ON: 22 August 2002
DELIVERED AT: Hobart
HEARING DATE: 2 August 2002
JUDGMENT OF: Cox CJ
CATCHWORDS:
Procedure - Discovery and interrogatories - Interrogatories - Answers - In general - Objections - Time for making - Form.
Procedure - Discovery and interrogatories - Interrogatories - Upon what matters - What questions disallowed - Irrelevance - General irrelevance.
Supreme Court Rules 2000 (Tas), rr409 and 410.
Aust Dig Procedure [67]
REPRESENTATION:
Counsel:
Appellant: M Settle
Respondent: R J Phillips
Solicitors:
Appellant: McMahon Fearnley
Respondent: Phillips Taglieri
Judgment Number: [2002] TASSC 52
Number of paragraphs: 12
Serial No 52/2002
File No 304/2001
ROYAL & SUN ALLIANCE ASSURANCE AUSTRALIA
LTD (ACN 008 413 545) v FRANK JOHN FALZON
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT COX CJ
22 August 2002
This is an appeal and cross-appeal from a decision of the Master made in respect of certain interrogatories pursuant to an application under the Supreme Court Rules 2000, r410, by the cross-appellant ("the plaintiff"). The plaintiff had delivered interrogatories for the examination of the appellant ("the defendant") and the latter had objected to answering interrogatories numbered 12, 14 and 17. The Master disallowed interrogatories 12 and 14, but ordered the defendant to answer interrogatory 17. The defendant appeals the order in respect of interrogatory 17 and the plaintiff cross-appeals the disallowance of interrogatories 12 and 14. The cross-appeal is slightly out of time, but application was made for an extension, which I allowed.
The relevant interrogatories and answers are as follows:
"12Subsequent to issuing the Policy to the Plaintiff did you request any information from Dr Klonaris with respect to the Plaintiff's past medical history and in particular past back pain or injury and if so on what date."
Answer:"I object to answering this interrogatory, as it is too wide and objectionable."
"14What information, material or documents did you consider for the purposes of determining the Plaintiff's claim."
Answer:"I object to answering this interrogatory as it is in the nature of cross-examination and objectionable."
"17Look at the document annexed hereto marked 'C' and state:
(a) Is the 'underwriter' referred to in the last paragraph of the last document an agent, employee or servant of the Defendant, stating which.
(b) The name of the 'underwriter'.
(c) Is Berndene Gordon an agent, servant or employee of the Defendant, stating which.
(d) What was the title or position of Berndene Gordon on the date the document was created.
(e)Whether Berndene Gordon was:
(i)authorised; or
(ii)permitted;
to create the document on behalf of the Defendant."
Answer:"(a) I object to answering this interrogatory as it is not relevant as it does not relate to a matter in issue between the parties and is objectionable.
(b)I object to answering this interrogatory as…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Royal & Sun Alliance Assurance Australia Ltd v Falzon and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2002] TASSC 52
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined the objections raised by the defendant against the interrogatories and the arguments presented by both parties. It noted that Rule 409(1) of the Supreme Court Rules 2000 required the defendant to state objections in writing with concise reasons, but Rule 410(3) permitted the court to disallow interrogatories on various grounds, including irrelevance. The court concluded that the preliminary point raised by the plaintiff, that the defendant should be confined to the objections taken in writing, was without merit. It found that Rule 410(3) did not restrict the court's ability to consider other grounds for disallowing interrogatories. The court further analysed each interrogatory in turn, assessing their relevance and propriety. It found interrogatory 12 relevant to the issues in dispute and ordered it to be answered. Interrogatory 14 was deemed to be cross-examinational in nature and thus irrelevant, leading to its disallowance. Regarding interrogatory 17, the court found it irrelevant as the information sought did not pertain to facts in issue or facts relevant to those issues, and thus it was also disallowed.
In conclusion, the court disallowed interrogatories 12 and 17 while allowing interrogatory 14 to be answered. The defendant was ordered to answer interrogatory 12, and the plaintiff's objections to interrogatories 12 and 14 were dismissed. The defendant's appeal against answering interrogatory 17 was upheld. The final orders reflected the court's determinations on the objections and the relevance of the interrogatories in question.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi