Rowley and Decision Maker

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

Rowley and Decision Maker [2023] AATA 2732 (22 August 2023)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2023/3780

Re:Rev Comrade Rowley

APPLICANT

AndDecision Maker

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Emeritus Professor P A Fairall, Senior Member

Date:22 August 2023

Date of written reasons:        25 August 2023

Place:Sydney

The application is dismissed pursuant to subsection 42A(4) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth).

......[SGD]..................................................................

Emeritus Professor P A Fairall, Senior Member

CATCHWORDS

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – jurisdiction – decision to exclude university student – student misconduct – no jurisdiction found – application dismissed

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)
Charles Sturt University Act 1989 (NSW)

Charles Sturt University By-law 2005 (NSW)

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Student Misconduct Rule 2020
University Student Appeals Policy

University Student Appeals Procedure

REASONS FOR DECISION

Emeritus Professor P A Fairall, Senior Member

25 August 2023

INTRODUCTION

  1. Rev Comrade Rowley (the Applicant) seeks review of a decision by Charles Sturt University (CSU) dated 1 May 2023 to affirm the CSU Appointed Officer’s decision to exclude the Applicant from enrolment for five years. The application was listed for an interlocutory hearing on 4 September 2023 to determine whether the Tribunal has jurisdiction to review CSU’s decision. Upon review of the filed materials, the Tribunal dismissed the application pursuant to subsection 42A(4) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (the AAT Act) without proceeding to the listed hearing.

  2. The Applicant was notified of the Tribunal’s decision on 22 August 2023 and requested written reasons for the Tribunal’s decision the following day.

    BACKGROUND

  3. On 27 May 2023, the Applicant lodged his application with the Tribunal, attaching the CSU decision dated 1 May 2023. This decision was the determination of an appeal against CSU’s earlier decision to exclude the Applicant from enrolment for a period of five years under the Student Misconduct Rule 2020 (the misconduct decision). The appeal was confined to considering two discrete issues. First, whether the Applicant was afforded procedural fairness in the misconduct decision, and second, whether the Applicant had new evidence relevant to that decision. In brief, CSU dismissed the appeal, being satisfied that the Applicant was afforded procedural fairness and that he did not have new, relevant evidence.

  4. The letter sent to the Applicant enclosing CSU’s decision includes an appeal clause. That clause states that there are two avenues of appeal against the decision, that is, a complaint to the NSW Ombudsman, or an application to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. On 3 May 2023, a CSU representative emailed the Applicant, in effect restating the appeals clause.

  5. On 5 June 2023, the Registry informed a CSU representative that CSU’s decision was not on the Tribunal’s jurisdiction list. The CSU representative acknowledged that the appeals clause in the letter was incorrect. It should have referred to the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT) rather than the AAT. The CSU representative stated that the appeals clause had now been updated to correct this error.

  6. On 6 June 2023, the Tribunal forwarded…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Rowley and Decision Maker and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 2732
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) concerned an application by a university student seeking review of a decision made by Charles Sturt University (CSU). CSU had previously decided to exclude the applicant from enrolment for five years under its Student Misconduct Rule 2020, following an appeal by the applicant which was dismissed. The applicant sought to appeal CSU's appeal decision to the AAT.

The primary legal issue before the AAT was whether it possessed jurisdiction to review CSU's decision. This question arose after CSU mistakenly informed the applicant that the AAT was an available avenue for appeal, when in fact the correct tribunal was the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT). The AAT was required to determine if any "enactment" as defined by section 3 of the AAT Act provided for review of decisions made under CSU's Student Misconduct Rule 2020, pursuant to section 25 of the AAT Act.

The Tribunal reasoned that for it to have jurisdiction, there must be an enactment that confers a power of review upon the AAT. The Student Misconduct Rule 2020 was made under the Vice-Chancellor's power pursuant to section 109 of the Charles Sturt University By-law 2005 (NSW). However, neither the By-law nor the Rule contained any provision that granted the AAT jurisdiction to review decisions made under them. The AAT noted that the appeal clause in the letter from CSU was incorrect and that the correct avenue for appeal was NCAT.

Consequently, the AAT found that it lacked jurisdiction to review CSU's decision. The application was dismissed under section 42A of the AAT Act.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Applicant was notified of the Tribunal’s decision on 22 August 2023 and requested written reasons for the Tribunal’s decision the following day. BACKGROUND On 27 May 2023, the Applicant lodged his application with the Tribunal, attaching the CSU decision dated 1 May 2023. This decision was the determination of an appeal against CSU’s earlier decision to exclude the Applicant from enrolment for a period of five years under the Student Misconduct Rule 2020 (the misconduct decision). The appeal was confined to considering two discrete issues. First, whether the Applicant was afforded procedural fairness in the misconduct decision, and second, whether the Applicant had new evidence relevant to that decision. In brief, CSU dismissed the appeal, being satisfied that the Applicant was afforded procedural fairness and that he did not have new, relevant evidence. The letter sent to the Applicant enclosing CSU’s decision includes an appeal clause. That clause states that there are two avenues of appeal against the decision, that is, a complaint to the NSW Ombudsman, or an application to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. On 3 May 2023, a CSU representative emailed the Applicant, in effect restating the appeals clause. On 5 June 2023, the Registry informed a CSU representative that CSU’s decision was not on the Tribunal’s jurisdiction list. The CSU representative acknowledged that the appeals clause in the letter was incorrect. It should have referred to the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT) rather than the AAT. The CSU representative stated that the appeals clause had now been updated to correct this error. On 6 June 2023, the Tribunal forwarded this correspondence to the Applicant with an accompanying letter requesting the Applicant to show that the Tribunal has jurisdiction to review CSU’s decision, and raising the possibility of dismissal under section 42A of the AAT Act. On 19 June 2023, the Applicant provided a response. This is considered below.RELEVANT LEGISLATION Section 25 of the AAT Act relevantly provides:(1) An enactment may provide that applications may be made to the Tribunal:(a) for review of decisions made in the exercise of powers conferred by that enactment; or(b) for the review of decisions made in the exercise of powers conferred, or that may be conferred, by another enactment having effect under that enactment An “enactment” is defined in section 3 of the AAT Act to mean:(a) an Act;(b) an Ordinance of a Territory other than the Northern Territory, the Australian Capital Territory or Norfolk Island; or(c) an instrument (including rules, regulations or by‑laws) made under an Act or under such an Ordinance;and includes an enactment as amended by another enactment. CSU’s original decision to exclude the Applicant was made under CSU’s Student Misconduct Rule 2020 (the Rule).[1] Clause 3 of the Rule states that it is made pursuant to the Vice-Chancellor’s power to make rules under section 109 of the Charles Sturt University By-law 2005 (NSW).[2] [1] Student Misconduct Rule 2020 / Document / CSU Policy Library[2] Charles Sturt University By-law 2005 - NSW Legislation

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 27 May 2023, the Applicant lodged his application with the Tribunal, attaching the CSU decision dated 1 May 2023. This decision was the determination of an appeal against CSU’s earlier decision to exclude the Applicant from enrolment for a period of five years under the Student Misconduct Rule 2020 (the misconduct decision). The appeal was confined to considering two discrete issues. First, whether the Applicant was afforded procedural fairness in the misconduct decision, and second, whether the Applicant had new evidence relevant to that decision. In brief, CSU dismissed the appeal, being satisfied that the Applicant was afforded procedural fairness and that he did not have new, relevant evidence. The letter sent to the Applicant enclosing CSU’s decision includes an appeal clause. That clause states that there are two avenues of appeal against the decision, that is, a complaint to the NSW Ombudsman, or an application to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. On 3 May 2023, a CSU representative emailed the Applicant, in effect restating the appeals clause. On 5 June 2023, the Registry informed a CSU representative that CSU’s decision was not on the Tribunal’s jurisdiction list. The CSU representative acknowledged that the appeals clause in the letter was incorrect. It should have referred to the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT) rather than the AAT. The CSU representative stated that the appeals clause had now been updated to correct this error. On 6 June 2023, the Tribunal forwarded this correspondence to the Applicant with an accompanying letter requesting the Applicant to show that the Tribunal has jurisdiction to review CSU’s decision, and raising the possibility of dismissal under section 42A of the AAT Act. On 19 June 2023, the Applicant provided a response. This is considered below.RELEVANT LEGISLATION Section 25 of the AAT Act relevantly provides:(1) An enactment may provide that applications may be made to the Tribunal:(a) for review of decisions made in the exercise of powers conferred by that enactment; or(b) for the review of decisions made in the exercise of powers conferred, or that may be conferred, by another enactment having effect under that enactment An “enactment” is defined in section 3 of the AAT Act to mean:(a) an Act;(b) an Ordinance of a Territory other than the Northern Territory, the Australian Capital Territory or Norfolk Island; or(c) an instrument (including rules, regulations or by‑laws) made under an Act or under such an Ordinance;and includes an enactment as amended by another enactment. CSU’s original decision to exclude the Applicant was made under CSU’s Student Misconduct Rule 2020 (the Rule).[1] Clause 3 of the Rule states that it is made pursuant to the Vice-Chancellor’s power to make rules under section 109 of the Charles Sturt University By-law 2005 (NSW).[2] [1] Student Misconduct Rule 2020 / Document / CSU Policy Library[2] Charles Sturt University By-law 2005 - NSW Legislation

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by examining whether the Tribunal had jurisdiction to review the decision of Charles Sturt University (CSU) under the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (AAT Act). The court noted that section 25 of the AAT Act allows for the review of decisions made in the exercise of powers conferred by an enactment, which includes rules and regulations made under an Act. In this case, CSU's decision was made under the Student Misconduct Rule 2020, which was created pursuant to the powers conferred by the Charles Sturt University By-law 2005 (NSW). However, the court found that the CSU decision did not fall under the jurisdiction of the AAT as it was not made under an enactment conferring powers directly but rather through a by-law of the university. This distinction was crucial as it differentiated between decisions made under direct statutory powers and those made under rules derived from a by-law.

The court then addressed whether section 25 of the AAT Act conferred jurisdiction on the Tribunal to review decisions made under the Student Misconduct Rule 2020 of CSU. It was determined that the rule was made under the authority of the Vice-Chancellor pursuant to the Charles Sturt University By-law 2005 (NSW), which is a state-based by-law rather than a Commonwealth enactment. Given this, the court held that the jurisdiction of the Tribunal under section 25 of the AAT Act did not extend to decisions made pursuant to state-based rules, even if those rules were exercising powers conferred by a Commonwealth by-law. This conclusion was reinforced by the specific language of section 25, which limits the Tribunal's jurisdiction to decisions made in the exercise of powers conferred by an enactment, thereby excluding decisions made under state-based rules.

Further, the court explored whether the CSU decision made pursuant to the Charles Sturt University By-law 2005 (NSW) was reviewable by the Tribunal under the AAT Act. The court clarified that the jurisdiction of the Tribunal under the AAT Act is confined to decisions made under Commonwealth enactments or those having effect under a Commonwealth enactment. As the decision in question was made under a state-based by-law and the rule was not linked to a Commonwealth enactment in a manner that conferred jurisdiction to the Tribunal, the court found that the decision was not reviewable by the Tribunal under the AAT Act.

The court also considered whether the Tribunal's jurisdiction was correctly identified in the correspondence sent to the Applicant and if the Tribunal should have referred the Applicant to the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT) instead. The court found that the appeal clause in the letter sent by CSU to the Applicant incorrectly stated that the decision could be appealed to the AAT rather than the NCAT. The CSU representative acknowledged this error and confirmed that the clause had been corrected. The court noted that while the error was rectified, it raised the question of whether the incorrect reference in the decision itself affected the validity of the Tribunal's jurisdiction or the Applicant's appeal.

In addressing whether the Applicant's appeal to the Tribunal was valid despite the incorrect reference in the CSU decision's appeal clause, the court considered the substance of the appeal and the Applicant's understanding of the available avenues of review. The court found that the Applicant's decision to appeal to the Tribunal, despite the incorrect reference, indicated that the Applicant was aware of the potential for review and chose the Tribunal as the forum for appeal. The court concluded that the Applicant's intent to seek review and the subsequent actions taken by the Tribunal were valid, notwithstanding the error in the CSU decision.

The court further deliberated whether the error in the CSU decision's appeal clause affected the Tribunal's ability to exercise its jurisdiction under the AAT Act. The court held that the error in the appeal clause did not confer jurisdiction to the Tribunal as the underlying decision was not made under an enactment conferring powers to the Tribunal. The court emphasized that the error in the appeal clause did not change the fundamental jurisdictional issue, which was the source of the decision-making power.

Finally, the court addressed whether the Tribunal should dismiss the Applicant's appeal under section 42A of the AAT Act due to lack of jurisdiction. The court found that the Tribunal did not have jurisdiction to review the CSU decision as it was made under a state-based by-law and rule. The court concluded that the Tribunal was correct in raising the issue of jurisdiction and considering the possibility of dismissal under section 42A. The court determined that the appeal should be dismissed due to the lack of jurisdiction, as the decision did not fall within the scope of the AAT Act. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that the Administrative Appeals Tribunal does not have jurisdiction to review decisions made under state-based by-laws and rules that do not confer powers directly under a Commonwealth enactment.