Rowan v Cornwall & Ors (No 4) No. Scciv-90-1481

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

ROWAN v CORNWALL & ORS (No 4)
[2001] SASC 348

Civil

  1. DEBELLE J.          The plaintiff applies pursuant to Rule 53 to amend the statement of claim to include a new paragraph to follow immediately after the existing para 5. The application is made after all parties have led their evidence and closed their respective cases in the course of submissions. The plaintiff seeks to add a paragraph in these terms:

    “The Review Committee was a joint Commonwealth and State of South Australia committee set up to advise both governments. The Commonwealth and the State of South Australia were jointly and vicariously liable for the torts of the Committee and of the Chairperson of the Committee acting in that role.”

    The application is made in the following circumstances.

  2. In this action, the plaintiff pleads a number of causes of action arising over the publication of a report called “Shelters in the Storm” and the circumstances surrounding the publication. The report had been prepared by a Review Committee. After the close of evidence and in the course of submissions, the Commonwealth defendant discovered an agreement made between the Commonwealth of Australia and the State of South Australia in respect of a program which in these proceedings has been called the Supported Accommodation Assistance Program (“SAAP”). Mr Stanley, counsel for the Commonwealth defendant, tendered the document with the consent of all parties. The agreement is made pursuant to the provisions of the Supported Accommodation Assistance Act 1985. The agreement provides in clause 8 sub-clause (7):

    “The Commonwealth and each State shall jointly review the State’s program at such times and in such manner as are agreed upon by the Commonwealth Minister and the State Minister.”

    One of the issues in this action is whether the Review Committee was a Ministerial Advisory Committee within the meaning of s 11 of the Community Welfare Act 1972. The question whether it was a Ministerial Advisory Committee is relevant, among other things, to the question whether it was possible for the Review Committee to be subject to a duty of care and, if so, whether such a duty of care existed. It is also relevant to the question of liability, given that s 235a of the Community Welfare Act provides an immunity for members of a Ministerial Advisory Committee from civil liability.

  3. Central to the submissions of the Commonwealth has been the question whether the Review Committee was a Ministerial Advisory Committee. Indeed, from the very outset of this case, the Commonwealth has made it clear that that question was central to its case, notwithstanding that it was not pleaded.

  4. The agreement between the Commonwealth and the State of South Australia relating to SAAP (“the SAAP agreement”) was, on any view, a discoverable document. There can be no doubt on that issue. It was discoverable because it is relevant to the question as to the nature of this Review Committee. It is relevant to the question whether the Committee was a joint committee under the SAAP program…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Rowan v Cornwall & Ors (No 4) No. Scciv-90-1481 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] SASC 348
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Rowan v Cornwall & Ors (No 4) No. Scciv-90-1481, the plaintiff seeks to amend the statement of claim to include a new paragraph regarding the liability of the Commonwealth and the State of South Australia for the actions of the Review Committee. The amendment application is made late in the proceedings, after all parties have led their evidence and closed their respective cases. The plaintiff seeks to assert that the Review Committee, which was set up to advise both governments, was a joint committee under the Supported Accommodation Assistance Program (SAAP). The proposed amendment also aims to hold the Commonwealth and the State of South Australia jointly and vicariously liable for the torts of the Committee and its Chairperson.

The primary legal issue before the court is whether to allow the plaintiff to amend the statement of claim to include the new paragraph regarding the joint liability of the Commonwealth and the State of South Australia for the actions of the Review Committee. The court must balance various factors in exercising its discretion, including the interests of justice, the potential strain on the litigants, the necessity for efficient court proceedings, and whether the amendment permits a correct issue to be decided.

The court acknowledges that the amendment application is made at an extraordinarily late stage in the proceedings. However, it recognises that the issues the plaintiff seeks to canvass are central to the determination of the case, particularly regarding the liability of the Commonwealth. The court considers that the amendment seeks to clarify an issue rather than introduce a fresh cause of action. The failure to discover the SAAP agreement, which is central to the case, is attributed to the Commonwealth and the State of South Australia. The court also notes that the issues to be addressed by the additional evidence are narrow and focused, which mitigates against the delay caused by reopening the evidence.

Ultimately, the court decides to allow the application to amend the statement of claim, considering the overarching principle of the interests of justice. The court will hear the parties regarding the consequences of the application and the costs occasioned by it.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

DEBELLE J

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: DEBELLE J