Round the Clock Transport Services Pty Limited v Flynn

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

WORKERS COMPENSATION COMMISSION

DETERMINATION OF APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE COMMISSION CONSTITUTED BY AN ARBITRATOR

CITATION:Round the Clock Transport Services Pty Limited v Flynn [2007] NSWWCCPD 204

APPELLANT:  Round the Clock Transport Services Pty Limited

RESPONDENT:  Steven Flynn

INSURER:Allianz Australia Workers Compensation (NSW) Limited

FILE NUMBER:  WCC1495-07

DATE OF ARBITRATOR’S DECISION:          14 June 2007

DATE OF APPEAL DECISION:  2 October 2007

SUBJECT MATTER OF DECISION: Probable earnings but for injury; section 40(2)(a) of Workers Compensation Act 1987; evidence

PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER:  Deputy President Bill Roche

HEARING:On the papers

REPRESENTATION:  Appellant:      Sparke Helmore

Respondent:   Leitch Hasson Dent

ORDERS MADE ON APPEAL:  The Arbitrator’s determination dated 14 June 2007 is confirmed.

The Appellant Employer is to pay the Respondent Worker’s costs of the appeal.

BACKGROUND TO THE APPEAL

  1. Steven Flynn (‘the Respondent Worker/Mr Flynn’) sustained injury to his neck in the course of his employment as a truck driver for Round the Clock Transport Services Pty Limited (wrongly sued as Round the Clock Transport) (‘the Appellant Employer’) on 13 January 2005 and as a result of the nature and conditions of his employment from 1 July 2002 to 13 January 2005.

  1. His claim for compensation was initially accepted but liability was declined by letter from the Appellant Employer’s insurer dated 20 May 2005 with compensation payments ceasing on 3 June 2005.  After being off work for an unidentified period, Mr Flynn returned to work on suitable duties, which he continued to perform up to the date of the arbitration and, presumably, thereafter.

  1. By his Application to Resolve a Dispute (‘the Application’) registered in the Commission on 6 March 2007 he claimed weekly compensation in the sum of $308.50 per week from 2 May 2005 to date and continuing together with lump sum compensation and a general order for medical expenses.

  1. The Appellant Employer’s Reply filed on 29 March 2007 disputed injury, substantial contributing factor, incapacity, entitlement to lump sum compensation and entitlement to medical expenses.

  1. The matter was listed for conciliation and arbitration on 2 and 30 May 2007 when Mr Flynn abandoned his claim for lump sum compensation because of his intention to have the cervical surgery recommended by his treating specialist.  The claim proceeded to arbitration on all remaining issues. 

  1. In a reserved decision delivered on 14 June 2007 the Arbitrator found in favour of Mr Flynn and made the following orders:

“1.That the Respondent pay the Applicant weekly compensation pursuant to s. 40 of the Act at the rate of $219.88 per week from 21 May 2005 to date and continuing in accordance with the provisions of the Workers Compensation Act 1987.

2.That the Respondent pay the Applicant’s expenses pursuant to s. 60 of the Act on production of accounts or receipts.

3.        That the Respondent pay the Applicant’s costs as agreed or assessed.”

  1. The Arbitrator arrived at the figure of $219.88 per week after finding probable earnings but for injury to be $950.00 per week and deducting Mr Flynn’s actual earnings of $730.12 per week. 

  1. The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Round the Clock Transport Services Pty Limited v Flynn and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] NSWWCCPD 204
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this matter, Round the Clock Transport Services Pty Limited (the employer) appeals against the decision of an arbitrator who determined the amount of weekly compensation payable to Steven Flynn (the employee) under the Workers Compensation Act 1987. The employer contests the probable earnings but for injury, arguing that the award should be $119.88 per week instead of the $219.88 awarded by the arbitrator. The appeal was heard on the papers and the issue was whether the arbitrator erred in determining the probable earnings but for injury and applying the five-step process set out in Mitchell v Central West Area Health Service.

The Deputy President considered the submissions and found that the employer’s evidence was vague, imprecise, and inadequate, and did not provide full and proper wage records for the alleged comparable employee. The Deputy President found that the employer's evidence was seriously deficient and fell well short of what was required. The arbitrator was entitled to give it less weight, and her determination was open on the evidence and disclosed no error. The Deputy President rejected the employer's grounds of appeal.

The Deputy President confirmed the arbitrator's determination and ordered that the employer pay the employee's costs of the appeal. The employer is to pay the employee's costs of the appeal. This decision is a true and accurate record of the reasons for decision of Bill Roche, Deputy President of the Workers Compensation Commission.

Background

Background to the litigation

Steven Flynn sustained a neck injury while working as a truck driver for Round the Clock Transport Services Pty Limited on 13 January 2005. The injury resulted from the conditions of his employment from 1 July 2002 to 13 January 2005. Flynn's claim for compensation was initially accepted by the Appellant Employer, but liability was declined by the insurer on 20 May 2005, leading to a cessation of compensation payments on 3 June 2005. After an unspecified period off work, Flynn returned to work on suitable duties until the arbitration hearing. Flynn filed an Application to Resolve a Dispute on 6 March 2007, seeking weekly compensation, lump sum compensation, and medical expenses. The Appellant Employer disputed the injury, incapacity, entitlement to lump sum compensation, and medical expenses. The claim for lump sum compensation was abandoned before arbitration, which proceeded on the remaining issues. The Arbitrator determined in Flynn's favour, awarding weekly compensation of $219.88, finding probable earnings but for injury to be $950.00 per week, and deducting Flynn's actual earnings of $730.12 per week.

The matter was initially heard by an Arbitrator who delivered a reserved decision on 14 June 2007, finding in favour of Flynn. The Appellant Employer sought leave to appeal the Arbitrator's decision, which was granted. The appeal was heard by Deputy President Bill Roche on the papers, and the determination was made on 2 October 2007. The Appellant Employer's appeal was dismissed, and the Arbitrator's determination was confirmed. The Appellant Employer was ordered to pay Flynn's costs of the appeal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Arbitrator erred in her determination of the probable earnings but for injury under section 40(2)(a) of the Workers Compensation Act 1987.
2. Whether the Arbitrator erred in her application of the five-step process set out in Mitchell v Central West Area Health Service.

Held
1. The court rejected the Appellant Employer's appeal against the Arbitrator's determination of probable earnings but for injury under section 40(2)(a) of the Workers Compensation Act 1987. The Arbitrator's finding of probable earnings at $950.00 per week was upheld.
2. The court also found no error in the Arbitrator's application of the five-step process set out in Mitchell v Central West Area Health Service. The Arbitrator's approach was deemed reasonable and appropriate given the evidence presented.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the evidence provided by both parties regarding the Appellant Employer's claim that the Arbitrator erred in determining probable earnings but for injury. The Appellant Employer argued that the Arbitrator should have accepted their evidence that probable earnings were $850.00 per week, as supported by the existence of a comparable employee earning that amount. However, the court found that the Appellant Employer's evidence was vague, unsubstantiated, and lacking in detail, particularly in relation to the identity and duties of the comparable employee. The Arbitrator had rightly discounted this evidence due to its deficiencies, and instead relied on Mr Flynn's evidence and the Appellant Employer's own admissions to arrive at the figure of $950.00 per week. This approach was reasonable and the Arbitrator's determination was upheld.

In relation to the five-step process set out in Mitchell, the court found that the Arbitrator had applied it correctly. The Appellant Employer's arguments centred on the claim that the Arbitrator had failed to properly apply the process, but the court found no such error. The Arbitrator had considered the evidence and applied the appropriate legal principles to arrive at her determination, which was not affected by any error of law or discretion.

The court concluded that the Appellant Employer's appeal should be dismissed, and the Arbitrator's determination was confirmed. The Appellant Employer was ordered to pay the Respondent Worker's costs of the appeal.