Roth v Redland Park Operations Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Roth & Anor v Redland Park Operations Pty Ltd  [2023] QCAT 199

PARTIES:

MANFRED ROTH AND TERESE ROTH

 (applicants)

v

REDLAND PARK OPERATIONS PTY LTD

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO:

OCL 097-21

MATTER TYPE:

Other civil dispute matters

DELIVERED ON:

6 June 2023

HEARING DATE:

On the papers

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Member Scott-Mackenzie

ORDERS:

The proceeding is dismissed.

CATCHWORDS:

REAL PROPERTY – MANUFACTURED HOMES – SITE AGREEMENT DISPUTE – market review of site rent – whether site agreement permits market review of site rent – whether site agreement excludes market review of site rent – whether site agreement states when site rent may be varied

Manufactured Homes (Residential Parks) Act 2003 (Qld), s 4(1), s 14A, s 63, s 64, s 65, s 66, s 69A, s 69B, s 69C, s 69D, s 69E, s 70, s 116, s 117, schedule 2

Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008, s 32(2)

Emmetltow Pty Ltd v Pomroy [2015] QCATA 131

REASONS FOR DECISION

Introduction

  1. The applicants, Manfred Roth and Theresa Roth, are parties to a residential park dispute.  On 13 October 2021 they applied to the Tribunal for an order to resolve the dispute (application).  The application named the park manager, Hometown Australia Communities (park manager), as respondent.

  2. The order of the Tribunal, for the reasons following, is that the proceeding is dismissed.

    Background

  3. The respondent, Redland Park Operations Pty Ltd (park owner), is the owner of a residential park at 22 – 28 Collingwood Road, Birkdale known as Redlands Birkdale (formerly Gateway Lifestyle Redlands).

  4. On 19 November 2018 the park owner and the applicants entered a manufactured homes - site agreement granting the applicants the following rights:

    (a)the right to occupy site number RL 129;

    (b)position a manufactured home on the site; and

    (c)non-exclusive use of the park’s common areas and commercial facilities

(site agreement).

  1. The site agreement is in four parts:

    (a)Part 1: Schedule (detailing the site, rent, and terms and conditions of use);

    (b)Part 2: Terms of the site agreement;

    (c)Part 3: Special terms of the site agreement; and

    (d)Part 4: Acceptance of the site agreement.

    The relevant provisions of the site agreement are referred to below, under the heading “Site agreement”.

  2. On 5 January 2020 the park owner gave to the applicants a notice of general increase in site rent proposing to increase the site rent from $335.70 per fortnight to $350.00 per fortnight (general increase notice).  The notice is referred to below, under the heading “General increase notice”.

    Application

  3. The applicants challenge the validity of the notice on the following grounds:

    1.The site agreement of the applicants does not allow for market review increases.

    2.The site agreement does allow for a CPI increase annually.

    3.The respondent gave a market review increase advice to the applicants on 5 January 2020.

    4.This increase was for the amount of $14.30 per fortnight payable from 9th February 2020.

    5.The relevant CPI increase would have been $7.92 per fortnight.

    6.The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Roth v Redland Park Operations Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] QCAT 199
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Roth v Redland Park Operations Pty Ltd involved a dispute between the applicants, who were residents of a manufactured home park, and the respondent, the owner of the park. The applicants contested a notice of rent increase issued by the respondent, arguing that it was invalid. The case was heard and determined by the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT). The applicants sought to set aside the proposed rent increase and requested a refund of the amount they had overpaid, along with any other appropriate orders.

The legal issues before the tribunal were whether the site agreement between the parties permitted a market review increase in the rent and whether the increase notice issued by the respondent complied with the Manufactured Homes (Residential Parks) Act 2003 (Qld). The applicants contended that the agreement did not allow for market review increases and only provided for annual Consumer Price Index (CPI) increases. They argued that the proposed increase exceeded the CPI increase and was, therefore, invalid. The respondent, on the other hand, asserted that the agreement did allow for market review increases and that the notice complied with the relevant statutory provisions.

In considering the matter, the tribunal examined the terms of the site agreement and the provisions of the MHRP Act. It found that section 10 of Part 1 of the agreement provided for a market review of the site rent, which supported the respondent's position. The tribunal also held that the general increase notice issued by the respondent was in compliance with section 69E of the MHRP Act. Consequently, the tribunal dismissed the applicants' proceeding and upheld the validity of the rent increase notice.

The tribunal's decision was based on its interpretation of the site agreement and the relevant statutory provisions. The tribunal found that the agreement allowed for market review increases and that the notice issued by the respondent was in accordance with the law. The applicants' argument that the increase exceeded the CPI increase was not accepted as the tribunal found that the agreement permitted market review increases, which could be higher than the CPI increase. As a result, the tribunal dismissed the applicants' claims and no orders were made in their favour.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The order of the Tribunal, for the reasons following, is that the proceeding is dismissed.Background The respondent, Redland Park Operations Pty Ltd (park owner), is the owner of a residential park at 22 – 28 Collingwood Road, Birkdale known as Redlands Birkdale (formerly Gateway Lifestyle Redlands). On 19 November 2018 the park owner and the applicants entered a manufactured homes - site agreement granting the applicants the following rights:(a)the right to occupy site number RL 129;(b)position a manufactured home on the site; and(c)non-exclusive use of the park’s common areas and commercial facilities The site agreement is in four parts:(a)Part 1: Schedule (detailing the site, rent, and terms and conditions of use);(b)Part 2: Terms of the site agreement;(c)Part 3: Special terms of the site agreement; and(d)Part 4: Acceptance of the site agreement.The relevant provisions of the site agreement are referred to below, under the heading “Site agreement”. On 5 January 2020 the park owner gave to the applicants a notice of general increase in site rent proposing to increase the site rent from $335.70 per fortnight to $350.00 per fortnight (general increase notice). The notice is referred to below, under the heading “General increase notice”.Application The applicants challenge the validity of the notice on the following grounds:1.The site agreement of the applicants does not allow for market review increases.2.The site agreement does allow for a CPI increase annually.3.The respondent gave a market review increase advice to the applicants on 5 January 2020.4.This increase was for the amount of $14.30 per fortnight payable from 9th February 2020.5.The relevant CPI increase would have been $7.92 per fortnight.6.The applicant [sic.] has made the incorrect payment since 9th February 2020. The orders sought by them are:1.That the market review increase be set aside.2.That a refund be made to the Applicants of the incorrect amount taken by the respondent.3.Any other orders that the tribunal deems appropriate.Response The respondent, in its response filed 15 December 2021 (response), asserts the site agreement, in section 10 of part 1, provides for a market review of the site rent.[1] The general increase notice, it further asserts, complies with section 69E of the Manufactured Homes (Residential Parks) Act 2003 (Qld) (MHRP Act).[2][1]Paragraph 2 of attachment A to the respondent’s response.[2]Paragraph 3 of attachment A to the respondent’s response. Submitted with the response are the following documents:(a)the site agreement;(b)the general increase notice; and(c)a market valuation prepared by John Watt & Associates dated 4 January 2020.Statement by Ms Cochrane The respondent, on 29 April 2022, filed a statement by Ms Wendy Cochrane. She is a sales consultant employed by the respondent and, on 19 September 2020, following payment of a deposit, gave to the applicants a park disclosure document (form 1).[3] The document, on page 15, states the basis for working out the amount of an increase in the site rent.[3]Annexure WC01 to the statement by Ms Cochrane.Applicants reply to the respondent’s response

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established