Ronald Crowe & Others on behalf of Gnulli; Raymond Dann & Others on behalf of the Amangu People; Dorothy Tucker on behalf of Narnoobinya; Andy Campbell & Others on behalf of the Birriliburu Native Title Claimants;...
[2011] NNTTA 156
•4 August 2011
NATIONAL NATIVE TITLE TRIBUNAL
Ronald Crowe & Others on behalf of Gnulli; Raymond Dann & Others on behalf of the Amangu People; Dorothy Tucker on behalf of Narnoobinya; Andy Campbell & Others on behalf of the Birriliburu Native Title Claimants; David Stock & Others on behalf of the Nyiyaparli People; Karajarri Traditional Lands Association Aboriginal Corporation on behalf of the Karajarri Native Title Claimants; Daisy Lungunan & Others on behalf of the Nykina & Mangala Native Title Claimant Group; Glenn Councillor & Others on behalf of Naaguja; Cyril Hayes & Others on behalf of Budina; Evelyn Gilla & Others on behalf of Yugumga-Nya; Scotty Birrell & Others on behalf of Koongie-Elvrie; Marianna Velickovic & Others on behalf of the Widji People; Wilma Freddie & Others on behalf of the Wiluna People; Phyllis Thomas & Others on behalf of the Mantijintjarra Ngalia People; John Graham & Ors on behalf of Ngadju; Andy Campbell & Others on behalf of Birriliburu; Ike Simpson & Others on behalf of Wajarri Yamatji; Elsa Derschow & Others on behalf of Palyku; Johnson Taylor & Others on behalf of Njamal / Western Australia / Atlas Iron Limited; Gindalbie Metals Ltd; Fraserx Pty Ltd; Encounter Resources Ltd; Witx Pty Ltd; Paul Winston Askins; Montezuma Mining Co. Ltd; Dustan Holdings Pty Ltd; Cauldron Energy Ltd; Agricola Resources Pty Ltd; JML Resources Pty Ltd; Gold & Mineral Resources Pty Ltd; Milford Resources Pty Ltd; Bluestar Resources Pty Ltd; Snap Hook (WA) Pty Ltd; Bolgart Rise Pty Ltd, [2011] NNTTA 156 (4 August 2011)
Application Nos: WO10/630, WO10/658, WO10/858, WO10/859, WO10/860, WO10/861, WO10/868, WO10/869, WO10/870, WO10/871, WO10/987, WO10/1169, WO10/1368, WO10/1374, WO10/1489, WO10/1490, WO10/1491, WO10/1492, WO10/1493, WO10/1494, WO10/1495, WO10/1496, WO10/1497, WO10/1557, WO10/1558, WO10/1658, WO10/1670, WO11/120, WO11/129, WO11/245, WO11/302, WO11/346, WO11/353, WO11/415, WO11/572, WO11/573, WO11/671, WO11/672, WO11/744, WO11/749
IN THE MATTER of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth)
- and -
IN THE MATTER of an inquiry into expedited procedure objection applications
Applications are listed in the attached schedule
DECISION TO DISMISS OBJECTION APPLICATIONS
Tribunal: Hon C J Sumner, Deputy President
Place: Perth
Date: 4 August 2011Catchwords: Native title – future acts – proposed grant of mining tenements – expedited procedure objection applications – applications for mining tenements withdrawn – objection applications dismissed.
Legislation:Native Title Act 1993 (Cth), s 148(a)
REASONS FOR DECISION TO DISMISS OBJECTION APPLICATIONS
[1] On the dates specified in the attached Schedule, the Government party gave notice under s 29 of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) of its intention to grant mining tenements to the grantee parties specified therein and included in the notices a statement that it considered that the grants attracted the expedited procedure.
[2] On the dates specified in the attached Schedule the native title parties made expedited procedure objection applications to the Tribunal.
[3] The Department of Mines and Petroleum on behalf of the Government party has advised the Tribunal that each of the applications specified in the attached Schedule were discontinued.
Decision
[4] The objection applications specified in the attached Schedule are dismissed pursuant to s 148(a) of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth).
Hon C J Sumner
Deputy President
4 August 2011
SCHEDULE - DECISION TO DISMISS OBJECTION APPLICATIONS
| Tenement No. | Date of Govt. Party Notification (s 29 Notice) | Objection Application No. | Date Objection Application Lodged | Grantee Party/ies | Native Title Party & Linked Claimant Application No. | Date Tenement Withdrawn or Discontinued |
| E09/1683 | 13/1/2010 | WO10/630 | 13/5/2010 | Atlas Iron Limited | Ronald Crowe & Others on behalf of Gnulli – WC97/28 | 29/7/2011 |
| E70/3607 | 13/1/2010 | WO10/658 | 12/5/2010 | Gindalbie Metals Ltd | Raymond Dann & Others on behalf of the Amangu People – WC04/2 | 21/6/2011 |
| E28/2022 | 10/3/2010 | WO10/858 | 23/6/2010 | Fraserx Pty Ltd | Dorothy Tucker on behalf of Narnoobinya – WC97/40 | 5/7/2011 |
| E28/2023 | 10/3/2010 | WO10/859 | 23/6/2010 | Fraserx Pty Ltd | Dorothy Tucker on behalf of Narnoobinya – WC97/40 | 5/7/2011 |
| E28/2024 | 10/3/2010 | WO10/860 | 23/6/2010 | Fraserx Pty Ltd | Dorothy Tucker on behalf of Narnoobinya – WC97/40 | 5/7/2011 |
| E28/2025 | 10/3/2010 | WO10/861 | 23/6/2010 | Fraserx Pty Ltd | Dorothy Tucker on behalf of Narnoobinya – WC97/40 | 5/7/2011 |
| E69/2702 | 24/3/2010 | WO10/868 | 29/6/2010 | Fraserx Pty Ltd | Dorothy Tucker on behalf of Narnoobinya – WC97/40 | 21/7/2010 |
| E69/2703 | 24/3/2010 | WO10/869 | 29/6/2010 | Fraserx Pty Ltd | Dorothy Tucker on behalf of Narnoobinya – WC97/40 | 21/7/2010 |
| E69/2704 | 24/3/2010 | WO10/870 | 29/6/2010 | Fraserx Pty Ltd | Dorothy Tucker on behalf of Narnoobinya – WC97/40 | 21/7/2010 |
| E69/2705 | 24/3/2010 | WO10/871 | 29/6/2010 | Fraserx Pty Ltd | Dorothy Tucker on behalf of Narnoobinya – WC97/40 | 21/7/2010 |
| E69/2692 | 24/3/2010 | WO10/987 | 16/7/2010 | Encounter Resources Ltd | Andy Campbell & Others on behalf of the Birriliburu Native Title Claimants – WC98/68 | 12/7/2010 |
| E46/825 | 5/5/2010 | WO10/1169 | 3/9/2010 | Witx Pty Ltd | David Stock & Others on behalf of the Nyiyaparli People – WC05/6 | 13/7/2011 |
| E04/2021 | 16/6/2011 | WO10/1368 | 18/10/2010 | Paul Winston Askins | Karajarri Traditional Lands Association Aboriginal Corporation on behalf of the Karajarri Native Title Claimants – WC00/2 | 28/6/2011 |
| E04/2021 | 16/6/2011 | WO10/1374 | 18/10/2010 | Paul Winston Askins | Daisy Lungunan & Others on behalf of the Nykina & Mangala Native Title Claimant Group – WC99/25 | 28/6/2011 |
| E52/2574 | 14/7/2010 | WO10/1489 | 26/10/2010 | Montezuma Mining Co. Ltd | David Stock & Others on behalf of the Nyiyaparli People – WC05/6 | 13/7/2011 |
| E69/2795 | 14/7/2010 | WO10/1490 | 26/10/2010 | Montezuma Mining Co. Ltd | David Stock & Others on behalf of the Nyiyaparli People – WC05/6 | 13/7/2011 |
| E70/3383 | 14/7/2010 | WO10/1491 | 26/10/2010 | Dustan Holdings Pty Ltd | Raymond Dann & Others on behalf of the Amangu People – WC04/2 | 21/7/2011 |
| E70/3384 | 14/7/2010 | WO10/1492 | 26/10/2010 | Dustan Holdings Pty Ltd | Raymond Dann & Others on behalf of the Amangu People – WC04/2 | 21/7/2011 |
| E70/3385 | 14/7/2010 | WO10/1493 | 26/10/2010 | Dustan Holdings Pty Ltd | Raymond Dann & Others on behalf of the Amangu People – WC04/2 | 21/7/2011 |
| E70/3386 | 14/7/2010 | WO10/1494 | 26/10/2010 | Dustan Holdings Pty Ltd | Raymond Dann & Others on behalf of the Amangu People – WC04/2 | 21/7/2011 |
| E70/3383 | 14/7/2010 | WO10/1495 | 26/10/2010 | Dustan Holdings Pty Ltd | Glenn Councillor & Others on behalf of Naaguja – WC97/73 | 21/7/2011 |
| E70/3384 | 14/7/2010 | WO10/1496 | 26/10/2010 | Dustan Holdings Pty Ltd | Glenn Councillor & Others on behalf of Naaguja – WC97/73 | 21/7/2011 |
| E70/3385 | 14/7/2010 | WO10/1497 | 26/10/2010 | Dustan Holdings Pty Ltd | Glenn Councillor & Others on behalf of Naaguja – WC97/73 | 21/7/2011 |
| E70/3387 | 28/7/2010 | WO10/1557 | 24/11/2011 | Dustan Holdings Pty Ltd | Raymond Dann & Others on behalf of the Amangu People – WC04/2 | 21/7/2011 |
| E70/3388 | 28/7/2010 | WO10/1558 | 24/11/2011 | Dustan Holdings Pty Ltd | Raymond Dann & Others on behalf of the Amangu People – WC04/2 | 21/7/2011 |
| E08/2161 | 25/8/2010 | WO10/1658 | 27/12/2010 | Cauldron Energy Ltd | Cyril Hayes & Others on behalf of Budina – WC04/5 | 18/7/2011 |
| E08/2161 | 25/8/2010 | WO10/1670 | 27/12/2010 | Cauldron Energy Ltd | Ronald Crowe & Others on behalf of Gnuli – WC97/28 | 18/7/2011 |
| E09/1684 | 6/10/2010 | WO11/120 | 7/2/2011 | Atlas Iron Limited | Ronald Crowe & Others on behalf of Gnulli – WC97/28 | 29/7/2011 |
| P20/2106 | 6/10/2010 | WO11/129 | 7/2/2011 | Agricola Resources Pty Ltd | Evelyn Gilla & Others on behalf of Yugumga-Nya – WC99/46 | 24/6/2011 |
| E80/4447 | 3/11/2010 | WO11/245 | 3/3/2011 | JML Resources Pty Ltd | Scotty Birrell & Others on behalf of Koongie-Elvrie – WC99/40 | 29/6/2011 |
| P26/3833 | 23/2/2011 | WO11/302 | 1/3/2011 | Gold & Mineral Resources Pty Ltd | Marianna Velickovic & Others on behalf of the Widji People – WC98/27 | 13/7/2011 |
| E53/1572 | 1/12/2010 | WO11/346 | 25/3/2011 | Milford Resources Pty Ltd | Wilma Freddie & Others on behalf of the Wiluna People – WC99/24 | 1/7/2011 |
| E53/1572 | 1/12/2010 | WO11/353 | 30/3/2011 | Milford Resources Pty Ltd | Phyllis Thomas & Others on behalf of the Mantijintjarra Ngalia People – WC06/6 | 1/7/2011 |
| E69/2815 | 15/12/2010 | WO11/415 | 31/3/2011 | Bluestar Resources Pty Ltd | John Graham & Ors on behalf of Ngadju – WC99/2 | 21/7/2011 |
| E69/2831 | 26/1/2011 | WO11/572 | 20/5/2011 | Encounter Resources Ltd | Andy Campbell & Others on behalf of Birriliburu – WC98/68 | 5/7/2011 |
| E69/2832 | 26/1/2011 | WO11/573 | 20/5/2011 | Encounter Resources Ltd | Andy Campbell & Others on behalf of Birriliburu – WC98/68 | 5/7/2011 |
| E52/2650 | 9/2/2011 | WO11/671 | 9/6/2011 | Snap Hook (WA) Pty Ltd | Ike Simpson & Others on behalf of Wajarri Yamatji – WC04/10 | 2/5/2011 |
| E52/2651 | 19/5/2010 | WO11/672 | 18/5/2010 | Snap Hook (WA) Pty Ltd | Ike Simpson & Others on behalf of Wajarri Yamatji – WC04/10 | 2/5/2011 |
| E46/908 | 9/3/2011 | WO11/744 | 4/7/2011 | Bolgart Rise Pty Ltd | Elsa Derschow & Others on behalf of Palyku - WC99/16 | 8/7/2011 |
| E46/908 | 9/3/2011 | WO11/749 | 4/7/2011 | Bolgart Rise Pty Ltd | Johnson Taylor & Others on behalf of Njamal – WC99/8 | 8/7/2011 |
0
0
0