Ronald Brian Morrison v Hanby Pty Ltd & Ors No. Scgrg-97-1533

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

[2000] SASC 135

MORRISON V HANBY P/L & ORS

  1. LANDER J:      The first to the fourth defendants have made two applications by application dated 12 May 2000.   The first application is effectively for further and better discovery.  The second application is for an order that the plaintiff submit himself for examination by a legally qualified medical practitioner provided and paid by the first to fourth defendants. 

  2. Both applications are brought out of time: Supreme Court Rules r 67.01(6) provides:

    “No further interlocutory orders should be made under this rule after the making of the order to proceed to trial unless special circumstances shall be shown to exist which require such order to be made in the interest of justice.”

  3. I am satisfied that these applications, although made out of time, should be heard because the defendants have made out special circumstances; those special circumstances being facts lately brought to the attention of the defendants, which could not have been known to the defendants at the time of the order for setting down. 

  4. The defendants seek the discovery of any will made by the plaintiff at any time.  Defendants' counsel, Ms S Maharaj, relied upon issues raised in the statement of claim and, in particular, the plaintiff's plea that he signed a document entitled 'Acceptance of Offer' as raising issues relating to any will made by the plaintiff.  She relied upon an exhibit to the affidavit of Mr Cullimore, being the 'Acceptance of Offer' itself.  That document provides, without going into any detail, that if the defendants complied with their side of what is said to be the bargain, the plaintiff would draw up a will whereby he would leave all his personal effects and furniture to some of the first to fourth defendants. 

  5. I am satisfied, as she submits, that the question of a will made by the plaintiff is raised on the pleadings and would be discoverable within the rule in The Compangnie Financiere et Commerciale Du Pacifique v The Peruvian Guano Company (1882) 11 QBD 55. However, in my opinion, the issue raised on the pleadings is limited to any will which might have been drawn up after the execution of the acceptance of offer; 1 May 1996. However, that would mean that the plaintiff would need, in my opinion, to have complied with his obligations under r 58, to discover any will which has been made subsequent to 1 May 1996.

  6. During argument Mr H Abbott, who appeared for the plaintiff, acknowledged and accepted that if there was a will which had been drawn after 1 May 1996, that will would need to be discovered.  He told me, however, that his client has made full discovery. 

  7. Later, during further argument, he frankly told me that his client had given instructions to his instructing solicitors relating to the drawing of a will and that he would have to consider, in those circumstances, whether those instructions ought to be discovered and privilege claimed in respect of them. 

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ronald Brian Morrison v Hanby Pty Ltd & Ors No. Scgrg-97-153... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] SASC 135
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Supreme Court of South Australia, the case of Ronald Brian Morrison v Hanby Pty Ltd & Ors (No. Scgrg-97-1533) involved two applications by the defendants seeking further and better discovery, as well as an order for the plaintiff to undergo a medical examination. The defendants argued that the plaintiff had not fully complied with the discovery obligations and that his medical condition was relevant to the case. The plaintiff had acknowledged the need to discover any will drawn up after a certain date but contested the other applications. The court had to determine whether special circumstances justified the out-of-time applications and whether the requested discovery and examination were warranted.

The legal issues before the court included whether the defendants had demonstrated special circumstances justifying the out-of-time applications and whether the discovery of any post-date will and the medical examination of the plaintiff were necessary. The court also had to consider whether the plaintiff's medical condition, if relevant, warranted a medical examination and whether the defendants had the right to compel such an examination. The court's reasoning involved assessing the evidence provided by both parties and determining whether the circumstances justified deviation from the standard rules of procedure.

The court found that the defendants had demonstrated special circumstances justifying the out-of-time applications. However, the court declined to order further and better discovery regarding the will, as it believed the plaintiff would comply with his obligations. Regarding the medical examination, the court determined that while the plaintiff's medical condition was not currently an issue in the pleadings, it would likely become one if the plaintiff amended his claim. The court granted the defendants' application for the plaintiff to undergo a medical examination to determine his medical condition and life expectancy, to be provided and paid for by the defendants. The court set terms for the examination, including the notification of the medical practitioner and the timing of the examination.

The final orders included denying the application for further and better discovery regarding the will, while granting the application for the plaintiff to undergo a medical examination to assess his medical condition and life expectancy. The defendants were required to notify the plaintiff of the medical practitioner and the details of the examination.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established