Rokobatini and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 69 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2000] AATA 445

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No  N1999/1443

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE  DIVISION       )          
           Re      EPENISA TIKO ROKOBATINI   
  Applicant
           And    MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS          
  Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       Dr D. Chappell, Deputy President           

Date5 June 2000

PlaceSydney

Decision      The decision under review is set aside and the matter is remitted back to the Minister with the Direction that Mr Rokobatini not be deported. 

(Sgd Dr Duncan Chappell)  ..............................................
  Deputy President
CATCHWORDS
  IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP – criminal deportation – citizen of Fiji – came to Australia aged nine years and one month – family granted permanent resident status on compassionate grounds – convicted as a minor of illegally using a motor vehicle, larceny, breaking and entering, stealing and robbery – first offence as an adult - robbery in company – sentenced – rendered liable for deportation – granted parole – placed in immigration detention – consideration of seriousness of the offences – risk of recidivism – consideration of performance in prison – breaches of prison discipline – consideration of parole reports – recommended as a special category parolee – consideration of psychological and psychiatric assessments - statistical risk of further offence is high - no evidence of any severe personality pathology or disorder – potential to mature into a responsible citizen – consideration of deterrent factor – consideration of hardship – spent formative years in Australia – some support in Fiji – plan to involve in church outreach - employment opportunity if not deported – consideration of other persons – close bonds among members of the family – weighing of factors – not to be deported.
Migration Act 1958 s200
Rokobatini v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (1999) FCA 492
Rokobatini v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (1999) FCA 1238
Danionel Bustescu v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs FCA 1713
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v SRT (1999) FCA 1197

REASONS FOR DECISION

Dr D. Chappell, Deputy President   

BACKGROUND
Application

  1. Mr Epenisa (Ben) Tiko Rokobatini, the applicant, seeks review of a decision of a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (the Minister), made pursuant to s200 of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act), to deport him from Australia. The Tribunal's jurisdiction to review that decision is granted by s500(1)(a) of the Act.

  2. Mr Ron Kessels, a solicitor, represented Mr Rokobatini at the hearing.  Mr Rokobatini also appeared in person and gave personal testimony to the Tribunal.  The following witnesses also testified on his behalf:

    Reverend R.H. Parr
    Mr J.C, Nametala
    Mr A. Waininall
    Pastor T. Vuli
    Mrs S. Rokobatini
    Ms A. Duffy
    Pastor J.A. Rokobatini

  3. Mr Gordon Johnston, of counsel, instructed by Mr Jason Fong, a departmental advocate, represented the respondent at the hearing.  The following witnesses testified on behalf of the respondent:

    Mr A.M. Pryor
    Mr A. Jain
    Dr G.R.W. Windham Davies
    Mr G. Wade

  4. The Tribunal had before it documents filed for the purposes of s37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (T…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Rokobatini and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Af... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] AATA 445
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Rokobatini v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs involved Mr Rokobatini, a citizen of Fiji who came to Australia as a child and was granted permanent resident status on compassionate grounds. Mr Rokobatini was convicted of several serious criminal offences, including illegally using a motor vehicle, larceny, breaking and entering, stealing, and robbery. Despite these convictions, the Federal Court was required to decide whether Mr Rokobatini should be deported under section 200 of the Migration Act 1958.

The central legal issue was whether Mr Rokobatini should be deported despite the severity of his criminal history, taking into account the hardship he and his family would face if deported, his potential for rehabilitation, and other relevant factors. The court considered the seriousness of the offences, the risk of recidivism, Mr Rokobatini's performance in prison, parole reports, psychological and psychiatric assessments, and the deterrent effect of deportation. It also weighed the hardship to Mr Rokobatini and his family, his formative years in Australia, potential support in Fiji, and employment opportunities.

The Federal Court concluded that despite the serious nature of Mr Rokobatini's crimes, the evidence presented indicated severe hardship for him and his family if he were deported. The court found that his prospects for rehabilitation and becoming a law-abiding citizen would be significantly reduced in Fiji, where access to therapeutic programs and family support would be limited. The court decided that the potential for rehabilitation and the severe hardship to his family outweighed the risk of re-offending. Consequently, the court ruled against deportation, acknowledging the difficult balance between community protection and individual circumstances.

The final orders of the court were that Mr Rokobatini should not be deported, allowing him to remain in Australia.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Given the importance and relevance of the three factors which have just been listed, attention is now turned to the evidence before the Tribunal in relation to each. Following this review the evidence is examined concerning certain other factors which the Policy Direction indicates require consideration by the Tribunal.EVIDENCESeriousness and Nature of the Crime The circumstances surrounding the commission of the deportable offences by Mr Rokobatini and a number of co-offenders was described in the following way by Johnston J at the time of his sentencing of Mr Rokobatini on 16 December 1997:… about 11am on Monday, 17 March 1997, the prisoner [Bolamatu] [sic] met with co-offenders [including Rokobatini] [sic] and a number of others as yet unidentified persons in the Redfern area. They then commenced to drive round the Sydney area, eventually arriving in Castle Hill with the intention of committing a robbery offence on a business premises. The prisoner and other co-offenders then targeted the ANZ Bank situate at 287 Old Northern Road, Castle Hill, as the subject of the robbery. A number of the group entered local shops and obtained plastic grocery style shopping bags in preparation for the robbery. At 2.07pm that day the prisoner and his co-offenders, numbering seven to eight in all, entered the ANZ Bank and commenced to verbally threaten and physically assault staff and customers inside the bank. All staff and customers were ordered to the floor by the offenders, who then commenced to scale the front counter of the bank which was unprotected by glass or screens. Two tellers, both females, were physically assaulted by being pushed to the ground by the offenders, who scaled the counter. These offenders then removed a large quantity of cash from the tellers' drawers whilst other offenders, including the prisoner, remained on the customer side of the counter and menaced customers in that area. Three customers were also robbed of their personal property at this time. The facts in relation to those three customers are set out in the statement of facts tendered in the Crown brief. At the time of entry to the bank a maintenance technician was standing on a ladder whilst repairing the automatic entry doors to the bank. One of the offenders unidentified at this time knocked him from the ladder and kicked him a number of times to the head and body. He sustained lacerations to his body and bruising to his chest. Following the robbery the prisoner and the co-offenders then fled the bank via the front door and ran to two waiting vehicles. Upon driving from the scene one of the vehicles was sighted by the police and a pursuit ensued. The vehicle was driven in a dangerous manner at a high speed to Campbell Street, Northmead, where it stopped outside the Northmead High School. The four occupants then ran from the vehicle and were chased by the police.(see T: 217-219; 225) In the course of his personal testimony to the Tribunal Mr Rokobatini indicated that he had been one of the occupants of the vehicle which had been involved in the high speed chase but he avoided apprehension at the time that the vehicle came to a stop and its four occupants ran away. Mr Rokobatini also gave the following personal description of his role in the robbery during his examination in chief by Mr Kessels:… Everyone has walked in, just me I was the only one that stayed out, everyone has walked in and I could from the outside what was happening. Everyone was, everything was like all over the counter and all that. So I decided to walk in and when I walked in I saw what was going on, I walked straight out. That's when they came out too. We all ran into the car.Now you don't deny that you were part of the robbery?---Yes I was part of the robbery.You knew what was going to happen?---I knew what was going to happen, yes.Were there any weapons involved that you know of?---No, there was no weapon.How was it that you were going to get the money from the tellers if there were no weapons? Was there a plan about how the money would be obtained?---They just went over with no weapons or anything and just took control.Okay. They scared them into it, is that right?---Yes they scared them, yes.Okay. And it was the fact that there were so many of you, is that what you were relying on to try and get the money, is that right?---Yes.Now, did you see anyone hurt during this?---All I saw was the bloke with the ladder, he was right on the window.What was it, a ladder?---Yes, he was on the ladder and I said to him, "Get down." That was it.Did you see anyone hurt him?---When I walked in, yes. There was punches, there was kicks.Can I ask you were you part of that?---Yes I was part of it.Of actually attacking that man?---I didn't attack, no I didn't touch anyone.Now, there were other people in the store who were robbed---?---Yes.Of money?---Yes.I'm not sure what it was but money or jewellery or whatever?---Yes.You were charged in relation to those with being in company with the others when that was done?---Yes.Did you actually take the things from those people yourself?---I never touched nothing.When you went into the bank - - -?---Yes.Again when I say you I mean you and the group, were you disguised at all?---I was just wearing a hat.A hat?---Yes.What about the others, did they have masked on or anything like that?---Everyone just had a hat on.Do you know how much was taken from the bank?---About 80,000 to 90,000.And did you get a portion of that?---Yes.Because you were part of it?---Yes.All right. And how much did you get?---I got a few grand.All right. And what happened to that money?---It all went.It went?---Yes.Where did it go?---It went on drugs.Right, okay. So you spent it?---Yes.(transcript 12 January 2000: 38-40)

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal found Pastor Vuli to be a credible and impressive witness who acknowledged his professional and personal association with the Rokobatini family. This association had extended over many years and had commenced well before the Rokobatini family migrated to Australia. As a former senior public servant, and as a trade union official, Pastor Vuli indicated that he retained close ties with his country of origin and visited Fiji on a regular basis. He was also in close contact with many senior members of the government including past and present Prime Ministers. On the basis of this expertise and experience the Tribunal found that his account of the likely difficulties that Mr Rokobatini would experience in finding employment, in obtaining appropriate counselling and allied services for his drug and related problems, and in being exposed to further crime related opportunities, convincing and authoritative. In Pastor Vuli's opinion Mr Rokobatini's prospects of achieving any rehabilitation would be substantially reduced if he were to be returned to Fiji. He also confirmed that the Rokobatini family would be greatly distressed by his removal from Australia.CONCLUSION The ultimate and very difficult question which the Tribunal must now answer is whether the Australian community's expectation to be protected against the risk of Mr Rokobatini re-offending outweighs the other factors which must be considered as part of the balancing process under the Policy Direction. On behalf of the applicant, Mr Kessels contended that the balance should be found to weigh in favour of his client while Mr Johnston, on behalf of the respondent, contended that the risk of recidivism was too great for Mr Rokobatini to be allowed to remain in Australia. Mr Johnston further contended that the deportation of Mr Rokobatini would send a strong deterrent message to other non-citizen offenders that they too would face such a fate if they were to indulge in similar criminal behaviour. On this occasion, having regard to all of the evidence and to the submissions made on behalf of both parties, the Tribunal is narrowly convinced that the scales weigh against deportation. This is a case in which despite the serious nature of Mr Rokobatini's criminal behaviour, and the associated risk of him re-offending, there is compelling evidence of severe hardship to both him and to his family if he were to now be sent back to Fiji. In particular, the prospects that he does have to be rehabilitated and become a contributing and law abiding person would be seriously diminished by sending him back to Fiji. In that country he would not have access to the same types of therapeutic programs, nor to the nurturing and closely supportive assistance of his immediate family that represent the positive, practical and essential components of any successful rehabilitation plan. In this country that plan would be further facilitated, upon his release from immigration detention, by his placement in a closely supervised parole program of the type which has already been envisaged by the Parole Board at the time of recommending his original release to parole in November 1998.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mention has already been made of the evidence provided by Pastor Rokobatini and Mrs Rokobatini concerning the hardship that they said they would experience if their son Ben were to be deported to Fiji. Pastor Vuli in his evidence confirmed that in his view this hardship would be severe and emphasised the close bonds that existed between the various members of the Rokobatini family (transcript 13 January 2000: 64).CONSIDERATIONPolicy and Submissions As is apparent from the chronology of events set out at the commencement of this decision this matter has now been the subject of extensive review both by this Tribunal and by the Federal Court. The present hearing of this matter occupied five days and the Tribunal had the benefit of receiving substantial and additional evidence about a number of the factors relevant to its decision making function within the framework of the Act and the Policy Direction. In their respective submissions to the Tribunal both parties referred to the circumstances which had led to the remittal of the case back to the Tribunal by the Full Federal Court. Mr Kessels, on behalf of the applicant, stressed that the Tribunal was not in any way bound by what the Full Federal Court had said about the potential prospects of success in Mr Rokobatini's case when it did make this remittal. Justices Whitlam and Gyles in their joint decision had said that they did not agree that deportation was the inevitable result of a proper de novo consideration of the matter in accordance with the Direction. Both justices had gone on, however, to state that:This is not to suggest, of course, that the appellant will necessarily succeed before the Tribunal. It is for the Tribunal to assess the severity of the hardship, and then to carry out the weighing process which is required by the Direction. It is merely to indicate that the possibility of success is not insubstantial.(paragraph 28) In his submissions made on behalf of the respondent, Mr Johnston did not demure from the contentions made by the applicant concerning the way in which the Tribunal should go about its decision making task. Mr Johnston and Mr Kessels were also in agreement that the Tribunal should adopt the approach proposed by Sackville J in Danionel Bustescu v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (1999) FCA 1713, its construction of the Policy Direction, and in particular to its consideration of paragraph 21 of that Direction. Justice Sackville's approach is outlined in the following passage from that decision:39 Mr Johnson submitted that, properly construed, the Direction is not intended to preclude the AAT from considering the particular circumstances of each case, including the degree of hardship likely to be suffered by the potential deportee or members of his or her family. It is therefore open to the decision-maker to find, depending on the circumstances of the case, that the likely hardship outweighs the 'primary consideration' of the expectations of the Australian community (par 6(a)). And this may be so even if the potential deportee has committed very serious offences.40 In my opinion, this approach to the construction of the Direction is correct. If the Direction were intended to have the rigid operation attributed to it by Mr Game, there would be little point in the express recognition in par 5 that the decision-maker should adopt a balancing process that takes into account all relevant considerations, not merely the two primary considerations. Similarly, there would be little point in the acknowledgment in par 21 that it is relevant to consider the degree of hardship which may be suffered by the potential deportee or member of his or her family. As par 22(b) implicitly recognises, even potential deportees who have committed serious criminal offences may escape deportation if, for example, they have spent the greater proportion of their formative years in Australia. Moreover, there is a well-established principle that if an instrument can be construed so as to avoid being held ultra vires, that interpretation should be adopted: D Pearce and S Argument, Delegated Legislation in Australia (2nd ed 1999), par 30.4; see also Hong v Minister for Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [1999] FCA 1567, at [20].41 It follows that, despite some ambiguity in the language, par 21 at the Direction must be read as preserving the discretion of the decision-maker to take into account all the relevant circumstances of the cases and, if otherwise appropriate, to hold that the hardship likely to be experienced by a potential deportee outweighs even serious criminal conduct. This conclusion does not resolve all questions of construction of the Direction, and perhaps not all questions going to validity, but it is sufficient for the purposes of the present case.(at paragraph 39-41)