Rogers v The Commissioner of Water Resources

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

[1993] QLC 8

 
  LAND COURT

BRISBANE.

6TH APRIL, 1993.

Re: Appeal under Water Resources Act. 1989 -

S.4.26

Ross G. Rogers and Nora D. Rogers
  v.
  The Commissioner of Water Resources

(Application for leave to amend grounds of appeal)

D E C I S I O N

Leave is sought to amend the grounds of an appeal made under S.4.26 of the Water Resources Act 1989 (The Act) against a decision of the Commissioner of Water Resources to issue Waterworks Licence No. G-55345 for works comprising an earth and rockfill dam on the Johnstone River, parish Malanda. The appellants objected to the application for the licence. Being dissatisfied with the decision they have appealed to the Court. The appeal in made on 19 grounds. Following lodgement of the appeal on 7th October, 1992, proceedings were instituted in the Supreme Court under Judicial Review Act 1991 for declarations covering numerous matters which if granted would render the decision of the Commissioner void, with the result that an inquiry into the application under the authority of S.4.18 of the Act would have to commence de novo. This matter was heard by Thomas J. The application was stayed until further order. On P.3 of the judgment His Honour summarised the claim before him as follows:-

"They claim that they did not receive the benefit of natural justice in relation to the proceedings and their counsel summarises the basic matters of complaint which underlie the application for review as:  (a) the applicants were wrongly denied a right to a hearing and access to relevant documents;  (b) the decision maker failed to take relevant considerations into account and took irrelevant considerations into account;  (c) the decision maker had no jurisdiction or was not empowered to make the decision."

Among the considerations which led to the proceedings being stayed was the fact that proceedings had been instituted in this Court by way of appeal which it seemed to His Honour "is potentially the more satisfactory course "since" the jurisdiction of the Land Court would enable a review on the merits which is a process not available to this Court.  The Land Court plainly has wider powers of review and correction than this Court has in the present proceedings."  This Court has the power to confirm, vary or revoke the decision (s4.26(4)).  Assuming that the hearing of the appeal proceeds as a hearing de novo (a matter which will be discussed later) the claims made before the Supreme Court may be dealt with by this Court.

Included in the evidence put before this Court in support of the application is a copy of a statement of reasons furnished to MacDonnells, Solicitors for the applicants under the Judicial Review Act which was received by Solicitors on 22nd September, 1992, in reply to a request made by them dated 21st August, 1992. It is noted in the judgment of Thomas J. that certain documentation was being sought under the Freedom of Information Act 1992. I assume that this action…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Rogers v The Commissioner of Water Resources and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1993] QLC 8
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Rogers v The Commissioner of Water Resources involved an appeal by Ross G. Rogers and Nora D. Rogers against the Commissioner of Water Resources. The appeal was made under section 4.26 of the Water Resources Act 1989 and contested the Commissioner's decision to issue a Waterworks Licence for an earth and rockfill dam on the Johnstone River. The appellants had objected to the licence application and, dissatisfied with the outcome, appealed to the Court. The appeal was based on nineteen grounds, primarily concerning the alleged denial of natural justice, procedural errors, and the Commissioner's jurisdiction.

The central legal issues revolved around the appellants' request to amend the grounds of their appeal beyond those originally stated in their Notice of Appeal. The appellants sought to include allegations of jurisdictional errors, breaches of natural justice, and improper consideration of irrelevant factors. The statutory provisions of section 4.26(3) of the Act were strict, limiting the grounds of appeal to those explicitly stated in the Notice of Appeal. The appellants argued that Rule 18 of the Rules of the Land Court, which allowed for necessary amendments, should permit the amendment of their grounds. However, the Court held that such rules could not override the statutory provisions, as evidenced by precedents such as R J Bradshaw and SAG Pratt v The Valuer-General. The Court found that the mandatory nature of the statutory language precluded amendments to the grounds of appeal beyond those initially stated.

The Court ruled that the appeal must proceed as a hearing de novo, meaning it would be conducted afresh, independent of the original decision-making process. This approach was deemed necessary because the administrative decision of the Commissioner did not follow judicial procedures. The Court further clarified that while jurisdictional issues could be raised at any time, the appellants were still bound by the grounds stated in their Notice of Appeal. The application for leave to amend the grounds of appeal was therefore refused.

The final orders of the Court were that the application for leave to amend the grounds of appeal was dismissed, and the appeal would proceed based on the original grounds stated in the Notice of Appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established