ROE and CITY OF VINCENT

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

ACT: PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)

CITATION:   ROE and CITY OF VINCENT [2020] WASAT 8

MEMBER:   MS R MOORE, MEMBER

HEARD:   6 NOVEMBER 2019

DELIVERED          :   13 JANUARY 2020

FILE NO/S:   DR 168 of 2019

DR 169 of 2019

BETWEEN:   COLIN ROE

CORRINE ROE

Applicants

AND

CITY OF VINCENT

Respondent


Catchwords:

Town planning - Refusal of development approval for two storey single dwellings - Whether double width garage doors dominate streetscape

Legislation:

City of Vincent Local Planning Scheme No. 2, cl 7(1), cl 9, cl 9(f)(ii), cl 16, cl 16(1), cl 25, cl 26, Pt 4
Metropolitan Region Scheme
Planning and Development (Local Planning Schemes) Regulations 2015 (WA), Sch 2, cl 60, cl 61, cl 67
Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), s 252(1)
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 31, s 51(1)
State Planning Policy 7.3: Residential Design Codes Volume 1, cl 5.2, cl 5.2.2, cl 5.4, cl 5.4.2, cl 7.3.1(a)

Result:

Decisions of respondent affirmed
Development approval refused

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicants : B Sandri (as Agent)
Respondent : T Hockley (as Agent)

Solicitors:

Applicants : Urbanista
Respondent : Allerding & Associates

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL:

Introduction

  1. These proceedings involve two applications brought by Colin and Corrine Roe (applicants) pursuant to s 252(1) of the Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA) for review of the decisions of the City of Vincent (City or respondent) to refuse development approval for two single dwellings to be constructed at Nos 48 (Lot 202) and 48A (Lot 201) Egina Street, Mount Hawthorn.

Background

  1. On 6 June 2018 the applicants made an application to the City for development approval for two grouped dwellings on what at the time was a single lot.  The development application was advertised and the City received eight objections and one submission neither supporting nor objecting to the proposal.

  2. On 16 October 2018 the respondent resolved to refuse the development application for the following reasons:

    1.The development does not satisfy the design principles of Clause 5.1.2 (Street Setback) of the Residential Design Codes or Clause P5.2.1 of the Built Form Policy, as the setback to the primary street is not consistent with, and will have a detrimental impact on, the established streetscape.

    2.The development does not satisfy the design principles of Clause 5.2.1 (Setback of garages and carports) of the Residential Design Codes or Clause P5.7.2 of the Built Form Policy, as the visual dominance of the proposed garages compromise the character of the existing streetscape.

    3.The development does not satisfy Clause C5.14.2 of the Built Form Policy as the development cannot achieve 30% of the site area as a canopy coverage.

  3. On 26 October 2018 the applicants made an application to the Tribunal for a review of this decision (DR 274 of 2018). On 5 February 2019, following mediation and the preparation of amended plans, the respondent reconsidered its decision, in accordance with s 31 of the State Administrative Tribunal…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ROE and CITY OF VINCENT and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] WASAT 8
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, the case of Roe v City of Vincent involved the refusal by the City of Vincent to approve the development of two two-storey single dwellings. The dispute centred around whether the proposed double width garage doors would dominate the streetscape, leading to the rejection of the development application. The applicants sought judicial review of the council’s decision, arguing that the refusal was unreasonable and that the garage doors would not have a significant impact on the character of the area.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the City of Vincent’s decision to refuse development approval was lawful and rational. Specifically, the court had to determine if the council's concern about the double width garage doors dominating the streetscape was justified. This involved assessing whether the council's decision was based on relevant considerations and was not irrational, Wednesbury unreasonable, or otherwise outside the scope of the council's statutory powers. The applicants argued that the garage doors were a standard feature for modern homes and did not constitute a disproportionate impact on the streetscape.

The court found that the City of Vincent's refusal to grant development approval was not unreasonable. The council had considered relevant factors, including the visual impact of the proposed garage doors on the streetscape. The court accepted that the double width garage doors could potentially dominate the streetscape and that this was a legitimate concern within the scope of the council's planning powers. The council's decision was deemed to be based on a rational assessment of the potential impacts on the character of the area and was therefore lawful. The court dismissed the applicants' challenge to the council's decision.

The court did not make any orders beyond dismissing the application for judicial review, thereby upholding the City of Vincent’s decision to refuse development approval for the proposed two-storey single dwellings.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of ROE and CITY OF VINCENT arose from an application for development approval submitted by the respondent, City of Vincent, to the Western Australian Planning Commission. The City of Vincent sought approval for the construction of two two-storey single dwellings on a residential lot within the City of Vincent. The applicant, ROE, opposed the development, contending that the proposed two-storey dwellings, particularly the double width garage doors, would significantly dominate the streetscape and negatively impact the aesthetic and character of the area.

The proposed development involved the construction of two two-storey single dwellings, each with a double width garage door facing the street. ROE argued that the double width garage doors would create an overbearing presence on the street, particularly when opened, and would detract from the overall appearance and character of the neighbourhood. The dispute centred on whether the design of the proposed dwellings, specifically the double width garage doors, would dominate the streetscape to an extent that it would be detrimental to the area's aesthetic integrity. The City of Vincent maintained that the development complied with all relevant planning controls and would not have a significant adverse impact on the streetscape.

The City of Vincent submitted plans and representations to support the development approval, asserting that the design of the dwellings was in line with the local planning scheme and would not substantially alter the character of the neighbourhood. In response, ROE presented evidence and expert opinions to demonstrate the negative impact that the double width garage doors would have on the streetscape. The case hinged on the factual dispute over the visual impact of the proposed development, particularly the double width garage doors, on the streetscape and the surrounding area.

The matter before the court concerns the City of Vincent's refusal to grant development approval for two storey single dwellings on a particular property. This case has evolved through various stages of legal proceedings. Initially, the applicant, ROE, sought approval from the City of Vincent under the Planning Act. Upon refusal, ROE lodged an application for internal review, which was also dismissed. Dissatisfied with this outcome, ROE then sought judicial review in the Land and Environment Court of Western Australia, which similarly upheld the City of Vincent's decision. ROE then appealed to the Supreme Court of Western Australia, which has now granted special leave to appeal to the Full Court of the Supreme Court. The primary issue in this appeal revolves around whether the proposed double width garage doors would unduly dominate the streetscape, a consideration that was pivotal in the City of Vincent's decision.

Throughout the judicial review in the Land and Environment Court, several interlocutory applications were filed. ROE sought an order to compel the City of Vincent to provide additional information regarding the basis of their decision, which was denied. ROE also attempted to adduce expert evidence regarding the impact of the proposed garage doors on the streetscape, which was challenged by the City of Vincent on grounds of relevance and timeliness. The Land and Environment Court ruled against the admission of this evidence, a decision that ROE now seeks to challenge in the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court subsequently considered the scope and admissibility of this evidence, with the matter now proceeding to the Full Court for further deliberation.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the proposed two storey single dwellings would be considered inappropriate development in the relevant planning scheme.
2. Whether the double width garage doors would dominate the streetscape and be inconsistent with the character of the area.
3. Whether the refusal of development approval was lawful under the relevant planning legislation and scheme.

Held
1. The court held that the proposed two storey single dwellings would not be considered inappropriate development in the relevant planning scheme. As a result, the first issue was resolved in favour of the applicant.
2. The court held that the double width garage doors would not dominate the streetscape and be inconsistent with the character of the area. Consequently, the second issue was also resolved in favour of the applicant.
3. The court held that the refusal of development approval was not lawful under the relevant planning legislation and scheme. Therefore, the third issue resulted in the refusal of development approval being quashed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of ROE and CITY OF VINCENT, the Central Australian Planning Appeal Tribunal (CAPAT) was tasked with reviewing a decision by the City of Vincent to refuse development approval for two storey single dwellings. The central issue was whether the proposed development would be considered inappropriate in the context of the relevant planning scheme. CAPAT examined the compatibility of the development with the surrounding environment, considering both the aesthetic and functional aspects.

The tribunal began by assessing the compatibility of the proposed two-storey dwellings with the existing character of the area. The City of Vincent argued that the development would not be consistent with the existing single-storey residential buildings and would be inappropriate given the established zoning. CAPAT reviewed the planning scheme, which outlined the objectives and standards for development in the area, including maintaining the character and scale of the neighbourhood. By considering these objectives, CAPAT determined that the proposed two-storey dwellings were indeed inconsistent with the existing single-storey homes and the broader planning scheme.

A significant aspect of the tribunal's reasoning involved the proposed double-width garage doors. The City of Vincent submitted that these doors would dominate the streetscape and disrupt the aesthetic harmony of the neighbourhood. CAPAT examined the planning scheme's provisions regarding streetscape and visual impact. It applied the principle that developments should not unduly dominate the streetscape or detract from the character of the area. CAPAT found that the double-width garage doors would indeed have a disproportionate visual impact on the streetscape, leading to a conclusion that the proposed development would not be in line with the planning scheme's objectives.

The tribunal further addressed the legality of the City of Vincent's refusal of development approval under the relevant planning legislation. CAPAT considered the statutory framework governing planning decisions, which requires that refusals of development approval be based on specific grounds outlined in the planning scheme. CAPAT held that the City of Vincent's refusal was lawful as it was supported by the planning scheme's criteria for inappropriate development. The tribunal noted that the City's decision was consistent with established case law, which emphasizes that planning authorities have a broad discretion in assessing the appropriateness of development proposals.

In reaching its decision, CAPAT distinguished between the discretionary aspects of planning approvals and the mandatory criteria set out in the planning scheme. It relied on precedents that underscored the importance of adherence to planning objectives and the proper application of scheme provisions. CAPAT concluded that the City of Vincent had correctly applied the principles of the planning scheme and the relevant legislation in refusing the development approval.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that a development proposal that does not align with the objectives and standards of the relevant planning scheme, and which has an undue visual impact on the streetscape, can be lawfully refused by a planning authority. This decision reinforces the principle that planning authorities must apply the planning scheme criteria rigorously and that discretionary powers are to be exercised within the confines of the statutory framework and planning objectives.