Robs Extreme Construction Pty Ltd v Workers Compensation Nominal Insurer (iCare)

Link copied
Case Copied 77 min read
CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MEMBER 
CITATION: Robs Extreme Construction Pty Ltd v Workers Compensation Nominal Insurer (iCare) & Anor [2025] NSWPIC 47
APPLICANT: Robs Extreme Construction Pty Ltd
FIRST RESPONDENT: Workers Compensation Nominal Insurer (iCare)
SECOND RESPONDENT: Hassan Saleh
MEMBER: Gaius Whiffin
DATE OF DECISION: 14 February 2025

CATCHWORDS:

WORKERS COMPENSATION - Workers Compensation Act 1987 (the 1987 Act); claim by uninsured employer pursuant to section 145(3) alleging that it is not liable in respect of compensation payments made by the first respondent to the second respondent; consideration of oral evidence, statement evidence, medical reports and other treatment records, claim correspondence, and factual material; consideration of which party bears the onus of proof; consideration of witnesses’ credit; consideration of the importance of contemporaneous medical records; consideration of the caution to be exercised with treating medical records; consideration of the extent of the injuries sustained by the second respondent; consideration of the second respondent’s correct pre-injury average weekly earnings (PIAWE); consideration of the second respondent’s current work capacity between 3 March 2021 and 15 August 2023; Malco Engineering Pty Ltd v Ferreira, Nguyen v Cosmopolitan Homes, Watson v Foxman, Raniere Holdings Pty Limited v Daley, Davis v Council of the City of Wagga Wagga, Mason v Demasi, Winter v New South Wales Police Force, A1 Granny Flats v Workers Compensation Nominal Insurer, Drca v KAB Seating Systems Pty Ltd, Onassis v Vergottis, Paric v John Holland (Constructions) Pty Limited, and Paric v John Holland (Constructions) Pty Limited considered; Held – the applicant has failed to discharge its onus of proving that the second respondent did not suffer injuries to his neck, back, right shoulder, right hip, and right knee; second respondent suffered injury to his neck, back, right shoulder, right hip, right knee, and right ankle pursuant to sections 4 and 9A; the applicant has failed to discharge its onus of proving that the first respondent paid weekly benefits compensation to the second respondent pursuant to an incorrect PIAWE of $808.50; the applicant has failed to discharge its onus of proving that the second respondent had current work capacity during the period between 3 March 2021 and 15 August 2023; as a result of the second respondent’s injury on 18 November 2020 he had no current work capacity during the period between 3 March 2021 and 15 August 2023; the second respondent was therefore entitled to weekly benefits compensation in accordance with sections 36(1) and 37(1); entitlement being calculated by the first respondent in accordance with a PIAWE of $808.50; as a result of the second respondent’s injury on 18 November 2020 he required medical treatment costing $242.50; the applicant was not insured in respect of its liability to compensate the second respondent in accordance with the 1987 Act; the amount of $91,724.88 has been paid by the first respondent which reflects the valid and legitimate entitlements of the second respondent to compensation with respect to his 18 November 2020…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Robs Extreme Construction Pty Ltd v Workers Compensation Nom... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] NSWPIC 47
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Robs Extreme Construction Pty Ltd sought a determination from the Workers Compensation Nominal Insurer (iCare) regarding its liability for compensation payments made to a former employee, who was injured while working for Robs Extreme Construction Pty Ltd. The dispute centred on whether the employer was liable for the compensation payments made by iCare, given that Robs Extreme Construction Pty Ltd was uninsured at the time of the injury. The case was heard in the relevant Australian court, where the primary issue was whether Robs Extreme Construction Pty Ltd could prove that the injured worker did not sustain injuries to his neck, back, right shoulder, right hip, right knee, and right ankle, and whether the compensation payments were based on an incorrect pre-injury average weekly earnings (PIAWE).

The court assessed various pieces of evidence, including oral testimony, written statements, medical reports, and treatment records, to determine the extent of the worker's injuries and the correctness of the PIAWE used in calculating compensation. The court also examined the credit of the witnesses and the reliability of the medical records, bearing in mind the need for caution in treating such records. The employer bore the onus of proving its claims, and it had to demonstrate that the worker did not suffer the injuries alleged, that the compensation payments were made based on an incorrect PIAWE, and that the worker had work capacity during a specified period. The court found that the employer had not successfully discharged this onus.

The court concluded that the worker had indeed suffered injuries to his neck, back, right shoulder, right hip, right knee, and right ankle, and that the compensation payments were correctly calculated based on the PIAWE of $808.50. The worker had no current work capacity from 3 March 2021 to 15 August 2023, entitling him to weekly benefits compensation. Additionally, the worker required medical treatment costing $242.50, and Robs Extreme Construction Pty Ltd was not insured for its liability to compensate the worker. Consequently, the employer was liable for the $91,724.88 paid by iCare, representing the worker's valid compensation entitlements. The court ordered Robs Extreme Construction Pty Ltd to pay iCare the amount of $91,724.88.

Background

Background to the litigation

Robs Extreme Construction Pty Ltd, an uninsured employer, made a claim under section 145(3) of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (the 1987 Act) against Workers Compensation Nominal Insurer (iCare), seeking to avoid liability for compensation payments made to a worker, the second respondent. The second respondent alleged he suffered injuries to his neck, back, right shoulder, right hip, right knee, and right ankle in an incident on 18 November 2020. The first respondent, iCare, had paid the second respondent weekly benefits compensation from 3 March 2021 to 15 August 2023. Robs Extreme Construction Pty Ltd disputed the worker's claims, arguing he did not sustain the alleged injuries, and that the compensation paid was based on an incorrect pre-injury average weekly earnings (PIAWE) figure. The court examined various forms of evidence, including oral and statement evidence, medical reports, treatment records, correspondence, and factual material, to determine the veracity of the claims and the extent of the injuries.

The matter was brought before the court as a claim by Robs Extreme Construction Pty Ltd under section 145(3) of the 1987 Act. This section allows an uninsured employer to seek a declaration that it is not liable for compensation payments made by the Workers Compensation Nominal Insurer. The case involved detailed examination of evidence and submissions from both parties. Prior to this hearing, there were no formal proceedings or decisions in other tribunals or courts directly related to this dispute. The primary focus of the hearing was to determine the liability of Robs Extreme Construction Pty Ltd for the compensation payments made to the second respondent.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the second respondent sustained injuries to his neck, back, right shoulder, right hip, right knee, and right ankle on 18 November 2020.
2. Whether the pre-injury average weekly earnings (PIAWE) of the second respondent was correctly calculated at $808.50.
3. Whether the second respondent had current work capacity between 3 March 2021 and 15 August 2023.
4. Whether Robs Extreme Construction Pty Ltd is liable for the compensation payments made by iCare in respect of the second respondent's injury on 18 November 2020.

Held
1. The court held that the second respondent did sustain injuries to his neck, back, right shoulder, right hip, right knee, and right ankle on 18 November 2020.
2. The court held that the pre-injury average weekly earnings (PIAWE) of the second respondent was correctly calculated at $808.50.
3. The court held that the second respondent did not have current work capacity between 3 March 2021 and 15 August 2023.
4. The court held that Robs Extreme Construction Pty Ltd is liable for the compensation payments made by iCare in respect of the second respondent's injury on 18 November 2020.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the evidence presented by both parties, including oral testimony, statement evidence, medical reports, and other treatment records. It considered the onus of proof and the credibility of the witnesses, emphasizing the importance of contemporaneous medical records while also exercising caution in interpreting treating medical records. The court held that the second respondent sustained injuries as alleged, rejecting the applicant's claims that these injuries did not occur or were less severe than claimed. Regarding the PIAWE, the court found no evidence to suggest the figure of $808.50 was incorrect and thus upheld the calculation made by the first respondent. The court also found that the second respondent did not have current work capacity during the specified period, thus supporting his entitlement to weekly benefits compensation. Given these findings, the court concluded that the applicant was not insured against its liability to compensate the second respondent under the Workers Compensation Act 1987. Consequently, the applicant was held liable for the compensation payments made by iCare, amounting to $91,724.88, in accordance with section 145(3) of the 1987 Act.