Robin Fletcher and TNT Australia Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

[2013] AATA 173

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

 2011/5408

Re

 Robin Fletcher

APPLICANT

And

 TNT Australia Pty Ltd

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

 Senior Member A K Britton

Date   27 March 2013
Place Sydney

Decision Summary

The decision under review is affirmed.

............[SGD]............................................................

Senior Member A K Britton

CATCHWORDS

WORKERS’ COMPENSATION—Whether back and neck conditions were an injury (other than a disease)—Whether there was an aggravation of an injury—Contribution, to a significant degree, by employment—Causation—Decision affirmed

LEGISLATION

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) – ss 4; 5A(1); 5B(1); 5B(2); 14;

CASES

Comcare v Etheridge (2006) 149 FCR 522

Comcare v Sahu-Khan (2007) 156 FCR 536

Commonwealth v Beattie (1981) 35 ALR 369

Federal Broom Co Pty Ltd v Semlitch (1964) 110 CLR 626

Kennedy Cleaning Services Pty Limited v Petkoska (2000) 200 CLR 286

Tippett v Australian Postal Corporation (1998) 27 AAR 40

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member A K Britton

27 March 2013

  1. Mr Robin Fletcher was employed as a warehouse operator by TNT Australia Pty Ltd between May 2005 and August 2010. The work was heavy in nature and involved loading and unloading freight. Twelve months after resigning from TNT, Mr Fletcher lodged a claim for compensation under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act1988 (Cth) (the Act) in respect of an alleged injury involving his back and neck. TNT refused that claim. Mr Fletcher now seeks review of that decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

  2. TNT will be liable to pay compensation in accordance with the Act in respect of any “injury” suffered by Mr Fletcher if it results in impairment or incapacity for work (s 14 of the Act).

  3. TNT became a “licenced corporation” on 1 July 2008. Therefore TNT’s liability (if any) under the Act is confined to Mr Fletcher’s employment after that date. Unless otherwise stated, in these reasons, all references to “Mr Fletcher’s employment” is to the period, 1 July 2008 to the date of his resignation, 13 August 2010.

  4. The principal issues in dispute are whether Mr Fletcher’s long-standing back condition (or any aggravation of that condition) was contributed to, to a significant degree, by his employment with TNT, or arose out of, or in the course of, that employment. With respect to the alleged neck injury, the main issue to be decided is whether Mr Fletcher suffers a neck “ailment” and, if so, whether it was contributed to, to a significant degree, by his employment with TNT.

    Did Mr Fletcher suffer “an injury” involving his back and/or neck for which TNT is liable?

  5. The Act defines “injury” to mean (s 5A(1)):

    (a)a disease suffered by an employee; or

    (b)an injury (other than a disease) suffered by an employee, that is a physical or mental injury arising out of, or in the course of, the employee's employment; or

    (c)an aggravation of a physical or mental injury (other than a disease) suffered by an employee (whether or not that injury arose out of, or in the course of, the employee's employment), that is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Robin Fletcher and TNT Australia Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] AATA 173
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Robin Fletcher versus TNT Australia Pty Ltd, the parties were engaged in a dispute concerning the nature and extent of Mr Fletcher's work-related injuries, and whether TNT was liable for any aggravation of his pre-existing back condition. The case was heard in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia. The central legal issues were whether Mr Fletcher's employment with TNT contributed to his pre-existing back condition or merely aggravated it, and if the aggravation was due to his work activities, whether TNT was liable for compensation.

The court examined the medical evidence, noting that there was no consensus among the experts on the cause of Mr Fletcher's symptoms, but all agreed that his employment did not contribute to the underlying pathology. Dr Schutz, who reviewed the Brazilian films, found them insignificant. The court also considered the nature of Mr Fletcher's work, which involved heavy lifting and repetitive movements, and acknowledged that such work could have aggravated his pre-existing condition. The court highlighted that Mr Fletcher's symptoms did not abate after leaving TNT, which suggested that his condition was not merely an aggravation of a pre-existing injury but rather a continuation of it.

The court concluded that while Mr Fletcher's employment could have aggravated his back condition, there was no evidence that it contributed to the underlying pathology. Consequently, TNT was not liable for compensation related to the aggravation of Mr Fletcher's pre-existing back condition. The court ordered that TNT was not responsible for any further compensation beyond what had already been paid.

The final orders of the court were that TNT was not liable for any additional compensation related to the aggravation of Mr Fletcher's back condition, and that the proceedings were to be dismissed with no order as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Dr Schutz is the only expert to have seen the Brazilian films. In his opinion they merely confirmed his interpretation of the October 2011 scans and were of “no significance”.Findings and conclusions The weight of medical evidence is that the degree of symptoms reported by Mr Fletcher is inconsistent with the findings on clinical examination and the radiological evidence. Drs Castle and Panjratan were unable to identify the cause of Mr Fletcher’s reported symptoms; Dr Carr thought an internal disc was possibly to blame; Dr Schutz thought the most likely cause was mild disc degeneration. While there is a range of medical opinion about the underlying cause of Mr Fletcher’s symptoms, none of the experts have stated that employment with TNT was a contributory factor. Dr Carr, who thought an internal disc disruption might be the cause of Mr Fletcher’s symptoms, did not suggest that that pathology was work related. While I do not accept as claimed by Mr Fletcher for the first time in these proceedings that on occasion he was required to lift parcels of up to 60 kilograms unaided, I accept as conceded by his manager that from time to time parcels weighing more than 30 kilograms found their way into his section. It is not implausible that work of the nature undertaken by Mr Fletcher, which was heavy in nature and involved, among other things, repeated lifting, bending and prolonged standing, could have aggravated Mr Fletcher’s long-standing back problems. While some of the experts thought work of this type made Mr Fletcher vulnerable to back injury and was therefore best avoided, none suggested that this type of work contributed to Mr Fletcher’s underlying back pathology (however described). Mr Fletcher has given a consistent history of intermittent back pain that has gradually worsened since 2001. He did not report any easing of symptoms after leaving TNT, to any of the practitioners who assessed him after that date. The sole evidence to suggest that there may have been some abatement of symptoms, is the questionnaire completed by Mr Fletcher a month after leaving TNT. In that questionnaire he rated his experience of pain as three (out of ten), a reduction from previous ratings of six and seven. The questionnaire in my opinion is not a reliable indicator of the history of Mr Fletcher’s back pain because the answers he gave were not specifically related to his back but but rather to his neck, lower back, leg, upper back and foot. In my opinion the history given to the practitioners is probably a more reliable account of the progress of Mr Fletcher’s back symptoms. While Dr Carr is not of the opinion that work contributed in some way to Mr Fletcher’s pathology, he is of the opinion that work aggravated his condition (see for example his report of 28 September 2009). The absence of evidence of any easing of symptoms after leaving TNT, suggests that Mr Fletcher’s condition falls within the first of the categories referred to by Finkelstein J in Tippett at [21] :[A] pre-existing injury that causes the worker to suffer pain whether or not the worker is at work and the case of a worker who has a pre-existing injury and it is the activities at work that cause the worker to suffer pain or to suffer pain more intensely. It is only in the latter case that it can be said that the worker has suffered an aggravation of his or her pre-existing injury.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Duration of the employment (s 5B(2)(a)): Mr Fletcher was employed by TNT from May 2005, initially on a casual basis and, from September 2007, on a full-time basis. He resigned in August 2010. For current purposes the only relevant period of employment is that throughout which TNT was a licenced corporation (i.e. 1 July 2008 to 13 August 2010). Nature of, and particular tasks involved in, the employment (s 5B(2)(b)): The parties agree that the report prepared by workplace assessor, Recovre dated 7 December 2009, contains a fair description of the type of work undertaken by Mr Fletcher while employed at TNT. The report states that while Mr Fletcher was required to undertake a range of tasks including data entry and other light duties, for the most part the work was heavy and involved loading, unloading and processing freight; the work also involved repetitive lifting (up to 30 kilograms), prolonged standing, frequent bending and twisting; the tasks were rotated on a daily/weekly basis. The only material issue in dispute between the parties about the nature of the work performed by Mr Fletcher was whether he was required to lift more than 30 kilograms. Mr Fletcher reported to Recovre in 2009 that he handled freight weighing anywhere between one and 40 kilograms. In these proceedings he testified that the freight he handled sometimes weighed up to 60 kilograms. Mr Fletcher’s supervisor, Mr Normy Chamoun, testified that the section in which Mr Fletcher worked handled small cartoons weighing up to 30 kilograms and heavier items were dealt with by another section. He conceded however that occasionally, possibly once a month, heavier items found their way into Mr Fletcher’s section. Any predisposition to a back condition (s 5B(2)(c)): There is no issue that Mr Fletcher’s back problems pre-dated his employment with TNT. Mr Fletcher commenced treatment with chiropractor, Andrew Iggo, in June 2007 for left foot and back problems and that treatment continued on a regular basis until a month after he left TNT. As noted, in mid-2009 Mr Fletcher was referred to rheumatologist, Dr Carr. In a report dated 16 July 2009, Dr Carr recorded that Mr Fletcher reported “some nuisance discomfort in the low back” for the past five years which has slowly worsened; he does not feel pain when lying down (except when turning) and generally once warmed up, while working he can tolerate any symptoms which are minimal. Dr Carr reviewed Mr Fletcher on a regular basis until October 2011. At one stage Mr Fletcher thought that his back pain was linked to a 2000 injury involving his left foot. The symptoms of that injury took some time to resolve; a stress fracture was not diagnosed for about 12 months and despite surgery in 2002, symptoms continued. Mr Fletcher reported to workplace assessor, Recovre, in December 2007 that he thought his back pain might have been the result of his body having to counteract the reduced weight bearing ability of his injured left ankle. His treating chiropractor, Mr Andrew Iggo, was also of that opinion (see report of 27 June 2007). None of the medical experts who have assessed Mr Fletcher share that opinion.