Robertson v McDonald's Australia Limited (No. 7)

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION

CITATION:

Robertson v McDonald's Australia Limited (No. 7) [2023] QIRC 191

PARTIES:

Robertson, B
(Complainant)

v

McDonald's Australia Limited
(Respondent)

CASE NO.:

AD/2021/7

PROCEEDING:

Applications in existing proceedings

DELIVERED ON:

23 June 2023

HEARING DATE:

23 June 2023

MEMBER:

HEARD AT:

Merrell DP

Brisbane

ORDERS:

The orders contained in paragraph [40] of these reasons for decision.

CATCHWORDS:

COURTS AND JUDGES – JUDGES – DISQUALIFICATION FOR INTEREST OR BIAS – REASONABLE APPREHENSION OF BIAS GENERALLY – CONDUCT, INCLUDING PUBLISHED STATEMENTS –Complainant alleges age discrimination and the asking of unnecessary questions against the Respondent – Complainant filed and served statement of facts and contentions – application for disqualification on the ground of apprehended bias – whether any reasonable apprehension of bias arises –  other applications in existing proceedings filed by the Complainant – application for disqualification on the ground of apprehended bias dismissed – Complainant's other applications in existing proceedings dismissed

LEGISLATION:

Industrial Relations (Tribunals) Rules 2011, r 49

CASES:

Attorney-General for the State of Queensland vWood [2023] QSC 78

Dunstan v Orr [2022] FCA 1006

QYFM v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2023] HCA 15; (2023) 66 Fam LR 369

Robertson v McDonald's Australia Limited (No. 5) [2023] QIRC 092

Robertson v McDonald's Australia Limited (No. 6) [2023] QIRC 093

APPEARANCES:

The Complainant on his own behalf.

Ms L. Dearlove of Colin Biggers & Paisley and Ms N. Longhurst of McDonald's Australia Limited for the Respondent.

Reasons for Decision

Introduction

  1. On 5 September 2020, Mr B. Robertson made a complaint to the Queensland Human Rights Commission ('QHRC') against McDonald's Australia Limited ('McDonald's'). The complaint concerned allegations, in the work area, of age discrimination and asking unnecessary questions contrary to the provisions of the Anti‑Discrimination Act 1991.

  2. On 16 February 2021, the complaint was referred from the QHRC to this Commission ('Mr Robertson's complaint').

  3. Mr Robertson's complaint has been allocated to me for hearing and determination.

  4. I have, to date, made a number of interlocutory decisions in relation to Mr Robertson's complaint in response to a number of Applications in existing proceedings filed by          Mr Robertson.

  5. Presently before me are four more applications made by Mr Robertson.  Mr Robertson seeks:

    ·in respect of an Application in existing proceedings filed on 17 April 2023, an order that I make a determination that two notices to admit facts Mr Robertson served on McDonald's are reasonably able to be understood ('the notices to admit facts application');

    ·in respect of an oral application made on 8 May 2023, an order that I recuse myself from further hearing and determining his complaint on the ground of apprehended bias ('the recusal application');

    ·in respect of an Application in existing proceedings filed on 17 May 2023, an order that McDonald's provides to him the contract or deed between it and an organisation referred to as 'SmartRecruiter' or, in the alternative, an order that McDonald's provides to him the criteria used by 'SmartRecruiter' to screen Australian applicants for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Robertson v McDonald's Australia Limited (No. 7) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] QIRC 191
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Robertson v McDonald's Australia Limited (No. 7), the Industrial Relations Commission was tasked with resolving a series of applications filed by the complainant, Mr. Robertson, against McDonald's Australia Limited. The applications included a notice to admit facts, a recusal application, a SmartRecruiter application, and an application to discontinue proceedings. The core issues before the court were whether the notice to admit facts application was valid, if there was any basis for the recusal application, if the SmartRecruiter application had merit, and if the application to discontinue should be granted. These issues were pivotal as they addressed the procedural aspects of the ongoing case and the potential for bias or procedural unfairness.

The court meticulously examined each application to determine their validity and merit. Firstly, regarding the notice to admit facts, the court found that the application was misconceived because McDonald's had already filed an application to dismiss Mr. Robertson's complaint for failure to file an appropriate statement of facts and contentions. The court held that any determination on the notice to admit facts would be premature until McDonald's application was resolved. Secondly, the recusal application, which sought the disqualification of the Commissioner on the grounds of apprehended bias, was dismissed. The court concluded that there was no reasonable apprehension of bias based on the conduct of the Commissioner, including any published statements. Thirdly, the SmartRecruiter application, which pertained to the use of artificial intelligence in determining age characteristics, was also dismissed due to lack of relevance and procedural impropriety. Lastly, the application to discontinue was dismissed as there was no merit in the applications made by Mr. Robertson.

The court's reasoning underscored the importance of procedural fairness and the necessity for all applications to be considered within the context of the broader case. The court dismissed all four applications filed by Mr. Robertson, emphasizing that the issues raised were either premature or lacked substantive merit. The final orders made by the court were that the notice to admit facts application, the recusal application, the SmartRecruiter application, and the application to discontinue were all dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

The orders contained in paragraph [40] of these reasons for decision.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons that follow:·the notice to admit facts application is dismissed; ·the recusal application is dismissed;·the SmartRecruiter application is dismissed; and·the application to discontinue is dismissed.The notice to admit facts application On 28 March 2023, Mr Robertson filed and served, pursuant to r 49 of the Industrial Relations (Tribunals) Rules 2011 ('the Rules'), a Notice to admit facts ('the First Notice'). On the same day, Mr Robertson filed and served a further Notice to admit facts which sought admissions about different facts ('the Second Notice'). On 6 April 2023, McDonald's filed and served responses, in respect of the First and Second Notices, stating that it did not understand the facts set out in the First and Second Notices but that, in any event, it disputed the facts. The First Notice stated:1. That on 21/6/21 (+/-1 day )M.A.L had 7 "activities" in relation my social media account2. That M.A.L careers page has 2200 + vacancies listed (as at 27/3/23) not a single One states "Junior position". "Youth wages etc3. That employment applicant data is retained for Three years of (unsuccessful) M.A.L careers applicant/s4. That A.I is used by SmartRrcruiter [sic] to determine age/s and or age characteristics Junior/Senior and or younger older /youngest.5. That M.A.L and or Third party/ies has sought to determine the identity of the applicant in A.D.2021/7 The Second Notice stated:1. Employment application/s Via M.A.L online careers page (unsuccessful applicant/s) data is retained for Three years.2. That retention is or as understood to be Six Months in (personalized/identifiable applicant ) form.3. That unidentified retention is or as understood as to be 2.5 Years.4. That the Recent D.O.B question/s in M.A.L careers page has potential for financial benefit/s including, potential wages saving/s5. That council refused generally to provide information related to the applicant to the applicant ,without reasoning the refusal This application by Mr Robertson is misconceived. As Mr Robertson well knew at the date he made the present application seeking the Commission to make a '… determination' about the clarity of the First and Second Notices, being 17 April 2023, McDonald's, on 6 April 2023, had made an application to dismiss Mr Robertson's complaint of unlawful discrimination on the basis that Mr Robertson has repeatedly failed to file an appropriate statement of facts and contentions ('McDonald's application'). Even if I had the power to make the determination sought by Mr Robertson (which I doubt), there would be no utility in doing so until I make a determination about McDonald's application. This is because, assuming the facts referred to in the First and Second Notices have some relevance to an issue in dispute between Mr Robertson and McDonald's, the only litigious role that the First and Second Notices could play would be at the trial of Mr Robertson's complaint. For the same reasons, whether or not McDonald's responses served on Mr Robertson comply with r 49(2) of the Rules is not a matter that should or needs to be presently determined.

Decision

Reasons for decision

For these reasons, I dismiss the application to discontinue.Conclusion For the reasons I have given, there is no merit in any of these four applications made by Mr Robertson. All four applications must be dismissed.Orders I make the following orders: