Robertson v McAdam No. Scgrg-97-1458 Judgment No. S6969

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

ROBERTSON  v  McADAM
[1998] SASC S6969

Full Court
Coram:  Millhouse, Debelle and Nyland JJ

  1. MILLHOUSE, DEBELLE AND NYLAND JJ.        This appeal is concerned with the determination of liability arising out of a motor vehicle accident which occurred at about 7.25 pm on 20 April 1994, on the southern carriageway of Bagster Road, Salisbury North.  On that date, a Volvo station wagon being driven by the respondent collided with a Nissan tow truck, driven by the appellant.  The force of the impact caused the front right section of the Volvo to be impaled underneath the rear left panel of the Nissan tow truck.  As a consequence of the collision, the respondent suffered serious injury to the right side of her body and permanent scarring to her face.

  2. The quantum of damages was agreed between the parties in the sum of $60,000.  The matter thereafter proceeded to trial on the issue of liability.  The action was heard by a stipendiary magistrate, sitting in the civil division of the Magistrates Court.  On 29 September 1997, the learned magistrate delivered judgment.  He held that the respondent had failed to prove any negligence on the part of the appellant and dismissed her claim.

  3. The respondent appealed against the dismissal of her claim to a single judge of this court.  The appeal was upheld.  The learned judge, on appeal, set aside the order dismissing the respondent’s claim and in lieu thereof entered judgment for the respondent in a sum equal to 70% of the agreed quantum of damages.  The appellant now appeals against that finding.  In order to consider the issues which arise for determination, it is necessary to review the evidence given at the trial.

  4. At the time of the collision, the respondent was aged 18 years.  She had only recently qualified for her probationary driver’s licence.  There were three passengers in her motor car, namely her 15 year old brother, Russell McAdam and his two friends, Jefferey Dean and Daniel Micu.  They were also aged 15 years.  Russell McAdam was in the front passenger seat and Mr Dean and Mr Micu were seated in the rear of the respondent’s car.

  5. The respondent was unable to give evidence about the exact nature of the collision as she was suffering from psychogenic amnesia due to shock.  She did, however, give evidence as to the sequence of the events before the collision.  She said that she had collected her brother and his friends from a basketball stadium.  This was situated in the Elizabeth recreation centre at Woodford Road and Elizabeth Way, Elizabeth.  The respondent planned to return to her parents’ home at Antrim Street, Salisbury Downs.  Her route took her along Kettering Road behind General Motors Holden on to Commercial Road.  She travelled along Commercial Road in a southerly direction.  At a roundabout on Commercial Road she turned left and entered Bagster Road.  Approximately 103 metres after the roundabout there is a railway crossing.  After the crossing, Bagster Road proceeds on a steady downhill decline.  The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Robertson v McAdam No. Scgrg-97-1458 Judgment No. S6969 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1998] SASC 6969
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Robertson v McAdam involved a motor vehicle accident where a Volvo station wagon driven by the respondent collided with a Nissan tow truck driven by the appellant. The respondent suffered serious injuries, and the matter proceeded to trial on the issue of liability. The trial magistrate found that the respondent had failed to prove any negligence on the part of the appellant and dismissed her claim. The respondent appealed against this decision to a single judge of the court, who set aside the order dismissing the respondent's claim and entered judgment for the respondent in a sum equal to 70% of the agreed quantum of damages. The appellant now appeals against this finding.

The court reviewed the evidence given at the trial and found that the respondent had an unobstructed view along Bagster Road from at least the railway line, and the appellant's vehicle was clearly visible. The court found that the respondent was driving at a speed that was not safe and that she failed to stop or slow her vehicle and that she did not take any proper or evasive action. The court held that the respondent was solely responsible for the collision.

The court rejected the criticisms made by the appellate judge and held that the trial magistrate's conclusions were open on the evidence. The court found that the appellant had not acted negligently and that the respondent was the author of her own misfortune. The court also found that the costs should not be computed on the footing that it was a complex action.

In conclusion, the court allowed the appeal, set aside the orders of the appellate judge, and restored the findings and orders of the magistrate. The respondent's claim for damages was dismissed, and the appellant was found not to be liable for the accident.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 20 April 1994, a Volvo station wagon driven by Louise McAdam collided with a Nissan tow truck driven by the appellant, causing serious injuries to McAdam. The incident occurred on Bagster Road, Salisbury North, at approximately 7:25 pm. McAdam had only recently obtained her probationary driver's licence and was driving with three passengers, including her brother and his friends. The collision resulted in McAdam suffering serious bodily injuries and permanent facial scarring. The parties agreed on a quantum of damages of $60,000, and the case proceeded to trial to determine liability. McAdam claimed that the appellant was negligent, while the appellant denied any negligence and asserted that the collision was caused by McAdam's reckless driving.

The case was initially heard by a stipendiary magistrate in the Magistrates Court of South Australia, who found that McAdam had failed to prove any negligence on the part of the appellant and dismissed her claim. McAdam appealed to a single judge of the Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia, who set aside the magistrate's order and entered judgment for McAdam, holding the appellant 70% liable. The appellant then appealed to the Full Court, challenging the decision on liability and the costs order.

Decision

Reasons for decision

MILLHOUSE, DEBELLE AND NYLAND JJ
Issues
1. Was the learned judge correct in setting aside the magistrate’s order and finding the appellant 70% liable for the collision?
2. Did the learned judge err in ordering the costs to be computed on the footing that this was a complex action?

Held
1. The court held that the learned judge was incorrect in setting aside the magistrate’s order and finding the appellant 70% liable for the collision. The court allowed the appeal against the decision on liability, restoring the findings and orders of the magistrate that the appellant was not negligent and the respondent was solely responsible for the collision.
2. The court held that the learned judge erred in ordering the costs to be computed on the footing that this was a complex action. The court allowed the appeal on the issue of costs, finding that the case was not complex and did not warrant doubling the costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MILLHOUSE, DEBELLE AND NYLAND JJ

The Full Court considered the evidence given at trial and the differing conclusions reached by the magistrate and the learned judge on appeal. The learned judge had conducted his own review of the evidence and made several criticisms of the magistrate's findings. However, the Full Court found that the judge should not have undertaken an experiment driving around the accident site himself, as this was not proper judicial conduct and could not be properly subjected to cross-examination. The judge also misunderstood the use of the stopping distance diagram by the magistrate. While the judge was entitled to reach his own conclusions, he needed to have regard to the magistrate's findings, particularly regarding the speed at which the respondent was driving. The Full Court ultimately found no basis to interfere with the magistrate's conclusion that the respondent was solely responsible for the collision. As for costs, the Full Court found the case was not complex and did not warrant doubling the costs under Rule 106(7) of the Magistrates Court Rules. The appeal against the costs order was allowed.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that a judge on appeal should not undertake experiments themselves to test evidence, as this assumes the role of a witness unavailable for cross-examination. The judge must also properly consider and give due weight to the findings of fact made by the original decision maker, unless there is a basis to interfere with those findings.