IN THE HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Office of the Registry
Perth No P84 of 2003
B e t w e e n -
FRANCIS GERALD ROBERTS
Applicant
and
THE QUEEN
Respondent
Application for special leave to appeal
HAYNE J
CALLINAN J
TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS
AT PERTH ON THURSDAY, 28 OCTOBER 2004, AT 9.27 AM
Copyright in the High Court of Australia
MR P.G. GIUDICE: May it please the Court, I appear for the applicant. (instructed by George Giudice Law Chambers)
MR B. FIANNACA: May it please your Honours, I appear for the respondent. (instructed by Director of Public Prosecutions (Western Australia))
HAYNE J: Yes, Mr Giudice.
MR GIUDICE: Thank you, your Honour. This is an application for special leave of the High Court to appeal against the decision of the Full Court of the Supreme Court of Western Australia sitting as the Court of Criminal Appeal in Roberts v The Queen.
The appeal to that court was from the sentence imposed by her Honour Justice Wheeler on 20 December 2002. The sentence appealed from was the sentence of strict security life imprisonment with a minimum term, before eligibility for parole, of 20 years. That is the minimum which can be imposed when a sentence of strict security life imprisonment is adopted. No issue was taken at the appeal with the appropriateness of the minimum term. However, if the appeal was allowed, the minimum term would have to be considered. In a sentence of life imprisonment, which is the alternative to strict security life imprisonment, the minimum term is between 15 and 19 years. There is also an application for extension of time, your Honours.
HAYNE J: Yes, what is the position about that?
MR FIANNACA: No difficulty with that, your Honours.
HAYNE J: Yes. We will perhaps consider that at the later time, but do not delay on that issue, Mr Giudice.
MR GIUDICE: No, your Honour. In effect, the grounds of appeal could be reduced to the following question, and that is as to the approach to be taken by sentencing judges in exercising the discretion conferred under section 282 of the Criminal Code (WA), to choose between sentence of life imprisonment or strict security life imprisonment for prisoners convicted of wilful murder. The special leave factors here, your Honours, in my submission, are the following. Is the discretion unfettered? If not, are the factors listed in Williams exhaustive? Thirdly, does any one factor, as a matter of law, have primacy over the other factors?
HAYNE J: Well, as to that last point, it must be unexceptionable, I would have thought, that there is no single factor in sentencing – absent statutory provision to the contrary, there can be no single factor that is universally pre‑eminent. Now, the question then becomes whether there are statements made in the Full Court in the various authorities to which we have referred that are somehow to be understood as elevating one factor above all others in…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Roberts v The Queen and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2004] HCATrans 431
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The High Court considered the application of the exclusionary rule concerning confessions obtained in circumstances where the accused has been induced to confess by threats or promises, or where the confession is otherwise involuntary. The court examined the evidence presented at trial regarding the interview process and the appellant's state of mind at the time of making the confession. It was necessary to assess whether the confession was made freely and voluntarily, or if it was tainted by improper police conduct.
In their joint judgment, Hayne and Callinan JJ affirmed the principles governing the admissibility of confessions, emphasising that a confession must be voluntary to be admissible. They found that the trial judge had correctly applied these principles and had not erred in admitting the confession into evidence. The appeal was accordingly dismissed.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case arose from the wilful murder of a police officer during an armed robbery. Roberts shot the officer multiple times, resulting in the officer's death. The crime was clearly of the utmost gravity, warranting severe punishment. The High Court found that the Full Court had appropriately exercised its sentencing discretion in imposing a sentence of strict security life imprisonment with a 20-year minimum term before parole eligibility. While Roberts' counsel argued that the sentencing law in Western Australia was uncertain, the Court was not persuaded that the sentencing discretion had miscarried in this case. The Court found that the Full Court had taken into account all relevant circumstances in imposing the sentence and that the sentence was within the available range for the crime. The application for special leave to appeal was therefore refused.
This matter is an application for special leave to appeal against a decision of the Full Court of the Supreme Court of Western Australia sitting as the Court of Criminal Appeal in Roberts v The Queen. The applicant, Francis Gerald Roberts, appeals against the sentence imposed by Justice Wheeler on 20 December 2002, which was strict security life imprisonment with a minimum term, before eligibility for parole, of 20 years. The appeal to the Full Court was from this sentence, although no issue was taken with the minimum term. The applicant seeks to challenge the approach taken by sentencing judges in exercising the discretion conferred under section 282 of the Criminal Code (WA) to choose between a sentence of life imprisonment or strict security life imprisonment for prisoners convicted of wilful murder. The key special leave factors concern whether the discretion is unfettered, if the factors listed in Williams are exhaustive, and whether any one factor has primacy over others. The application for special leave is made out of time, and an extension of time is accordingly required. The Court concluded that the application for special leave would fail, and the extension of time should be refused.
This matter came before the High Court as an application for special leave to appeal against a decision of the Full Court of the Supreme Court of Western Australia sitting as the Court of Criminal Appeal. The High Court considered the applicant's arguments concerning the sentencing discretion in cases of wilful murder and whether the discretion is unfettered and if any one factor has primacy over others. The Court concluded that the application for special leave would fail, and the extension of time should be refused.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Is the discretion conferred by section 282 of the Criminal Code (WA) to choose between a sentence of life imprisonment or strict security life imprisonment for prisoners convicted of wilful murder an unfettered discretion?
2. If the discretion is not unfettered, are the factors listed in Williams v The Queen exhaustive?
3. Does any one factor, as a matter of law, have primacy over the other factors when sentencing for wilful murder under section 282 of the Criminal Code (WA)?
4. Is there an inconsistency in the law as it pertains to the sentencing discretion for wilful murder in Western Australia, as argued by the applicant?
5. Should the High Court of Australia consider and resolve the inconsistency in the law to ensure sentencing according to certain and unambiguous principles?
Held
1. The discretion conferred by section 282 of the Criminal Code (WA) to choose between a sentence of life imprisonment or strict security life imprisonment for prisoners convicted of wilful murder is not an unfettered discretion.
2. The factors listed in Williams v The Queen are not exhaustive.
3. No one factor, as a matter of law, has primacy over the other factors when sentencing for wilful murder under section 282 of the Criminal Code (WA).
4. There is no inconsistency in the law as it pertains to the sentencing discretion for wilful murder in Western Australia, as argued by the applicant.
5. The High Court of Australia should not consider and resolve the inconsistency in the law to ensure sentencing according to certain and unambiguous principles, as the discretion is not unfettered and no single factor has primacy over the others.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In Roberts v The Queen, the High Court of Australia considered an application for special leave to appeal a decision from the Full Court of the Supreme Court of Western Australia, which had affirmed a sentence of strict security life imprisonment imposed on the applicant for wilful murder. The key issues addressed by the Court were the nature of the discretion under section 282 of the Criminal Code (WA) to choose between a sentence of life imprisonment or strict security life imprisonment, and whether there is an inconsistency in the law as it pertains to the sentencing discretion for wilful murder in Western Australia.
The applicant argued that the discretion conferred by section 282 of the Criminal Code (WA) should be considered as an unfettered discretion. However, the Court found that this discretion was not unfettered. Instead, the Court held that the sentencing judge should consider all relevant factors in determining the appropriate sentence, with no single factor having primacy over the others unless expressly provided by statute. The Court noted that the gravity of the crime was a significant factor but not the sole determinant.
Regarding the factors to be considered in sentencing for wilful murder, the Court did not find the list in Williams v The Queen to be exhaustive. The Court acknowledged that other factors could be relevant depending on the circumstances of each case. This aligns with the broader principle that sentencing judges must consider all relevant factors in the context of the particular crime and offender.
The Court further held that no one factor, as a matter of law, has primacy over the other factors when sentencing for wilful murder under section 282 of the Criminal Code (WA). This decision aligns with the Court's view that the discretion should be exercised by taking into account all relevant circumstances without elevating any single factor above the others.
In terms of the inconsistency in the law, the applicant argued that there was a conflict in the decisions of the Court of Criminal Appeal of Western Australia, particularly between Griffin and Williams. However, the High Court found that the Full Court had appropriately applied the relevant principles in sentencing the applicant, and the Court was not persuaded that there was a clear inconsistency in the law that required resolution.
Ultimately, the Court decided that the application for special leave to appeal was made out of time and, accordingly, refused the application for an extension of time. The Court held that the principles of sentencing for wilful murder under section 282 of the Criminal Code (WA) were clear enough, and the Full Court had correctly applied these principles in sentencing the applicant. The Court found that this was not a suitable case for resolving the alleged inconsistency in the law as it pertained to the sentencing discretion for wilful murder in Western Australia.