Roberts-Smith v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Limited (No 38)

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Roberts-Smith v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Limited (No 38) [2022] FCA 597

File numbers: NSD 1485 of 2018
NSD 1486 of 2018
NSD 1487 of 2018
Judgment of: BESANKO J
Date of judgment: 23 May 2022
Catchwords: EVIDENCE — Ruling on admissibility of document applicant seeks to tender — document recording WhatsApp message from a Mr Sharif Khoram to solicitors for respondents dated 1 December 2020 — where witness called by respondents, Mohammed Hanifa Fatih, cross-examined by applicant on whether he had spoken to Afghan Independent Human Rights Commission (AIHRC) about events at village of Darwan on 11 September 2012 and whether he had applied for compensation from AIHRC — where counsel for applicant put to Mohammed Hanifa and Mohammed Hanifa denied that he had had telephone conversation with AIHRC official in presence of Mr Khoram during which he was informed of certain matters, including possibility of compensation by AIHRC — where WhatsApp message from Mr Khoram sets out matters Mohammed Hanifa was told by “the HRC director”, including possibility of compensation by AIHRC — whether document contains prior statement, inconsistent or otherwise, made by Mohammed Hanifa — inference that WhatsApp message records statement made by Mohammed Hanifa to Mr Khoram on or shortly before 1 December 2020 — whether applicant put to Mohammed Hanifa substance of evidence and enough of circumstances of making of statement to enable witness to identify statement in accordance with ss 43 and 106(1)(a) of Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) — tender refused
Legislation: Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) ss 43, 101A, 102, 106
Cases cited: Roberts-Smith v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Limited (No 10) [2021] FCA 317
Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Other Federal Jurisdiction
Number of paragraphs: 17
Date of hearing: 2 August 2021
Date of last submissions: 6 August 2021 (Applicant)
4 August 2021 (Respondents)
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr A Moses SC with Mr P Sharp
Solicitor for the Applicant: Mark O’Brien Legal
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr N Owens SC with Ms L Barnett and Mr C Mitchell
Solicitor for the Respondents: MinterEllison
Counsel for the Commonwealth of Australia: Ms C Ernst
Solicitor for the Commonwealth of Australia: Australian Government Solicitor

ORDERS

NSD 1485 of 2018
BETWEEN:

BEN ROBERTS-SMITH

Applicant

AND:

FAIRFAX MEDIA PUBLICATIONS PTY LIMITED (ACN 003 357 720) (and others named in the Schedule)

First Respondent

NSD 1486 of 2018
BETWEEN:

BEN ROBERTS-SMITH

Applicant

AND:

THE AGE COMPANY PTY LIMITED (ACN 004 262 702) (and others named in the Schedule)

First Respondent

NSD 1487 of 2018
BETWEEN:

BEN ROBERTS-SMITH

Applicant

AND:

THE FEDERAL CAPITAL PRESS OF AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED (ACN 008 394 063) (and others named in the Schedule)

First Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

BESANKO J

DATE OF ORDER:

23 MAY 2022

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The tender of MFI D (WhatsApp message dated 1 December 2020) be rejected.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

BESANKO J:

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Roberts-Smith v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Limited (No 3... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FCA 597
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Roberts-Smith v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Limited (No 38), the primary focus was on the admissibility of a WhatsApp message as evidence. The document in question was a WhatsApp message from Mr Sharif Khoram to the respondents' solicitors dated 1 December 2020. This message purportedly recorded a conversation between Mr Khoram and Mohammed Hanifa Fatih, in which the latter was informed by an Afghan Independent Human Rights Commission (AIHRC) official about events at the village of Darwan on 11 September 2012, including the possibility of compensation. The applicant, Mr Roberts-Smith, argued that the document was relevant to discredit Mr Fatih's testimony, where he denied having any conversation with AIHRC officials about these events.

The legal issue before the court was whether the WhatsApp message constituted a prior inconsistent statement made by Mr Fatih that could be admitted under section 106 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth). This section allows for evidence that rebuts a witness's denial of prior inconsistent statements if certain conditions are met, including that the witness was given enough information to identify the statement during cross-examination. The applicant contended that Mr Fatih had denied discussing the events with AIHRC officials and had not admitted to a conversation with an AIHRC official in the presence of Mr Khoram. The court had to determine whether the substance of the WhatsApp message was put to Mr Fatih during cross-examination and whether he denied or did not admit to the substance of the evidence.

The court concluded that the WhatsApp message did not qualify as a prior inconsistent statement for several reasons. The applicant had not sufficiently informed Mr Fatih during cross-examination of the circumstances of the making of the statement, nor did he draw Mr Fatih's attention to the part of the statement that was inconsistent with his evidence. Additionally, the court found that the WhatsApp message did not meet the criteria for admissibility under section 106 because it did not establish a prior inconsistent statement made by Mr Fatih. Consequently, the tender of the WhatsApp message was rejected, and the court ordered that it be not admitted as evidence in the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The tender of MFI D (WhatsApp message dated 1 December 2020) be rejected.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Section 102 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) establishes the credibility rule which is that credibility evidence about a witness is not admissible. The concept of credibility evidence is defined in s 101A. There are specific exceptions to the credibility rule and they are set out in the sections which follow s 102. Only one exception has been identified by the applicant as relevant and that is the exception in s 106. That section is in the following terms:106 Exception: rebutting denials by other evidence(1)The credibility rule does not apply to evidence that is relevant to a witness’s credibility and that is adduced otherwise than from the witness if:(a) in cross-examination of the witness:(i)the substance of the evidence was put to the witness; and(ii)the witness denied, or did not admit or agree to, the substance of the evidence; and(b) the court gives leave to adduce the evidence.(2)Leave under paragraph (1)(b) is not required if the evidence tends to prove that the witness:(a)is biased or has a motive for being untruthful; or(b)has been convicted of an offence, including an offence against the law of a foreign country; or(c)has made a prior inconsistent statement; or(d)is, or was, unable to be aware of matters to which his or her evidence relates; or(e)has knowingly or recklessly made a false representation while under an obligation, imposed by or under an Australian law or a law of a foreign country, to tell the truth. The applicant claims that the evidence in the WhatsApp message is relevant to Mohammed Hanifa’s credibility because it shows that his evidence that he never spoke with anyone from the AIHRC is false. It is uncontentious that the evidence is to be adduced otherwise than from Mohammed Hanifa. For admission of the evidence under s 106, the applicant must satisfy the Court that the substance of the evidence was put to Mohammed Hanifa and Mohammed Hanifa denied, or did not admit or agree to, the substance of the evidence (s 106(1)(a)). The applicant asserted that he did not need leave under s 106(1)(b) because the evidence in the WhatsApp message tends to prove that Mohammed Hanifa has made a prior inconsistent statement. The term prior inconsistent statement is defined in the Dictionary in the Evidence Act as follows:prior inconsistent statement of a witness means a previous representation that is inconsistent with evidence given by the witness. The term representation is defined in the Dictionary as follows:representation includes: (a)an express or implied representation (whether oral or in writing); or (b)a representation to be inferred from conduct; or (c)a representation not intended by its maker to be communicated to or seen by another person; or (d)a representation that for any reason is not communicated. Section 43 defines the circumstances in which a cross-examiner may adduce evidence of a prior inconsistent statement of a witness. The section provides as follows:43 Prior inconsistent statements of witnesses(1)A witness may be cross-examined about a prior inconsistent statement alleged to have been made by the witness whether or not:(a)complete particulars of the statement have been given to the witness; or(b)a document containing a record of the statement has been shown to the witness.(2)If, in cross-examination, a witness does not admit that he or she has made a prior inconsistent statement, the cross-examiner is not to adduce evidence of the statement otherwise than from the witness unless, in the cross-examination, the cross-examiner:(a)informed the witness of enough of the circumstances of the making of the statement to enable the witness to identify the statement; and(b)drew the witness’s attention to so much of the statement as is inconsistent with the witness’s evidence.(3)For the purpose of adducing evidence of the statement, a party may re-open the party’s case.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established