Robert Symes and Kim Louise Filmer v Mick Fabar Constructions Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

Civil and Administrative Tribunal


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Robert Symes and Kim Louise Filmer v Mick Fabar Constructions Pty Ltd [2015] NSWCATCD 77
Hearing dates:22 May 2015 (on the papers)
Decision date: 30 June 2015
Jurisdiction:Consumer and Commercial Division
Before: G Meadows, Senior Member
Decision:

The renewal application includes:

1  whether it is appropriate to convert the work order (or any particular item within the work order) into a money order;
2  whether any of the works have been complied with;
3  whether any of the works not complied with are still necessary;
4  whether the applicants have prevented any of the works;
5  whether any of the works not completed are impossible or impractical to complete;
6  whether an opinion as to satisfactory completion of any of the items requires expert opinion of a particular type, such as general building, structural, hydraulic;
7  any other issues a party asserts may be relevant.
Catchwords: Administrative Law—Home Building Claim—consent work orders—applicants allege incomplete—whether respondents estopped from calling fresh evidence to disagree with owners’ experts’ “reasonable satisfaction”
Legislation Cited: Home Building Act 1989
Category:Procedural and other rulings
Parties: Robert Symes and Kim Louise Filmer—applicants;
Mick Fabar Constructions Pty Ltd—respondent
Representation: Counsel: Michele Fraser for the applicant
File Number(s):HB 14/06604
Publication restriction:Nil

REASON FOR DECISION

Application

  1. This application raises interesting and important issues in relation to renewal of proceedings in circumstances in which the original proceedings were settled, or partly settled, by consent orders. (In these reasons, I will refer to the orders made on 14 August 2013 as “consent orders”. In their submissions the parties variously refer to the orders as “work orders” or “consent orders”: there appears to be no distinction intended by the different words used.)

  2. The renewal application was in respect of certain consent orders made in matter number HB 10/44392 on 14 August 2013. Pursuant to the provisions of Clause 12 of Schedule 1 “Savings, transitional and other provisions” (Schedule 1) to the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 (the CAT Act), and Clause 14 of Schedule 1, the order made in HB 10/44392 is taken to be as if made by the Civil and Administrative Tribunal of New South Wales (NCAT) in exercise of functions allocated to the Consumer and Commercial Division (CCD) of NCAT.

Applicable Legislation

  1. Clause 14 of Schedule 1 provides:

14   Orders of existing tribunals

(1)   An existing order of an existing tribunal made under other legislation is taken, on and from the establishment day, to be an order made by NCAT under the corresponding provision of that legislation (as amended by a relevant amending Act) or this Act (as the case may be).

(2)   This clause is subject to the other provisions of this Schedule.

(3)   In this clause:

existing order of an existing tribunal is an order made by the tribunal before the establishment day, and includes an order that would have come into effect on or after the establishment day.

  1. A right of renewal,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Robert Symes and Kim Louise Filmer v Mick Fabar Construction... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NSWCATCD 77
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicants, Robert Symes and Kim Louise Filmer, commenced proceedings against Mick Fabar Constructions Pty Ltd in relation to alleged incomplete home building works. They sought to have the matter heard in the Consumer, Trader and Tenancy Tribunal (CTTT). The applicants alleged that the construction company had failed to complete certain works, resulting in a dispute over the adequacy of the building works and the liability for rectification. The court was required to decide whether the construction company was estopped from calling fresh evidence to contradict the owners’ experts’ opinion of reasonable satisfaction regarding the completion of the works. Additionally, the court needed to determine the appropriate scope of the work order, whether the works had been complied with, and whether any incomplete works were still necessary, among other issues.

The tribunal began by considering the nature of the work orders and the evidence presented. It noted that the applicants’ experts had expressed a reasonable satisfaction with the completion of the works, while the construction company presented fresh evidence to the contrary. The tribunal examined whether the construction company was estopped from presenting this new evidence, given that it had not raised these issues earlier in the proceedings. The tribunal concluded that the construction company was not estopped from presenting fresh evidence, as the applicants had not relied on the previous evidence to their detriment. The tribunal found that the fresh evidence was relevant and should be considered in determining whether the works had been adequately completed.

The tribunal proceeded to consider the other issues relevant to the work order, including whether any of the works had been complied with and whether any incomplete works were still necessary. The tribunal found that some of the works had not been adequately completed and that the construction company was liable for the rectification of these works. The tribunal also considered the applicants’ request to convert the work order into a money order, determining that this was not appropriate given the specific nature of the works required. The tribunal ordered the construction company to complete the outstanding works to the satisfaction of the applicants’ experts and to pay any associated costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

The renewal application includes:

1 whether it is appropriate to convert the work order (or any particular item within the work order) into a money order;

2 whether any of the works have been complied with;

3 whether any of the works not complied with are still necessary;

4 whether the applicants have prevented any of the works;

5 whether any of the works not completed are impossible or impractical to complete;

6 whether an opinion as to satisfactory completion of any of the items requires expert opinion of a particular type, such as general building, structural, hydraulic;

7 any other issues a party asserts may be relevant.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established