Robert Michael Turnbull v

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

[2014] QCA 240

COURT OF APPEAL

MORRISON JA

Appeal No 8959 of 2014
QCAT No 1191 of 2014

ROBERT MICHAEL TURNBULL  Applicant

v

THE STATE OF QUEENSLAND THROUGH
THE DEPARTMENT OF HOUSING
AND PUBLIC WORKS  Respondent

BRISBANE

WEDNESDAY, 24 SEPTEMBER 2014

JUDGMENT

MORRISON JA:  This is an application to stay a decision in the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal, pending an appeal from that decision.

The applicant is currently a resident at premises in Lenneberg Street, Southport, which he has on a form of tenancy where the Department of Housing and Public Works is the landlord.  He has resided in those premises since August 2010.

The material reveals that in about June 2014 the applicant's premises was searched by Queensland Police.  That search resulted in the discovery of a number of boxes containing approximately 108 items which the police contend are items for the production of an illegal drug, namely, methylamphetamine.  The items include equipment such as reaction vessels, condensers, glassware, beakers, burners, and scales, and chemicals such as Iodine and caustic soda.  The applicant has since been charged with offences relating to what was discovered, but those charges have not been finalised.

On the 7th of July 2014 the respondent issued a notice to leave, entitled First and Final Strike Notice and Notice to Leave, requiring the applicant to vacate the premises by 22 July 2014.  This was done under a departmental policy whereby the recipient of a first and final strike notice is no longer eligible for public housing.  The basis of the notice was the discovery of the items characterised by the police and by the respondent as, a category C Clandestine Drug Laboratory.

The notice relied on sections of the Residential Tenancies and Rooming AccommodationAct 2008 (Qld), providing that the landlord may give such a notice if it, "reasonably believes the tenant, an occupant, a guest of the tenant or a person allowed on the premises by the tenant", has used the premises for an illegal activity: s 290A(1)(a), or has intentionally or recklessly endangered others in those premises or nearby premises: s 290A(1)(b)(ii).

The applicant did not vacate the premises and on 28 July 2014 the respondent brought an application to QCAT seeking a termination order and a warrant to enforce that order.  Part of the material relied upon at the hearing of that application included alleged admissions by the applicant, that there was an illegal drug laboratory or apparatus and toxic chemicals stored in boxes in his premises; that he suspected what was in the boxes, but was not 100 per cent sure of their contents, as the boxes belonged to someone else.

The material also revealed a contended course of abusive and anti-social behaviour by the applicant towards his neighbours and staff in the residential block where he lives.  This included allegations of harassing, intimidating, abusing and threatening neighbours and staff.  The applicant in that respect had been given a number of verbal warnings and a written formal warning.

The QCAT adjudicator…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Robert Michael Turnbull v and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] QCA 240
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Robert Michael Turnbull, has applied to the Court of Appeal for a stay of a decision made by the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT), which is in turn seeking to enforce an order that he vacate his premises. The respondent is the State of Queensland through the Department of Housing and Public Works, who are the landlord of the applicant's premises. The applicant has been served a First and Final Strike Notice, terminating his tenancy due to the discovery of items that the police believe are used in the production of illegal drugs. The applicant has been charged in relation to these items, but these charges have not been finalised. The applicant has applied for a stay of the QCAT decision, pending an appeal from that decision to the Court of Appeal. The legal issue in this case is whether the Court of Appeal has the jurisdiction to grant a stay of the QCAT decision, pending an appeal to the Court of Appeal. The Court of Appeal found that the applicant does not have the right to appeal to the Court of Appeal from the QCAT decision, as the appeal must be made to the appellate division of QCAT. The Court of Appeal found that the applicant cannot bring himself within the provisions entitling an appeal to be made to the Court of Appeal, and thus the power to grant the stay, pending an appeal or an application for leave to appeal, is not enlivened. Therefore, the application must be dismissed. The Court of Appeal orders that the applicant pay the respondent's costs of and incidental to the application, to be assessed on the standard basis.

Background

Background to the litigation

Robert Michael Turnbull is a resident at premises in Lenneberg Street, Southport, under a form of tenancy where the Department of Housing and Public Works is the landlord. He has lived there since August 2010. In approximately June 2014, Queensland Police searched his premises and found approximately 108 items, including equipment and chemicals, which they believe were used for the production of methylamphetamine. Turnbull has been charged in relation to these items, but the charges have not been finalised. On 7 July 2014, the Department issued a First and Final Strike Notice and Notice to Leave, requiring Turnbull to vacate the premises by 22 July 2014. This notice was issued under a policy where the recipient is no longer eligible for public housing. The notice was based on the discovery of items characterised as a category C Clandestine Drug Laboratory. Turnbull did not vacate the premises and the Department sought a termination order and a warrant to enforce that order from the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT). The QCAT adjudicator made an order on 28 August 2014 requiring Turnbull to vacate the premises.

On 12 September 2014, Turnbull filed an application seeking leave to appeal the QCAT decision and for a stay of the adjudicator's orders. The application for a stay was heard on the papers by Acting Senior Member Paratz and was refused. Directions were given that if Turnbull did not notify QCAT by 22 September 2014 if he wished to proceed with the application for leave to appeal, that application would be dismissed without further order. On 18 September 2014, Turnbull's solicitors sent a letter to QCAT indicating their intention to appeal the decision to refuse the stay and requesting written reasons for the decision. This letter was not seen by QCAT as being sufficient to satisfy the direction for notice to be given by 22 September 2014. On 23 September 2014, an order was made by Acting Senior Member Paratz confirming the dismissal of the proceedings if the applicant did not comply with the direction. Turnbull's application to this Court is to seek a stay of the order made on 12 September 2014, so that an application for leave to appeal can be made against that order.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Court of Appeal has jurisdiction to grant a stay of the QCAT decision pending an appeal to this Court.
2. Whether the Court should grant a stay of the QCAT decision pending an appeal to this Court.

Held
1. The Court of Appeal does not have jurisdiction to grant a stay of the QCAT decision pending an appeal to this Court.
2. The application for a stay of the QCAT decision pending an appeal to this Court is dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal considered the jurisdictional basis for the applicant's appeal and the possibility of granting a stay. The Court first examined whether the applicant had the right to appeal to this Court from the QCAT decision. The Court noted that the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 provides for an appeal to the appeal division of QCAT, but only with leave. Further, the Court found that the applicant could not appeal to this Court from the QCAT decision as the appeal provision in the Act only applies to proceedings other than an appeal under Division 1. The Court also clarified that the appeal tribunal could consist of judicial members or suitably qualified members, and the Acting Senior Member Paratz was appropriately appointed as a member of the appeal tribunal. The Court concluded that the applicant's appeal should be directed to the appeal division of QCAT and not to this Court. The Court further determined that it did not have jurisdiction to grant a stay of the QCAT decision as the applicant's right to appeal to this Court was not established. The Court dismissed the application for a stay and ordered the applicant to pay the respondent's costs of and incidental to the application.