Roadshow Films Pty Ltd v Telstra Corporation Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 70 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Roadshow Films Pty Ltd v Telstra Corporation Ltd [2016] FCA 1503

File numbers: NSD 239 of 2016
NSD 241 of 2016
Judges: NICHOLAS J
Date of judgment: 15 December 2016
Catchwords: COPYRIGHT – Section 115A of Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) – where proceedings brought by copyright owners against carriage service providers (“CSPs”) providing internet access to customers – whether CSPs should be ordered to take reasonable steps to disable access to various online locations that infringe or facilitate the infringement of copyright – proper interpretation of s 115A(1) – appropriate form of injunctions and ancillary orders relating to existing and future scope and operation of injunctions – whether applicants should be required to pay CSPs’ costs of complying with injunctions and, if so, in what amounts – whether applicants should pay CSPs’ costs of the proceedings
Legislation:

Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) ss 10, 22, 86, 101, 115A, 116B(1)(a), 126, 132AC(1)(a), 132(1)(a)

Copyright Amendment (Online Infringement) Act 2015 (Cth)

Copyright Amendment (Online Infringement) Bill 2015

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 23, 43

Telecommunications Act 1997 (Cth) ss 7, 16, 87

Children and Young Person Act 1969 (UK) s 1(2)   

Cases cited:

Cooper v Universal Music Australia Pty Ltd (2006) 156 FCR 380

In re D. (A Minor) [1987] 1 AC 317

Roadshow Films Pty Ltd v iiNet Ltd (2012) 248 CLR 42

Twentieth Century Fox Film & Ors v British Telecommunications plc [2011] EWHC 2714 (Ch)

Date of hearing: 23-24 June 2016
Date of last submissions: 22 November 2016
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Intellectual Property
Sub-area: Copyright and Industrial Designs
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 156
NSD 239 of 2016:

Counsel for the Applicants:

Mr RPL Lancaster SC and Mr JS Cooke
Solicitor for the Applicants: Baker McKenzie
Counsel for the First to Third Respondents: Mr AJL Bannon SC and Mr AR Lang
Solicitor for the First to Third Respondents: King & Wood Mallesons
Counsel for the Fourth to Fifteenth Respondents: Mr JM Hennessy SC and Ms F St John
Solicitor for the Fourth to Fifteenth Respondents: Clayton Utz
Counsel for the Sixteenth to Twenty-Ninth Respondents: Mr BA Mee
Solicitor for the Sixteenth to Twenty-Ninth Respondents: Thomson Geer Lawyers
Counsel for the Thirty-Second and Thirty-Fourth to Fiftieth Respondents: Mr C Burgess
Solicitor for the Thirty-Second and Thirty-Fourth to Fiftieth Respondents: Aleco Vrisakis
NSD 241 of 2016:
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr RPL Lancaster SC and Ms JM Beaumont
Solicitor for the Applicant: Minter Ellison
Counsel for the First, Second and Eighteenth to Thirty-Third Respondents: Mr C Burgess
Solicitor for the First, Second and Eighteenth to Thirty-Third Respondents: Aleco Vrisakis
Counsel for the Third to Fourteenth Respondents: Mr JM Hennessy SC and Ms F St John
Solicitor for the Third to Fourteenth Respondents: Clayton Utz
Counsel for the Fifteenth to Seventeenth Respondents: Mr AJL Bannon SC and Mr AR Lang
Solicitor for the Fifteenth to Seventeenth Respondents: King & Wood Mallesons
Table of Corrections
21 December 2016 Para [90],…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Roadshow Films Pty Ltd v Telstra Corporation Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] FCA 1503
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, Roadshow Films Pty Ltd, along with other copyright owners, filed an application against Telstra Corporation Ltd and other carriage service providers (CSPs) seeking an injunction and ancillary orders under section 115A of the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) to disable access to websites facilitating the infringement of their copyright in cinematograph films. The court was required to decide on the interpretation of section 115A(1), the appropriate form of injunctions and ancillary orders, and whether the applicants should be required to pay the CSPs' costs of complying with injunctions and the proceedings. The court held that the primary purpose of the SolarMovie website was to infringe or facilitate the infringement of copyright and granted an injunction against the respondents to disable access to the website. The court also made various ancillary orders relating to the implementation of the injunction and the payment of costs. The court held that the injunction should be implemented by DNS blocking, IP address blocking or re-routing, URL blocking, or any alternative technical means agreed in writing between the applicant and the respondent. The court also held that the applicant should pay the respondents' compliance costs, calculated at a rate of $50 per Domain Name subject to DNS blocking, and the costs of the proceedings as agreed or taxed. The court held that the applicant should not be required to pay the respondents' costs of complying with the injunctions or the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The requirement under s 115A(4) of the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) that the applicant give notice of its application to the persons who operate the Target Online Locations be dispensed with in so far as any such notice has not already been given.

2. Each respondent must, within 15 business days of these orders, take reasonable steps to disable access to the Target Online Locations.

3. Order 2 is taken to have been complied with by a respondent if that respondent implements any one or more of the following steps:

(a) DNS Blocking in respect of the Target Domain Names;

(b) IP Address blocking or re-routing in respect of the Target IP Addresses;

(c) URL blocking in respect of the Target URLs and the Target Domain Names; or

(d) any alternative technical means for disabling access to the Target Online Locations as agreed in writing between the applicant and a respondent.

4. If a respondent in complying with order 2 does not implement one of the steps referred to in order 3, that respondent must, within 15 business days of these orders, notify the applicant of the step or steps it has implemented.

5. Each respondent must redirect any communication by a user of its service seeking access to a Target Online Location which has been disabled pursuant to order 2 to a webpage established, maintained and hosted by either:

(a) the applicant, or its nominee, pursuant to order 6; or

(b) that respondent or its nominee.

The applicant’s obligations pursuant to orders 6 and 7 only arise if a respondent notifies the applicant that the respondent will redirect a communication pursuant to order 5(a) and for so long as at least one respondent redirects communications to that webpage.

6. The applicant, or its nominee, must establish, maintain and host a webpage which informs users of a respondent’s service who have been redirected to the webpage pursuant to order 5 that access to the website has been disabled because this Court has determined that it infringes or facilitates the infringement of copyright.

7. Within 5 business days of these orders, the applicant will notify each of the respondents in writing of the URL of the webpage established, maintained and hosted under order 6 and, if the webpage ceases to operate for any reason, will notify each of the respondents in writing of a different URL that complies with order 6.

8. If, in complying with order 5, a respondent redirects any communication by a user of its service to a webpage established, maintained and hosted by it, that respondent or its nominee must ensure that the webpage informs the user of that respondent's service that access to that the website has been disabled because this Court has determined that it infringes or facilitates the infringement of copyright.

9. In the event that the applicant has a good faith belief that:

(a) any Target URL, Target IP Address or Target Domain Name which is subject to these orders has permanently ceased to enable or facilitate access to a Target Online Location; or

(b) any Target URL, Target IP Address or Target Domain Name has permanently ceased to have the primary purpose of infringing or facilitating the infringement of copyright,

a representative of the applicant must, within 15 business days of the applicant forming such a good faith belief, notify each respondent of that fact in writing, in which case the respondents shall no longer be required to take steps pursuant to order 2 to disable access to the relevant Target URL, Target IP Address or Target Domain Name that is the subject of the notice.

10. A respondent will not be in breach of order 2 if it temporarily declines or temporarily ceases to take the steps ordered in order 2 (either in whole or in part) upon forming the view, on reasonable grounds, that suspension is necessary to:

(a) maintain the integrity of its network or systems, or functioning of its blocking system;

(b) upgrade, troubleshoot or maintain its blocking system;

(c) avert or respond to an imminent security threat to its network or system; or

(d) ensure the reliable operation of its ability to block access to online locations associated with criminal content if it reasonably considers that such operation is likely to be impaired, or otherwise to comply with its statutory obligations including under section 313(3) of the Telecommunications Act 1997 (Cth)

provided that:

(e) unless precluded by law, it notifies the applicant or their legal representative(s) of such suspension, including the reasons and the expected duration of such suspension by 5.00 pm on the next business day; and

(f) such suspension lasts no longer than is reasonably necessary and, in any case, no longer than 3 business days or such longer period as the applicant may agree in writing or the Court may allow.

11. The owner or operator of any of the Target Online Locations and the owner or operator of any website who claims to be affected by these orders may apply on 3 days' written notice, including notice to all parties, to vary or discharge these orders, with any such application to:

(a) set out the orders sought by the owner or operator of the Target Online Locations or affected website; and

(b) be supported by evidence as to:

(i) the status of the owner or operator of the Target Online Locations or affected website; and

(ii) the basis upon which the variation or discharge is sought.

12. The parties have liberty to apply on 3 days' written notice, including, without limitation, for the purpose of any application:

(a) for further orders to give effect to the terms of these orders;

(b) for further orders in the event of any material change of circumstances including, without limitation, in respect of the consequences for the parties and effectiveness of the technical methods under order 2; and/or

(c) for orders relating to other means of accessing the Target Online Locations not already covered by these orders.

13. If a website the subject of any of the Target Online Locations is at any time during the operation of these orders provided from a different Domain Name, IP Address or URL:

(a) the applicant may file and serve:

(i) an affidavit which:

(A) identifies the different Domain Name, IP Address or URL;

(B) states that, in the good faith belief of the deponent, the website operated from the different Domain Name, IP Address or URL is a new location outside Australia for the Target Online Locations the subject of these orders and brief reasons therefor; and

(ii) proposed short minutes of order to the effect that:

(A) the definition of Target Online Locations in these orders is amended to include the different Domain Name, IP Address or URL; and

(B) the time period in order 2 of these orders starts to run in relation to the different Domain Name, IP Address or URL upon service in accordance with order 17(d) of the orders as made.

14. These orders are to operate for a period of 3 years from the dates of these orders.

15. Six months prior to the expiry of these orders:

(a) the applicant may file and serve:

(i) an affidavit which states that, in the good faith belief of the deponent, that some or all of the Target Online Locations continue to have the primary purpose of infringing or facilitating the infringement of copyright; and

(ii) short minutes of order extending the operation of these orders in relation to the relevant Target Online Locations for a further 3 year period; and

(b) the process contained in order 17 shall apply.

16. The affidavits referred to in orders 13 and 15 are to be given by a deponent duly authorised to give evidence on behalf of the applicant and may be given by its solicitor.

17. If an affidavit and short minutes of order are filed and served in accordance with orders 13 or 15:

(a) within 7 business days, the respondents must notify the applicant and the Court if they object to the orders being made in accordance with the short minutes of orders served by the applicant;

(b) if any respondent gives notice of any objection, or the Court otherwise thinks fit, the proceeding will be relisted for further directions;

(c) if no respondent gives notice of any objection and the Court does not otherwise require the proceeding to be relisted, then the Court may make orders in terms of the short minutes of orders served by the applicant without any further hearing; and

(d) the applicant must serve on the respondents any such orders made.

18. The applicant pay Optus’ compliance costs in the amount of $1,500.

19. The applicant pay Telstra’s and TPG’s compliance costs calculated at the rate of $50 per Domain Name the subject of DNS Blocking undertaken for the purposes of complying with order 2 hereof.

20. The applicant pay the respondents’ costs as agreed or taxed of and incidental to the preparation of evidence and written submissions, and the making of oral submissions, in relation to the applicant’s proposed order 12 and the issue of compliance costs (but excluding set-up costs referred to in [142] of the reasons for judgment).

21. There be no other order as to costs.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Schedule

Background

Background to the litigation

For reasons which I will explain I am satisfied that it is appropriate to grant an injunction under s 115A of the Act in each proceeding and to make various ancillary orders relating to its implementation. TECHNICAL BACKGROUND In this section of my reasons I provide some technical background relevant to the applications that are before me. This description of the technical background is substantially based upon evidence from the applicants’ expert witnesses that was not contentious. The Internet The Internet is a network of interconnected computers and other digital devices. It enables computers or other digital devices (for convenience I will refer to all such devices as “computers”) to establish connections to other computers by cables or wireless technologies. These connections allow computers to communicate with other computers that are “online” using various protocols including the Internet protocol (“IP”) and transmission control protocol (“TCP”). A protocol in this context is a set of rules that computers use to communicate with one another. These communications are transmitted in packets of data sent or received by computers that are identified by their IP Addresses. Internet Protocol Address An Internet Protocol Address (“IP Address”) is a unique string of numbers separated by full stops that enables a computer to communicate with another computer via the Internet. A computer requires an IP Address to ensure that data sent over the Internet reaches its intended destination. Internet Service Providers (“ISPs”) usually provide their customers with access to the Internet via a router to which the ISP assigns an IP Address. Blocks of IP Addresses are allocated by the Internet Assigned Numbers Authority (“IANA”) to five Regional Internet Registries (“RIR”) which then allocate them to ISPs and other entities. Uniform Resource Locator A Uniform Resource Locator (“URL”) is a reference (an address) to a resource, such as a computer server, an electronic document, or a webpage on the Internet, and refers to the entire address used to fetch a resource from an online location. A URL has two main components, a Protocol Identifier and a Resource Name. The Protocol Identifier indicates the name of the Protocol to be used to fetch the resource. For example “https” is the Protocol Identifier which tells a computer to use a protocol known as a Hyper Text Transfer Protocol Secure (“HTTPS”). HTTPS is a secure version of Hyper Text Transfer Protocol (“HTTP”). Both protocols can be used to send data between an online computer and another online location such as a website. The Resource Name refers to the computer that contains the relevant resource, such as a webpage, together with other information (eg. directory, subdirectory and file name) that may be required to locate and access the resource on that computer. Domain Names The Domain Name System (“DNS”) is the system for naming computer servers and other resources connected to the Internet. A Domain Name is a complete address to a resource on the Internet. Domain Names are allocated by a Domain Name Registrar. While the Internet works with IP Addresses, Domain Names provide a more user friendly way for users to interact with the Internet. A computer’s web browser works in the background to seamlessly translate typed Domain Names (eg. “google.com”) into an IP Address (eg. 74.125.224.72). A DNS query is a process whereby a computer or networking device makes an inquiry with a DNS server to find a server that contains the IP Address for the Domain Name. The label at the end of a Domain Name (eg. “.com”) is the top level domain (“TLD”). The core group of TLDs are maintained by IANA and are “com”, “info”, “net” and “org”. There are also many different country code TLDs (“ccTLDs”). IANA is responsible for delegating the management of these ccTLDs (eg. .au, .us, and .uk) to a trustee which is often required to have a local presence in the relevant country. Domain Name System Server

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

I am also satisfied that the primary purpose of the SolarMovie website was to infringe or to facilitate the infringement of copyright in cinematograph films. The Supplementary Evidence The supplementary evidence relating to the SolarMovie website consisted of further affidavits by the Roadshow applicants’ solicitor, Mr Stewart, which indicated that the SolarMovie website was not accessible via any of the SolarMovie URLs, the SolarMovie Domain Names or the SolarMovie IP Addresses as at 22 July 2016 and until at least 14 November 2016 when the last of Mr Stewart’s affidavits was sworn. There is nothing before me to explain why the SolarMovie website was taken off-line. Nor is there any evidence to suggest that the present state of affairs as described in the supplementary evidence is permanent or that the operators of the SolarMovie website will not re-activate it at some time in the near future. Should an injunction be granted? I am satisfied that the SolarMovie website is situated on servers located outside Australia to which each of the respondents provide access. Evidence from Mr Herps establishes that each of the Roadshow films was made available online at the SolarMovie website without the licence of the copyright owner. I am therefore satisfied that by making available online each of the Roadshow films to the public without the licence of the owner of the copyright in such films, the SolarMovie website both infringed and facilitated the infringement of the Roadshow copyright owners’ copyright in the Roadshow films. I am also satisfied that the primary purpose of the SolarMovie website is and was, at the time the Roadshow proceeding was commenced, to infringe or facilitate the infringement of copyright. In particular, I am satisfied that the SolarMovie website was designed and operated to facilitate easy and free access to cinematograph films made available online, something which, I would infer, has almost certainly occurred without the permission of the owners of the copyright in such films. On the matter of discretion, I have had regard to the matters referred to in s 115A(5). It is apparent that the SolarMovie website positively encouraged the infringement of copyright on what I am satisfied is likely to be a widespread scale. These activities involved a flagrant disregard for the Roadshow copyright owners’ rights, the rights of other copyright owners whose films were made available online at the SolarMovie website, and copyright generally. Blocking orders have already been made in relation to many of the SolarMovie sites in other jurisdictions. I have also had regard to the supplementary evidence. The fact that the SolarMovie website is, or at least appears to have been, off-line since July this year, is a matter relevant to the exercise of the discretion to grant relief under s 115A. However, in the circumstances, I am satisfied that there is a substantial risk that this inactivity is merely temporary and that it does not warrant refusing the Roadshow applicants’ relief under s 115A to guard against the possibility that the website will be re-activated at some time in the near future.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.