RnD Funding Pty Ltd v Roncane Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 81 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

RnD Funding Pty Limited v Roncane Pty Limited [2023] FCAFC 28  

Appeal from:

Goldus Pty Ltd (Subject to Deed of Company Arrangement) v Cummins (No 4) [2021] FCA 1095

Goldus Pty Ltd (Subject to Deed of Company Arrangement) v Cummins (No 5) [2021] FCA 1352

RnD Funding Pty Ltd v Goldus Pty Ltd (Subject to Deed of Company Arrangement) [2021] FCA 1096

File number: NSD 1209 of 2021
Judgment of: BEACH, DERRINGTON AND HALLEY JJ
Date of judgment: 9 March 2023
Catchwords:

EQUITY – tracing – holder of equitable charge seeks to trace into assets acquired with funds subject to crystallised charge – whether sufficient proprietary base to invoke right to trace in equity – whether antecedent breach of fiduciary duty required before a right to trace arises – whether underlying rationale for tracing is an interest in property or the existence of a breach of duty owed in respect of the property – whether Grimaldi v Chameleon Mining NL (No 2) (2012) 200 FCR 296 requires antecedent breach of duty

EQUITY – tracing – right of holder of security to trace into property acquired with funds subject of a security interest – whether right to trace distinct from right to trace in equity

Cases cited:

Agip (Africa) Ltd v Jackson [1991] Ch 547

Attorney-General for Hong Kong v Reid [1994] 1 AC 324

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v GDK Financial Solutions Pty Ltd (in liq) (No 5) [2008] FCA 1700

AVCO Financial Services Ltd v Commonwealth Bank of Australia (1989) 17 NSWLR 679

Belmont Finance Corporation v Williams Furniture Ltd (No 2) [1980] 1 All ER 393

Black v S Freedman & Company (1910) 10 CLR 105

Boscawen v Bajwa [1996] 1 WLR 328

Buhr v Barclays Bank plc [2001] EWCA Civ 1223

Bunnings Group Ltd v Asden Developments Pty Ltd [2014] 1 Qd R 493

CFHW Pty Ltd v Burness [2014] VSC 451

Chase Manhattan Bank NA v Israel-British Bank (London) Ltd [1981] Ch 105

Commissioner of Stamp Duties (Queensland) v Livingston [1965] AC 694

Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Saleh [2007] NSWSC 903

Creak v James Moore & Sons Pty Ltd (1912) 15 CLR 426

Dick v Harper [2006] BPIR 20

El Ajou v Dollar Land Holdings plc [1993] 3 All ER 717

Elliot v Secretary, Department of Education, Employment & Workplace Relations (2008) 249 ALR 182

Foskett v McKeown [2001] 1 AC 102

Grimaldi v Chameleon Mining NL (No 2) (2012) 200 FCR 296

Hamersley Iron Pty Ltd v Forge Group Power Pty Ltd (2018) 53 WAR 325

Heperu Pty Ltd v Belle (2009) 76 NSWLR 230

Hurt v Freeman [2002] NSWSC 264

In re Diplock [1948] Ch 465

In re Hallett’s Estate (1879) 13 Ch D 696

Latec Investments Ltd v Hotel Terrigal Pty Ltd (1956) 113 CLR 256

Muschinski v Dodds (1986) 160 CLR 583

Official Trustee in Bankruptcy v Alvaro (1996) 66 FCR 372

Opus Productions Pty Ltd v Popwing Pty Ltd (unreported, Supreme Court of New South…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read RnD Funding Pty Ltd v Roncane Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCAFC 28
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Court of Appeal in RnD Funding Pty Ltd v Roncane Pty Ltd considered an appeal from a decision of the primary judge concerning claims by RnD Funding Pty Ltd, a commercial lender, that it was entitled to trace its security interest in funds held by ATG, a mining company, into shares purchased by Roncane. The underlying dispute involved complex financial arrangements and a security interest granted by ATG to RnD. The Court of Appeal identified that the primary judge's decision was complicated by RnD's unclear claims, particularly regarding the nature of the proprietary interest it sought to trace.

The legal issues central to the appeal involved the conditions under which RnD could trace its security interest into the shares acquired by Roncane. Specifically, the Court had to determine if RnD's claim was based on a legal or equitable interest in the funds and whether the occurrence of a Control Event, which triggered a "locked box" provision, was sufficient to invoke the right to trace. Additionally, the Court considered whether an antecedent breach of fiduciary duty was necessary for a right to trace to arise and if Grimaldi v Chameleon Mining NL (No 2) required such a breach.

The Court of Appeal held that the right to trace is indeed an incident of an underlying property right, and a foundational property claim is necessary for any tracing claim to succeed. The Court distinguished between a common law property right and equitable interests, noting that the nature of the foundational property interest determines the outcome of any tracing claim. The Court concluded that RnD's security interest was sufficient to support a tracing claim. The Court allowed the appeal and declared that the shares in Goldus Pty Ltd held by Roncane Pty Ltd were subject to the security interest of RnD Funding Pty Ltd. The Court also ordered Roncane to pay RnD's costs of the appeal and granted leave for further submissions regarding the costs of the hearing before the primary judge.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal is allowed.

2. It is declared that the shares in Goldus Pty Ltd held by Roncane Pty Ltd are subject to the security interest of RnD Funding Pty Ltd, granted by a deed in writing called “General Security Deed” which is dated 22 December 2017, for the repayment to RnD Funding Pty Ltd of the sum of $320,000 (Three Hundred and Twenty Thousand Dollars).

3. The respondent is to pay the appellant’s costs of the appeal, to be taxed.

4. The parties have leave to make further submissions in relation to the costs of the hearing before the primary judge.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Although the appeal should be allowed, it must be recognised that a perusal of the pleadings and the submissions made to the learned primary judge in this particularly complex matter did not greatly assist his Honour in identifying the different bases on which RnD’s claim was advanced. Indeed, its emphasis on a claim based upon the erroneous argument that it had acquired legal title to the funds in ATG’s account, tended to distract from the somewhat more straightforward argument based on tracing a security interest into the shares in Roncane’s hands. That distraction was enlarged by a vague reference to the concept of the so called “locked box” provisions of the relevant security agreement, without any sufficient attempt to define that term clearly. Further, the submissions made to the learned primary judge did not engage with the difficulties and complexity surrounding the law of tracing in Australia and, in that respect, his Honour was not provided with the assistance given to this Court.Background Although the facts in relation to the overall litigation were complex, it is possible to isolate a relatively small portion of them for the purposes of this appeal. RnD, which conducts business as a commercial lender, provided finance to ATG, a mining company, pursuant to what came to be known as “the First Facility”. Its repayment was secured by a General Security Deed granted by ATG which created a revolving security. By cl 2.1 each Obligor, being the Grantor, ATG, and each Guarantor, provided security over their respective assets to secure repayment of the obligations secured. It read as follows:2.1 Security interest(a) Each Obligor grants a security interest in its Secured Property to the Secured Party as security for the due and punctual payment of the Secured Moneys. (b) This security interest is a transfer by way of security of Secured Property consisting of:(i) Accounts and Chattel Paper which are not, or cease to be, Revolving Assets; or(ii) a Key Document.(c) To the extent any Secured Property is not transferred, this security interest is a charge. If for any reason it is necessary to determine the nature of this charge, it is a floating charge over Revolving Assets and a fixed charge over all other Secured Property. The definition of “Secured Property” in the deed was as follows: Secured Property means in respect of each Obligor, all of the Obligor’s present and after-acquired property (including without limitation the Relevant Property). It includes anything in respect of which the Obligor has at any time sufficient right, interest or power to grant a security interest. By cl 2.5, upon the occurrence of a Control Event, ATG was obliged to deposit money in a particular account. It provided:2.5 Proceeds(a)If a Control Event occurs, each Obligor must immediately and until notified otherwise by the Secured Party deposit in the Controlled Account any proceeds each Obligor receives in respect of any book debt, insurance policy and/or third party claims or any other debts or other amounts now or in the future payable to each Obligor.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

RnD claimed that it was entitled to trace its security interest in the funds held by ATG in its account into the shares purchased by Roncane. It further claimed that it was entitled to an order that the shares be transferred to it. The decision of the primary judge Despite the complexity of the factual circumstances, the learned primary judge synthesised them into the framework set out above and dealt with the tracing claim in that context. There was no suggestion that his Honour erred in this. He found (PJ [263]) that there were two fundamental issues to be determined. The first was whether the Control Event triggered the so-called “locked box” provisions, and secondly, if they were triggered, there was an issue as to whether RnD had a proprietary interest in the funds in the ATG account which could be traced into the Goldus shares acquired by Roncane. The claims advanced by RnD The learned primary judge correctly observed (PJ [263]) that the exact nature of the proprietary interest claimed by RnD was not precisely identified other than by the assertion that, on the occurrence of the Control Event, the funds belonged to it and that there had been a “theft” of the funds which could be traced to Roncane. That would seem to suggest that RnD’s starting point was that it had a legal interest in the funds and that it was entitled to trace them through a number of bank accounts and into the shares. However, his Honour also recognised that RnD advanced an alternative claim which appeared to be derived from its security, being an entitlement to “an equitable charge over those shares by reason of its security” (PJ [260]). He also correctly found (PJ [295]) that the General Security Deed initially created a revolving (floating) security over the secured assets which turned into a fixed charge on the occurrence of a Control Event, as a result of which ATG was no longer entitled to use the secured assets. Later in his reasons (PJ [309]) he described the duality of RnD’s claims as follows:The claim made by RnD Funding was based upon its security rights under the General Security Deed. It sought to characterise those rights as being ownership rights in respect of the secured property upon default by ATG but it claimed in the alternative that its interest as equitable chargee was a sufficient foundational property interest to be able to identify traceable proceeds as being the subject of its equitable charge.The primary judge’s consideration of the issues His Honour considered the principles relating to tracing claims. There is no need to assay his analysis now although this Court and the parties before it derived considerable assistance from it. His general conclusion was that in all cases, a tracing claim depends upon the presence of a foundational property claim. He accepted (PJ [266]) that tracing was a process which did not itself generate rights, so that the existence of some right in respect of property provided part of the justification for a claim to proceeds or value derived from it in the hands of third parties. As such the right to trace was described as “an incident of the underlying property right”. Of the nature of the right he said (PJ [267]):… Despite the change in its character or its mixing with other property, the ownership rights of the original property trace their way into the new property. For that reason, the ability of a property owner to claim the traceable proceeds of property is part of the law of property: Foskett v McKeown [2000] UKHL 29; [2001] 1 AC 102 at 127 (Lord Millett).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The learned primary judge correctly observed (PJ [263]) that the exact nature of the proprietary interest claimed by RnD was not precisely identified other than by the assertion that, on the occurrence of the Control Event, the funds belonged to it and that there had been a “theft” of the funds which could be traced to Roncane. That would seem to suggest that RnD’s starting point was that it had a legal interest in the funds and that it was entitled to trace them through a number of bank accounts and into the shares. However, his Honour also recognised that RnD advanced an alternative claim which appeared to be derived from its security, being an entitlement to “an equitable charge over those shares by reason of its security” (PJ [260]). He also correctly found (PJ [295]) that the General Security Deed initially created a revolving (floating) security over the secured assets which turned into a fixed charge on the occurrence of a Control Event, as a result of which ATG was no longer entitled to use the secured assets. Later in his reasons (PJ [309]) he described the duality of RnD’s claims as follows:The claim made by RnD Funding was based upon its security rights under the General Security Deed. It sought to characterise those rights as being ownership rights in respect of the secured property upon default by ATG but it claimed in the alternative that its interest as equitable chargee was a sufficient foundational property interest to be able to identify traceable proceeds as being the subject of its equitable charge.The primary judge’s consideration of the issues His Honour considered the principles relating to tracing claims. There is no need to assay his analysis now although this Court and the parties before it derived considerable assistance from it. His general conclusion was that in all cases, a tracing claim depends upon the presence of a foundational property claim. He accepted (PJ [266]) that tracing was a process which did not itself generate rights, so that the existence of some right in respect of property provided part of the justification for a claim to proceeds or value derived from it in the hands of third parties. As such the right to trace was described as “an incident of the underlying property right”. Of the nature of the right he said (PJ [267]):… Despite the change in its character or its mixing with other property, the ownership rights of the original property trace their way into the new property. For that reason, the ability of a property owner to claim the traceable proceeds of property is part of the law of property: Foskett v McKeown [2000] UKHL 29; [2001] 1 AC 102 at 127 (Lord Millett). His Honour reasoned (PJ [267]) that it was a consequence of this that the original owner’s claim to trace to the substitute property or its proceeds may result in a proprietary remedy such as the imposition of a constructive trust, or the recognition of a charge or equitable lien and may also provide a foundation for personal claims, such as an account of profits or compensation. In that latter respect he was referring to claims against persons who owed equitable duties to the original owner of the original property as opposed to volunteers who had come into possession of it or its derivative. He then noted that “in all cases, a claim that depends upon the application of tracing principles must begin with a ‘proprietary base’; that is, a foundational property claim”: for which proposition he relied upon the Full Court’s decision in Grimaldi v Chameleon Mining NL (No 2) (2012) 200 FCR 296 at [560] – [561]. He then identified that a common law property right would be sufficient as would some equitable interests, and that the outcome of any claimed entitlement to trace will depend upon the nature of the foundational property interest.