Rivera and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2002] AATA 261

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No N2000/1451

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE  DIVISION       )          
           Re      SALVADOR ERNESTO RIVERA           
  Applicant
           And    MINISTER FOR IMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
  Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       The Hon. R N J Purvis Q.C., Deputy President

Date18 April 2002 

PlaceSydney

Decision      The decision under review is affirmed. 
  ..............................................
  The Hon. R N J Purvis Q.C.
  Deputy President
CATCHWORDS
IMMIGRATION – criminal deportation – primary considerations – seriousness and nature of crime – medical condition of Applicant – community expectations – risk of recidivism – other considerations – position if Applicant remains in Australia – hardship on Applicant in the event of deportation – degree of hardship on family of Applicant in the event of deportation – international obligations  

Migration Act 1958 – sections 200, 201, 499
Ministerial direction No 9 – Criminal Deportation under Section 200 of the Migration Act 1958
Refugee Convention – Article 33(1)

REASONS FOR DECISION

The Hon. R N J Purvis Q.C., Deputy President            

the application

  1. This is an application made by Salvador Ernesto Rivera ("the Applicant") seeking review of the decision of a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs ("the Respondent") made on 21 August 2000. By such decision a deportation order was made against the Applicant pursuant to section 200 of the Migration Act 1958 ("the Act").

  2. In the course of the delegate's reasons for the decision it was stated (T43 pp129-134):

    "PRIMARY CONSIDERATIONS
    COMMUNITY EXPECTATIONS
    Seriousness and nature of the crime
    Mr Rivera's offence of Aggravated Sexual Assault is a serious offence as outlined in the Minister's General Direction No 9.
    …
    A sentence administration print-out provided by the Department of Corrective Service on 7 June 2000 states that Mr Rivera had 48 internal offences recorded against his name.  Of concern is that the offences are predominantly of a violent nature.
    …
    In view of the above it appears that Mr Rivera has made no attempt to address his violent behaviour nor accept the consequences of alcohol consumption. Coupled with the fact that he believes that rehabilitation is not acquired in goal and that he has learned to become angry whilst in goal, it is submitted that his risk of recidivism is assessed as high.
    …
    Community expectation that non-citizen perpetrators of crimes abhorrent to the community should not be allowed to remain in the community
    …
    Mr Rivera's offence is such that the community would expect that he be deported from Australia.  It is an offence prescribed as a serious offence within the Minister's General Direction No 9.
    …
    OTHER CONSIDERATION
    Degree of hardship which may be suffered by the potential deportee
    …
    He had no settlement problems upon arrival [in Australia], as he was only a child. He further stated that he has become used to living in Australia and that if he were deported it would be his worst nightmare. He does not know who would be able to assist him with resettlement if he were deported.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Rivera and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affair... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] AATA 261
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Rivera versus the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs, the parties were contesting the decision to deport the Applicant, Rivera, back to his country of origin, El Salvador. The Applicant, who had arrived in Australia as a child refugee, had been convicted of multiple criminal offences, including aggravated sexual assault, over a period of approximately 13 years. The dispute involved the balance of various factors in determining whether the Applicant's deportation would be in the public interest, including the seriousness of his crimes, his medical condition, and the potential hardship to his family if he were deported.

The central legal issues before the court were the application of the primary considerations under the Migration Act 1958, particularly section 200, and Ministerial Direction No 9 regarding criminal deportation. The court needed to assess the seriousness and nature of Rivera's crimes, the risk of recidivism, and the degree of hardship to his family if deported. Additionally, the court considered whether deporting Rivera would contravene Australia's international obligations under the Refugee Convention, specifically Article 33(1), which prohibits the return of a refugee to a country where their life or freedom would be threatened.

The court deliberated on the arguments presented by both parties. The Applicant's counsel emphasised his long-term residence in Australia, his brain damage resulting from a car accident, and the lack of adequate psychiatric care in El Salvador. It was argued that deporting him would likely result in recidivism and severe hardship for his family. Conversely, the Minister's representative highlighted the seriousness of Rivera's criminal history and the community's expectation that such offenders should be deported. The court noted that while Rivera's medical condition and family ties in Australia were significant, they did not outweigh the need to protect the community from his criminal behaviour. The court also concluded that deporting Rivera would not breach Australia's international obligations.

Ultimately, the court decided that the seriousness of Rivera's crimes and the protection of the community outweighed the potential hardship to his family and his medical needs. The court determined that deporting him did not contravene Australia's international obligations and that the Applicant's deportation was in the public interest. The decision was upheld, and the Applicant was to be deported back to El Salvador.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Respondent submitted that the critical issue in this regard is whether the life or freedom of the Applicant would be threatened on account of his race, religion, nationality, and membership of a particular social group or political opinion pursuant to article 33(1) of the Refugees Convention. It was contented that the Applicant would not be exposed to a threat if returned to his country of origin. There not being any other material on this issue tendered before the Tribunal it sees no reason to do other than to accept the above conclusions, which it does.submissions and decision It was maintained by Mr Duncombe, on behalf of the Applicant, that the Applicant arriving in Australia at the age of 11 years had little knowledge of El Salvador. He had experienced the motor vehicle accident and as a consequence suffered brain damage, the consequences of which are still manifest. It was further suggested that the Applicant had not received appropriate psychiatric supervision or medication whilst incarcerated and that his medical condition had in effect been ignored by the prison system. Whilst the former is clearly established by the evidence, the lack of supervision and attention was largely attributable to the conduct of the Applicant himself and his not making appropriate arrangements for, or extending a willingness to engage in, medical assistance programs. It was further submitted that if the Applicant be deported to El Salvador that he would be there on his own, with minimal relative support, without assets and assistance and supervision, and that in all likelihood he would "fall into trouble" and "be back where he was". Whilst his family would provide such assistance and support as they were able, the same may not be sufficient. His propensity to consume alcohol and use drugs displayed in the past and on the occasions whilst in detention may well re-occur to his detriment. The long-term prospect of coping with the Applicant's mental and associated problems depends very much on his being able to continue his ties with his family. If he be sent back to El Salvador, support of a like nature would not be available and, it was submitted, would destroy all efforts to try and stabilise his lifestyle and prevent him from re-offending. The entire family, it was submitted, would suffer severe hardship if he be deported. The Applicant has a strong and continuing support in Australia from his family, particularly his mother and brother with who's aid the Applicant "may be still be able to make a limited contribution to the community as well as maintain a law abiding existence". On the other hand in El Salvador "he has few contacts and …his mental illness and associated disabilities would place him in an extremely vulnerable position". The Tribunal is mindful of these matters that have been submitted on behalf of the Applicant and accepts that the Applicant would be so disadvantaged and there would be a hardship experienced by members of his family. On the other hand it was submitted by Mr Leerdam on behalf of the Respondent that it is a primary objective of Direction 9 that the Australian community is to be protected from crime. It is an established fact that the Applicant consistently breached Australia's laws over a period of approximately 13 years continually committing acts of aggression upon others. This factor should weigh very heavily in favour of deportation. Sexual assaults, whether or not accompanied by violence, especially were there has been more than one sexual offence are clearly included in the Minister's Direction. The severity of the crime is indeed reflected in the sentence imposed, the same clearly being within the category of crimes regarded as serious.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the course of the delegate's reasons for the decision it was stated (T43 pp129-134):"PRIMARY CONSIDERATIONSCOMMUNITY EXPECTATIONSSeriousness and nature of the crimeMr Rivera's offence of Aggravated Sexual Assault is a serious offence as outlined in the Minister's General Direction No 9.…A sentence administration print-out provided by the Department of Corrective Service on 7 June 2000 states that Mr Rivera had 48 internal offences recorded against his name. Of concern is that the offences are predominantly of a violent nature.…In view of the above it appears that Mr Rivera has made no attempt to address his violent behaviour nor accept the consequences of alcohol consumption. Coupled with the fact that he believes that rehabilitation is not acquired in goal and that he has learned to become angry whilst in goal, it is submitted that his risk of recidivism is assessed as high.…Community expectation that non-citizen perpetrators of crimes abhorrent to the community should not be allowed to remain in the community…Mr Rivera's offence is such that the community would expect that he be deported from Australia. It is an offence prescribed as a serious offence within the Minister's General Direction No 9.…OTHER CONSIDERATIONDegree of hardship which may be suffered by the potential deportee…He had no settlement problems upon arrival [in Australia], as he was only a child. He further stated that he has become used to living in Australia and that if he were deported it would be his worst nightmare. He does not know who would be able to assist him with resettlement if he were deported. He also stated that whilst he has no friends he is close to his mother.There is also every indication that Mr Rivera sustained some brain damage following a car accident in 1993. As such, it maybe that medical services of the nature required by Mr Rivera are either not available or not the same standard as available in Australia.…Degree of hardship to any Australian citizen or permanent resident, including the deportee's family…At interview Ms Rivera [the Applicant's mother] stated that she cried when she received the news that her son may be deported.…Ms Rivera also stated that she can not offer her son financial assistance as her husband is a pensioner and although she does not know what assistance she can offer him, he will reside with her upon release……International obligationsMr Rivera entered Australia on 19 September 1985 as the holder of a K4722 migrant visa (dependent child, special humanitarian program, Central Americans). He is therefore considered to be a refugee within the terms of the Refugee Convention.…Onshore Protection Section, Central Office, examined Australia's obligations under section 33(1), in particular Mr Rivera's claim that his family was targeted by the authorities because of his uncle's alleged anti-government activities....Onshore Protection assessed that Australia would not breach its international obligations under the International Convention on Civil and Political Rights or the Convention Against Torture if he were returned to El Salvador."