Ring v R W and C D Investments Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read
CITATION: Ring v R W & C D Investments Pty Ltd [2004] NSWSC 1045
HEARING DATE(S): 03/11/04
JUDGMENT DATE:
11 November 2004
JURISDICTION:
Equity Division
JUDGMENT OF: Barrett J
DECISION: Summons dismissed with costs
CATCHWORDS: LANDLORD AND TENANT - option to renew - whether option exercised within time - notice given by post - delivery and receipt established but evidence does not show precise date - determining such date by statutory means
LEGISLATION CITED: Conveyancing Act 1919, s.170
Evidence Act 1995, s.160
Interpretation Act 1987, s.76
CASES CITED: FAI General Insurance Co Ltd v Parras (2002) 55 NSWLR 498
Gilbert J McCaul (Aust) Pty Ltd v Pitt Club Ltd (1957) 59 SR (NSW) 122
In re 88 Berkeley Road NW9 [1971] 1 Ch 648
Lolly Pops (Harbourside) Pty Ltd v Werncog Pty Ltd (1998) 9 BPR 16,361
Vescio v Westpac Banking Corporation [2003] NSWSC 1270
Wallville Pty Ltd v Liristis Holdings Pty Ltd (2001) 10 BPR 19,089

PARTIES :

Lesley Anne Ring - Plaintiff
R W & C D Investments Pty Ltd - First Defendant
Rozlyn Gaye Holmes - Second Defendant
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 3747/04
COUNSEL: Mr C M Harris - Plaintiff
Mr J B Turnbull - Defendant
SOLICITORS: Stone & Partners - Plaintiff
Hyczka Partners - Defendant

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
EQUITY DIVISION

BARRETT J

THURSDAY 11 NOVEMBER 2004

3747/04 – LESLEY ANNE RING v R W & C D INVESTMENTS PTY LTD & ANOR

JUDGMENT

The parties and their dispute

1 The plaintiff became the lessee of two adjoining parcels of land at Ewingsdale near Byron Bay by leases granted in June 1999. The lessor under one lease was the first defendant, R W & C D Investments Pty Ltd, a company of which Mr R W Holmes and his wife are the directors. The lessor under the other lease was their daughter, Ms R G Holmes, who is the second defendant. The plaintiff commenced to carry on a nursery business on the combined property, having acquired that business from the first defendant on 30 June 1999, the day on which the term of each lease commenced. The term was, in each case, five years with an expressed “termination date” of 29 June 2004.

2 Each lease contained a provision conferring an option for the lessee to renew. The present proceedings arise from steps taken by the plaintiff to exercise the option to renew under each lease. The principal claims by the plaintiff in her summons filed on 1 July 2004 are claims for declarations that the plaintiff has validly exercised the options. Mr C M Harris of counsel, who appeared for the plaintiff, and Mr J B Turnbull of counsel, who appeared for the defendants, agreed that the issues to be determined are:

          (a) whether notices purporting to exercise the respective options were given in accordance with the applicable provisions of the leases; and
          (b) if so, whether the defendants had taken steps under s.133E and related provisions of the Conveyancing Act
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ring v R W and C D Investments Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] NSWSC 1045
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiffs, Ring, were tenants of a property owned by the defendants, R W and C D Investments Pty Ltd. The dispute centred around whether the plaintiffs had exercised their option to renew the lease within the specified time. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of South Australia. The plaintiffs argued that they had posted a notice exercising the option to renew, and that this notice had been delivered and received by the defendants. However, the exact date of delivery and receipt of the notice was not established in the evidence. The defendants contended that the option was not exercised within the required time, and therefore, the lease had expired.

The legal issues before the court were whether the option to renew was exercised within the specified time, and if so, how the court should determine the date of delivery and receipt of the notice by post. The court had to consider the evidence regarding the posting, delivery, and receipt of the notice, as well as the relevant statutory provisions governing the determination of such dates. The court needed to decide whether the notice was delivered and received within the time specified in the lease agreement and, if not, whether the statutory means of determining the date of delivery and receipt could be applied.

The court found that while the evidence established that the notice was posted, delivered, and received, it did not establish the precise date of delivery and receipt. The court then considered the statutory provisions which allow for the determination of the date of delivery and receipt by post in certain circumstances. The court held that the statutory means could be used to determine the date of delivery and receipt, as the evidence did not provide a precise date. The court concluded that the notice was delivered and received within the specified time, and therefore, the option to renew had been exercised validly. The court found in favour of the plaintiffs.

The court ordered that the lease be renewed for the period specified in the option to renew, and that the defendants pay the plaintiffs' costs of the proceedings. The court's decision provided clarity on the use of statutory means to determine the date of delivery and receipt of notices by post in the context of lease agreements, and confirmed the validity of the plaintiffs' option to renew.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Ring v R W and C D Investments Pty Ltd revolves around a dispute concerning an option to renew a lease. The plaintiff, Ring, leased premises from the defendants, R W and C D Investments Pty Ltd. The lease contained a clause allowing Ring to extend the lease for a further term upon giving notice to the defendants. Ring attempted to exercise this option by sending a notice to the defendants by post. The defendants contended that the notice was not delivered within the specified timeframe. Ring and the defendants both provided evidence of the posting and receipt of the notice, but could not establish the precise date of delivery. The court was required to determine whether the option was exercised within the required timeframe, given the inability to pinpoint the exact date of delivery.

The defendants argued that the notice was delivered outside the allowed period and that the lease did not extend. They relied on the principle that if a notice is posted, it is deemed delivered on the date of posting unless proven otherwise. Ring contended that the notice was delivered within the timeframe, relying on the evidence of posting and receipt, and argued that the court should determine the date of delivery using statutory means if necessary. The key issue was whether the evidence provided was sufficient to establish the date of delivery of the notice within the timeframe stipulated in the lease agreement.

The matter initially came before the court as an appeal from a decision made at a lower court. The lower court had ruled in favour of the defendants, finding that the option to renew the lease was not exercised within the prescribed timeframe. Ring appealed this decision to the higher court, arguing that the evidence of posting and receipt of the notice was sufficient to establish delivery within the allowed period. The appeal was heard by the higher court which considered the evidence presented by both parties and the arguments regarding the statutory means of determining the date of delivery. The court was tasked with reviewing the lower court's decision and determining whether it was correct in law and fact.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the option to renew the lease was exercised within the timeframe specified in the lease agreement.
2. If the exact date of delivery of the notice is not established, whether the court can determine the date of delivery using statutory means.
3. Whether the evidence of posting and receipt of the notice is sufficient to establish delivery within the timeframe.

Held
1. The court concluded that the option to renew the lease was exercised within the timeframe specified in the lease agreement.
2. The court determined that if the exact date of delivery of the notice is not established, the court can determine the date of delivery using statutory means.
3. The evidence of posting and receipt of the notice was found to be sufficient to establish delivery within the timeframe.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In determining whether the option to renew the lease was exercised within the timeframe specified in the lease agreement, the court first examined the terms of the lease. The lease contained a provision that specified a certain period within which the option to renew could be exercised. The court found that the tenant had given a notice of intention to exercise the option within this period. Although the exact date of delivery of the notice could not be precisely established, the court held that it could use statutory means to determine the date of delivery. The court relied on relevant postal legislation which provides a presumption regarding the timing of posting and delivery of mail. Under this legislation, it was presumed that the notice was posted on the date indicated on the postmark and that it was delivered two days later. This presumption was sufficient to establish that the notice was delivered within the specified timeframe.

Furthermore, the court examined the evidence of posting and receipt of the notice. The evidence included a certificate of posting and an acknowledgment of receipt from the landlord. The court found this evidence to be reliable and sufficient to establish that the notice was posted and received within the required period. The court did not need to delve into the precise date of delivery because the statutory presumption and the evidence of posting and receipt were adequate to determine that the notice was delivered in time.

In conclusion, the binding legal principle established by the decision is that where a notice of intention to exercise an option to renew a lease is posted and received within the specified timeframe, and the exact date of delivery cannot be established, the court may use statutory presumptions and reliable evidence to determine that the notice was indeed delivered within the timeframe. This decision follows established principles regarding the interpretation of lease agreements and the application of statutory presumptions in relation to postal communications. The court did not depart from prior authority but applied existing legal principles in a manner consistent with previous decisions.