Rimhart Nominees Pty Ltd v Glenent Pty Ltd (No 4)

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

RIMHART NOMINEES PTY LTD v GLENENT PTY LTD (No 4)

[2008] SASC 224

Reasons of Judge Withers a Master of the Supreme Court

18 August 2008

PROCEDURE

Joinder of additional defendant.

Supreme Court Act 1935 (SA) s 27; Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006 (SA) r 73, r 74 and r 232, referred to.
Ceneavenue Pty Ltd & Ors v Martin & Ors [2008] SASC 158; Bryan v Maloney (1994-1995) 182 CLR 609; Woolcock Street Investments Pty Ltd v CDG Pty Ltd & Anor (2003-2004) 216 CLR 515; Fancourt v Mercantile Credits Ltd (1983) 154 CLR 87, discussed.
Review Australia Pty Ltd v Redberry Enterprise Pty Ltd [2003] FCA 1009; Universal Music Australia Pty Ltd v Cooper [2004] FCA 78; Re Androma Pty Ltd (1987) 2 Qd R 134; Massart v Blight & Anor 82 CLR 423; Robins v Goddard [1905] 1 KB 294; Building and Construction Contracts in Australia Dorter and Sharkey (2nd ed), p 2693; Equity Doctrines & Remedies Meagher, Gummow and Lehane (4th ed), par 6-520, considered.

RIMHART NOMINEES PTY LTD v GLENENT PTY LTD (No 4)
[2008] SASC 224

  1. JUDGE WITHERS.  By interlocutory application filed 3 December 2007 – FDN 9 –  the plaintiff (“Rimhart”) sought various interlocutory orders including:

    2ALeave to join Baulderstone Hornibrook as a defendant to make consequential amendments to the Statement of Claim dated 19 November 2007.

  2. The interlocutory application was further amended on 13 December 2007 – FDN 12 – but those amendments have no relevance to application 2A which is the joinder issue presently before me.

  3. An affidavit of Peter James Rimington, who is the sole director of the plaintiff company – FDN 8 – was filed in support of the application on 4 December 2007.

  4. A brief overview of the background to this matter is that the plaintiff in December 2004 entered into an agreement with the defendant Glenent for the purchase of an entertainment complex at the foreshore at Glenelg after that complex had been built.  The defendant was a company equally owned and controlled by the proposed additional defendant, Baulderstone Hornibrook Pty Ltd (hereafter “Baulderstone”), and Urban Construct Pty Ltd (hereafter “Urban”).

  5. Baulderstone is and was a builder that was substantially engaged in the development and construction of a foreshore development at Glenelg over a number of years.  Mr Rimington and the plaintiff and Baulderstone had been involved in various agreements and arrangements regarding a particular aspect of the proposed development since 2001.  That aspect was the acquisition of the original entertainment complex and business known as the Magic Mountain and its eventual replacement – see proposed amended statement of claim – FDN 22a – paragraphs 5E to 5U.

  6. The agreement that Rimhart entered into with Glenent is Exhibit “PJR 3” to the affidavit of Mr Rimington filed 19 November 2007 – see Document 3c.  That agreement provided inter alia that Glenent would carry out or cause to be carried out building works…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Rimhart Nominees Pty Ltd v Glenent Pty Ltd (No 4) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] SASC 224
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Rimhart Nominees Pty Ltd sought permission to join Baulderstone Hornibrook as a defendant in an existing proceeding against Glenent Pty Ltd. The primary dispute involved claims of defects in a building and fitout project. Baulderstone argued that it was protected by an indemnity agreement with Glenent, which was not considered sufficient to bar the plaintiff’s claim. The court needed to determine if the plaintiff could join Baulderstone as a defendant and whether the claims against Baulderstone were valid and not futile. The court also considered the potential for avoiding multiplicity of suits and ensuring justice.

The court examined the nature of the indemnity agreement between Glenent and Baulderstone, finding that it did not constitute a release at large and was limited to works carried out under the sale contract. The court further analysed the commonality of issues between the claims against Baulderstone and Glenent, focusing on whether the building and fitout were defective and whether the plaintiff suffered losses due to any breaches. The court concluded that joining Baulderstone would be appropriate under the relevant rules of court and would help avoid unnecessary litigation, aligning with the objectives of the Supreme Court Act.

The court granted permission for Rimhart to join Baulderstone as a defendant, permitting an amended summons and statement of claim to be filed within seven days. The plaintiff was instructed to provide further particulars of the alleged breaches of duty and losses. The court indicated its intention to make an order for the costs of the application to be costs in the cause but left open the possibility for the parties to be heard on this issue. The decision was certified as fit for counsel.

The final order permitted Rimhart to join Baulderstone as a defendant, allowing the filing of an amended summons and statement of claim with specified conditions. The court also directed that the plaintiff provide detailed particulars of the alleged breaches and losses. The decision emphasised the importance of avoiding multiple suits and achieving justice in the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Baulderstone says that it was one of Glenent’s contractors and therefore is covered by that indemnity agreement. However, that clause in my view does not amount to a release at large. It contains its own qualification in relation to works being carried out pursuant to the sale contract. It cannot be effective other than as at the date when the agreement was signed. Baulderstone was not a party. In my view it is not an impenetrable barrier to the plaintiff’s claim.Conclusion I am satisfied that the proposed claims by the plaintiff against Baulderstone involve issues common to some of the claims by the plaintiff against Glenent. Some of those issues are whether the building and fitout in some aspects was defective or not built in compliance with the contract or with due care and skill. There is a common issue as to whether the plaintiff has suffered loss as a result of any contractual breach or breach of duty. In my view it is appropriate to give permission to join Baulderstone as a defendant pursuant to R 74(1)(a), (d) and (e) and such joinder meets the requirements of R 73(2). Such a course would also avoid a multiplicity of suits and thus meet the objectives of s 27 of the Supreme Court Act. I am not satisfied that the proposed claims against Baulderstone are futile. The plaintiff faces a number of difficulties in its claims but in my view the circumstances presently before the Court would not result in the proposed defendant inevitably obtaining summary judgment in its favour. I am mindful of the High Court’s warning in Fancourt. For the foregoing reasons there will be an order that the plaintiff has permission to join Baulderstone Hornibrook as a defendant to these proceedings. Permission is given to the plaintiff within 7 days to file and serve an amended summons and statement of claim in the form of that exhibited as “MEH 1” to the affidavit of Mr Hamilton sworn 19 June 2008. Further permission is given to the plaintiff to re-number the paragraphs in that proposed amended statement of claim to more sensibly incorporate and delineate the presently proposed amended paragraphs. The plaintiff is to provide in the amended statement of claim further particulars of the alleged breaches of duty and the alleged losses flowing therefrom. I am presently minded to make an order that the costs of the application be costs in the cause but I will hear the parties on that issue if they seek to be heard. I certify fit for counsel.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established