Riley v Fraser

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read
16 CLR 173

FRASER AND OTHERS

RESPONDENTS.

PLAINTIFFS AND DEFENDANTS.

ON APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF Will-Interpretation-Direction to accumulate in certain event-Intestacy.

A testator by his will gave certain real estate to trustees upon trust to pay the net rents and profits to his wife during her life, and after her death to pay the net rents and profits to his daughters " so long as the present wife of my son

shall live or remain his wife and on the death of my said son's said wife or her ceasing to be his wife or if she shall predecease my wife then to accumu- late the said rents for a period of five years from the time of her death or of her ceasing to be my said son's wife whichever event shall first happen if she sur- vive my wife or from my wife's death if my said son's wife shall predecease her," and he then directed what was to be done with the accumulations at the end of five years. At the time of the testator's death his son was living with a woman as his reputed wife, having gone through the ceremony of mar- riage with her. The marriage was invalid because she was already married, and this fact was discovered after the testator's death, but before the death of the testator's wife.

Held, that the person referred to in the will as the present wife" of the testator's son was his reputed wife, that she ceased to be his wife, within the meaning of the will, when the fact of her previous marriage was discovered, that the accumulations should begin on the death of the testator's wife, and that there was no intestacy in respect of such accumulations.

Decision of the Supreme Court of Victoria (Madden C.J.) affirmed.

APPEAL from the Supreme Court of Victoria.

Joseph Riley, who died on 27th October 1898, by his will, dated 3rd October 1898, gave to his trustees his farm at Spring-

16 CLR 174

mount, near Creswick, Victoria, " Upon trust to pay the net rents

and profits thereof to my wife during her life and after her death to pay the net rents and profits of the said property to my said daughters Margaret Annie and Jessie SO long as the present wife of my son Joseph shall live or remain his wife and on the death of my said son's said wife or her ceasing to be his wife or if she shall predecease my wife then to accumulate the said rents for a period of five years from the time of her death or of her ceasing to be my said son's wife whichever event shall first happen if she sur- vive my wife or from my wife's death if my said son's wife shall predecease her and if at the end of the said period of five years my trustees shall be of opinion that my said son has conducted himself soberly and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Riley v Fraser and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1913] HCA 16
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of *Riley v Fraser* concerned a dispute over the interpretation of a testator's will regarding the disposition of rents from a farm. The testator's will established a life estate for his wife, followed by a trust for his daughters. This trust was to continue as long as the testator's son's "present wife" lived or remained his wife. Upon the death of the son's wife or her ceasing to be his wife, the rents were to accumulate for five years, after which the disposition depended on the son's conduct. The testator's son was living with a woman, Katherine Hourigan, as his reputed wife, but their marriage was invalid due to her prior existing marriage, a fact discovered after the testator's death. The testator's wife died in 1906, and the son remained unmarried and childless. The executor and executrix of the will sought a determination from the Supreme Court of Victoria as to whether the testator died intestate regarding the rents accrued since his widow's death and future rents. The Supreme Court, per Madden C.J., held that there was no intestacy, and this decision was appealed to the High Court of Australia.

The central legal issues before the High Court were: first, whether the phrase "the present wife of my son Joseph" referred to Katherine Hourigan, the testator's son's reputed wife; second, when Katherine Hourigan ceased to be the son's wife within the meaning of the will; and third, whether the direction for the accumulation of rents was valid and when it commenced, thereby avoiding an intestacy. The appellant argued that the condition precedent for the accumulation and subsequent gifts could not occur if the reputed wife was never legally married to the son.

The High Court, affirming the decision of the Supreme Court, held that the testator intended to refer to Katherine Hourigan as his son's "present wife," despite the invalidity of their marriage. The Court reasoned that the phrase "ceased to be his wife" encompassed the situation where the reputed relationship was revealed to be legally invalid. This occurred when the fact of Katherine Hourigan's prior marriage was discovered. Consequently, she ceased to be the son's wife within the contemplation of the will at that point. Although the son's reputed wife ceased to be his wife in 1904, the testator's widow's life estate took precedence. Therefore, the five-year accumulation period commenced upon the death of the testator's widow in 1906. The Court applied the principle of interpreting wills to avoid intestacy where possible, finding that the dispositions regarding the rents were operative and not void.

The appeal was dismissed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established