Ridley Agriproducts Pty Ltd v CMAs Consulting Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Ridley Agriproducts Pty Ltd v CMAS Consulting Pty Ltd [2003] QDC 284

PARTIES:

RIDLEY AGRIPRODUCTS PTY LTD (ACN 006 544 145)

Applicant

v

CMAS CONSULTING PTY LTD (ACN 010 643 802)

Respondent

FILE NO/S:

1092 of 2003

DIVISION:

Civil

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

District Court, Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

14 August 2003

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

29 April 2003

JUDGE:

Shanahan DCJ

ORDER:

The applicant is granted leave to join the respondent as a contributor to the claim made by Edgar Balbarais, the claimant

CATCHWORDS:

PERSONAL INJURY – where claimant suffered an aggravation of a psychiatric injury in the course of his employment

APPLICATION TO JOIN CONTRIBUTOR – s 16(2) Personal Injuries Proceeding Act 2002 (Qld) – where claimant employed by the respondent, a labour hire agency – where claimant working on the premises of the applicant pursuant to a labour hire agreement – where allegation that the respondent breached implied conditions of the labour hire agreement by failing to provide labourers suitable to the position and failing to inform the applicant of the claimant’s employment and medical history

INTERACTION BETWEEN PERSONAL INJURIES PROCEEDING ACT 2002 AND WOKCOVER QUEENSLAND ACT 1996 – where WorkCover purported to provide indemnity to the respondent – whether claim for contribution under the Personal Injuries Proceeding Act was prohibited by s 253 of the WorkCover Queensland Act 1996 (Qld) – whether claim in respect of breach of implied terms was a claim for damages “for personal injury” – whether s 16 Personal Injuries Proceeding Act is restricted to claims for personal injury – in what circumstances concurrent actions can be maintained

DELAY IN GIVING WRITTEN NOTICE TO THE RESPONDENT – whether there was an adequate explanation – whether any prejudice was suffered

Cases cited –

Cottee v Franklins Self Serve Pty Ltd [1997] 1 Qd R 469, cited

Devlin v South Molle Island Resort [2003] QSC 020, followed

Oxley County Council v MacDonald & Ors [1999] NSWCA 126 (2 July 1999), cited

Statutes cited –

Personal Injuries Proceeding Act 2002 (Qld) – ss 6, 9 and 16 

WorkCover Queensland Act 1996 (Qld) – ss 253, 280(2)(b), 293 and 305

 COUNSEL:

Mr K Holyoak for the applicant

Mr S A McLeod for the respondent

Mr J McDougall for WorkCover Queensland

SOLICITORS:

Barry & Nilsson for the applicant

Bradley & Co for the respondent

WorkCover Queensland

  1. Pursuant to s 16(2) of the Personal Injuries Proceeding Act 2002 (“the Act”), the applicant seeks an order that leave be granted to join the respondent as a contributor to the notice of claim made by one Edgar Balbarais.  The claimant does not oppose the application.  The respondent opposes the order sought.  WorkCover Queensland, insofar as it indemnifies the respondent, also opposes the application.

The background

  1. The claimant claims he suffered personal injury while working at the premises of the applicant on or about 20 July 1999.  The claimant was employed by the respondent, a labour hire agency, on the day of the incident.  It…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ridley Agriproducts Pty Ltd v CMAs Consulting Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] QDC 284
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Ridley Agriproducts Pty Ltd v CMAs Consulting Pty Ltd involves a claim for personal injury by Edgar Balbarais, who suffered an aggravation of a pre-existing psychiatric condition while working under a labour hire agreement between CMAs Consulting Pty Ltd and Ridley Agriproducts Pty Ltd. Balbarais seeks to join CMAs Consulting as a contributor to the claim, alleging that CMAs Consulting failed to provide labourers suitable to the position and did not inform Ridley Agriproducts of Balbarais's employment and medical history. This allegation pertains to the implied terms of the labour hire agreement.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether Balbarais could join CMAs Consulting as a contributor under section 16(2) of the Personal Injuries Proceeding Act 2002 (Qld), and if so, whether this was precluded by section 253 of the WorkCover Queensland Act 1996 (Qld). Additionally, the court needed to determine if the claim for breach of implied terms was a claim for damages for personal injury and if section 16 of the Personal Injuries Proceeding Act was limited to such claims. The court also considered the adequacy of the explanation for the delay in notifying CMAs Consulting of the claim and whether any prejudice resulted from this delay.

In its reasoning, the court found that Balbarais could join CMAs Consulting as a contributor, as the claim for breach of implied terms was not inherently a claim for damages for personal injury, but rather for a breach of contract. The court held that section 16 of the Personal Injuries Proceeding Act is not limited to claims for personal injury, and concurrent actions can be maintained. Furthermore, the court accepted that there was an adequate explanation for the delay in notifying CMAs Consulting and found no prejudice had resulted from this delay. Consequently, the application to join CMAs Consulting as a contributor was granted.

The court's final order was that Ridley Agriproducts Pty Ltd is granted leave to join CMAs Consulting Pty Ltd as a contributor to the claim made by Edgar Balbarais.

Orders

Orders of the court

The applicant is granted leave to join the respondent as a contributor to the claim made by Edgar Balbarais, the claimant

Background

Background to the litigation

The claimant in this matter, Edgar Balbarais, commenced proceedings against the applicant, Ridley Agriproducts Pty Ltd, seeking damages for personal injury sustained in the course of his employment. Balbarais was engaged by the respondent, CMAs Consulting Pty Ltd, a labour hire agency, to work on the premises of Ridley Agriproducts Pty Ltd under a labour hire agreement. During the course of his employment, Balbarais suffered an aggravation of a pre-existing psychiatric condition, which he attributes to the conditions of his workplace and the events occurring therein.

Balbarais alleges that CMAs Consulting Pty Ltd breached implied conditions of the labour hire agreement by failing to provide labourers suitable to the positions they were to occupy and by failing to inform Ridley Agriproducts Pty Ltd of Balbarais's employment and medical history. The claim seeks to join CMAs Consulting Pty Ltd as a contributor to the proceedings under section 16(2) of the Personal Injuries Proceeding Act 2002 (Qld). This application raises questions regarding the interaction between the Personal Injuries Proceeding Act 2002 and the WorkCover Queensland Act 1996 (Qld), specifically whether a claim for contribution under the Personal Injuries Proceeding Act is prohibited by section 253 of the WorkCover Queensland Act 1996, and whether the claim for breach of implied terms constitutes a claim for damages "for personal injury" within the meaning of the WorkCover Queensland Act 1996. The case also explores whether section 16 of the Personal Injuries Proceeding Act is restricted to claims for personal injury and under what circumstances concurrent actions can be maintained.

Further, the application addresses the issue of the delay in giving written notice to the respondent, CMAs Consulting Pty Ltd, and whether there was an adequate explanation for this delay and whether any prejudice was suffered by the respondent. The case seeks to clarify the procedural requirements and the implications of delays in giving notice under the Personal Injuries Proceeding Act 2002.

The matter before the court is an application by Ridley Agriproducts Pty Ltd, the applicant, to join CMAs Consulting Pty Ltd, the respondent, as a contributor to a personal injury claim brought by Edgar Balbarais, the claimant. The claimant, employed by the respondent, a labour hire agency, suffered an aggravation of a psychiatric injury in the course of his employment while working on the premises of the applicant pursuant to a labour hire agreement. The applicant alleges that the respondent breached implied conditions of the labour hire agreement by failing to provide labourers suitable to the position and by failing to inform the applicant of the claimant’s employment and medical history. The application to join the respondent was brought pursuant to section 16(2) of the Personal Injuries Proceedings Act 2002 (Qld). The case raises complex issues regarding the interaction between the Personal Injuries Proceedings Act and the WorkCover Queensland Act 1996 (Qld), specifically whether a claim for contribution under the Personal Injuries Proceedings Act is prohibited by section 253 of the WorkCover Queensland Act and whether the claim in respect of breach of implied terms constitutes a claim for damages “for personal injury.” Additionally, the application addressed whether there was an adequate explanation for the delay in giving written notice to the respondent and whether any prejudice was suffered as a result of this delay. The court was tasked with considering these procedural aspects in the context of the broader legal framework governing personal injury claims and contribution actions in Queensland.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does s 16(2) of the Personal Injuries Proceeding Act 2002 (Qld) permit a claimant to join a labour hire agency as a contributor in a personal injury claim?

2. Was there a breach of the implied conditions of the labour hire agreement by the respondent in failing to provide labourers suitable to the position and in failing to inform the applicant of the claimant’s employment and medical history?

3. Does the provision of indemnity by WorkCover Queensland under s 253 of the WorkCover Queensland Act 1996 (Qld) prohibit a claim for contribution under the Personal Injuries Proceeding Act 2002?

4. Is a claim for breach of implied terms a claim for damages “for personal injury” within the meaning of s 253 of the WorkCover Queensland Act 1996 (Qld)?

5. Is s 16 of the Personal Injuries Proceeding Act 2002 (Qld) restricted to claims for personal injury, or does it also encompass claims for breach of implied terms in a labour hire agreement?

6. In what circumstances can concurrent actions be maintained under the Personal Injuries Proceeding Act 2002 (Qld) and the WorkCover Queensland Act 1996 (Qld)?

7. Was there an adequate explanation for the delay in giving written notice to the respondent, and was any prejudice suffered as a result of this delay?

Held
1. Does s 16(2) of the Personal Injuries Proceeding Act 2002 (Qld) permit a claimant to join a labour hire agency as a contributor in a personal injury claim? The court concluded that s 16(2) does permit a claimant to join a labour hire agency as a contributor in a personal injury claim. The applicant is granted leave to join the respondent as a contributor to the claim made by Edgar Balbarais.

2. Was there a breach of the implied conditions of the labour hire agreement by the respondent in failing to provide labourers suitable to the position and in failing to inform the applicant of the claimant’s employment and medical history? The court concluded there was no breach of the implied conditions by the respondent. The labour hire agency did not breach its obligations in this respect.

3. Does the provision of indemnity by WorkCover Queensland under s 253 of the WorkCover Queensland Act 1996 (Qld) prohibit a claim for contribution under the Personal Injuries Proceeding Act 2002? The court concluded that the provision of indemnity by WorkCover Queensland does not prohibit a claim for contribution under the Personal Injuries Proceeding Act 2002.

4. Is a claim for breach of implied terms a claim for damages “for personal injury” within the meaning of s 253 of the WorkCover Queensland Act 1996 (Qld)? The court concluded that a claim for breach of implied terms is not a claim for damages “for personal injury” within the meaning of s 253 of the WorkCover Queensland Act 1996.

5. Is s 16 of the Personal Injuries Proceeding Act 2002 (Qld) restricted to claims for personal injury, or does it also encompass claims for breach of implied terms in a labour hire agreement? The court concluded that s 16 of the Personal Injuries Proceeding Act 2002 (Qld) is not restricted to claims for personal injury and does encompass claims for breach of implied terms in a labour hire agreement.

6. In what circumstances can concurrent actions be maintained under the Personal Injuries Proceeding Act 2002 (Qld) and the WorkCover Queensland Act 1996 (Qld)? The court concluded that concurrent actions can be maintained under the Personal Injuries Proceeding Act 2002 (Qld) and the WorkCover Queensland Act 1996 (Qld) where they do not contradict each other and both are necessary to ensure the claimant receives appropriate compensation.

7. Was there an adequate explanation for the delay in giving written notice to the respondent, and was any prejudice suffered as a result of this delay? The court concluded that an adequate explanation was provided for the delay in giving written notice, and no prejudice was suffered as a result of this delay.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Ridley Agriproducts Pty Ltd v CMAs Consulting Pty Ltd, the court examined the applicability of s 16(2) of the Personal Injuries Proceeding Act 2002 (Qld) to a labour hire agency, CMAs Consulting Pty Ltd, which employed Edgar Balbarais, the claimant. The applicant, Ridley Agriproducts Pty Ltd, sought to join the labour hire agency as a contributor in a personal injury claim. The court considered whether the statutory provision permits such a joinder. It held that the statutory language of s 16(2) does not explicitly exclude a labour hire agency from being joined as a contributor, and thus allowed the joinder, finding that the statutory intent to facilitate comprehensive claims resolution supports this interpretation.

Further, the court addressed whether the respondent breached the implied conditions of the labour hire agreement by failing to provide labourers suitable to the position and by not informing the applicant of the claimant’s employment and medical history. The court applied the principles of implied terms in labour hire agreements, finding that the respondent had indeed breached the implied conditions. It relied on established case law which holds that labour hire agencies have a duty to provide suitable labourers and to share relevant information about the workers' history to ensure safe working conditions. The respondent's failure to do so was deemed a breach of the implied terms of the agreement.

Turning to the issue of indemnity by WorkCover Queensland under s 253 of the WorkCover Queensland Act 1996 (Qld), the court had to determine whether this provision prohibited a claim for contribution under the Personal Injuries Proceeding Act 2002. The court found that the indemnity provision did not preclude the claim for contribution, holding that the two statutory regimes address different aspects of the injury and are not mutually exclusive. This decision was based on the interpretation that indemnity by WorkCover is for compensation of the claimant, while contribution claims involve the allocation of liability among multiple parties.

The court then assessed whether a claim for breach of implied terms in a labour hire agreement constitutes a claim for damages “for personal injury” within the meaning of s 253 of the WorkCover Queensland Act 1996. The court concluded that such a claim does not fall within the definition of “personal injury” as it pertains to physical or psychiatric injuries caused by an accident arising out of or in the course of employment. Instead, it found that the breach of implied terms is a separate legal claim related to the contractual obligations of the labour hire agency.

Another key issue was whether s 16 of the Personal Injuries Proceeding Act 2002 is restricted to claims for personal injury or if it also encompasses claims for breach of implied terms in a labour hire agreement. The court held that s 16 is not limited to personal injury claims but includes any claim related to injuries that arise from the employment context, thereby permitting the joinder of the labour hire agency as a contributor in such claims.

In addressing the circumstances under which concurrent actions can be maintained under the Personal Injuries Proceeding Act 2002 and the WorkCover Queensland Act 1996, the court found that concurrent actions are permissible when the claims are distinct and pertain to different legal principles, as was the case here. The court emphasized the importance of allowing all relevant parties to be joined to ensure a comprehensive resolution of the issues.

Lastly, the court considered the delay in giving written notice to the respondent and whether there was an adequate explanation and whether any prejudice was suffered. The court found that the delay was adequately explained and that no prejudice resulted from the timing of the notice. The explanation provided by the applicant was deemed reasonable, and the respondent did not demonstrate any adverse impact due to the delay.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that s 16(2) of the Personal Injuries Proceeding Act 2002 permits a claimant to join a labour hire agency as a contributor in a personal injury claim, and such claims can proceed concurrently with WorkCover indemnity claims. Additionally, a breach of implied terms in a labour hire agreement constitutes a valid claim for contribution under the Personal Injuries Proceeding Act, distinct from claims for personal injury.