COURT OF APPEAL
THOMAS JA
Appeal No 265 of 2002
JOHN ALAN RIDDLE Respondent (Applicant)
and
JOHN LAWRENCE COFFEY Appellant (Respondent)
BRISBANE
..DATE 06/02/2002
JUDGMENT
HIS HONOUR: This is an application to stay a judgment pending appeal. The judgment in issue awarded $70,200 criminal compensation against the applicant (Mr Coffey) in favour of the respondent (Mr Riddle). Having read the material I must say that at first glance the judgment looks high. It is very close to the maximum amount that may be awarded despite an apportionment that was allowed for the respondent's contribution to the incident. Further, the injuries, whilst serious, are not of the kind or extent that necessarily suggest that a maximum award is appropriate. These, however, are only broad general observations.
So far as the viability of the appeal is concerned I am satisfied that there are matters capable of succeeding, although I express no opinion as to whether or not they will do so. I am also satisfied that if full payment were now made, and part of it is later found to be unnecessary, the applicant would have little chance of recovering it from the respondent.
The task at hand is to identify the level at which it may safely be thought that the respondent will hold the compensation. There is no doubt that he is entitled to some compensation.
The more arguable of the applicant's grounds, in my view, include the suggestion that there has been some overlapping of items of compensation. In particular, I note that items 9, 25 and 28 may be thought to have encompassed the same injury or injuries and that the cumulative award of such amounts may be contrary to section 26 subsection (1) of the Compensation of Victims Act.
It also may be arguable if the discretion has miscarried that the percentages awarded under some of the items were on the generous side. In other words, it is possible that some arguments on quantum may find favour.
So far as the apportionment is concerned, whilst apportionments are difficult to disturb it is by no means unarguable that 10 per cent is too low an apportionment on the facts that have been found.
There is one further point as to which I have some difficulty. It is submitted on behalf of the applicant that during the sentencing procedure the applicant's plea to grievous bodily harm was clearly confined to what was described as the head injury. The head injury would seem to be the result of three blows to the head with a cane knife and there is some difficulty in separating these three blows. There were, however, multiple other injuries to other parts of the body which were delivered in the course of the same confrontation between the two men.
The submission on behalf of the applicant is that the sentence ought to have been confined to the harm caused to the head and that in turn the compensation ought to be limited to…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Riddle v Coffey and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2002] QCA 22
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the Court included whether the award of compensation was excessive, whether there had been overlapping items of compensation, and whether the discretion exercised by the trial judge was miscarried. The Court considered whether there were arguable grounds for the appeal to succeed and whether the appellant would suffer significant prejudice if the stay was not granted. The Court also examined whether the compensation award should have been limited to the head injury, as argued by the appellant.
In granting a stay of the judgment, the Court found that there were arguable grounds for the appeal, particularly regarding the possibility of overlapping items of compensation and the appropriateness of the percentages awarded under some of the items. The Court was also mindful of the appellant's financial situation, which was less than the amount awarded. The Court determined that it was appropriate to stay the judgment in respect of any sum exceeding $25,000, to allow the appellant to avoid bankruptcy if a lesser amount was ultimately upheld.
The Court of Appeal granted a stay of the judgment in respect of any sum exceeding $25,000 and reserved the costs of the appeal to the Court of Appeal. This decision allowed the appellant to avoid potential financial ruin while providing an opportunity for the appeal to be heard and determined on its merits.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi