Ricky Whatmore v Uniting Care West

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read
[2022] FWC 3153

FAIR WORK COMMISSION

DECISION

Fair Work Act 2009

s.394—Unfair dismissal

Ricky Whatmore
v

Uniting Care West

(U2022/9176)

DEPUTY PRESIDENT BEAUMONT

PERTH, 2 DECEMBER 2022

Application for an unfair dismissal remedy – application pursuant to s 399A.

  1. On 12 September 2022, Mr Ricky Whatmore (the Applicant) made an unfair dismissal application to the Fair Work Commission under s 394 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (the Act) on the basis that he had been unfairly dismissed by Uniting Care West (the Respondent).

  1. Having been non-compliant with directions that issued on 3 November 2022, the Respondent applied to have the Applicant’s unfair dismissal application dismissed pursuant to s 399A of the Act.

  1. The exercise of the Commission’s powers under s 399A of the Act to dismiss an unfair dismissal application for the identified unreasonable conduct set out in subsections (a)-(c) involves the exercise of a broad discretion.[1] This type of matter involves two discretionary decisions. First, that the applicant has unreasonably failed to attend a conference or hearing, comply with a direction, or order, or discontinue the application after a settlement agreement has been concluded. Second, if the decision-maker is satisfied that the applicant has unreasonably failed to comply with one or more of their obligations referred to in subsection (b) of s 399A of the Act, the decision-maker has a further discretionary decision as to whether the unfair dismissal application should be dismissed.

  1. In this instance, I have decided to dismiss the Applicant’s unfair dismissal application under s 399A(1)(b) of the Act. My detailed reasons follow.

Background

  1. Directions were issued on 3 November 2022 for the filing of submissions, witness statements and any other documentary material.  The Applicant was directed that his materials were to be filed by no later than 4:00PM on Wednesday, 23 November 2022.

  1. It appears uncontroversial between the parties that Uniting Care West is a national system employer albeit given its status as a not-for-profit organisation, the parties were asked to address this point in the directions that issued on 3 November 2022, in addition to filing materials on merits and remedy.

  1. On 23 November 2022, Chamber received an email from the Applicant, time stamped 2:06PM in which the Applicant requested that the hearing date of 20 December 2022 be adjourned on the basis that he would not be in Perth at the time, as he would be working on that date.  The request for the adjournment was made on the same date as the Applicant’s materials fell due to be filed.  The Applicant’s email dated 23 November 2022, made no mention of extending the period in which his materials were to be filed.

  1. On 23 November 2022, Chambers sought the Respondent’s view of the Applicant’s request for an adjournment. On that same date, by email time stamped 6:14PM, the Respondent informed the Commission that it did not object to an adjournment of the proceedings but that the Applicant had failed to comply with the directions of 3 November 2022,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ricky Whatmore v Uniting Care West and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FWC 3153
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Ricky Whatmore has made an application to the Fair Work Commission for an unfair dismissal remedy. The application was made pursuant to s 394 of the Fair Work Act 2009. The application was against Uniting Care West, which Whatmore claimed had unfairly dismissed him. Uniting Care West applied to have the application dismissed. The application to dismiss was pursuant to s 399A of the Act. The exercise of the Commission’s power to dismiss an unfair dismissal application for unreasonable conduct involves the exercise of a broad discretion. The decision-maker must first be satisfied that the applicant has unreasonably failed to comply with the directions, orders, or a settlement agreement. If satisfied, the decision-maker has a further discretionary decision as to whether the unfair dismissal application should be dismissed. The Deputy President decided to dismiss Whatmore’s unfair dismissal application under s 399A(1)(b) of the Act. Whatmore’s non-compliance with the directions of 3 November 2022, and subsequent failure to file the requisite materials on an urgent basis, demonstrated that he had failed to prosecute his unfair dismissal application as required. Such conduct was objectively unsatisfactory. This is despite having been provided with time to respond to the various directions and prompts. The parties are entitled to have the matter heard quickly and as efficiently as possible. The Respondent’s preparation of its case is evidently dependent, to a significant extent, on the receipt of Whatmore’s submissions, evidence and documents. The Applicant has been provided with clear directions on what was required, the resources available and the timeframe in which materials were to be filed. His request for an adjournment of the hearing date was granted given his unavailability at the time of the listed hearing. However, whilst the adjournment was granted, an extension of time in which to file his materials was not granted. The Applicant details in his email dated 23 November 2022, that he was offered the new employment at the end of October 2022 and had to attend court to request to have his driver’s licence conditions changed – which took place on 14 November 2022. Whilst appreciative that his dismissal, obtaining a new job and attending at court may have proved stressful for Whatmore, the Deputy President did not consider that such events provided justification for his failure to file materials in support of his unfair dismissal application by 23 November 2022, some nine days after his court attendance. The object of Part 3-4 not only required the Deputy President to ensure that a ‘fair go all around’ was afforded to the employee, but also to the employer. It had been open to Whatmore to file his materials in respect of the merits of the matter on an urgent basis – even after the 23 November 2022 deadline. The Applicant has not done so and in this respect points to a level of confusion emanating from the directions issued, all of which set out clearly what was required of him. The Deputy President was satisfied that there had been non-compliance with directions of the Commission relating to the substantive application and that in all the circumstances such conduct had been unreasonable. The Applicant’s non-compliance with the directions of 3 November 2022 and absence of what the Deputy President considered to be cogent reasons for the same, in addition to his non-responsiveness to the directions issued on 25 November 2022 and 28 November 2022, in relation to filing materials on merits and remedy, led the Deputy President to the following conclusion. The Deputy President dismissed Whatmore’s unfair dismissal application. An Order dismissing the unfair dismissal application will be issued today. The application has been dealt with on the basis that the Respondent was a ‘national system employer’, given no argument was advanced by either party to the contrary.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established