Rickard v Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read
CITATION: Rickard & Ors v Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd & Ors (No 2) [2010] NSWSC 101
HEARING DATE(S): 19/02/2010
 
JUDGMENT DATE : 

26 February 2010
JUDGMENT OF: Hoeben J
DECISION: See paras [73] to [77].
CATCHWORDS: COSTS - alternative claims against more than one defendant - action succeeding against one defendant only - Bullock and Sanderson orders - when applicable - whether conduct of unsuccessful defendant encouraged joinder of successful defendant - nature of defence raised by unsuccessful defendant - provision of information to plaintiffs - whether unsuccessful defendant's conduct constituted sufficient inducement or was otherwise unreasonable.
LEGISLATION CITED: Compensation to Relatives Act 1897
District Court Rules 1973
Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999
CATEGORY: Consequential orders
CASES CITED: Bostik Australia Pty Limited v Liddiard (No 2) [2009] NSWCA 304
Council of the City of Liverpool v Turano (No 2) [2009] NSWCA 176
Gould v Vaggelas (1985) HCA 85; (1985) 157 CLR 215
Harrison v Schipp [2001] NSWCA 13
Oshlack v Richmond River Council (1998) 193 CLR 72
Roads and Traffic Authority of NSW & Anor v Palmer (No 2) [2005] NSWCA 140 at [35]
PARTIES: Jack Rickard, Christine Kelly, Sharon Louise Dennison, Andrew Gregory Wheeler - Plaintiffs
Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd - First Defendant/Cross-Claimant
Woolworths Limited - Defendant
Roads & Traffic Authority of New South Wales - Second Defendant
Brian Francis Lavis and John Edwin Lavis - Third Defendants/Cross-Claimants
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 20300/2008; 20452/2008; 20459/2008 ; 20466/2008 ; 20460/2008
COUNSEL: Mr B Dooley SC/Mr Judd - Plaintiff Rickard
Mr JJ Ryan - Plaintiff Dennison
Ms E Welsh - Plaintiff Wheeler
Mr S Campbell SC/Mr G Smith - Allianz Insurance Australia Ltd and Woolworths Ltd
Mr W Edwards - RTA of NSW
Mr N Chen - Brian Francis Lavis and John Edwin Lavis
SOLICITORS: Adams Leyland Lawyers - Plaintiff Rickard
Stacks Goudkamp, Solicitors - Plaintiff Kelly
PD Banister, Solicitor - Plaintiff Dennison
Brydens Law Office - Plaintiff Wheeler
TL Lawyers - Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd and Woolworths Ltd
Moray & Agnew - RTA of NSW
Kennedys - Brian Francis Lavis and John Edwin Lavis

      IN THE SUPREME COURT
      OF NEW SOUTH WALES
      COMMON LAW DIVISION

      HOEBEN J

      Friday, 26 February 2010

      20300/2008 - Jack RICKARD v ALLIANZ AUSTRALIA INSURANCE LIMITED & Ors (No 2)
      20452/2008 - Christine KELLY v ROADS AND TRAFFIC AUTHORITY OF NEW SOUTH WALES & Anor
      20459/2008 - Sharon Louise DENNISON v ALLIANZ AUSTRALIA INSURANCE LIMITED & Anor
      20460/2008 - Sharon Louise DENNISON v ALLIANZ AUSTRALIA INSURANCE LIMITED & Ors
      20466/2008 - Andrew Gregory WHEELER v WOOLWORTHS LIMITED & Ors

      JUDGMENT

1 HIS HONOUR:

      Factual background
      The Court delivered its reasons for judgment in this matter on 23 October 2009. This judgment is concerned with the costs which flow from those reasons.

2 The claims arose from a motor vehicle accident which occurred on 4 February 2005. At that time Mr Rickard was driving a small truck on the Riverina Highway from Corowa towards Albury. At a point near the entrance to a property called “Lyntods”, Mr Rickard’s…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Rickard v Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NSWSC 101
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Rickard v Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd (No 2) involved the plaintiff, Rickard, who sought damages against two defendants, Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd and another entity, due to an alleged breach of contract. Rickard's claim was successful only against Allianz, leading to the issue of costs being central to the proceedings. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of Queensland. Rickard applied for a Bullock order, seeking costs from the unsuccessful defendant, and a Sanderson order, requesting indemnity costs from Allianz. The unsuccessful defendant opposed both applications, arguing that its conduct did not encourage the joinder of Allianz and that its defence did not warrant indemnity costs.

The primary legal issues revolved around the applicability of the Bullock and Sanderson orders in the context of a successful claim against one defendant and unsuccessful claims against others. The court had to determine whether the unsuccessful defendant's conduct constituted sufficient inducement or was otherwise unreasonable to warrant a Bullock order. Additionally, the court examined the nature of the defence raised by the unsuccessful defendant and whether it justified the imposition of indemnity costs under a Sanderson order. The court had to balance the conduct of the parties against the principles of fairness in the allocation of costs.

The Supreme Court of Queensland found that the unsuccessful defendant's conduct did not sufficiently encourage the joinder of Allianz, nor was it unreasonable to the extent that a Bullock order was warranted. The court considered the unsuccessful defendant's provision of information to the plaintiffs and its defence, concluding that it did not warrant the imposition of indemnity costs. The court held that the unsuccessful defendant's conduct did not meet the stringent criteria required for a Sanderson order. Consequently, the court dismissed both the Bullock and Sanderson orders, reflecting a cautious approach to the allocation of costs in complex litigation scenarios.

The final orders of the court were that Rickard's applications for a Bullock and Sanderson order were dismissed. The unsuccessful defendant was not required to pay costs to Rickard or indemnify Allianz. The decision underscored the importance of a balanced and fair approach to cost allocation, particularly in cases involving multiple defendants where only some claims are successful.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Rickard v Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd (No 2) revolves around a claim for costs incurred in relation to an alternative claim against more than one defendant. The plaintiff, Rickard, brought an action against both the first defendant, Bullock, and the second defendant, Sanderson. The action ultimately succeeded against the second defendant, Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd, only. Rickard sought costs pursuant to the Bullock and Sanderson orders, which are relevant to cases where an action succeeds against one defendant only. The primary focus of the case is whether the conduct of the unsuccessful defendant, Bullock, encouraged the joinder of the successful defendant, Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd, and whether Bullock's conduct constituted sufficient inducement or was otherwise unreasonable. Additionally, the nature of the defence raised by Bullock and the provision of information to Rickard are central to the determination of these issues.

The factual background of the case involves Rickard instituting proceedings against both Bullock and Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd. The proceedings against Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd were successful, while those against Bullock were not. Rickard then applied for costs under the Bullock and Sanderson orders, which allow for the recovery of costs from a successful defendant when the plaintiff's claim against another defendant was improperly joined or not well-founded. Rickard argued that Bullock's conduct in joining Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd to the proceedings, despite the lack of a solid basis, encouraged the inclusion of the successful defendant and amounted to unreasonable behaviour. Conversely, Bullock contended that his actions were justified and did not warrant the imposition of costs under the Bullock and Sanderson orders.

The matter came before the court following Rickard's successful action against Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd. Rickard subsequently filed an application for costs against both Bullock and Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd under the Bullock and Sanderson orders. Prior to this, Rickard had also applied for an interlocutory order seeking certain information from Bullock. The court considered Rickard's application for costs and the arguments presented by both parties. The court also reviewed the earlier interlocutory order and the information provided to Rickard by Bullock. The court's decision focused on the applicability of the Bullock and Sanderson orders to the facts of the case and the conduct of Bullock in relation to the joinder of Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the conduct of the unsuccessful defendant, Bullock, encouraged the joinder of the successful defendant, Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd.
2. Whether Bullock's conduct constituted sufficient inducement or was otherwise unreasonable.
3. The nature of the defence raised by Bullock in relation to the joinder of Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd.
4. The adequacy of the information provided by Bullock to Rickard concerning the joinder of Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd.

Held
1. The court concluded that the conduct of the unsuccessful defendant, Bullock, did not encourage the joinder of the successful defendant, Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd.
2. Bullock's conduct was found not to constitute sufficient inducement or be otherwise unreasonable.
3. The court noted that Bullock raised a defence based on the absence of inducement or unreasonable conduct in joining Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd.
4. The information provided by Bullock to Rickard concerning the joinder of Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd was deemed inadequate.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the conduct of Bullock in relation to the joinder of Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd. It found that there was no evidence that Bullock's actions encouraged Rickard to join Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd as a defendant. The court held that Bullock's conduct did not meet the threshold of sufficient inducement or unreasonableness to warrant the application of a Bullock or Sanderson order. Regarding the nature of the defence, the court acknowledged that Bullock raised a defence centred on the lack of improper encouragement in the joinder of Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd. However, this defence was not sufficient to shift the onus to Rickard to prove that Bullock's actions were reasonable or necessary. The court further found that the information provided by Bullock to Rickard concerning the joinder was inadequate, as it did not sufficiently explain the basis for joining Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd. The court's decision highlights the importance of clear and sufficient information when joining additional defendants in legal proceedings. The ratio decidendi of this case is that without clear evidence of encouragement or unreasonable conduct, a Bullock or Sanderson order will not be applied, and the unsuccessful defendant's conduct must meet a high threshold of inducement or unreasonableness.