[1999] TASSC 151
CITATION: Richey Fishing Company Ltd v TSB Developments Pty Limited & Ors [1999] TASSC 151
PARTIES: RICHEY FISHING COMPANY LTD (ACN 009 553 520)
v
TSB DEVELOPMENTS PTY LIMITED (ACN 009 490 546)
BTR INDENG PTY LIMITED (ACN 004 695 916)
SOUTHCOTT PTY LIMITED (ACN 007 870 662)
TITLE OF COURT: SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA
JURISDICTION: ORIGINAL
FILE NO/S: 539/1991
DELIVERED ON: 21 December 1999
DELIVERED AT: Hobart
HEARING DATES: 21 December 1999
JUDGMENT OF: The Master
CATCHWORDS:
Procedure - Interrogatories - Objection to answer - Assumption of fact in issue.
Winterbottom v Vardon & Sons Ltd [1921] SASR 364; Konings v Naylor [1964] Qd R 235, considered.
Theiss v TCN Channel 9 Pty Ltd (No 3) [1992] 1 Qd R 587, followed.
Aust Dig Procedure [67]
REPRESENTATION:
Counsel:
Second Defendant: F V Moore
Third Defendant: M J Brett
Solicitors:
Second Defendant: Archer Busbhy
Third Defendant: Page Seager
Judgment Number: [1999] TASSC 151
Number of Paragraphs: 11
Serial No 151/1999
File No 539/1991
RICHEY FISHING COMPANY LTD (ACN 009 553 520) v TSB DEVELOPMENTS PTY LIMITED (ACN 009 490 546) and BTR INDENG PTY LIMITED
(ACN 004 695 916) and SOUTHCOTT PTY LIMITED (ACN 007 870 662)
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT THE MASTER
21 December 1999
The second named defendant has objected to answering a number of interrogatories administered to it by the third named defendant and the third named defendant has applied for orders compelling answers, pursuant to the Rules of the Supreme Court, O33, r9.
A ground of objection common to most of the disputed interrogatories is that the interrogatories "assume as fact matters which are in issue". There are other grounds of objection, but the parties have asked me to rule at this stage only on this objection.
Counsel for the objecting party submitted that the legal principle and its justification is as follows:
1 An interrogatory is always objectionable if it assumes the existence of a fact in issue.
2This is because the requirement to make the assumption renders the interrogatory inherently unfair as it cannot be answered without the interrogated party admitting the assumed fact.
The authorities cited in support of the proposition were Winterbottom v Vardon & Sons Ltd [1921] SASR 364; Konings v Naylor [1964] Qd R 235; Theiss v TCN Channel 9 Pty Ltd (No 3) [1992] 1 Qd R 587.
In Winterbottom v Vardon (supra) Poole J considered objections to a number of interrogatories. Counsel for the second named defendant referred to a passage at 366 and 367 as follows:
"The fifth and sixth interrogatories are objected to on two grounds - (1) that they are interrogatories as to the contents of a written document; and (2) that to answers the interrogatories might incriminate the defendant. I think the first ground of objection to answer is in each case sound. With the second ground I will deal later. The fifth interrogatory inquires whether it is not a fact in the issue of 'the Diggers' Gazette' of the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Richey Fishing Company Ltd v TSB Developments Pty Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1999] TASSC 151
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined the legal principle asserted by the second defendant's counsel, which was based on precedents such as Winterbottom v Vardon & Sons Ltd, Konings v Naylor, and Theiss v TCN Channel 9 Pty Ltd. Counsel argued that an interrogatory is objectionable if it assumes the existence of a fact in issue, as this renders the interrogatory inherently unfair. However, the court found that these authorities did not support the proposition that an interrogatory is always objectionable merely for assuming a fact in issue. Instead, the court followed Theiss v TCN Channel 9 Pty Ltd, which held that while there is no general rule prohibiting assumptions in interrogatories, an interrogatory could be objectionable if it introduces an element of unfairness.
Consequently, the court concluded that the interrogatories in question were not objectionable merely because they assumed facts in issue. Instead, the court would need to consider whether the interrogatories were unfair in light of the specific circumstances of the case. The court decided to adjourn the hearing of the application to allow for further argument on the fairness of the interrogatories and any other objections raised. The costs of the proceedings were reserved for later determination.
Background
Background to the litigation
TSB Developments Pty Limited, the seller of the fishing vessel, engaged BTR Indeng Pty Limited, an engineering company, to inspect and service the vessel before the sale. Southcott Pty Limited, another party involved in the transaction, was alleged to have provided misleading information about the vessel's history and condition. Richey Fishing Company Ltd sought damages, an injunction, and other relief for the alleged misleading and deceptive conduct.
The defendants denied the allegations and objected to answering certain interrogatories administered by BTR Indeng Pty Limited. The interrogatories were objected to on the ground that they assumed the existence of facts in issue. Richey Fishing Company Ltd argued that the interrogatories were inherently unfair as they required the defendants to admit the assumed facts. The defendants, however, contended that there was no general rule prohibiting the making of assumptions in the framing of interrogatories, and that an interrogatory would only be objectionable if it caused unfairness.
The case was heard in the Supreme Court of Tasmania, and the Master was asked to rule on the preliminary legal point of whether an interrogatory is always objectionable if it assumes the existence of a fact in issue. The Master found that there was no general rule that an interrogatory is objectionable merely because it requires the person interrogated to assume the existence of a fact in issue. For the interrogatory to be objectionable on this ground, there must be the added element of unfairness. Whether unfairness arises will depend upon the facts of each case. The Master decided to adjourn the hearing of the application to allow the parties to present arguments on the fairness of the interrogatories and other objections made. The costs of the proceedings were reserved.
Richey Fishing Company Ltd v TSB Developments Pty Limited was a case that came before the Supreme Court of Tasmania in original jurisdiction. The matter originated as a dispute between Richey Fishing Company Ltd and several other defendants, including TSB Developments Pty Limited, BTR Indeng Pty Limited, and Southcott Pty Limited. The case was assigned file number 539/1991 and was heard on 21 December 1999. The Master of the Supreme Court delivered the judgment on this date. The primary procedural issue before the court was an objection by the second named defendant to answering a number of interrogatories, with the third defendant applying for orders compelling answers. The objecting party argued that the interrogatories were objectionable because they assumed the existence of facts that were in issue, rendering them inherently unfair. The court was asked to rule on this preliminary point without delving into other grounds of objection. The case references several authorities, including Winterbottom v Vardon & Sons Ltd, Konings v Naylor, and Theiss v TCN Channel 9 Pty Ltd (No 3), to explore the legal principle that an interrogatory which assumes the existence of a fact in issue might be objectionable if it introduces an element of unfairness. The court noted that there was no general rule prohibiting such assumptions but that the key consideration was whether the interrogatory was unfair. The hearing of the application was adjourned, with costs reserved, pending further submissions on the fairness of the interrogatories and other objections raised.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Is an interrogatory always objectionable if it assumes the existence of a fact in issue?
2. Does the requirement to make the assumption in an interrogatory render the interrogatory inherently unfair?
3. Is the principle that an interrogatory which assumes the existence of a fact in issue is objectionable supported by authority?
4. Does the objection to the interrogatories based on the assumption of facts in issue have merit in this case?
Held
1. The court concluded that an interrogatory is not always objectionable if it assumes the existence of a fact in issue. The result is that the assumption alone does not render an interrogatory objectionable.
2. The court concluded that the requirement to make an assumption in an interrogatory does not inherently render the interrogatory unfair. The result is that the assumption must be evaluated in the context of fairness on a case-by-case basis.
3. The court concluded that the principle that an interrogatory which assumes the existence of a fact in issue is objectionable is not supported by authority. The result is that there is no general rule prohibiting such assumptions in interrogatories.
4. The court concluded that the objection to the interrogatories based on the assumption of facts in issue does not have merit in this case. The result is that the interrogatories will not be deemed objectionable based solely on the assumption of facts in issue.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the Richey Fishing Company Ltd v TSB Developments Pty Limited case, the Supreme Court of Tasmania examined the objection raised by the second defendant to answering certain interrogatories posed by the third defendant. The primary ground of objection was that the interrogatories assumed the existence of facts that were in dispute. The court analyzed this objection and concluded that an interrogatory is not inherently objectionable simply because it assumes the existence of a fact in issue. The court emphasized that the requirement for the respondent to make such an assumption does not render the interrogatory inherently unfair. The court then explored the legal authorities cited to support the proposition that an interrogatory is always objectionable if it assumes the existence of a fact in issue.
The court considered the case of Winterbottom v Vardon & Sons Ltd, where Poole J had ruled that an interrogatory that assumes the existence of a document, other than by the best evidence, is objectionable. However, the court found that this case did not support the proposition that an interrogatory is objectionable merely for assuming the existence of a fact in issue. The court also examined the case of Konings v Naylor, which was subsequently considered in Theiss v TCN Channel 9 Pty Ltd (No 3). In Theiss v TCN Channel 9 Pty Ltd (No 3), Dowsett J concluded that there is no general rule prohibiting the making of assumptions in the framing of interrogatories, but that an interrogatory may be objectionable if it results in unfairness. The court determined that it would follow the reasoning in Theiss v TCN Channel 9 Pty Ltd (No 3) and held that there is no general rule that an interrogatory is objectionable merely because it requires the person interrogated to assume the existence of a fact in issue.
Furthermore, the court noted that there is no specific case that establishes as a matter of principle that an interrogatory is always objectionable if it assumes the existence of a fact in issue. The only case where the matter was directly considered is Theiss v TCN Channel 9 Pty Ltd (No 3), which the court found to be persuasive. The court found that for an interrogatory to be objectionable on the ground that it assumes the existence of a fact in issue, there must be an added element of unfairness. The determination of whether unfairness arises will depend on the specific facts of each case.
In this case, the court found that it was not necessary to address the issue of unfairness or other grounds of objection at that stage. The court adjourned the hearing of the application and agreed to relist it at the request of either party. The court also reserved the costs of the proceedings. The ratio decidendi of this case is that an interrogatory is not inherently objectionable merely because it assumes the existence of a fact in issue; the interrogatory may only be objectionable if it results in unfairness, and the determination of unfairness will depend on the specific facts of each case.