RICHARDSON and CITY OF SWAN

Link copied
Case Copied 53 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

ACT: PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)

CITATION:   RICHARDSON and CITY OF SWAN [2024] WASAT 12

MEMBER:   MS R LAVERY, MEMBER

HEARD:   16 AND 17 MAY 2023

WRITTEN SUBMISSIONS DATED 2 OCTOBER 2023, 3 OCTOBER 2023 AND 29 NOVEMBER 2023

DELIVERED          :   27 FEBRUARY 2024

FILE NO/S:   DR 184 of 2021

BETWEEN:   DANIEL RICHARDSON

Applicant

AND

CITY OF SWAN

Respondent


Catchwords:

Town planning - Development application - Conditions of approval relating to secondary street fence, a balcony and appurtenant French doors - State heritage significance - Contributory building in State heritage listed Guildford Historical Townsite - Local heritage significance - Whether proposed black iron spears in the Hubert Street fence should be approved - Whether the proposed rear balcony and appurtenant French doors should be approved - Cultural heritage significance considerations - Streetscape, character and amenity

Legislation:

City of Swan Local Heritage Inventory 2022
City of Swan Local Planning Scheme No. 17, cl 1.6, cl 2.1, cl 4.2.7, cl 7.2A.1
City of Swan Local Planning Strategy, cl 1.6
City of Swan Town Planning Scheme No. 9
Heritage Act 2018 (WA), s 3, s 73
Local Government (Administration) Regulations 1996 (WA), reg 10
Local Government Act 1995 (WA), s 5.25(1)(e)
Metropolitan Region Scheme
Planning and Development (Local Planning Schemes) Regulations 2015 (WA), Sch 2, cl 1A, cl 7, cl 8(1), cl 61, cl 67(2), cl 67(2)(a), cl 67(2)(b), cl 67(2)(c), cl 67(2)(fa), cl 67(2)(g), cl 67(2)(k), cl 67(2)(l), cl 67(2)(m), cl 67(2)(n), cl 67(2)(y), cl 67(2)(zb), cl 77, cl 87, Pt 2, cl 4(3)
Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), s 241(1)(a), s 241(2), s 242, s 252, s 252(1)
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 27(2), s 27(3), s 31(1)
Town Planning and Development Act 1928 (WA) (repealed), s 8A

Result:

Part 1 of the respondent's decision is set aside and a decision is substituted that refuses the Hubert Street fence and approves the remainder of amendments dealt with by part 1
Part 2 of the decision of the respondent is affirmed

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicant : Ms D Mrdja
Respondent : CA Slarke

Solicitors:

Applicant : Urbanista Planning
Respondent : McLeods

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Clive Elliot Jennings & Co Pty Ltd v Western Australian Planning Commission [2002] WASCA 276; (2002) 122 LGERA 433

Harper Investments WA Pty Ltd and Presiding Member of the Metro Inner North Joint Development Assessment Panel [2023] WASAT 130

Kaard and City of Nedlands [2005] WASAT 2

Koltasz Smith & Partners v Western Australian Planning Commission (2000) 23 SR (WA) 266

Marshall v Metropolitan Redevelopment Authority [2015] WASC 226

Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) [1979] 2 ALD 634

Richardson and City of Swan [2022] WASAT 17

REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL:

Introduction

  1. Mr Daniel Richardson (applicant) seeks review by the Tribunal under s 252(1) of the Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA) (PD Act) of the decision of the City of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read RICHARDSON and CITY OF SWAN and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] WASAT 12
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Richardson, the applicant, sought approval from the City of Swan for a development application concerning a secondary street fence, a balcony, and appurtenant French doors on a property within the Guildford Historical Townsite. The property is a contributory building of State heritage significance, and the proposed alterations, including the design of the fence and balcony, were subject to scrutiny due to their potential impact on the local and cultural heritage values of the area. The City of Swan's decision to reject the application was appealed by the applicant, leading to a review by the State Administrative Tribunal.

The central legal issues addressed by the Tribunal involved the assessment of the proposed alterations in light of the cultural heritage significance of the site, the streetscape, character, and amenity of Hubert Street, and the relevant State Planning Policy (SPP) 3.5 and Guildford-Mandoon Heritage Area Local Planning Policy. Specifically, the Tribunal had to decide whether the condition requiring the deletion of the proposed black iron spears in the Hubert Street fence should be upheld and whether the proposed rear balcony and French doors should be approved. The decision hinged on balancing the proposed development with the need to conserve and respect the heritage significance of the area.

The Tribunal examined the cultural heritage significance of the property and its setting, the structural integrity of the building, and the proposed measures to conserve its heritage significance. It also considered the aesthetic impact of the proposed modifications on the streetscape and the overall character of Hubert Street. The Tribunal concluded that the proposed alterations, particularly the design of the fence and the balcony, did not sufficiently respect the heritage significance of the area. It found that the proposed black iron spears in the fence and the balcony with French doors would adversely affect the cultural heritage significance and streetscape of the area. Therefore, the Tribunal upheld the City of Swan's decision to reject the development application.

The Tribunal's decision was that the proposed alterations to the property did not align with the objectives of the Heritage Act and the relevant planning policies. Consequently, the development application was dismissed, and the proposed modifications were not approved. The Tribunal's ruling emphasized the importance of conserving the heritage significance of the Guildford Historical Townsite and maintaining the aesthetic integrity of Hubert Street.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Section 6.5 of SPP 3.5 provides the specific matters that should be considered in assessing an application for approval to demolish a heritage place as:Alterations, extensions, change of use or demolition affecting a heritage place (including a place within a heritage area)•The level of heritage significance of the place, based on a relevant heritage assessment. •Measures proposed to conserve the heritage significance of the place and its setting. •The structural condition of the place, and whether the place is reasonably capable of conservation. •Whether the place is capable of adaptation to a new use which will enable its retention and conservation.[11][11] Respondent's s 24 Bundle of Documents Tab 8, pages 262 – 267 – SPP 3.5, s 6.5, Western Australian, Government Gazette, No. 112 (29 May 2007), page 2481. Development control principles are set out in s 6.6 of SPP 3.5. With respect to development within a heritage area it provides:•Alterations and additions to existing buildings should be designed and sited in a manner that respects and complements the heritage significance of the area. The subject land is within the Guildford Historic Town (Place Number 02915), which is included in the State Register of Heritage Places kept pursuant to the Heritage Act. Under cl 241(2) of the PD Act the Tribunal is to refer an application for review to the Heritage Council for advice, receive and hear submissions, and have due regard to the objects of the Heritage Act as follows:(2)In the case of an application that relates to land to which the Heritage Act 2018 applies, and whether or not a State planning policy provides for the conservation of that land, the State Administrative Tribunal — (a)is to refer the matter to the Heritage Council for advice; and(b)may receive and hear submissions made on behalf of the Heritage Council; and(c)may join the Heritage Council as a party to the application; and(d)is to have due regard to the objects of the Heritage Act 2018. The Objectives of the Heritage Act as stated in s 3 are:3.ObjectivesThe objectives of this Act are, with due regard for the rights of property ownership — (a)to promote understanding and appreciation of Western Australia's cultural heritage; and(b)to recognise the importance of places of cultural heritage significance and their stories in understanding the course of Western Australia's history; and(c)to provide for the identification and documentation of Western Australia's places of cultural heritage significance; and(d)to encourage and facilitate the conservation, continuing use, development and adaptive reuse of places of cultural heritage significance in ways that represent high standards of heritage conservation and are in harmony with cultural heritage values. The issues for determination in this case as agreed by the parties are:(1)In regard to the approval of the Hubert Street fence, should condition 1 of part 1 be deleted in order for the proposed black iron spears in the Hubert Street fence to be approved; and(2)In regard to part 2, should the proposed rear balcony and appurtenant French doors be approved.having regard to:(a)cultural heritage significance considerations;(b)the streetscape, character and amenity of Hubert Street;(c)SPP 3.5; and(d)the Guildford-Mandoon Heritage Area Local Planning Policy.