Richard Fraser v Martin Kingham

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

C A T C H W O R D S

Amalgamated union - express provisions in rules re "transitional period" - rule to show cause - whether power under rules to abolish the offices of full-time elected organisers - whether rules authorise an alteration to rules that would abolish offices of organisers during "transitional period" - whether such a rule would impose on members conditions, obligations or restrictions that are oppressive, unreasonable or unjust - whether organisers hold "office" within s.4, Industrial Relations Act 1988 (Cth)

Industrial Relations Act 1988 (Cth) - ss. 4, 195 and 196

Roughan v. A.M.I.E.U. (1992) 36 FCR 536

RICHARD FRASER v. MARTIN KINGHAM & OTHERS
No. VI 1070 of 1994

KEELY J.
MELBOURNE
28 October 1994

IN THE INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COURT )
  )
OF AUSTRALIA  )                  No. VI 1070 of 1994
  )
VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY  )

B E T W E E N :

RICHARD FRASER
  Applicant

- and -

MARTIN KINGHAM, VINCE RAFFA, BILL OLIVER, RAY CARTER,
     DEREK CAFFERTY, PETER GRUNDY, WAYNE TORPY, DIRK VAN DAM,
            VICTOR NICOLI, BERNARD GIAGNACOVA, GERARD LAVERY,
  ROY WILLIAMS, FRANK O'GRADY, MALCOLM RATEL, JOHN McPARTLIN,
         PATRICK LENNON, DAVID NOONAN, JOHN LOH, DAVID PILLAR,
     JOHN CANNING, ZELKO PRAZAK, MALCOLM NEWHAM, K. HUGHES,
        M. GARCIA, P. BOYLE, M. EVANS, J. SUTTON, L. FRASER, C. BATES,
        T. BURKE, W. TROHEAR, M. CORDWELL, B. CARSLAKE, G. WASON,
      D. MATTHEWS, A. RANKIN, T. CARROLL, K. REYNOLDS, A. LITTLER,
      W. ETHELL, P. WATERS, V. FITZGERALD, S. SHARKEY, J. MAITLAND,
           T. SMITH, T. MAHER, C. NORTHOVER, M. O'CONNOR, F. WILKS,
    F. HAWKINS, J. McGIRR, G. McARTHUR, O. COOK, G. HILLIER, G. SHAW,
     S. MURPHY, R. JUDD, E. BUTCHER, R. LAND, P. NEILSON, B. WATSON,
            L. MOORE, D. BEAN, G. WOOD, B. O'NEIL, G. CHILDS, G. BETTS,
  J. VAN CAMP, M. GREY, G. DAY, D. McINTYRE, S. WALES, V. ROBERTSON,
  D. FRATER, L. KYRIACOU and A. FINLAY
  Respondents

CORAM:      Keely J.
PLACE:         Melbourne
DATE:           28 October 1994

IN THE INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COURT )
  )
OF AUSTRALIA  )                  No. VI 1070 of 1994
  )
VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY  )

B E T W E E N :

RICHARD FRASER
  Applicant

- and -

MARTIN KINGHAM, VINCE RAFFA, BILL OLIVER, RAY CARTER,
     DEREK CAFFERTY, PETER GRUNDY, WAYNE TORPY, DIRK VAN DAM,
            VICTOR NICOLI, BERNARD GIAGNACOVA, GERARD LAVERY,
  ROY WILLIAMS, FRANK O'GRADY, MALCOLM RATEL, JOHN McPARTLIN,
         PATRICK LENNON, DAVID NOONAN, JOHN LOH, DAVID PILLAR,
     JOHN CANNING, ZELKO PRAZAK, MALCOLM NEWHAM, K. HUGHES,
        M. GARCIA, P. BOYLE, M. EVANS, J. SUTTON, L. FRASER, C. BATES,
        T. BURKE, W. TROHEAR, M. CORDWELL, B. CARSLAKE, G. WASON,
      D. MATTHEWS, A. RANKIN, T. CARROLL, K. REYNOLDS, A. LITTLER,
      W. ETHELL, P. WATERS, V. FITZGERALD, S. SHARKEY, J. MAITLAND,
           T. SMITH, T. MAHER, C. NORTHOVER, M. O'CONNOR, F. WILKS,
    F. HAWKINS, J. McGIRR, G. McARTHUR, O. COOK, G. HILLIER, G. SHAW,
     S. MURPHY, R. JUDD, E. BUTCHER, R. LAND, P. NEILSON, B. WATSON,
            L. MOORE, D. BEAN, G. WOOD, B. O'NEIL, G. CHILDS, G. BETTS,
  J. VAN CAMP, M. GREY, G. DAY,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Richard Fraser v Martin Kingham and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1994] IRCA 92
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Industrial Relations Court of Australia, Richard Fraser, an applicant, filed a case against Martin Kingham and others, respondents, regarding the abolition of the offices of full-time elected organisers. The court had to decide whether the rules of the union authorized the alteration of rules that would abolish the offices of organisers during a "transitional period." The court also had to determine whether such a rule would impose on members conditions, obligations, or restrictions that are oppressive, unreasonable, or unjust. Additionally, the court had to determine whether the organisers held an "office" within the meaning of section 4 of the Industrial Relations Act 1988 (Cth). After considering the parties' submissions, the court concluded that there was no power to make the decisions challenged by the applicant. The court also found that the three organisers were not "holders of office" within the meaning of the definition in s.4 of the Act. The court further held that the power to alter rules must be construed as not authorising any rule-making body to repeal the special provisions contained in National rule 42. The court accepted the submission by the applicants' counsel that the power to alter rules, whether conferred by National rules 15 and 25 or by the rules of the Building Unions Division and Building Unions Divisional Branches, must be read as being subject to a limitation. The limitation is that, during the period dealt with in the "Transitional Provisions" in National rule 42, the rules can not be altered in such a way as to repeal the express provisions contained in rule 42 or to abolish the offices of the three organisers. The court also held that, in its view, any such repeal of provisions in National rule 42, or abolition of the offices of the three organisers, would also be contrary to the whole spirit of the legislative scheme in Division 7 of Part IX of the Act. The court concluded that the rules conferring the general power to alter rules should be construed as not authorising an alteration of the rules that would abolish those offices during the transitional period. The court further held that, if there be any doubt as to the meaning of the rule-making power, it should be construed as not authorizing an alteration of the rules that would abolish those offices during the transitional period. The court also held that, if the power under the rules to alter the rules were to be construed as conferring power to abolish those offices, then the rules conferring that power would themselves be contrary to s.196(c) of the Act, as being rules which, if so construed, would "impose on members conditions, obligations or restrictions that, having regard to the objects of [the] Act and the purposes of the registration of organisations... are unreasonable [and] unjust" (s.196(c)). The court ordered that the respondents, other than Mr D. Cafferty, be ordered to perform and observe the rules of the Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union by permitting and taking all steps to ensure that the applicant and Terrence Edema and Darren Moule (the three organisers) are able to fully perform the duties and functions of their offices as organisers in the Building Unions Division, Victorian Divisional Branch of the union in accordance with the rules. The court also ordered that the respondents refrain from purporting to amend the rules of the union to abolish the office of any of the three organisers with effect from any date earlier than 2 January 1997.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

KEELY J

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: KEELY J

Full text does not contain this section.