Richani v Martins Plaza Shopping Centre Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Court of Appeal: Civil)

RICHANI v MARTINS PLAZA SHOPPING CENTRE PTY LTD

[2022] SASCA 80

Judgment of the Honourable Justice Bleby (ex tempore)

28 July 2022

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - PROCEDURE - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - SECURITY FOR COSTS

Application for security for costs.

The appellant is appealing against a decision of a single judge of this Court, granting the respondent’s application for summary judgement on the appellant’s claim.

This is an application for security for costs by the respondent. The respondent seeks an order that the appellant is to provide security for costs in the sum of $20,000, and that the appeal be stayed until the appellant provides that security.

Held, per Bleby JA: granting the application for security for costs:

1.The risk of impecuniosity of the appellant and the relatively low prospects of success on the appeal speak in favour of making an order for security for costs.

2.The appellant is to provide security for costs by payment of $15,000 into Court as security for costs.

3.      The appeal is stayed until security in that sum is provided by the appellant.

4.In the event security is not paid within 21 days, the respondent has liberty to apply for summary dismissal of the appeal.

Limitation of Actions Act 1936 (SA) s 32(1); Uniform Civil Rules 2020 (SA) r 215.1, 215.3, 115.1(1)(e), referred to.
Draoui v Lee & Ors [2020] SASC 155; Viscariello v Livesey [2013] SASC 198; Watson v Anderson (1976) 13 SASR 329; Nanosecond Corporation v Glen Carron Pty Ltd [2019] SASC 124; Melunu Pty Ltd v Claron Constructions Pty Ltd [2004] NSWSC 1064, considered.

RICHANI v MARTINS PLAZA SHOPPING CENTRE PTY LTD

[2022] SASCA 80

Court of Appeal - Civil

  1. BLEBY JA:     This is an application for security for costs. The respondent, which is the Trustee of the Martins Plaza Trust (a unit trust), has applied for an order that the appellant is to provide security for costs in the sum of $20,000 and that the appeal be stayed until the appellant provides that security. The appeal is against a decision granting the respondent’s application for summary judgment on the appellant’s claim.

  2. In 1999, the appellant and two other people were the original directors of the respondent. The respondent purchased land at Parafield Gardens to develop a shopping centre. This development was the appellant’s conception. He drove the project.

  3. The project attracted some 15 or 16 further investors. Each obtained a share in the respondent and each was allocated units in the unit trust. Investors obtained 50,000 units each at the price of $1 per unit. The appellant and his wife received 100,000 units for no consideration, in recognition of the appellant’s efforts in driving the project. The appellant and his wife held their units as trustees of the Richani Family Trust.

  4. The development project was successful. Trading at the shopping centre commenced in early 2001. On about 1 July 2001, the appellant and his wife sold…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Richani v Martins Plaza Shopping Centre Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] SASCA 80
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by the appellant, Mr Richani, against Martins Plaza Shopping Centre Pty Ltd. The dispute arose in the context of an application for security for costs made by the respondent. The court was required to determine whether to order the appellant to provide security for the respondent's costs of the appeal.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the appellant's prospects of success on appeal were low, and whether the appellant's financial circumstances warranted an order for security for costs, despite the potential for such an order to stifle the appeal. The court also considered whether the appeal raised any issue of general legal importance and the appellant's residency within the state.

The court reasoned that the appellant's affidavit evidence regarding his financial position was insufficient to explain his assertion of "limited financial means," particularly given that beneficiaries of the Richani Family Trust stood to benefit from the litigation. Coupled with the lack of explanation for his financial situation over the past 20 years, the court found the prospects of success on appeal to be low. While acknowledging that an order for security could bring the appeal to an end, the court gave little weight to the appellant's residency within the state due to his effective impecuniosity.

Ultimately, the court concluded that the risk of impecuniosity and the low prospects of success favoured making an order for security for costs. The court ordered the appellant to provide security for costs in the amount of $15,000, staying the appeal until payment. The appellant was given 21 days to provide the security, failing which the respondent had liberty to apply for summary dismissal of the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Richani v Martins Plaza Shopping Centre Pty Ltd arose from a dispute concerning the adequacy of security provided by the appellant for costs associated with an appeal against a summary judgment. The appellant, Mr Richani, was a unitholder in the Martins Plaza Trust, and the respondent, Martins Plaza Shopping Centre Pty Ltd, was the trustee of the trust. The initial litigation involved an allegation by Mr Richani that the respondent failed to recognise his position as a unitholder and had erroneously claimed that he had redeemed his units without payment. This led to a summary judgment being entered against Mr Richani in the initial proceedings. Unsatisfied with the outcome, Mr Richani appealed the summary judgment, setting the stage for the subsequent dispute over security for costs.

In response to the appeal, the respondent sought an order for security for costs, estimating the amount required to be just over $20,000, which included fees for Senior Counsel. This amount did not account for the additional costs of preparing the application, which were estimated at around $5,000. The respondent's initial correspondence with Mr Richani had sought security in the amount of $12,000. Mr Richani, in his affidavit, asserted that he did not have the financial means to meet any order for security and that such an order would effectively end his appeal. Despite this, he provided little detail about his financial situation beyond stating that he did not own real property and was of limited means.

The factual background also included Mr Richani's claim that the respondent failed to acknowledge his status as a unitholder and that this oversight contributed to his financial difficulties. However, the court noted that this assertion did not adequately account for the last twenty years of Mr Richani's life and the events leading up to the current litigation. The court had to consider the appellant's impecuniosity and the relatively low prospects of success on the appeal when deliberating on the appropriate amount of security for costs.

The matter of Richani v Martins Plaza Shopping Centre Pty Ltd came before the court as an appeal against a summary judgment previously entered in the respondent's favour. The appeal was initiated by the appellant, Mr Richani, who contested the lower court's decision that dismissed his claims against the respondent. Prior to this appeal, the appellant had unsuccessfully sought to have the summary judgment set aside. The appeal was listed for hearing before the court, with the respondent subsequently applying for security for costs, citing the appellant's limited financial means and the relatively low prospects of success on appeal. The respondent's application was supported by affidavit evidence and estimates of the costs likely to be incurred if the appeal proceeded.

In response, the appellant filed an affidavit stating his inability to meet the respondent's security for costs demand. Despite the appellant's assertions of financial hardship, the court considered the respondent's evidence and the lack of detailed financial information from the appellant. The court concluded that an order for security for costs was warranted, given the appellant's impecuniosity and the limited scope of the appeal. The court determined that the reasonable amount for security for costs would be $15,000, and ordered that the appeal be stayed until such security was provided. If the appellant failed to provide the security within 21 days, the respondent was granted liberty to apply for summary dismissal of the appeal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The appeal does not appear to raise any issue of general legal importance. I take into account the fact that the appellant does not reside outside the State, however, in circumstances where I have found that he is effectively impecunious, I give that factor little weight.Conclusion Taking everything into account, I consider that the risk of impecuniosity of the appellant and the relatively low prospects of success on the appeal speak in favour of making an order for security for costs. The respondent initially sought security in the amount of $12,000 in correspondence with the appellant. The affidavit of Mr Hagivassilis quantifies the respondent’s estimate at just over $20,000. As I have noted, that includes fees for Senior Counsel but does not include the costs of preparing the application itself, which the solicitor estimated would cost in the order of $5,000. Having regard to the terms of the Notice of Appeal, its nature as an appeal against summary judgment of limited scope and the original estimate by the respondent’s solicitors, I consider that it would be reasonable to order security in the amount of $15,000. I propose to make the following orders:1.The appellant is to provide security for costs by payment of $15,000 into court as security for costs, pursuant to UCR 215.1, 215.3 and 115.1(1)(e).2.The appeal is stayed until security in that sum is provided by the appellant.3.In the event security is not paid within 21 days, the respondent has liberty to apply for summary dismissal of the appeal.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Nevertheless, in the face of the affidavit evidence and the documents adduced by the respondent, and the lack of explanation by the appellant, the prospects of success on the appeal appear to be low.Other considerations The appellant, in his affidavit of 27 July 2022, says that he does not have the financial means to meet an order for the amount sought by the respondent, and that an order for security for costs will therefore bring his appeal to an end. The prospect that an order for security would stifle the appeal is a relevant consideration.[5] However, this assertion is just that. The appellant has not given evidence explaining his financial situation, other than that he does not own real property and is of limited means. He has not identified in evidence any steps he has taken to ascertain the availability of funds for the provision of security and at the very least, has not explained his assertion of ‘limited financial means’. I take into account here that those who ultimately stand to benefit from the litigation would be the beneficiaries of the Richani Family Trust.[5] Nanosecond Corporation v Glen Carron Pty Ltd [2019] SASC 124 at [60]. Otherwise, the appellant attributes his limited means to the respondent failing to recognise his position as a unitholder of the Martins Plaza Trust, and claiming he has redeemed his units, but not having paid for them. That is not a strong submission, as it does not account for the last 20 years of his life.[6][6] See Melunu Pty Ltd v Claron Constructions Pty Ltd [2004] NSWSC 1064 at [31]. The appeal does not appear to raise any issue of general legal importance. I take into account the fact that the appellant does not reside outside the State, however, in circumstances where I have found that he is effectively impecunious, I give that factor little weight.Conclusion Taking everything into account, I consider that the risk of impecuniosity of the appellant and the relatively low prospects of success on the appeal speak in favour of making an order for security for costs. The respondent initially sought security in the amount of $12,000 in correspondence with the appellant. The affidavit of Mr Hagivassilis quantifies the respondent’s estimate at just over $20,000. As I have noted, that includes fees for Senior Counsel but does not include the costs of preparing the application itself, which the solicitor estimated would cost in the order of $5,000. Having regard to the terms of the Notice of Appeal, its nature as an appeal against summary judgment of limited scope and the original estimate by the respondent’s solicitors, I consider that it would be reasonable to order security in the amount of $15,000. I propose to make the following orders:1.The appellant is to provide security for costs by payment of $15,000 into court as security for costs, pursuant to UCR 215.1, 215.3 and 115.1(1)(e).2.The appeal is stayed until security in that sum is provided by the appellant.3.In the event security is not paid within 21 days, the respondent has liberty to apply for summary dismissal of the appeal.