SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
RHG Construction Fitout and Maintenance Pty Ltd v Kangaroo Point Developments MP Property Pty Ltd & Ors [2021] QCA 57
PARTIES:
RHG CONSTRUCTION FITOUT AND MAINTENANCE PTY LTD
ABN 67 159 703 349
(appellant/applicant)
v
KANGAROO POINT DEVELOPMENTS MP PROPERTY PTY LTD ATF FOR KANGAROO POINT DEVELOPMENTS MP PROPERTY UNIT TRUST
ABN 80 283 808 292
(first respondent)
CHERIDEN FARTHING (ADJUDICATION REGISTRAR)
(second respondent/not a party to the application)
NOEL EVAN JENSEN (ADJUDICATOR J1057076)
(third respondent/not a party to the application)FILE NO/S:
Appeal No 2738 of 2021
SC No 13394 of 2020DIVISION:
Court of Appeal
PROCEEDING:
Application for Stay of Execution
ORIGINATING COURT:
Supreme Court at Brisbane – [2021] QSC 30 (Dalton J)DELIVERED ON:
26 March 2021
DELIVERED AT:
Brisbane
HEARING DATE:
24 March 2021
JUDGES:
Morrison JA
ORDERS:
1. The appellant gives an undertaking as to damages, and the first respondent gives an undertaking that the first respondent, its officers, servants, agents or otherwise, will not seek payment out of Court pursuant to order 2 of Dalton J's order made on 9 March 2021 until the determination of the appeal or further earlier order.
2. Orders 2 and 4 made on 9 March 2021 are stayed pending the determination of the appeal or further order by this Court.
3. Costs reserved.
4. The following directions apply to the appeal:
(i) The appeal be heard on 12 April 2021;
(ii) The appellant file and serve the appeal record book and its outline of submissions by 4.00 pm on 1 April 2021;
(iii) The respondent file and serve its outline of submissions by 4.00 pm on 8 April 2021.
CATCHWORDS:
APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – PROCEDURE – QUEENSLAND – STAY OF PROCEEDINGS – WHEN GRANTED – where the appellant and the respondent entered into a design and construction contract for the construction of a building – where the appellant served a payment claim on the respondent – where a dispute arose between the appellant and the respondent as to what constituted a payment schedule within the meaning of s 69 of the Building Industry Fairness (Security of Payment) Act 2017 (Qld) – where the adjudicator handed down a decision that an amount was payable to the appellant – where a Supreme Court judge found the adjudication decision was void and made orders for the payment out of the monies held in court – where the appellant seeks a stay of the orders, specifically focussing on those orders which would permit payment out of the sum held in court – where plainly the parties contemplated that whatever the outcome in the determination of the originating application below, an appeal might follow, with the consequence that a stay might be sought and the money continued to be held in court – where the appellant has demonstrated it has, within the scope an application for a stay, a good arguable case – where the material demonstrates that the appellant would suffer greater prejudice if a stay…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read RHG Construction Fitout and Maintenance Pty Ltd v Kangaroo P... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] QCA 57
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the Court of Appeal were whether a stay should be granted and if so, what conditions should accompany it. The respondent argued that the relief sought was akin to a Mareva injunction and should not be granted. They contended that the money paid into court was security for an interlocutory injunction and should not remain in court once the adjudication decision was set aside. They also argued that if the funds were paid out, RHG Construction would be in the same position as if it had succeeded in the appeal, and that requiring the money to remain in court would provide greater protection than the appellant had at the time of the adjudication decision. The respondent further argued that RHG Construction did not have a good arguable case and that the appellant would not suffer real prejudice if the stay was not granted.
The Court of Appeal found that the appellant had demonstrated a good arguable case within the scope of an application for a stay, and that the material showed that the appellant would suffer greater prejudice if a stay were not granted than the respondent would if a stay was granted. The Court noted that the appeal could be brought on quickly, and that any disadvantage to the respondent would be of short duration. Given these considerations, the Court found it appropriate to grant a stay of the orders pending the determination of the appeal or further order.
In conclusion, the Court of Appeal made several orders, including that RHG Construction provide an undertaking as to damages, and that Kangaroo Point Developments refrain from seeking payment out of Court until the determination of the appeal or further order. The Court also stayed certain orders made by the Supreme Court, reserving costs and setting directions for the appeal. The appeal is set to be heard on 12 April 2021, with the appellant required to file and serve the appeal record book and outline of submissions by 4.00 pm on 1 April 2021, and the respondent to do the same by 4.00 pm on 8 April 2021.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The appellant gives an undertaking as to damages, and the first respondent gives an undertaking that the first respondent, its officers, servants, agents or otherwise, will not seek payment out of Court pursuant to order 2 of Dalton J's order made on 9 March 2021 until the determination of the appeal or further earlier order.
2. Orders 2 and 4 made on 9 March 2021 are stayed pending the determination of the appeal or further order by this Court.
3. Costs reserved.
4. The following directions apply to the appeal:
(i) The appeal be heard on 12 April 2021;
(ii) The appellant file and serve the appeal record book and its outline of submissions by 4.00 pm on 1 April 2021;
(iii) The respondent file and serve its outline of submissions by 4.00 pm on 8 April 2021.
Background
Background to the litigation
RHG Construction filed an originating application in the Supreme Court of Queensland. Dalton J made orders for payment out of the sum held in court, which RHG Construction sought to stay. Brown J had previously made orders that RHG Construction be restrained from enforcing the adjudication certificate until the final decision in Kangaroo Point Developments' originating application. Kangaroo Point Developments paid the adjudicated amount, interest, and 50% of the adjudicator's fees into court. RHG Construction appealed against Dalton J's orders to the Supreme Court of Queensland.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
For the respondent it was contended that the relief sought on this application was the equivalent of a Mareva injunction and should not be granted. The principal points of contention made were:(a)the money paid into court was the agreed price paid for the appellant not to take steps to enforce its then right to payment under the adjudication decision; it was paid as security only for that interlocutory injunction and once the adjudication decision had been set aside there was nothing left to secure, and so the monies should not remain in court;(b)if the monies were paid out and the appellant succeeded in its appeal, the appellant would be in the same position it would have been in in any event; that is, it would be in the position of having a valid adjudication decision which could be enforced as an order of the court; that was all the appellant was ever entitled to, absent the agreement to put money in court as the price of the interlocutory injunction;(c)to require that the money remain in court would convert that money from the price paid for the interlocutory injunction into a greater form of security, and give the appellant greater protection than it had at the time the adjudication decision was made;(d)it was contended that the appellant did not have a good arguable case, essentially relying upon the analysis of the learned primary judge;(e)as to the question of prejudice, the respondent contended the appellant would suffer no real prejudice if the stay was not granted because if it was successful in the appeal it would have all of the enforcement mechanisms provided by BIFA, and would be able to pursue the adjudication certificate as a judgment;(f)the evidence as to the respondent’s conduct of construction projects was not sufficient to demonstrate a real risk that the money would be improperly dispersed; each project was embarked upon until completion; in each case the special purpose vehicles established for each project remained in existence until the project was completed; it was pointed out that the particular project in question in this case had not reached completion; and(g)if the monies were held in court the disadvantage suffered by the respondent was that it would be forced to go to the lending market to raise sufficient funds to ensure completion; there were risks attached to that in terms of securing the funds in the first place, and the likelihood of high rates of interest necessarily incurred to obtain it.Consideration The orders made by Brown J on 18 December 2020 were by consent. Relevantly they provide as follows:“1.Upon [Kangaroo Point Developments] giving the usual undertaking as to damages, [RHG Construction] be restrained … from filing the adjudication certificate … in a court of competent jurisdiction as a judgment for a debt … or otherwise to attempt to enforce or apply upon the Adjudication Decision in any manner, until the final decision in [Kangaroo Point Developments] originating application filed on 15 December 2020.2.It is recorded that [Kangaroo Point Developments] gives the usual undertaking as to damages.3.[Kangaroo Point Developments] is to pay into court as security the sum of $839,992.62 (Money), being the adjudicated amount of $788,439.54, interest thereon at the rate of 10% per annum from 18 August 2020 to 18 December 2020 (inclusive) and 50% of the Adjudicator’s fees, …4.The Money is to be held by the court pending the final decision in [Kangaroo Point Developments] Originating Application filed on 15 December 2020, or further order.”