Rhazi and Rhazi and Anor

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

RHAZI & RHAZI AND ANOR [2011] FamCA 262
FAMILY LAW – CHILDREN – Orders as to parental responsibility and time spent with
FAMILY LAW - PROPERTY – Whether the husband owes money to a third party – Whether the husband has an interest in a property overseas – Just and equitable
Family Law Act 1975 (Cth): s 60CA, s 60CC(2), s 60CC(3), s 61DA(1), s 61DA(2), s 61DA(4), s 75(2), s 79(1), s 79(2), s 79(4)
Benjamin & Bardot [2010] FamCAFC 252
Chorn & Hopkins (2004) FLC 93-204
Coghlan & Coghlan (2005) FLC 93-220
Gosper & Gosper (1987) FLC 91-818
Hickey & Hickey & Attorney-General for the Commonwealth (2003) FLC 92-144
Marvel & Marvel (No. 2) [2010] FamCAFC 101
APPLICANT: Ms Rhazi
RESPONDENT: Mr Rhazi
SECOND RESPONDENT: Mr S
FILE NUMBER: CAC 114 of 2010
DATE DELIVERED: 5 April 2011
PLACE DELIVERED: Canberra
PLACE HEARD: Canberra
JUDGMENT OF: Faulks DCJ
HEARING DATE: 4 & 5 April 2011

REPRESENTATION

COUNSEL FOR THE APPLICANT: Mr M. Anderson
SOLICITOR FOR THE APPLICANT: Watts McCray McGuinness Eley
COUNSEL FOR THE RESPONDENT: Mr C. McKeown
SOLICITOR FOR THE RESPONDENT: Jeanine Lloyd & Associates
THE SECOND RESPONDENT: No appearance by or on behalf of the Second Respondent

Orders

IT IS ORDERED THAT:

  1. The mother will have sole parental responsibility for M, born on … June 1997.

  2. Notwithstanding Order 1, M’s mother will inform Mr Rhazi, M’s father, about:

a.All serious medical issues relating to M;

b.The names of M’s medical practitioners and of any other practitioners of a similar sort, be they dental practitioners or psychologists upon whom M may be attending;

c.Details about her schooling including any information about M’s progress;

d.Any major events in M’s life including important visits either by her, or to her, and about her activities.

e.This information may be conveyed in the communication book or by email or by letter from time to time as it may be appropriate to do so and M’s mother will ensure that the information is conveyed as soon as practicable after the happening of the events referred to.

  1. M’s mother will authorise and direct the following to provide information to the father upon his request about M.

a.M’s school, her school teachers and any counsellor at the school (in the last case subject to normal professional confidentiality);

b.M’s doctors, dentists, therapists or other medical or allied professionals including information about her treatment, her diagnosis and her prognosis from time to time.

  1. M’s mother will consider consulting and discussing with M’s father major decisions affecting M’s wellbeing.

  2. Notwithstanding the above orders, M’s mother will have the right to make decisions about M’s long-term care, welfare and development.

  3. M will live with her mother.

  4. a.   M will spend time with her father as she determines is appropriate.

b.In relation to the time M spends with her father M’s mother will facilitate and encourage M to spend time with her father and to develop a meaningful relationship with her father.

c.M is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Rhazi and Rhazi and Anor and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] FamCA 262
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned proceedings between Mr Rhazi (the husband/father) and Mrs Rhazi (the wife/mother), with their son, Mr S, also a respondent. The dispute involved orders relating to parental responsibility for their daughter, M, and the division of property. The decision was made by Faulks DCJ in the Family Court of Australia.

The court was required to determine the terms of parental responsibility for M, including who would have sole parental responsibility, the extent of information sharing between the parents, and M's living arrangements and time spent with each parent. Additionally, the court needed to make orders regarding the division of the parties' property, including a specific sum to be paid by the husband to the wife and the disposition of a property located at H Street, G, in the Australian Capital Territory.

In relation to M, the court ordered that the mother would have sole parental responsibility, but with specific provisions for the father to be informed about M's medical issues, schooling, and major life events. The mother was also directed to authorise the disclosure of information about M from her school and medical practitioners to the father upon request, and to consider consulting with the father on major decisions affecting M's wellbeing. M was to live with her mother, and while she would spend time with her father as she determined appropriate, the mother was to facilitate and encourage M to spend time with her father and develop a meaningful relationship. The court also made detailed orders concerning the property settlement, including a payment of $280,000 from the husband to the wife, and provisions for the sale of the H Street property in the event of default, with the net proceeds to be divided. The court also declared ownership of certain jewellery and other personal items to each party.

Orders

Orders of the court

IT IS ORDERED THAT:

1.

The mother will have sole parental responsibility for M, born on … June 1997.

2.

Notwithstanding Order 1, M’s mother will inform Mr Rhazi, M’s father, about:

a. All serious medical issues relating to M;

b. The names of M’s medical practitioners and of any other practitioners of a similar sort, be they dental practitioners or psychologists upon whom M may be attending;

c. Details about her schooling including any information about M’s progress;

d. Any major events in M’s life including important visits either by her, or to her, and about her activities.

e. This information may be conveyed in the communication book or by email or by letter from time to time as it may be appropriate to do so and M’s mother will ensure that the information is conveyed as soon as practicable after the happening of the events referred to.

3.

M’s mother will authorise and direct the following to provide information to the father upon his request about M.

a. M’s school, her school teachers and any counsellor at the school (in the last case subject to normal professional confidentiality);

b. M’s doctors, dentists, therapists or other medical or allied professionals including information about her treatment, her diagnosis and her prognosis from time to time.

4.

M’s mother will consider consulting and discussing with M’s father major decisions affecting M’s wellbeing.

5.

Notwithstanding the above orders, M’s mother will have the right to make decisions about M’s long-term care, welfare and development.

6.

M will live with her mother.

7.

a. M will spend time with her father as she determines is appropriate.

b. In relation to the time M spends with her father M’s mother will facilitate and encourage M to spend time with her father and to develop a meaningful relationship with her father.

c. M is free to call her father at any reasonable time; and

d. M’s mother will provide uninterrupted and private time for M to call her father and will facilitate such communication.

IT IS ORDERED, IN RELATION TO PROPERTY, THAT:

8.

The husband will pay to the wife the sum of $280,000 within 60 days of the date of this order.

9.

a. In default of his payment unless the wife otherwise agrees to an extension of time for payment she will become the Trustee for sale of the property known as the H Street property at G in the Australian Capital Territory.

b. There be liberty to apply about the terms of the sale if it is necessary to do so.

c. That upon completion of the sale the net proceeds will be divided so that the wife receives 57.5 per cent of the pool of property as previously defined that the net sale price inserted into the pool in lieu of the $470,000 which presently occupies that place in the pool.

10. The wife is declared to be the owner of the jewellery in her possession or control.

11. The husband and wife will do such things as are necessary to ensure that the items contained in list 1 of the two lists of property produced in relation to the parties is transferred to both physically and legally if necessary to the wife.

12. Otherwise each of the parties shall keep those items of personality in his or her possession or control and each is declared respectively to be the owner both at law and in equity of such items.

13. a. The parties’ son, Mr S, the second respondent to these proceedings, will do all things necessary, as he has previously agreed to do, to assist the father to raise money to pay the wife in accordance with order 8 that I have set out above or do such things as may be necessary to cooperate in the sale of the H Street property at G by the wife as Trustee for the sale and to execute all necessary documents.

b. If the father, or Mr S, shall fail to execute in deed or instrument presented to him within seven days of its being so presented a Registrar of the Family Court of Australia in Canberra is appointed to execute such document in place of the husband or Mr S and to do all things that are necessary to give validity to the operation of the deed or the instrument in accordance with section 106A(1) of the Family Law Act 1975.

14. All material produced by subpoena which did not become the subject of exhibits will be returned by the Court to the persons producing it as soon as practicable. Any material produced by subpoena which became an exhibit will be returned by the Court at the expiration of the appeal period to the person producing it.

15. All extant applications are discharged.

16. The matter be removed from the Pending Cases Inventory.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

For the purposes of the evidence before the Court, I set out paragraphs 8 to 14 of Family Consultant N’s report hereunder: 8.[The child] is an assertive and well spoken young girl. She is ambitious about attaining a good education and going to university. By all reports [the child] is a straight A student. [The child] described a close relationship with all of her siblings and reports that her mother’s home is where they regularly meet over evening meals. 9.[The child] believes that all children do not have a particularly close relationship with their father as he was absent for much of their childhood. On the occasion when he is at home, [the child] feels that he was not available to them as he spent time pursuing his own interests. 10.[The child] feels very close to her mother whom she believes raised her. She asserts that her mother has always worked hard to support them and insists that she has spent little time or money looking after herself. [The child] is angered by her father’s unwillingness to move out of the family home, she feels it would be more appropriate if the majority of the family could live in the family home. She indicates that their current home is cramped, however understands that this is all that her mother can currently afford. 11.[The child] sees her mother as being a kind, generous and sensitive person who has always been available to care for all the children in the family. [The child] feels that her mother has performed both the roles of mother and father in the family unit. 12.Adolescence [sic] are at a stage of their development where they see people and situations in “black and white”, they have as yet not developed the ability, nor gained experience to factor in shades of grey. [The child] is currently very angry with her father for “throwing” the family out of their home and for hurting her mother. CONCLUSION13.[The child] has agreed to spend time with her father in the presence of her brother and his girlfriend for an evening every three weeks. Her decision to do this is based on her desire to comply with her mother wishes, feeling that it will remove some of the stress that [the mother] is feel over the current court action. [The child] has judged her father to be looking after his own interests rather than those of his children. 14.[The child], at this stage of her development, is struggling to balance her need to maintain a relationship with her father verses avenging and punishing him for hurting the family. Her lack of commitment to the father/daughter relationship could also reflect the possibility that the relationship between them has always been porous.[2] She may well be questioning the benefits of investing in a relationship with [the father] given his desire to return to [South Central Asia] only returning for holidays. [2] I assume, in the context of these proceedings, that the Family Consultant meant “poisonous”. I note that there was no request by either counsel to cross-examine the family consultant and no adjournment was sought to enable further consideration to be given to the material in the family report.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established